Global
Highlights Macro Outlook: Global growth is decelerating and the composition of that growth is shifting back towards the United States. Policy backdrop: The specter of trade wars represents a real and immediate threat to risk assets. Meanwhile, many of the "policy puts" that investors have relied on have been marked down to a lower strike price. Global equities: We downgraded global equities from overweight to neutral on June 19th. Investors should favor developed market equities over their EM counterparts. Defensive stocks will outperform deep cyclicals, at least until the dollar peaks early next year. Government bonds: Treasury yields may dip in the near term, but will rise over a 12-month horizon. Overweight Japan, Australia, New Zealand, and the U.K. relative to the U.S., Canada, and the euro area. Credit: The current level of spreads points to subpar returns over the next 12 months. We have a modest preference for U.S. over European corporate bonds. Currencies: EUR/USD will fall into the $1.10-to-1.15 range during the next few months. The downside risks for the pound and the yen are limited. Avoid EM and commodity currencies. The risk of a large depreciation in the Chinese yuan is rising. Commodities: Favor oil over metals. Gold will do well over the long haul. Feature I. Macro Outlook Back To The USA The global economy experienced a synchronized expansion in 2017. Global real GDP growth accelerated to 3.8% from 3.2% in 2016. The euro area, Japan, and most emerging markets moved from laggards to leaders in the global growth horse race. The opposite pattern has prevailed in 2018. Global growth has slowed, a trend that is likely to continue over the next few quarters judging by a variety of leading economic indicators (LEIs) (Chart 1). The U.S. has once again jumped ahead of its peers: It is the only major economy where the LEI is still rising (Chart 2). The latest tracking data suggest that U.S. real GDP growth could reach 4% in the second quarter, more than double most estimates of trend growth. Chart 1Global Growth Is Slowing Again Chart 2U.S. Is Outshining Its Peers Such a lofty pace of growth cannot be sustained. For the first time in over a decade, the U.S. economy has reached full employment. The unemployment rate stands at a 48-year low of 3.75%. The number of people outside the labor force who want a job, as a percentage of the total working-age population, is back to pre-recession lows (Chart 3). For the first time in the history of the Bureau of Labor Statistics' Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS), there are more job vacancies than unemployed workers (Chart 4). Chart 3U.S. Is Back To Full Employment Chart 4There Are Now More Vacancies Than Jobseekers Mainstream economic theory states that governments should tighten fiscal policy as the economy begins to overheat in order to accumulate a war chest for the next inevitable downturn. The Trump administration is doing the exact opposite. The budget deficit is set to widen to 4.6% of GDP next year on the back of massive tax cuts and big increases in government spending (Chart 5). Chart 5The U.S. Budget Deficit Is Set To Widen Even If The Unemployment Rate Continues To Decline The Fed In Tightening Mode As the labor market overheats, wages will accelerate further. Average hourly earnings surprised to the upside in May. The Employment Cost Index for private-sector workers - one of the cleanest and most reliable measures of wage growth - rose at a 4% annualized pace in the first quarter. The U.S. labor market has finally moved onto the 'steep' side of the Phillips curve (Chart 6). Rising wages will put more income into workers' pockets who will then spend it. As aggregate demand increases beyond the economy's productive capacity, inflation will rise. The New York Fed's Underlying Inflation Gauge, which leads core CPI inflation by 18 months, has already leaped to over 3% (Chart 7). The prices paid components of the ISM and regional Fed purchasing manager surveys have also surged (Chart 8). Chart 6Wage Inflation Will Accelerate Chart 7U.S. Inflation: Upside Risks (Part I) Chart 8U.S. Inflation: Upside Risks (Part II) The Fed has a symmetric inflation target. Hence, a temporary increase in core PCE inflation to around 2.2%-to-2.3% would not worry the FOMC very much. However, a sustained move above 2.5% would likely prompt an aggressive response. The fact that the unemployment rate has fallen 0.7 percentage points below the Fed's estimate of full employment may seem like a cause for celebration, but this development has a dark side. There has never been a case in the post-war era where the unemployment rate has risen by more than one-third of a percentage point without this coinciding with a recession (Chart 9). The Fed wants to avoid a situation where the unemployment rate has fallen so much that it has nowhere to go but up. Chart 9Even A Small Uptick In The Unemployment Rate Is Bad News For The Business Cycle As such, we think that the bar for the Fed to abandon its once-per-quarter pace of rate hikes is quite high. If anything, the risk is that the Fed expedites monetary tightening in order to keep real rates on an upward trajectory. Jay Powell's announcement that he will hold a press conference at the conclusion of every FOMC meeting opens the door for the Fed to move back to its historic pattern of hiking rates once every six weeks. Housing And The Monetary Transmission Mechanism Economists often talk about the "monetary transmission mechanism." As Ed Leamer pointed out in his 2007 Jackson Hole symposium paper succinctly entitled, "Housing Is The Business Cycle," housing has historically been the main conduit through which changes in monetary policy affect the real economy.1 A house will last a long time, and the land on which it sits - which in many cases is worth more than the house itself - will last forever. Thus, changes in real interest rates tend to have a large impact on the capitalized value of one's home. Today, the U.S. housing market is in pretty good shape (Chart 10). Construction activity was slow to increase in the aftermath of the Great Recession. As a result, the vacancy rate stands at ultra-low levels. Home prices have been rising briskly, but are still 13% below their 2005 peak once adjusted for inflation. On both a price-to-rent and price-to-income basis, home prices do not appear overly stretched. Mortgage-servicing costs, expressed as a share of disposable income, are near all-time lows. The homeownership rate has also been trending higher, thanks to faster household formation and an improving labor market. Lenders remain circumspect (Chart 11). The ratio of mortgage debt-to-disposable income has barely increased during the recovery, and is still 31 percentage points below 2007 levels. The average FICO score for new mortgages stands at a healthy 761, well above pre-recession standards. Chart 10U.S. Housing Is In Pretty Good Shape Chart 11Mortgage Lenders Remain Circumspect The Urban Institute Housing Credit Availability Index, which measures the percentage of home purchase loans that are likely to default over the next 90 days, is nowhere close to dangerous levels. This is particularly the case for private-label mortgages, whose default risk has hovered at just over 2% during the past few years, down from a peak of 22% in 2006. If Not Housing, Then What? Since the U.S. housing sector is in reasonably good shape, the Fed may need to slow the economy through other means. Here's the rub though: Other sectors of the economy are not particularly sensitive to changes in interest rates. Decades of empirical data have clearly shown that business investment is only weakly correlated with the cost of capital. Unlike a house, most business investment is fairly short-lived. A computer might be ready for the recycling heap in just a few years. The Bureau of Economic Analysis estimates that the depreciation rate for nonresidential assets is nearly four times higher than for residential property (Chart 12). During the early 1980s, when the effective fed funds rate reached 19%, residential investment collapsed but business investment was barely affected (Chart 13). Chart 12U.S.: Depreciation Rate For Business ##br##Investment Is Much Larger Than For Residential Property Chart 13Residential Investment Collapsed In ##br##Response To Higher Interest Rates In The Early 80s... While Business Investment Was Barely Affected Rising rates could make it difficult for corporate borrowers to pay back loans, which could indirectly lead to lower business investment. That said, a fairly pronounced increase in rates may be necessary to generate significant distress in the corporate sector, given that interest payments are close to record-lows as a share of cash flows (Chart 14). In addition, corporate bonds now represent 60% of total corporate liabilities. Bonds tend to have much longer maturities than bank loans, which provides a buffer against default risk. A stronger dollar would cool the economy by diverting some spending towards imports. However, imports account for only 16% of GDP. Thus, even large swings in the dollar's value tend to have only modest effects on the economy. Likewise, higher interest rates could hurt equity prices, but the wealthiest ten percent of households own 93% of all stocks. Hence, it would take a sizable drop in the stock market to significantly slow GDP growth. The conventional wisdom is that the Fed will need to hit the pause button at some point next year. The market is pricing in only 85 basis points in rate hikes between now and the end of 2020 (Chart 15). That assumption may be faulty, considering that housing is in good shape and other sectors of the economy are not especially sensitive to changes in interest rates. Rates may need to go quite a bit higher before the U.S. economy slows materially. Chart 14U.S. Corporate Sector Interest Payments ##br##At Near Record-Low Levels As A Share Of Cash Flows Chart 15Market Expectations Versus The Fed Dots Global Contagion Investors and policymakers talk a lot about the neutral rate of interest. Unfortunately, the discussion is usually very parochial in nature, inasmuch as it focuses on the interest rate that is consistent with full employment and stable inflation in the United States. But the U.S. is not an island unto itself. Even if a bit outdated, the old adage that says that when the U.S. sneezes the rest of the world catches a cold still rings true. What if there is a lower "shadow" neutral rate which, if breached, causes pain outside the U.S. before it causes pain within the U.S. itself? Eighty per cent of EM foreign-currency debt is denominated in U.S. dollars. Outside of China, EM dollar debt is now back to late-1990s levels both as a share of GDP and exports (Chart 16). Just like in that era, a vicious cycle could erupt where a stronger dollar makes it difficult for EM borrowers to pay back their loans, leading to capital outflows from emerging markets, and an even stronger dollar. The wave of EM local-currency debt issued in recent years only complicates matters (Chart 17). If EM central banks raise rates, this could help prevent their currencies from plunging. However, higher domestic rates will make it difficult for local-currency borrowers to pay back their loans. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. Chart 16EM Dollar Debt Is High Chart 17EM Borrowers Like Local Credit Too China To The Rescue? Don't Count On It When emerging markets last succumbed to pressure in 2015, China saved the day by stepping in with massive new stimulus. Fiscal spending and credit growth accelerated to over 15% year-over-year. The government's actions boosted demand for all sorts of industrial commodities. Today, Chinese growth is slowing again. May data on industrial production, retail sales, and fixed asset investment all disappointed. Our leading indicator for the Li Keqiang index, a widely followed measure of economic activity, is in a clear downtrend (Chart 18). Property prices in tier one cities are down year-over-year. Construction tends to follow prices. So far, the policy response has been muted. Reserve requirements have been cut and some administrative controls loosened, but the combined credit and fiscal impulse has plunged (Chart 19). Onshore and offshore corporate bond yields have increased to multi-year highs. Bank lending rates are rising, while loan approval rates are dropping (Chart 20). Chart 18Chinese Growth Is Slowing Anew Chart 19China: Policy Response To Slowdown ##br##Has Been Muted So Far Chart 20China: Credit Tightening There is no doubt that China will stimulate again if the economy appears to be heading for a deep slowdown. However, the bar for a fresh round of stimulus is higher today than it was in the past. Elevated debt levels, excess capacity in some parts of the industrial sector, and worries about pollution all limit the extent to which the authorities will be willing to respond with the usual barrage of infrastructure spending and increased bank lending. The economy needs to feel more pain before policymakers come to its aid. Rising Risk Of Another RMB Devaluation Chart 21China: Currency Wars Are Good And ##br##Easy To Win Even if China does stimulate the economy, it may try to do so by weakening the currency rather than loosening fiscal and credit policies. Chart 21 shows that the yuan has fallen much more over the past week than one would have expected based on the broad dollar's trend. The timing of the CNY's recent descent coincides with President Trump's announcement of additional tariffs on $200 billion of Chinese goods. Global financial markets went into a tizzy the last time China devalued the yuan in August 2015. The devaluation triggered significant capital outflows, arguably only compounding China's problems. This has led commentators to conclude that the authorities would not make the same mistake again. But what if the real mistake was not that China devalued its currency, but that it did not devalue it by enough? Standard economic theory says that a country should always devalue its currency by a sufficient amount to flush out expectations of a further decline. China was too timid, and paid the price. Capital controls are tighter in China today than they were in 2015. This gives the authorities more room for maneuver. China is also waging a geopolitical war with the United States. The U.S. exported only $188 billion of goods and services to China, a small fraction of the $524 billion in goods and services that China exported to the United States. China simply cannot win a tit-for-tat trade war with the United States. In contrast, a currency war from China's perspective may be, to quote Donald Trump, "good and easy to win." The Chinese simply need to step up their purchases of U.S. Treasurys, which would drive up the value of the dollar. Trump And Trade Needless to say, any effort by the Chinese to devalue their currency would invite a backlash from the Trump administration. However, since China is already on the receiving end of punitive U.S. trade actions, it is not clear that the marginal cost to China would outweigh the benefits of having a more competitive currency. The truth is that there may be little that China can do to fend off a trade war. Protectionism is popular among American voters, especially among Trump's base (Chart 22). Donald Trump ran on a protectionist platform, and he is now trying to deliver on his promise of a smaller trade deficit. Whether he succeeds is another story. Trump's macroeconomic policies are completely at odds with his trade agenda. Fiscal stimulus will boost aggregate demand, which will suck in more imports. An overheated economy will prompt the Fed to raise rates more aggressively than it otherwise would, leading to a stronger dollar. All of this will result in a wider trade deficit. What will Trump tell voters two years from now when he is campaigning in Michigan and Ohio about why the trade deficit has widened under his watch? Will he blame himself or America's trading partners? No trophy for getting that answer right. Trump seems to equate countries with companies: Exports are revenues and imports are costs. If a country is exporting less than it is importing, it must be losing money. This is deeply flawed reasoning. I run a current account deficit with the place where I eat lunch and they run a capital account deficit with me - they give me food and I give them cash - but I don't go around complaining that they are ripping me off. A trade war would be much more damaging to Wall Street than Main Street. While trade is a fairly small part of the U.S. economy, it represents a large share of the activities of the multinational companies that comprise the S&P 500. Trade these days is dominated by intermediate goods (Chart 23). The exchange of goods and services takes place within the context of a massive global supply chain, where such phrases as "outsourcing," "vertical integration" and "just-in-time inventory management" have entered the popular vernacular. Chart 22Free Trade Is Not In Vogue In The U.S. Chart 23Trade In Intermediate Goods Dominates This arrangement has many advantages, but it also harbors numerous fragilities. A small fire at a factory in Japan that manufactured 60 per cent of the epoxy resin used in chip casings led to a major spike in RAM prices in 1993. Flooding in Thailand in 2011 wreaked havoc on the global auto industry. The global supply chain is highly vulnerable to even small shocks. Now scale that up by a factor of 100. That is what a global trade war would look like. The Euro Area: Back In The Slow Lane Euro area growth peaked late last year. Real final demand grew by 0.8% in Q4 of 2017 but only 0.2% in Q1 of 2018. The weakening trend was partly a function of slower growth in China and other emerging markets - net exports contributed 0.41 percentage points to euro area growth in Q4 but subtracted 0.14 points in Q1. Domestic factors also played a role. Most notably, the euro area credit impulse rolled over late last year, taking GDP growth down with it (Chart 24).2 It is too early to expect euro area growth to reaccelerate. German exports contracted in April. Export expectations in the Ifo survey sank in June to the lowest level since January 2017, while the export component of the PMI swooned to a two-year low. We also have yet to see the full effect of the Italian imbroglio on euro area growth. Italian bond yields have come down since spiking in April, but the 10-year yield is still more than 100 basis points higher than before the selloff (Chart 25). This amounts to a fairly substantial tightening in financial conditions in the euro area's third largest economy. And this does not even take into account the deleterious effect on Italian business confidence. Chart 24Peak In Euro Area Credit Impulse Last Year##br## Means Slower Growth This Year Chart 25Uh Oh Spaghetti-O If You Are Gonna Do The Time, You Might As Well Do The Crime At this point, investors are basically punishing Italy for a crime - defaulting and possibly jettisoning the euro - that it has not committed. If you are going to get reprimanded for something you have not done, you are more likely to do it. Such a predicament can easily create a vicious circle where rising yields make default more likely, leading to falling demand for Italian debt and even higher yields (Chart 26). The fact that Italian real GDP per capita is no higher now than when the country adopted the euro in 1999, and Italian public support for euro area membership is lower than elsewhere, has only added fuel to investor concerns (Chart 27). Chart 26When A Lender Of Last Resort Is Absent, Multiple Equilibria Are Possible Chart 27Italy: Neither Divine Nor A Comedy The ECB could short-circuit this vicious circle by promising to backstop Italian debt no matter what. But it can't make such unconditional promises. Recall that prior to delivering his "whatever it takes" speech in 2012, Mario Draghi and his predecessor Jean-Claude Trichet penned a letter to Silvio Berlusconi outlining a series of reforms they wanted to see enacted as a condition of ongoing ECB support. The contents of the letter were so explosive that they precipitated Berlusconi's resignation after they were leaked to the public. One of the reforms that Draghi and Trichet demanded - and the subsequent government led by Mario Monti ultimately undertook - was the extension of the retirement age. Italy's current leaders promised to reverse that decision during the election campaign. While they have softened their stance since then, they will still try to deliver on much of their populist agenda over the coming months, much to the consternation of the ECB and the European Commission. It was one thing for Mario Draghi to promise to do "whatever it takes" to protect Italy when the country was the victim of contagion from the Greek crisis. But now that Italy is the source of the disease, the rationale for intervention has weakened. Italy's Macro Constraints Much has been written about what Italy should be doing, but the fact is that there are no simple solutions. Italy suffers from an aging population that is trying to save more for retirement. Italian companies do not want to invest in new capacity because the working-age population is shrinking, which limits future domestic demand growth. Thus, the private sector is a chronic net saver, constantly wanting to spend less than it earns (Chart 28). Italy is not unique in facing an excess of private-sector savings. However, Italy is unique in that the solutions available to most other countries to deal with this predicament are not available to it. Broadly speaking, there are two ways you can deal with excess private-sector savings. Call it the Japanese solution and the German solution. The Japanese solution is to have the government absorb excess private-sector savings with its own dissavings. This is tantamount to running large, sustained fiscal deficits. Italy's populist coalition Five Star-Lega government tried to pursue this strategy, only to have the bond vigilantes shoot it down. The German solution is to ship excess savings out of the country through a large current account surplus (in Germany's case, 8% of GDP). However, for Italy to avail itself of this solution, it would need to have a hypercompetitive economy, which it does not. Unlike Spain, Italy's unit labor costs have barely declined over the past six years relative to the rest of the euro area, leaving it with an export base that is struggling to compete abroad (Chart 29). Chart 28The Italian Private Sector Wants To Save Chart 29Italy: More Work Needs To Be Done On The Labor Competitiveness Front Since there is little that can be done in the near term that would improve Italy's competitiveness vis-à-vis the rest of the euro area, the only thing the ECB can do is try to improve Italy's competitiveness vis-à-vis the rest of the world. This means keeping monetary policy very loose and hoping that this translates into a weak euro. II. Financial Markets Downgrade Global Risk Assets From Overweight To Neutral Investors are accustomed to thinking that there is a "Fed put" out there - that the Fed will stop raising rates if growth slows and equity prices fall. This was a sensible assumption a few years ago: The Fed hiked rates in December 2015 and then stood pat for 12 months as the global economic backdrop darkened. These days, however, the Fed wants slower growth. And if weaker asset prices are the ticket to slower growth, so be it. The "Fed put" may still be around, but the strike price has been marked down to a lower level. Likewise, worries about growing financial and economic imbalances will limit the efficacy of the "China stimulus put" - the tendency for the Chinese government to ease fiscal and credit policy at the first hint of slower growth. The same goes for the "Draghi put." The ECB is hoping, perhaps unrealistically so, to wind down its asset purchase program later this year. This means that a key buyer of Italian debt is stepping back just when it may be needed the most. The loss of these three policy puts, along with additional risks such as rising protectionism, means that the outlook for global risk assets is likely to be more challenging over the coming months. With that in mind, we downgraded our 12-month recommendation on global risk assets from overweight to neutral last week. Fixed-Income: Stay Underweight Chart 30U.S. Corporate Bonds: Leverage-Adjusted Value A less constructive stance towards equities would normally imply a more constructive stance towards bonds. Global bond yields could certainly fall in the near term, as EM stress triggers capital flows into safe-haven government bond markets. However, if we are really in an environment where an overheated U.S. economy and rising inflation force the Fed to raise rates more than the market expects, long-term bond yields are likely to rise over a 12-month horizon. As such, asset allocators should move the proceeds from equity sales into cash. The U.S. yield curve might still flatten in this environment, but it would be a bear flattening - one where long-term yields rise less than short-term rates. Bond yields are strongly correlated across the world. Thus, an increase in U.S. Treasury yields over the next 12 months would likely put upward pressure on bond yields abroad, even if inflation remains contained outside the United States. BCA's Global Fixed Income Strategy service favors Japan, Australia, New Zealand, and the U.K. over the U.S., Canada, and euro area bond markets. Investors should also pare back their exposure to spread product. Our increasing caution towards equities extends to the corporate bond space. BCA's U.S. Corporate Health Monitor (CHM) remains in deteriorating territory. With profits still high and bank lending standards continuing to ease, a recession-inducing corporate credit crunch is unlikely over the next 12 months. Nevertheless, our models suggest that both investment grade and high yield credit are overvalued (Chart 30). In relative terms, our fixed-income specialists have a modest preference for U.S. over European credit. The near-term growth outlook is more challenging in Europe. The ECB is also about to wind down its bond buying program, having purchased nearly 20% of all corporate bonds in the euro area over the course of only three years. Currencies: King Dollar Is Back The U.S. dollar is a counter-cyclical currency, meaning that it tends to do well when the global economy is decelerating (Chart 31). If the Chinese economy continues to weaken, global growth will remain under pressure. Emerging market currencies will suffer in this environment especially if, as discussed above, the Chinese authorities engineer a devaluation of the yuan. Momentum is moving back in the dollar's favor. Chart 32 shows that a simple trading rule - which goes long the dollar whenever it is above its moving average and shorts it when it is below - has performed very well over time. The dollar is now trading above most key trend lines. Chart 31Decelerating Global Growth Tends To Be##br## Bullish For The Dollar Chart 32The Dollar Trades On Momentum Some commentators have argued that a larger U.S. budget deficit will put downward pressure on the dollar. However, this would only happen if the Fed let inflation expectations rise more quickly than nominal rates, an outcome which would produce lower real rates. So far, that has not happened: U.S. real rates have risen across the entire yield curve since Treasury yields bottomed last September (Chart 33). As a result, real rate differentials between the U.S. and its peers have increased (Chart 34). Chart 33U.S. Real Rates Have Risen Across ##br##The Entire Yield Curve Chart 34Real Rate Differentials Have Widened ##br##Between The U.S. And Its DM Peers Historically, the dollar has moved in line with changes in real rate differentials (Chart 35). The past few months have been no exception. If the Fed finds itself in a position where it can raise rates more than the market anticipates, the greenback should continue to strengthen. Chart 35Historically, The Dollar Has Moved In Line With Interest Rate Differentials True, the dollar is no longer a cheap currency. However, if long-term interest rate differentials stay anywhere close to where they are today, the greenback can appreciate quite a bit from current levels. For example, consider the dollar's value versus the euro. Thirty-year U.S. Treasurys currently yield 2.98% while 30-year German bunds yield 1.04%, a difference of 194 basis points. Even if one allows for the fact that investors expect euro area inflation to be lower than in the U.S. over the next 30 years, EUR/USD would need to trade at a measly 84 cents today in order to compensate German bund holders for the inferior yield they will receive.3 We do not expect EUR/USD to get down to that level, but a descent into the $1.10-to-$1.15 range over the next few months certainly seems achievable. Brexit worries will continue to weigh on the British pound. Nevertheless, we are reluctant to get too bearish on the pound. The currency is extremely cheap (Chart 36). Inflation has come down from a 5-year high of 3.1% in November, but still clocked in at 2.4% in April. Real wages are picking up, consumer confidence has strengthened, and the CBI retail survey has improved. In a surprise decision, Andy Haldane, the Bank of England's Chief Economist, joined two other Monetary Policy Committee members in voting for an immediate 25 basis-point increase in the Bank Rate in June. Perhaps most importantly, Brexit remains far from a sure thing. Most polls suggest that if a referendum were held again, the "Bremain" side would prevail (Chart 37). Rules are made to be broken. It is the will of the people, rather than legal mumbo-jumbo, that ultimately matters. In the end, the U.K. will stay in the EU. The yen is likely to weaken somewhat against the dollar over the next 12 months as interest rate differentials continue to move in the dollar's favor. That said, as with the pound, we think the downside for the yen is limited (Chart 38). The yen real exchange rate remains at multi-year lows. Japan's current account surplus has grown to nearly 4% of GDP and its net international investment position - the difference between its foreign assets and liabilities - stands at an impressive 60% of GDP. If financial market volatility rises, as we expect, some of those overseas assets will be repatriated back home, potentially boosting the value of the yen in the process. Chart 36The Pound Is Cheap Chart 37When Bremorse Sets In Chart 38The Yen's Long-Term Outlook Is Bullish Commodities: Better Outlook For Oil Than Metals The combination of slower global growth and a resurgent dollar is likely to hurt commodity prices. Industrial metals are more vulnerable than oil. China consumes around half of all the copper, nickel, aluminum, zinc, and iron ore produced around the world (Chart 39). In contrast, China represents less than 15% of global oil demand. The supply backdrop for oil is also more favorable than for metals. While Saudi Arabia is likely to increase production over the remainder of the year, this may not be enough to fully offset lower crude output from Venezuela, Iran, Libya, and Nigeria, as well as potential constraints to U.S. production growth due to pipeline bottlenecks. Additionally, a recent power outage has knocked about 350,000 b/d of Syncrude's Canadian oil sands production offline at least through July. The superior outlook for oil over metals means we prefer the Canadian dollar relative to the Aussie dollar. Chart 40 shows that the AUD is expensive compared to the CAD based on a Purchasing Power Parity calculation. Although the Canadian dollar deserves some penalty due to NAFTA risks, the current discount seems excessive to us. Accordingly, as of today, we are going tactically short AUD/CAD. Chart 39China Is A More Dominant Consumer ##br##Of Metals Than Oil Chart 40The Canadian Dollar Is Undervalued ##br##Relative To The Aussie Dollar The prospect of higher inflation down the road is good news for gold. However, with real rates still rising and the dollar strengthening, it is too early to pile into bullion and other precious metals. Wait until early 2020, by which time the Fed is likely to stop raising rates. Equities: Prefer DM Over EM One can believe that emerging market stocks will go up; one can also believe that the Fed will do its job and tighten financial conditions in order to prevent the U.S. economy from overheating. But one cannot believe that both of these things will happen at the same time. As Chart 41 clearly shows, EM equities almost always fall when U.S. financial conditions are tightening. Chart 41Tightening U.S. Financial Conditions Do Not Bode Well For EM Stocks Our overriding view is that U.S. financial conditions will tighten over the coming months. As discussed above, the adverse effects of rising U.S. rates and a strengthening dollar are likely to be felt first and foremost in emerging markets. Our EM strategists believe that Turkey, Brazil, Argentina, South Africa, Malaysia, and Indonesia are most vulnerable. We no longer have a strong 12-month view on regional equity allocation within the G3 economies, at least not in local-currency terms. The sector composition of the euro area and Japanese bourses is more heavily tilted towards deep cyclicals than the United States. However, a weaker euro, and to a lesser extent, a weaker yen will cushion the blow from a softening global economy. In dollar terms, the U.S. stock market should outperform its peers. Getting Ready For The Next Equity Bear Market A neutral stance does not imply that we expect markets to move sideways. On the contrary, volatility is likely to increase again over the balance of the year. We predicted last week that the next "big move" in stocks will be to the downside. We would consider moving our 12-month recommendation temporarily back to overweight if global equities were to sell off by more than 15% during the next few months or if the policy environment becomes more market-friendly. Similar to what happened in 1998, when the S&P 500 fell by 22% between the late summer and early fall, a significant correction today could set the scene for a blow-off rally. In such a rally, EM stocks would probably rebound and cyclicals would outperform defensives. However, absent such fireworks, we will probably downgrade global equities in early 2019 in anticipation of a global recession in 2020. The U.S. fiscal impulse is set to fall sharply in 2020, as the full effects of the tax cuts and spending hikes make their way through the system (Chart 42).4 Real GDP will probably be growing at a trend-like pace of 1.7%-to-1.8% by the end of next year because the U.S. will have run out of surplus labor at that point. A falling fiscal impulse could take GDP growth down to 1% in 2020, a level often associated with "stall speed." Investors should further reduce exposure to stocks before this happens. The next recession will not be especially severe in purely economic terms. However, as was the case in 2001, even a mild recession could lead to a very painful equity bear market if the starting point for valuations is high enough. Valuations today are not as extreme as they were back then, but they are still near the upper end of their historic range (Chart 43). A composite valuation measure incorporating both the trailing and forward PE ratio, price-to-book, price-to-cash flow, price-to-sales, market cap-to-GDP, dividend yield, and Tobin's Q points to real average annual total returns of 1.8% for U.S. stocks over the next decade. Global equities will fare slightly better, but returns will still be below their historic norm. Long-term equity investors looking for more upside should consider steering their portfolios towards value stocks, which have massively underperformed growth stocks over the past 11 years (Chart 44). Chart 42U.S. Fiscal Impulse Set To Drop In 2020 Chart 43U.S. Stocks Are Pricey Chart 44Value Stocks: An Attractive Proposition Appendix A depicts some key valuation indicators for global equities. Appendix B provides illustrative projections based on the discussion above of where all the major asset classes are heading over the next ten years. Peter Berezin, Chief Global Strategist Global Investment Strategy peterb@bcaresearch.com 1 Edward E. Leamer, "Housing Is The Business Cycle," Proceedings, Economic Policy Symposium, Jackson Hole, Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, (2007). 2 Recall that GDP is a flow variable (how much production takes place every period), whereas credit is a stock variable (how much debt there is outstanding). By definition, a flow is a change in a stock. Thus, credit growth affects GDP and the change in credit growth affects GDP growth. Euro area private-sector credit growth accelerated from -2.6% in May 2014 to 3.1% in March 2017, but has been broadly flat ever since. Hence, the credit impulse has dropped. 3 For this calculation, we assume that the fair value for EUR/USD is 1.32, which is close to the IMF's Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) estimate. The annual inflation differential of 0.4% is based on 30-year CPI swaps. This implies that the fair value for EUR/USD will rise to 1.49 after 30 years. If one assumes that the euro reaches that level by then, the common currency would need to trade at 1.49/(1.0194)^30=0.84 today. 4 We are not saying that fiscal policy will be tightened in 2020. Rather, we are saying that the structural budget deficit will stop increasing as the full effects of the tax cuts make their way through the system and higher budgetary appropriations are reflected in increased government spending (there is often a lag between when spending is authorized and when it takes place). It is the change in the fiscal impulse that matters for GDP growth. Recall that Y=C+I+G+X-M. If the government permanently raises G, this will permanently raise Y but will only temporarily raise GDP growth (the change in Y). In other words, as G stops rising in 2020, GDP growth will come back down. Appendix A Appendix A Chart 1Long-Term Return Prospects Are Slightly Better Outside The U.S. Appendix A Chart 1Long-Term Return Prospects Are Slightly Better Outside The U.S. Appendix A Chart 1Long-Term Return Prospects Are Slightly Better Outside The U.S. Appendix A Chart 1Long-Term Return Prospects Are Slightly Better Outside The U.S. Appendix B Appendix B Chart 1Market Outlook: Bonds Appendix B Chart 2Market Outlook: Equities Appendix B Chart 3Market Outlook: Currencies Appendix B Chart 4Market Outlook: Commodities Strategy & Market Trends Tactical Trades Strategic Recommendations Closed Trades
Highlights Oil markets are on tenterhooks, as unplanned outages; continued losses in Venezuela's output; pipeline bottlenecks in the U.S. shales; and a higher likelihood of sharper losses of Iranian exports are priced into global benchmarks. In our updated base-case balances model, we expect core OPEC 2.0 to front-load their just-agreed production increase, with ~ 800k b/d added to the market in 2H18, and just over 210k b/d in 1H19.1 This will lift the core's total output ~ 1.1mm b/d by the end of 1H19 vs. 1H18. This is offset by losses in the rest of OPEC 2.0 of ~ 530k b/d in 2H18, and just under 640k b/d in 1H19. This leaves OPEC 2.0's net output up ~ 275k b/d in 2H18, and down ~ 430k b/d in 1H19 vs. 1H18 levels (Chart of the Week). We keep demand growth at 1.7mm b/d in 2018 and 2019. Our base case is augmented with three scenarios: i) Venezuela production collapses; ii) a reduction in our forecasted U.S. shale production increase arising from pipeline bottlenecks; and iii) both of these occurring simultaneously in the Oct/18 - Sep/19 interval. Our revised Brent ensemble forecast for 2H18 now stands at $70/bbl, versus $76/bbl last month, reflecting the front-loaded OPEC 2.0 production increase. We expect the global benchmark to average $77/bbl next year, against our previous expectation of $73/bbl. We continue to expect WTI to trade $6/bbl under Brent during the next 18 months (Chart 2). Chart of the WeekOPEC 2.0's Core's Production Increase##BR##Offset By Non-Core Losses Chart 2Updated Ensemble Forecast Reflects Venezuela Deterioration, Shale Bottlenecks Highlights Energy: Overweight. We remain long call spreads along the Brent forward curve, given our belief upside risks will dominate oil markets. These positions are up 34.1% on average over the past four months they've been open. We expect backwardation to increase as OECD storage falls, supporting our long S&P GSCI trade, which is up 13.8%. Base Metals: Neutral. In a tit-for-tat response to U.S. tariffs on steel and aluminum, the EU imposed import duties on U.S. products this past Friday. Canada plans to impose tariffs beginning July 1, while Mexico has already implemented duties on U.S. exports. Risks that ongoing trade disputes could escalate into a trade war are weighing on the metals complex. Copper retraced its early June jump, despite ongoing contract renegotiations at Chile's Escondida mine. Precious Metals: Neutral. Gold traded down to the low $1,250/oz level as a stronger broad trade-weighted USD and rising real rates pressure the market. Ags/Softs: Underweight. In effort to diversify its source of imports amid the ongoing trade row with the U.S., China announced the removal of import tariffs on animal feed from five Asian countries earlier this week.2 Ag prices have fallen since the beginning of June amid fears escalating trade fights will bear down on U.S. farmers. Nevertheless, May trade data show China's ag imports have remained robust. Feature In recent weeks, markets have been buffeted by reports of a 350k b/d unplanned outage in Canada; 400k b/d of losses in Libya; continued force majeures in Nigeria's Bonny system; and indications Venezuela's production decline is accelerating: The country's U.S. refiner Citgo was left to fend for itself on the open market, in the wake of the failure of state-run supplier PDVSA to deliver crude. On top of that, markets appear to be pricing in as much as 1mm b/d of lost Iranian exports, on the back of increased pressure from the Trump Administration in the U.S., which is leaning on American allies to take Iranian imports to zero. In our modeling, we continue to expect 500k b/d will be lost to export markets, as a result of the re-imposition of sanctions by the U.S., but are watching the situation closely. The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) is attempting to get out ahead of an almost-certain tightening of the global market. In what appears to be hastily arranged leaks, the Kingdom signaled it already has undertaken a two-month production ramp - lifting its output to record levels this month and next: 10.8mm b/d in June, 11mm b/d in July. This is up from ~ 10mm b/d earlier this year, per over-compliance by KSA on its OPEC 2.0 quota of 10.54mm b/d. Russia, the other putative leader of OPEC 2.0, is signaling it will be able to contribute ~ 200k b/d over 2H18, vs production of ~ 11.2mm b/d at present.3 OPEC 2.0 Front-Loads Output Hike Lacking detail from OPEC 2.0, we are front-loading the coalition's just-agreed production increase in our updated base-case balances model, with ~ 800k b/d added to the market in 2H18, and just over 210k b/d in 1H19. This lifts core OPEC 2.0's output ~ 1.1mm b/d compared to 1H18 levels. Core OPEC 2.0's increased production will be offset by continued losses in the rest of the coalition amounting to ~ 530k b/d in 2H18, and ~ 640k b/d in 1H19. This leaves OPEC 2.0's net output up ~ 275k b/d in 2H18, and down ~ 430k b/d in 1H19 vs. 1H18 levels. Globally, we expect global supply to rise ~ 2mm b/d this year and next, averaging 99.9mm b/d and 101.7mm b/d, respectively. Our base case is augmented with three scenarios: i) Venezuela production collapses to 250k b/d from current levels of ~ 1.3mm b/d, which allows it to support domestic refined product demand and nothing more; ii) a reduction in our forecasted U.S. shale production increase arising from pipeline bottlenecks; and iii) both of these occurring simultaneously in the Oct/18 - Sep/19 interval. In our simulations, a Venezuela collapse would be met by OPEC 2.0's core producers lifting production another 200k b/d, which takes its total output hike to 1.2mm b/d in 2019. OPEC 2.0 does not respond to the temporary lower-than-expected U.S. shale growth contingency we're modeling, which is brought on by pipeline bottlenecks in the Permian Basin. On the demand side, we are keeping annual growth at ~ 1.7mm b/d in 2018 and 2019. For all the agita in the market at present - largely a function of increasingly acrimonious trade frictions between the U.S. and its allies and China - fundamentals remain well supported. Indeed, one of our key gauges, EM trade import volumes, remains well supported (Chart 3). EM import volumes are closely aligned with income levels - as income grows, import volumes grow. Likewise, as EM incomes grow, demand for commodities - particularly oil and copper - grows. Chart 3Growing EM Incomes Support Import Volumes,##BR##And Oil Demand Chart 4Balances Remain##BR##In Deficit As always, EM demand growth paces global growth, rising at a rate of ~ 1.3mm b/d over the 2018 - 19 interval. In 2018, we expect consumption to average just over 100mm b/d globally, while next year we're expecting demand to come in at 102mm b/d. Even with OPEC 2.0's production hike, the contingencies we're modeling - in Venezuela and the U.S. shales - along with weak net growth in overall production volumes for the better part of the next 18 months, leaves global balances in deficit (Chart 4 and Table 1). This continues to force OECD inventories lower over the next 18 months (Chart 5). Table 1BCA Global Oil Supply - Demand Balances (mm b/d) Chart 5Physical Deficits Draw Inventories Lower Our revised Brent ensemble forecast for 2H18 now stands at $70/bbl, versus $76/bbl last month, reflecting the front-loaded OPEC 2.0 production increase. We expect the global benchmark to return to $77/bbl next year, against our previous expectation of $73/bbl. We continue to expect WTI to trade $6/bbl under Brent during the next 18 months (Chart 2). OPEC 2.0 Likely Taps Spare Capacity At this point it appears OPEC 2.0 could be forced to revisit its just-concluded deal to lift production, particularly if, as appears increasingly likely, Venezuela's production collapses, and the market loses its 1mm b/d or so of exports. The country reportedly is falling behind in meeting commitments to its customers, which deprives it of the cash to pay for additives needed to run its heavy oil as a charging stock in refineries. Venezuela's state-owned Citgo refinery operating in the U.S. reportedly is being forced to source crude away from Venezuela, as the barrels it relied on in the past no longer are shipping on schedule. Chart 6Unplanned Outages Are Back Unplanned outages are once again picking up, following a relatively tranquil period (Chart 6). We expect continued volatility in crude oil markets over the next 18 months, particularly if unplanned outages continue to rise, and OPEC 2.0 is forced to cover another event(s) similar to the most recent loss of production in Libya, where civil unrest took ~ 400k b/d off the market, and Canada (~ 350k b/d), where a power failure at Syncrude Canada's oil sands facility in Alberta shut down production. Chart 7Global Spare Capacity Stretched Thin On this score, the market is extremely vulnerable - the U.S. EIA estimates OPEC's spare capacity presently is ~ 1.8mm b/d, most of which is found in KSA. By next year, the EIA expects spare capacity to be slightly over 1mm b/d (Chart 7). Estimated 2018 spare capacity translates into 1.8% of global consumption this year, and a little over 1.0% next year, given our demand estimates of 100mm and 102mm b/d this year and next. By way of comparison, in 2007, spare capacity stood at 2.4% of global demand - 2.1mm b/d vs. 86.4mm b/d. This was the period when WTI prices were headed to $150/bbl, and OPEC was meeting demand out of spare capacity. EM Consumers Exposed China and India pressed OPEC 2.0 leadership to raise production, because, along with other large EM economies, they implemented fuel-subsidy reforms, which expose their consumers to higher fuels costs. This is a key difference in the current cycle vs history: Many more consumers are directly exposed to higher prices. Recent academic research suggests higher prices resulting from strong demand are not destabilizing to economic growth if they reflect rising consumer incomes. However, rising prices due to supply shocks are destabilizing to economic growth, and typically are followed by recession. Higher oil prices resulting from a supply shock - e.g., if Venezuela were to go off line for a long enough period of time - would force OPEC 2.0 and the U.S. shales to replace more than 3mm b/d of lost production. At this point, it is not clear they can do this in short order. Indeed, given the inelasticity of oil demand, it is likely demand destruction - via higher prices - would be required to balance supply and demand globally. Higher prices required to equilibrate markets almost surely would reduce EM oil demand - the dominant source of growth in our models - and derail the global economic recovery, if households' budgets are hit too hard by higher oil prices. Bottom Line: In our revised ensemble forecast for 2H18, we expect Brent crude prices to average $70/bbl, reflecting the front-loaded OPEC 2.0 production increase. We expect the global benchmark to average $77/bbl next year. We continue to expect WTI to trade $6/bbl under Brent during the next 18 months. Higher volatility is expected. We remain long call spreads along the forward curve, and expect backwardation to steepen, which will support our long S&P GSCI recommendation. Robert P. Ryan, Senior Vice President Commodity & Energy Strategy rryan@bcaresearch.com Matt Conlan, Senior Vice President Energy Sector Strategy mattconlan@bcaresearchny.com Hugo Bélanger, Senior Analyst Commodity & Energy Strategy HugoB@bcaresearch.com 1 OPEC 2.0 is the coalition led by the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) and Russia. This past week it agreed to raise production 1mm b/d beginning in July. The core consists of KSA, Russia, Iraq, UAE, Kuwait, Oman, and Qatar. 2 Please see "China drops tariffs on animal feed from Asian countries as U.S. dispute escalates," dated June 26, 2018, available at reuters.com. 3 Please see "Oil rises on supply losses, U.S. push to isolate Iran," published by reuters.com June 27, 2018, for reporting on KSA's intention to go to 11mm b/d. The number reported by Reuters for KSA's June production is slightly less than 800k b/d over the 10.03mm b/d production level for May KSA self-reported in this month's OPEC Monthly Oil Market Report. See also "OPEC, Russia Agree to Raise Production," published June 24, 2018, by egyptoil-gas.com. 11mm b/d would be record production for KSA. Investment Views and Themes Recommendations Strategic Recommendations Tactical Trades Commodity Prices and Plays Reference Table Trades Closed in 2018 Summary of Trades Closed in 2017
NOTE: We will not be publishing a report next week. The next Global Fixed Income Strategy Weekly Report will be published on Tuesday, July 10th. Highlights Global Corporates: The clash between monetary policy and the markets that we have been expecting to unfold in 2018 is upon us. Downgrade global spread product exposure to neutral (3 of 5) from overweight, and raise government bond exposure to neutral. Maintain a below-benchmark portfolio duration, however, as global bond yields have not yet peaked for this cycle. Country Allocation: Move to neutral on U.S. investment grade and high-yield corporates, while staying underweight (2 of 5) on euro area corporates. Downgrade emerging market hard currency sovereign and corporate debt to maximum underweight (1 of 5) - the combination of a rising dollar, Fed tightening and slower Chinese growth will remain a huge problem for emerging market assets. Feature Chart Of The Week3 Big Reasons To Downgrade Spread Product Last week, BCA as a firm moved to a less positive stance on global equities and credit, downgrading both to neutral from overweight on a cyclical (6-12 month) horizon.1 Dating back to our 2018 Outlook published at the end of last December, we had anticipated that we would be shifting to a less aggressive asset allocation sometime around mid-year.2 The expected trigger would be a move by central banks to a more restrictive policy stance that would start to impact future growth expectations. That time has come, and we are now recommending moving to a less bullish stance on global credit. Many of the tailwinds that supported the stellar performance of risk assets in 2017 - most importantly, coordinated global growth, accommodative monetary policies and a weakening U.S. dollar - have transformed into headwinds over the course of 2018 and are unlikely to reverse before risk assets suffer a setback (Chart of the week). At a minimum, there is now enough uncertainty, at a time when many asset classes are richly priced, to make the risk/reward balance for being long growth-sensitive assets like equities and corporate debt less attractive. This week, we are downgrading our recommended stance on global spread product to neutral (3 out of 5) from overweight, while upgrading our recommended allocation for government bonds to neutral from underweight. This represents an unwind of a long-standing recommendation that dates back to January 31st, 2017 when we strategically downgraded U.S. Treasury exposure and upgraded U.S. corporate debt.3 We are closing that recommendation at a relative total return gain of 2.3% for U.S. investment grade and 6.7% for U.S. high-yield over Treasuries (Chart 2). Chart 2Closing A Successful Overweight Stance ##br##On U.S. Corporates We still believe that global bond yields will remain under upward pressure from both higher inflation and a less favorable supply/demand balance for fixed income (more issuance, less central bank buying). The fact that bond yields will NOT be able to fall much to reinvigorate softening global growth - because of rising inflation at a time of diminished economic slack - is a critical reason why we are turning more cautious on global credit. Thus, we are maintaining our recommended below-benchmark overall portfolio duration stance, even as we upgrade our government bond allocation to neutral. We recommend placing the proceeds of a reduction of global corporate debt exposure into shorter-maturity government bonds, which we are doing in our model bond portfolio (see page 15). At the country level, we are downgrading U.S. corporate bonds, both investment grade and high-yield, to neutral from overweight. We still are of the view that U.S. corporates are better positioned to outperform non-U.S. credit, however, even in a more challenging environment for credit returns. Thus we are keeping our recommended underweight allocations to euro area corporate debt (2 out of 5 for both investment grade and high-yield). We see a much nastier backdrop brewing for emerging markets (EM), however - a stronger dollar, higher U.S. interest rates, slowing Chinese growth, diminished global capital flows - so we are downgrading both EM hard currency sovereign and corporate debt to maximum underweight (1 out of 5). In terms of other spread product categories, we are maintaining our neutral allocation to U.S. mortgage-backed securities, while downgrading U.K. and Canadian corporate debt to underweight. For those that can invest in U.S. muni debt, we are upgrading that sector to overweight (4 out of 5). The Reasons To Cut Corporate Credit Exposure Now Global credit has not performed well in the first half of 2018, with only U.S. high-yield corporates providing a positive return year-to-date among the major markets: U.S. investment grade: -3.6% total return, -1.7% excess return over duration-matched Treasuries U.S. high-yield: +0.7% total return, +1.5% excess return Euro area investment grade: -0.3% total return, -1.1% excess return Euro area high-yield: -0.5% total return, -1.0% excess return EM USD-denominated sovereign debt: -5.5% total return, -3.6% excess return EM USD-denominated corporate debt: -2.9% total return, -1.7% excess return Chart 3The Start Of Something Big? While there have been plenty of geopolitical tensions for markets to fret over this year (U.S. trade policy, North Korea), the biggest reason for the underperformance of credit is due to the most typical of reasons - tightening global monetary policy. One way to measure the stance of monetary policy is to look at the slope of government bond yield curves. According to the Bloomberg Barclays government bond index data, the "global yield curve" - the spread between the Global Treasury index yield for the 7-10 year and 1-3 year maturity buckets - is now a mere 6bps (Chart 3). That is the flattest the global curve has been since the first quarter of 2007. That is a potentially ominous sign given that the Global Financial Crisis began brewing around the same time. The global yield curve became deeply inverted in the late 1990s, as well, which preceeded the 1998 EM crisis and, later, the global telecom bust. Fundamentally, we see four main reasons to downgrade global credit now: 1. Global growth is slowing and becoming less synchronized The first half of 2018 has seen a deceleration of global economic activity from the robust pace of 2017. This has been a broad-based cooling of activity so far, with cyclical indicators like manufacturing PMIs still well above the 50 level that suggests expanding growth in all major economies. Yet there are signs that the pullback in growth may persist throughout 2018 and into 2019. The OECD's global leading economic indicator (LEI) is rolling over and our LEI diffusion index - a leading indicator of the LEI - suggests additional weakness should be expected. This is significant for credit markets, as returns on corporate bonds are highly correlated to the swings in the global LEI (Chart 4). This is true even in the U.S., which is bucking the slowing global growth trend and where confidence is booming and domestic leading indicators are accelerating (Chart 5). Chart 4Corporate Bonds Follow The Global LEI Chart 5Upside Risks For U.S. Growth That easing of non-U.S. growth is likely rooted in the slowdown underway in China. Policymakers there have been tightening monetary conditions and acting to reign in excessive debt growth. This has resulted in a slowing of overall economic growth after the stimulus-fueled boom in 2016 that helped kick-start global growth last year through robust Chinese imports and consumption of industrial commodities. Given the sheer size of Chinese demand, the global economy will look very different when Chinese imports are growing at a 30% pace rather than the current pace below 10%. Our most reliable forward-looking indicators for Chinese growth, like our Li Keqiang leading indicator, are calling for additional cooling of Chinese economic activity in the latter half of 2018 (Chart 6). This reinforces the signal given by our global LEI diffusion index, with both indicating that additional struggles in the performance of global credit markets should be expected (based off the relationship shown in Chart 4). One additional point: the ongoing trade tensions between the Trump administration and all of the major U.S. trading partners represents an additional potential downside risk to global growth. The story is still quite fluid, as it always is with this president, but the uncertainty created by the trade frictions is definitely a negative for risk assets, at a minimum. 2. Global inflation pressures are rising, most notably in the U.S. Even with the latest dip in non-U.S. growth, the global economy is still operating with the least amount of spare capacity since the mid-2000s boom. The U.S. unemployment rate is down to 3.8%, the lowest level in eighteen years. 75% of OECD countries now have unemployment rates below the OECD's estimate of the full-employment NAIRU, with capacity utilization rates also rising. The pricing backdrop is as healthy as it has been since 2011, according to the measure of world export prices from the Netherlands-based Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis which is now growing at a 10% annual rate (Chart 7). Chart 6Downside Risks For Chinese Growth Chart 7A More Inflationary Global Backdrop, Especially In The U.S. The previous two times export prices grew that rapidly in 2008 and 2011 - two very challenging years for financial markets - global CPI inflation rates expanded rapidly, especially in the U.S. Headline CPI inflation ended up reaching peaks of 6% and 4%, respectively, during those prior two episodes. Non-U.S. inflation rates also accelerated, but not to the same degree as in the U.S. A similar dynamic is playing out in 2018, with U.S. inflation rates accelerating (both headline and core), at a faster pace than in the other major developed economies. With the U.S. labor market growing tighter each month, and with U.S. growth likely to continue expanding at an above-potential pace for the next few quarters, it is unlikely that the current upturn in U.S. inflation will slow on its own. This will ensure that the Fed will continue on its planned monetary tightening path that will soon take U.S. monetary conditions into restrictive territory - eventually weighing on U.S. growth expectations and raising concerns over future downgrade and default risks, and returns, in U.S. corporate bond markets. 3. Growth and monetary policy divergences will continue to boost the value of the U.S. dollar The divergences between growth, inflation and monetary policy in the U.S. and the rest of the world are now helping raise the value of the U.S. dollar, which had declined nearly 10% on peak-to-trough basis in 2017. The dollar has been rising in 2018, which has been weighing on EM currencies and financial markets as is typically the case during periods of dollar strength. EM economies have been rapidly accumulating dollar-denominated debt in recent years, leaving EM borrowers as highly exposed to the swings in the dollar and interest rates as they have been since the late 1990s. The current backdrop is setting itself up for a repeat of the 2015/16 period when pro-U.S. growth divergences caused the dollar to soar and triggered major selloffs in EM financial assets that spilled over into U.S. and developed market equities and credit (Chart 8). Right now, the moves have been far more modest than seen in the 2015/16 period. Since the start of 2018, the U.S. trade-weighted dollar is up 4% and EM equities are down -6% (in U.S. dollar terms), while U.S. investment grade credit spreads have risen 37bps from the February lows. This is far less than the moves seen in 2015/16, where the dollar rose 16%, EM equities sold off -34% and U.S. credit spreads widened nearly 100bps. Those moves were enough to cause the Fed to delay its rate hike plans after the initial post-QE rate hike in December 2015, triggering a significant decline in U.S. bond yields (bottom panel) and the dollar that eventually stabilized global financial markets. With the U.S. economy in a much healthier position today than two years ago, and with U.S. core inflation running close to the Fed's 2% target, it will take much larger market moves than have been seen of late before the Fed would consider taking a pause on its current 25bps-per-quarter pace of rate hikes. The mechanism for that to happen will be a stronger dollar and any associated impact on U.S. financial markets. However, it must be a very large move (as it was in 2015/16) to have enough of a negative impact on the U.S. economy, U.S. corporate profits or U.S. inflation for financial markets, and the Fed, to take notice. In Chart 9, we show the U.S. trade-weighted dollar with three different scenarios for the change in the currency to the end of 2018: flat, up 5% and up 10%. We show the dollar in level terms in the top panel, while showing the year-over-year growth rate of the dollar (on an inverted scale) in the bottom three panels. In those last three panels, we also show the potential areas where a strong dollar would impact the U.S. economy the most: net exports, corporate profit growth from earnings earned outside the U.S. (using top-down profit data) and headline inflation. Chart 82015/16 Revisited? Not Yet Chart 9A Much Stronger USD Is Needed To Impact U.S. Growth & Inflation The charts show that a 10% rise in the dollar by year-end would likely take enough of a bite out of U.S. growth and inflation for U.S. equity and credit markets to sell off and for the Fed to take a pause on its rate hike plans. A more modest 5% rise in the dollar will have a more muted impact, especially with stronger underlying U.S. growth and inflation pressures than was the case in 2015/16. That latter scenario of a more moderate rise in the dollar would be our most likely scenario - one that would prove to be challenging for U.S. credit market performance. The dollar increase would be enough to keep EM financial markets on the defensive, but would not be large enough to get Fed rate hikes out of the way and allow for a big decline in Treasury yields that would help support risk assets. A slowly rising dollar is another reason to reduce credit exposure in fixed income portfolios. 4. Central bank liquidity provision through asset purchases is slowing rapidly One of our major themes for 2018 has been that the removal of the extraordinary liquidity expansion by central banks would weigh on asset returns. This would occur through the Fed allowing maturing bonds accumulated during its QE program to begin running off its balance sheet, and through a slower pace of bond buying in the case of the European Central Bank (ECB) and the Bank of Japan (BoJ). Already, the increase in developed market bond yields, and the lowering of returns in global equities and credit, have largely followed the path laid out by our indicator of central bank liquidity provision - the annual growth in the balance sheets of the Fed, ECB, BoJ and Bank of England (Chart 10). Our central bank liquidity indicator suggests that there is still more upside for global government bond yields as central banks become less directly active in bond markets. At the same time, the diminished liquidity growth means there is less investor money to be forced out of risk-free government bonds into risky assets like corporate credit, which should help erode credit market returns on the margin. This will occur through reduced inflows into credit that are just chasing yield, and a return to more fundamental drivers of credit market valuation like growth, inflation, leverage and downgrade/default risks - all of which are now on the rise in the U.S. Bottom Line: The clash between monetary policy and the markets that we have been expecting to unfold in 2018 is upon us. Tightening monetary policies, rising bond yields, slowing global growth, widening growth divergences, increasing U.S. inflation pressures, a strengthening U.S. dollar, emerging market instability, diminished central bank liquidity, reduced global capital flows, global trade tensions - all are now creating a backdrop that is more challenging for risk assets. Downgrade global spread product exposure to neutral (3 of 5) from overweight, and raise government bond exposure to neutral. Maintain a below-benchmark portfolio duration, however, as global bond yields have not yet peaked for this cycle. Asset Allocation Decisions To Be Made So in terms of our fixed income asset allocation recommendations, but in our strategic tables on page 16 and our model bond portfolio on page 15, we are making the following changes: Downgrade U.S. Investment Grade & High-Yield Corporates To Neutral (3 out of 5) The bulk of our primary indicators for U.S. credit are at levels that are consistent with a neutral allocation (Chart 11). Our top-down Corporate Health Monitor is right at the line dividing the deteriorating health and improving health regimes (although this is only because of a cyclical improvement in some of the underlying indicators). U.S. monetary policy is close to neutral, as measured by the real fed funds rate versus the Fed's r-star estimate. The U.S. Treasury curve is very flat, although it is not yet inverted as typically precedes the end of a credit cycle. Finally, bank lending standards are only modestly in "net easing" territory according to the Fed's senior loan officer survey. Chart 10Fading Impact Of Global QE On Bond Markets Chart 11Downgrade U.S. IG & HY Corporates To Neutral With all these indicators hovering around neutral levels, a neutral allocation to U.S. corporates seems justified. Additionally, we recommend cutting across all credit tiers for both investment grade and high-yield, rather than focusing on cutting a specific tier more than another. Our preferred valuation metric - the 12-month breakeven spread relative to its history - is near the bottom quartile for all credit tiers (Charts 12 & 13) without one looking particularly more expensive than the others. Chart 12Not Much Of A Spread Cushion In U.S. Investment Grade ... Chart 13... Or U.S. High-Yield Keep Euro Area Investment Grade & High-Yield At Underweight (2 out of 5) We have maintained this strategic view based on the convergence between our top-down Corporate Health Monitors for both the U.S. and euro area. Right now, the cyclical improvement in U.S. financial metrics has come at the same time as a cyclical deterioration of euro area metrics from very healthy levels (Chart 14). The spread between the two Monitors has proven to be a good directional indicator for the relative performance between U.S. and euro area credit. That spread continues to point to additional expected outperformance by U.S. corporates, even in an overall more challenging environment for global credit markets. Throw in increased Italian political turmoil, softer euro area growth and the upcoming ECB tapering of its asset purchases - which will include corporate debt that the ECB has been buying steadily for the past three years - and the case for underweighting euro area corporates, especially versus U.S. equivalents, is a strong one. Downgrade EM Hard Currency Sovereign & Corporate Debt To Maximum Underweight (1 out of 5) We have been favoring U.S. investment grade credit over EM credit the past several months. The growth divergence between the U.S. and EM has been widening, while EM market valuations had gotten very rich. Now, EM spread widening is starting to correct that mis-valuation, although is still early in the process. The spread differential between U.S and EM credit is a good leading indicator of the relative returns between the two asset classes (Chart 15), thus last year's EM outperformance is leading to this year's underperformance. Chart 14Stay Underweight Euro Area Corporates Chart 15Move To Maximum Underweight EM Credit We wish to maintain the same "two notch" gap between our recommended level of U.S. and EM credit exposure, so by downgrading U.S. corporates to neutral (3 of 5), we must downgrade EM corporates to maximum underweight (1 of 5). All of the above changes will be reflected in our model bond portfolio on page 15. One final point - we should lay out the case for out next move from here. If the Fed tightening cycle goes as we envision it will, with U.S. growth staying strong and inflation expectations rising back to levels consistent with the Fed's inflation target, then we expect the next move will be to downgrade U.S. corporates to underweight. However, if there is enough of a market setback to cause the Fed to delay its rate hike cycle, as was the case in 2016, then we may consider moving back to overweight U.S. corporates on a tactical basis. We suspect, however, that the moves today are the beginning of the end game for the current credit cycle - the negatives for corporates are now outweighing the positives, and that gap is likely to get wider in the coming months. Robert Robis, Senior Vice President Global Fixed Income Strategy rrobis@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see BCA Global Investment Strategy Special Report, "Three Policy Puts Go Kaput: Downgrade Global Equities To Neutral", dated June 19th 2018, available at gis.bcaresearch.com. 2 Please see BCA Global Fixed Income Strategy Weekly Report, "2018 Key Views: BCA's Outlook & What It Means For Global Fixed Income Markets", dated December 5th 2017, available at gfis.bcaresearch.com. 3 Please see BCA Global Fixed Income Strategy Weekly Report, "The Global Growth Upturn Has Legs: Reduce Duration, Upgrade Credit Exposure", dated January 31st 2017, available at gfis.bcaresearch.com. Recommendations The GFIS Recommended Portfolio Vs. The Custom Benchmark Index Duration Regional Allocation Spread Product Tactical Trades Yields & Returns Global Bond Yields Historical Returns
Highlights Global Inflation has upside on a cyclical basis, but this narrative is well known and investors have already placed their bets accordingly, buying inflation protection in a wide swath of markets. However, global growth has not yet found its footing, suggesting a mini-deflation scare, at least relative to expectations, is likely this summer. The U.S. dollar will benefit in such a scenario, and NOK/SEK will depreciate. While GBP/USD has downside, the pound should rally versus the euro. Weakness in EUR/CAD has not yet fully played out; the recent bout of strength was only a countertrend move. Feature Inflation is coming back, and this will obviously have major consequences for both asset and currency markets. However, macro investing is not just about forecasting fundamentals correctly; often, just as importantly, it is about understanding how other investors have priced in these expected economic developments. Therein lies the problem. While we understand why inflation could pick up, so too have most investors, and they have positioned themselves accordingly. With global growth currently looking shaky, we believe a better entry point for long-inflation plays will emerge in the coming months. In the meanwhile, a defensive, pro-U.S. dollar posture still makes sense. Investors Are Long Inflation Bets We have long argued that inflation was likely to make a cyclical comeback, a return that would begin in the U.S. before spreading to the rest of the globe. This story is currently playing out. However, in response these developments, investors have placed their bets accordingly, and the story currently seems well baked in. Prices of assets traditionally levered to inflation have already moved to discount a significant pick-up in inflation. The most evident dynamics can be observed in the U.S. inflation breakevens. Both the 10-year breakevens as well as the 5-year/5-year forward breakevens just experienced some of their sharpest two-year changes of the past 20 years, notwithstanding the pricing out of a post-Lehman, depression-like outcome (Chart I-1). Breakevens are not alone. Other assets have displayed similar behavior. In the U.S., investors have aggressively sold their holdings of utilities stocks, which have been greatly outperformed by industrial stocks. Traditionally, investors lift the price of XLI relative to that of XLU when they anticipate global inflation to pick up (Chart I-2). Chart I-1Markets Are Positioning Themselves##br## For Higher Inflation Chart I-2U.S. Sectoral Performance Suggests Investors ##br##Have Already Bet On Higher Inflation... It is not just intra-equity market dynamics that support this assertion. The behavior of the U.S. stock market relative to Treasurys further buttresses the idea that investors have already aggressively discounted an upturn in global consumer prices (Chart I-3). Potentially, the best illustration of investors' preference for inflation protection is currently visible in EM assets. A seemingly paradoxical phenomenon has been puzzling us: How have EM equities managed to avoid the gravitational pull that has caused EM bonds to nearly flirt with the nadir of early 2016? After all, EM equities, EM currencies and EM bonds are normally closely correlated, driven by investors' wagers on the direction of global growth. A simple variable can explain this strange dichotomy: anticipated inflation. As Chart I-4 illustrates, the performance of a volatility adjusted long EM stocks / short EM bonds portfolio tends to anticipate fluctuations in global inflation. The current price action in this basket indicates that investors have made their bets, and they think inflation is going up. Chart I-3...So Does The Stock-To-Bond Ratio Chart I-4Inflation Bets Explain Why EM Stocks And EM Bond Prices Have Diverged Anecdotal evidence suggests that in recent quarters, pension plans have been aggressive buyers of commodities - a move that normally coincides with these long-term investors putting in place some inflation hedges. Moreover, positioning in the futures markets corroborates these stories: speculators are still very long commodities like copper and oil - commodities traditionally perceived as efficient protectors against inflation spikes (Chart I-5). Finally, despite the potentially deflationary risks created by Italy three weeks ago, speculators remain short U.S. Treasury futures, bond investors are underweight duration, and sentiment toward the bond market remains near its lowest levels of the past eight years (Chart I-6). Again, this behavior is consistent with investors being positioned for an inflationary environment. Chart I-5Money Has Flown Into Resources Chart I-6Bond Market Positioning Is Still Very Short Bottom Line: There is a well-defined case to be made that a global economy that was not so long ago defined by the presence of deflationary risks is now morphing into a world where inflation is on the upswing. However, based on inflation breakevens, sectoral relative performance, equities relative to bonds in both DM and EM as well as on the positioning of investors in commodity and bond markets, this changing state has been quickly discounted by investors. The Decks Are Stacked, But Where Does The Economic Risk Lie? The problem facing investors already long inflation protection every which way they can be is that the global economy is slowing, which normally elicits deflationary fears, not inflationary ones. This seems a recipe for disappointment, albeit one that is likely to help the dollar. Our global economic and financial A/D line, which tallies the proportion of key variables around the world moving in a growth-friendly fashion, has fallen precipitously. This normally heralds a slowdown in global economic activity (Chart I-7). Chart I-7Global Growth Is Losing Traction In similar vein, global leading economic indicators have also begun to roll over - a trend that could gain further vigor if the diffusion index of OECD economies experiencing rising versus contracting LEIs is to be believed (Chart I-8). The global liquidity picture has also deteriorated enough to warrant caution. Currency carry strategies - as approximated by the performance of EM carry trades funded in yen - have sagged violently. This tells us that funds are flowing out of EM economies and moving back to countries already replete with excess savings like Japan or Switzerland (Chart I-9). Historically, these kinds of negative developments for global liquidity have preceded industrial slowdowns, as EM now accounts for the lion's share of global IP growth. Finally, China doesn't yet look set to bail out the world's industrial sector. This month's money and credit numbers were weaker than anticipated, and our leading indicator for the Li-Keqiang index - our preferred gauge of industrial activity in the Middle Kingdom - points to further weakness (Chart I-10). This makes it unlikely that China's imports will rise, lifting global growth. Additionally, China has re-stocked in various commodities, suggesting it is front-running its own domestic demand, highlighting the risk that its commodities intake could become even weaker than what domestic growth implies. Chart I-8More Weakness In LEIs Chart I-9Global Liquidity Tightening Chart I-10China Not Yet Set To Bail Out The World With this kind of backdrop, we expect the current slowdown in global growth to run further before ebbing, probably in response to what will be a policy move out some kind from China to put a floor under growth. As a result, the current infatuation with inflation hedges among investors may wane for a bit as slower growth could shock inflation expectations downward, especially in a global context that has been defined by excess capacity since the late 1990s. An environment where global inflation expectations could be downgraded in response to slower growth is likely to be an environment where the dollar performs well, particularly as U.S. growth continues to outperform global growth (Chart I-11). This also confirms our analysis from two weeks ago that showed that when bonds rally the dollar tends to outperform most currencies, with the exception of the yen.1 Moreover, with the Federal Open Market Committee upgrading its path for interest rates by one additional hike in 2018, this reinforces the message from our previous work noting that once the fed funds rate moves in the vicinity of r-star, the dollar performs well, nearly eradicating the losses it incurred when the fed funds rate rises but is well below the neutral rate (Table I-1). This is especially true if vulnerability to higher rates rests outside - not inside - the U.S., as is currently the case.2 Chart I-11The Dollar Likes Lower Global Inflation Table I-1Fed And The Dollar: Where We Stand Matters As Much As The Direction Beyond the dollar, one particular currency cross has historically been a good correlate to investors betting on higher inflation: NOK/SEK. As Chart I-12 illustrates, when investors buy inflation hedges such as going long EM equities relative to EM bonds, this generates a rally in NOK/SEK. These dynamics played in our favor when we were long this cross earlier this year. However, not only are EM equities extended relative to EM bonds, the current economic environment portends a growing risk of investors curtailing these kinds of bets. The implication is bearish for NOK/SEK, and we recommend investors sell this cross at current levels. Chart I-12NOK/SEK Suffers If Inflation Bets Are Unwound Bottom Line: Investors have quickly and aggressively positioned themselves to protect their portfolios against upside inflation risks. However, the global economy is still slowing - a development that has further to run. As a result, this current anticipation of inflation could easily morph into a temporary fear of deflation, at least relative to lofty expectations. This would undo the dynamics previously seen in the market. This is historically an environment in which the dollar performs well, suggesting the greenback rally is not over. Moreover, NOK/SEK could suffer in this environment. The Bad News Is Baked Into The Pound There is no denying that the data flow out of the U.K. has been poor of late. In fact, despite what was already a low bar for expectations, the U.K. economy has managed to generate large negative surprises (Chart I-13). One of the direct drivers of this poor performance has been the complete meltdown in the British credit impulse (Chart I-14). Additionally, the slowdown in British manufacturing can be easily understood in the context of slowing global growth (Chart I-15). Chart I-13Anarchy In The U.K. Chart I-14The Credit Impulse Has Bitten Chart I-15U.K. Exports Are Slowing Because Of Global Growth But, the bad new seems well priced into the pound, especially when compared to the euro. Not only is the GBP trading at a discount to the EUR on our fundamental and Intermediate-term timing models, speculators have accumulated near-record short bets on the pound versus the euro (Chart I-16). This begs the question: Could any positive factor come in and surprise investors, resulting in a fall in EUR/GBP? We think the answer to this question is yes. First, despite the negatives already priced in, incremental bad news have had little traction in dragging the pound lower versus the euro in recent weeks, suggesting that EUR/GBP buying has become exhausted. Second, a falling EUR/USD tends to weigh on EUR/GBP, as the pound tends to act as a low-beta version of the euro (Chart I-17). Chart I-16Investors Are Well Aware Of Britain's Problems Chart I-17EUR/GBP Sags When EUR/USD Weakens Third, the economic outlook for the U.K. is improving. It is true that in the context of slowing global growth, the manufacturing and export sectors are unlikely to be a source of positive surprises for Great Britain. However, the domestic economy could well be. As Chart I-14 highlights, the credit impulse has collapsed, but the good news is that outside of the Great Financial Crisis it has never fallen much below current levels, suggesting that a reversion to the mean may be in offing. Additionally, U.K. inflation is peaking, which is lifting British real wages (Chart I-18). In response, depressed consumer confidence is picking up. This is crucial as consumer spending, which represents roughly 70% of the U.K.'s GDP, has been the key drag on growth since 2016. Any improvement on this front will lift the whole British economy, even if the manufacturing sector remains soft. Fourth, Brexit is progressing. This week's vote in the House of Commons was confusing, but it is important to note than an amendment that gives Westminster the right to force a renegotiation between the U.K. and the EU if no deal is reached in 2019 has been passed. This also decreases the risk of a completely economically catastrophic Brexit down the road, but increases the risk that PM Theresa May could be ousted over the next 12 months. Our positive view on the pound versus the euro (or negative EUR/GBP bias) is not mimicked in cable itself. Ultimately, despite the GBP/USD's beta to EUR/GBP being below one, it is nonetheless greater than zero. As such, it is unlikely that GBP/USD will be able to rally if the DXY rallies and the EUR/USD weakens (Chart I-19). Therefore, while we recommend selling EUR/GBP, we are not willing buyers of GBP/USD. Chart I-18A Crucial Support To Growth Chart I-19Cable Will Not Avoid The Downward Pull Of A Strong Dollar Bottom Line: The British economy has undergone a period of weakness, which is already reflected in the very negative positioning of investors in the GBP versus the EUR. However, the bad data points are losing their capacity to push EUR/GBP higher, and the British economy may begin to heal as consumer confidence is rebounding thanks to improving real wages. The low beta of GBP/USD to the euro also implies that a falling EUR/USD will weigh on EUR/GBP. However, while the pound has upside against the euro, it will continue to suffer against the dollar if EUR/USD experiences further downside. What To Do With EUR/CAD? One weeks ago, we were stopped out of our short EUR/CAD trade. Has EUR/CAD finished its fall, or was the recent rally a pause within a downward channel? We are inclined to think the latter. Heated rhetoric on trade has hit the CAD harder than the EUR, as exports to the U.S. represent a much larger share of Canada's GDP than of the euro area, forcing the pricing of a risk premium in the loonie. However, even after a rather explosive G7 meeting, we do believe that a compromise is still feasible and that NAFTA is not dead on arrival. A deal is still likely because, as Chart I-20 demonstrates, Canadian tariffs on U.S. imports are not only marginally in excess of U.S. tariffs on Canadian imports, they are also in line with international comparisons. This suggests only a small push is needed to arrive to a deal that salvages NAFTA, which ultimately is much more important to Canada than the dairy industry. Chart I-20Canada And The U.S. Can Find A Compromise Despite this reality, we cannot be too complacent, U.S. President Donald Trump is likely to be playing internal politics ahead of the upcoming mid-term elections. U.S. citizens are distrustful of free trade (Chart I-21), a trend especially pronounced among his base. However, a good result for the GOP in November is contingent on the Republican base showing up at the polls. Firing this base up with inflammatory trade rhetoric is a sure way to do so. This means that risks around NAFTA are still not nil. Chart I-21America Belongs To The Anti-Globalization Bloc However, EUR/CAD continues to trade at a substantial premium to fair-value on an intermediate-term horizon (Chart I-22). Moreover, as the last panel of the chart illustrates, speculators remain massively short the CAD against the EUR. This creates a cushion for the CAD versus the EUR if global growth slows. Moreover, technicals are still favorable of shorting EUR/CAD. Not only is EUR/CAD still overbought on a 52-week rate-of-change basis, it seems to be in the process of forming a five-wave downward pattern, with the fourth one - a countertrend wave - potentially ending (Chart I-23). Chart I-22EUR/CAD Is Still Vulnerable Chart I-23Wave Pattern Not Completed Finally, EUR/CAD tends to perform poorly when the USD strengthens, which fits with our current thematic for the remainder of 2018. Bottom Line: The headline risk surrounding NAFTA has weighed on the loonie against the euro, stopping us out of our short EUR/CAD trade with a small profit. However, the valuation, positioning and technical dynamics suggest the timing is ripe to short this cross once again. Mathieu Savary, Vice President Foreign Exchange Strategy mathieu@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, titled "Rome Is Burning: Is It The End?", dated June 1, 2018, available at fes.bcaresearch.com 2 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report, titled "This Time Is NOT Different", dated May 25, 2018, available at fes.bcaresearch.com Currencies U.S. Dollar Chart II-1USD Technicals 1 Chart II-2USD Technicals 2 U.S. data was stellar: NFIB Business Optimism Index climbed to 107.8, outperforming expectations; the price changes and good times to expand components are also very strong; Headline and core PPI both outperformed expectations, auguring well for future consumer inflation; Headline and core retail sales grew by 0.8% and 0.9% in monthly terms, beating expectations; Both initial and continuing jobless claims also came out below expectations, highlighting that the labor market is still tightening, and wage growth could pick up further. The Fed raised interest rates this week to 2%, and added one additional rate hike to its guidance for 2018. FOMC members once again highlighted the "symmetric" target, suggesting that the Fed expects the economy to overheat slightly. An outperforming U.S. economy relative to the rest of the world is likely to propel the greenback this year. Report Links: This Time Is NOT Different - May 25, 2018 Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 The Euro Chart II-3EUR Technicals 1 Chart II-4EUR Technicals 2 Economic data was largely disappointing: Italian industrial output contracted by 1.2% on a monthly basis, and grew only by 1.9% on a yearly basis; The German ZEW Survey declined substantially across all metrics; European industrial production increased by 1.7% annually, less than the expected 2.8% increase; However, Spanish headline inflation spiked up from 1.1% to 2.1%. Yesterday, ECB President Mario Draghi announced the ECB's plan to taper asset purchases to EUR 15 bn a month in September, and phase them out completely by year-end. Moreover, Draghi highlighted that the ECB was not anticipating to implement its first hike until after the summer of 2019. Furthermore, the ECB President highlighted the current slowdown in global growth, as well as the rising protectionist risk from the U.S. potentially negatively impacting the European economy and the ECB's decisions going forward, suggesting that the plans are not set in stone. 2018 is likely to remain a volatile year for the euro. Report Links: Rome Is Burning: Is It The End? - June 1, 2018 This Time Is NOT Different - May 25, 2018 Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 The Yen Chart II-5JPY Technicals 1 Chart II-6JPY Technicals 2 Japanese data has been strong this week: Machine orders increased on a 9.6% annual basis, and a 10.1% monthly basis, in April, outperforming expectations by a large margin; The Domestic Corporate Goods Price Index also increased by 2.7% annually, higher than the expected 2.2% increase. As political and economic risks in Europe and South America having subsided for now, the yen has lost some of its glitter. However, with ongoing uncertainty on trade and populism across the globe, we maintain our tactically bullish stance on the yen, especially against commodity currencies and the euro. However, beyond the short-term horizon, the BoJ will remain determined to cap any excess appreciation in the yen, as a strong JPY tightens Japanese financial conditions, weighing on the BoJ's ability to hit its inflation target. This will ultimately limit the yen's upside on a cyclical basis. Report Links: Rome Is Burning: Is It The End? - June 1, 2018 Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 British Pound Chart II-7GBP Technicals 1 Chart II-8GBP Technicals 2 Data from the U.K. was somewhat disappointing: Manufacturing and industrial production both increased less than expected, at 1.4% and 1.8%, respectively; The goods trade deficit widened to GBP 14.03bn from GBP 12bn, and the overall trade deficit widened to GBP 5.28bn from GBP 3.22bn; Average earnings grew by 2.8%, less than the expected 2.9%; However, headline inflation came in at 2.4%, less than the expected 2.5%, while retail price inflation also underperformed expectations. This means that the uptrend in real wages continues. Given the limited movement in the pound, it seems that a lot of the bad news was already priced in by last month's depreciation. However, Theresa May's ongoing blunders in parliament represent a continued source of risk for the pound. While the GBP has downside against the EUR, it is unlikely to see much upside against the greenback. Report Links: Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 Do Not Get Flat-Footed By Politics - March 30, 2018 Australian Dollar Chart II-9AUD Technicals 1 Chart II-10AUD Technicals 2 Australian data was weak: NAB Business Confidence and Conditions surveys both declined, also underperforming expectations; Australian employment grew by 12,000, less than expected. Moreover, full-time employment contracted. While the unemployment rate dropped as a result, this was largely due to a fall in the participation rate. RBA's Governor Lowe, in a speech on Wednesday, announced that any increase in interest rates "still looks some time away" as the slack in the labor market does not seem to be diminishing. Annual wage growth has been constant at 2.1% for the past three quarters, and did not pick up despite an improvement in full-time employment earlier this year. We remain bearish on the AUD. Report Links: Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 Who Hikes Again? - February 9, 2018 New Zealand Dollar Chart II-11NZD Technicals 1 Chart II-12NZD Technicals 2 The NZD is likely to face significant downside against the greenback along with the other commodity currencies as global growth slows down. However, due to its weaker linkages to Chinese industrial demand, the kiwi is likely to see less downside than the AUD. Nevertheless, it is likely to weaken against the CAD and the NOK as the NZD is expensive against these oil currencies, and oil's is likely to continue to outperform other commodities will support this view. Report Links: Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 Who Hikes Again? - February 9, 2018 Canadian Dollar Chart II-13CAD Technicals 1 Chart II-14CAD Technicals 2 USD/CAD has been on an uptrend given the greenback generally strong performance since February year, a force magnified by the volatile rhetoric surrounding NAFTA negotiations. However, the Canadian economy has been accelerating this year, thanks to robust growth in the U.S., to a strong Quebecer economy, and to a pickup in Alberta. In addition, the Canadian labor market is tightening further and wage growth is above 3%. Furthermore, risks surrounding NAFTA seem already reflected in the CAD's behavior and valuation. There is more clarity on the CAD versus its crosses than on the CAD versus the USD. Outperforming U.S. and Canadian growth relative to the rest of the world mean that the CAD should outperform most other G10 currencies. Report Links: Rome Is Burning: Is It The End? - June 1, 2018 Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 Swiss Franc Chart II-15CHF Technicals 1 Chart II-16CHF Technicals 2 Recent data out of Switzerland was decent: Industrial production increased by 9% in annual terms, albeit less than the previous 19.6% growth; Producer and import prices increased by 3.2% year on year, in line with expectations, however the monthly increase underperformed markets anticipations. With global trade tensions rising, and Germany having entered President Trump's line of sight, the CHF could experience additional upside against the euro in the coming months. However, the SNB is unlikely to deviate from its ultra-accommodative stance, which means that any downside in EUR/CHF will proved to be short lived. Report Links: Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 The SNB Doesn't Want Switzerland To Become Japan - March 23, 2018 Norwegian Krone Chart II-17NOK Technicals 1 Chart II-18NOK Technicals 2 Both headline and core inflation underperformed, coming in at 2.3% and 1.2%, respectively. However, the Regional Network Survey hinted at a pickup in capacity utilization as expectations for industrial output remained robust, as well as at an additional strength in employment. This led to a forecast of a resurgence in inflationary pressures. We expect the NOK to outperform the EUR. Report Links: Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 Who Hikes Again? - February 9, 2018 Swedish Krona Chart II-19SEK Technicals 1 Chart II-20SEK Technicals 2 Swedish inflation rose from 1.7% to 1.9%, coming in line with expectations. Additionally, Prospera 1-year inflation expectations survey rose to 1.9% from 1.8% in the March survey. This is likely to provide the Riksbank with reasons to turn gradually more hawkish, which should support the very cheap krona. Report Links: Updating Our Intermediate Timing Models - May 18, 2018 Value Strategies In FX Markets: Putting PPP To The Test - May 11, 2018 Who Hikes Again? - February 9, 2018 Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Closed Trades
Highlights The chaotic conclusion to last weekend's G7 summit in Charlevoix is a reminder that the specter of trade wars will not fade quietly into the night. A trade war would hurt the U.S., but would punish the rest of the world even more. The U.S. dollar typically strengthens when global trade slows. Despite President Trump's antics, the dollar is at little risk of losing its status as the world's premier reserve currency. Fiscal stimulus should keep U.S. growth above trend well into next year, allowing the Fed to maintain its once-per-quarter pace of rate hikes. We are currently overweight global equities, but we expect to shift to neutral before the end of the year. Feature Hit First, Ask Questions Later Donald's Trump's negotiating style - hit as hard as you can and then compromise - has worked well in dealing with tin-pot dictators, at least judging by the apparent outcome of this week's Singapore summit with Kim Jong-Un. It has also worked well throughout Trump's career as a real estate developer. However, as the breakdown of last weekend's G7 summit demonstrates, it is not clear if it is a winning strategy in the realm of international trade. Down-on-their-luck creditors may be willing to settle for twenty cents on the dollar when they had been promised one hundred, but governments have their citizens to answer to, and national pride often trumps (ahem) narrow financial interests in such matters. How Not To Fight A Trade War The U.S. is a fairly closed economy and hence a trade war probably would not have severe effects on growth. However, the way Trump is waging his war ensures that whatever impact it has on the domestic economy will be negative. This is not only because Trump's tariffs are certain to invite retaliation; it is also because Trump is targeting intermediate goods - goods that are used as inputs into production of final goods - for tariffs. Chart 1Rising Productivity In The Steel Sector ##br##Caused Employment To Decline Consider the case of steel. Today, the U.S. steel industry employs just 145,000 workers, down from 203,000 workers in 2000. In contrast, there are about two million workers employed in steel-consuming sectors of the economy.1 A reasonable rule-of-thumb from the international trade literature is that a one-percent increase in foreign prices causes domestic prices to rise by about half a percent. This is mainly because domestic producers end up capturing some of the gains from tariffs through higher profit margins. A 25% increase in steel tariffs would thus raise steel prices by around 12.5%. Higher steel prices will lead to higher prices for many American goods such as automobiles, some of which are exported abroad. It is actually quite conceivable that steel tariffs would reduce exports more than they would depress imports, leading to a wider trade deficit. Ironically, foreign competition probably explains only a small fraction of the decline in U.S. steel employment. The U.S. produces roughly as much steel now as it did in 2000 (Chart 1). What has changed is that output-per-worker in the steel industry has increased by a total of 43% since then. Blame technological progress, not trade. Trade Wars, The Fed, And The Dollar Chart 2The Dollar Tends To Strengthen ##br##When Global Trade Deteriorates Even if higher tariffs did produce a one-off increase in consumer and producer prices, slower GDP growth would likely prompt the Fed to moderate the pace of rate hikes. If the stock market declined in sympathy with slower growth and rising protectionist sentiment, the resulting tightening in financial conditions would further justify a go-slow approach to monetary normalization. All things equal, a more dovish-than-expected Fed would likely translate into a weaker dollar. All things are not equal, however. A trade war would probably hurt the rest of the world more than the U.S. This is partly because the rest of the world is more open to trade, but it is also because the rest of the world runs a trade surplus with the U.S., which makes it more vulnerable to a broad-based decline in trade volumes. Chart 2 shows that the dollar tends to strengthen when global trade is weakening. Reserve Currency Status In Jeopardy? An often-heard counterargument to the "protectionism is good for the dollar" view is that at some point, rising trade tensions could undermine the dollar's standing as the world's premier reserve currency. The U.S. has run a trade deficit almost continuously for 40 years, accumulating 40% of GDP in net liabilities to the rest of the world in the process (Chart 3). If foreign buyers decide to scale back their purchases of U.S. assets, the dollar could swoon. Chart 3U.S. External Deficit: 40 Years And Counting Trump's statement at the conclusion of the G7 summit that "We're like a piggy bank that everybody's robbing" seems to imply that he thinks that foreigners are living beyond their means by draining the U.S. of its wealth. The opposite is actually the case: The U.S. has been able to spend more than it earns for decades precisely because foreigners have been willing to deposit ever more money into the U.S. piggy bank. Fortunately for the greenback, America's status as the world's piggy bank of choice is unlikely to change any time soon. The euro area remains hopelessly divided. The Italian bond market - the biggest in Europe - has once again become the object of investor angst. Japan is drowning in a sea of government debt, with debt monetization probably the only viable solution. China would like to transform the renminbi into a global reserve currency, but opacity in government decision-making, and a still largely closed capital account, will limit any progress towards that goal for some time to come. China and other countries could try to "punish" the U.S. government by buying fewer Treasury bonds, but where would that get them? The average maturity of U.S. government debt is less than six years. The Fed, not China, largely sets rates at that portion of the yield curve. Granted, a decline in Treasury purchases would reduce the demand for dollars. However, that would just put upward pressure on the value of the renminbi. China does not want a stronger currency. For all the talk about how America's rivals are keen to reduce their dollar holdings, their share of global central bank reserves has actually climbed over the past two decades, largely because they have been gobbling up dollars to keep their own currencies from appreciating (Chart 4). Today, nearly two-thirds of global currency reserves are denominated in dollars, a higher proportion than when the Berlin Wall fell in 1989 (Chart 5). Chart 4Geopolitics Is Not Driving Demand For Treasurys Chart 5The Dollar Remains The Preferred Reserve Currency A Not So Exorbitant Privilege Chart 6The U.S. Term Premium Is ##br##Higher Than Elsewhere In any case, it's not clear how much the U.S. benefits from having a reserve currency. There is little evidence that U.S. long-term bond yields are lower than they would otherwise be because of foreign reserve accumulation. Chart 6 shows that the term premium - the difference between the yield on a long-term bond and the market's expectation of the average level of short-term rates over the life of the bond - is higher in the U.S. than in the rest of the world. If foreign central bank purchases were pushing down U.S. bond yields, one would expect to see the reverse pattern. The only tangible benefit the United States gets from having a reserve currency is that the U.S. Treasury can issue currency to foreigners who hold it as a store of value rather than spending it. This amounts to an interest-free loan to the U.S. government. This so-called "seigniorage revenue" is not trivial: Last year, foreigners increased their holdings of U.S. currency by $60 billion.2 However, this is still less than one-third of one percent of U.S. GDP. What Really Explains Why The U.S. Has A Current Account Deficit? It is often argued that the dollar's reserve currency status has allowed the U.S. to run large current account deficits. However, Australia has run even bigger current account deficits than the U.S., and it does not have a reserve currency. What matters in the end is whether people trust you to pay back your debts, not whether you have a reserve currency. The rate of return that a country offers investors is also important. As we explained in our weekly report on April 6th, an often-overlooked reason for why the U.S. and Australia run current account deficits is that both countries enjoy faster trend growth than most of their peers.3 Faster growth tends to push up the neutral real rate of interest, otherwise known as r-star. A country with a relatively low neutral rate needs to have an "undervalued" currency that is expected to appreciate over time in order to compensate investors for the subpar yield that its bonds provide. As sketched out in Chart 7, this results in current account surpluses for countries with low neutral rates, and current account deficits for countries with high neutral rates. Chart 7Interest Rates And Current Account Balances Commentators who claim that the euro is cheap are barking up the wrong tree. The euro needs to be cheap to entice investors into holding low-yielding German bunds and other safe-haven euro area bond markets. Indeed, one could argue that the euro is not cheap enough. Thirty-year U.S. Treasurys currently yield 3.07% while 30-year German bunds yield 1.16%, a difference of 191 basis points. Even if one allows for the fact that investors expect euro area inflation to be lower than in the U.S. over the next 30 years, EUR/USD would need to trade at a measly 84 cents today in order to compensate German bund holders for the inferior yield they will receive.4 The euro got a good clobbering yesterday following the release of the ECB's post-meeting statement, which established a timeline for ending asset purchases by the end of this year but promised no rate hikes for at least another 12 months. We continue to expect EUR/USD to hit 1.15, with a high likelihood that it goes even lower. Lessons From The Nixon Shock We are skeptical of the argument that threatening to raise tariffs is an effective tool for talking down one's currency. It is true that the Nixon Administration imposed an across-the-board 10% tariff in August 1971, which succeeded in forcing America's trading partners to revalue their currencies within the quasi-fixed exchange-rate Bretton Woods system that prevailed at that time. Such an arrangement would be difficult to orchestrate today. For one thing, the U.S. does not have the geopolitical sway that it once did. Moreover, when exchange rates are pegged, one can often revalue a currency to the upside while cutting interest rates (if investors expect a series of revaluations, they would be willing to hold government bonds even if they yielded less than those abroad). In today's world of flexible exchange rates, a country would need to be willing to tighten monetary policy to drive up its currency. Thus, it would get hit on two fronts: From a stronger currency and from higher interest rates. This additional cost to the economy lowers the odds that any country would voluntarily undertake such measures in the hope (probably futile anyway) of placating Trump. In any case, most of the dollar's weakness in the 1970s occurred after the December 1971 Smithsonian Agreement reversed Nixon's tariff hike. What followed was a period of trade liberalization on the back of successive GATT negotiation rounds. U.S. tariffs actually fell more in the 1970s than in the prior two decades (Chart 8). The fact that the dollar weakened during that period had more to do with the Fed, which permitted inflation to get out of hand by allowing real rates to remain in chronically negative territory. The dollar also suffered from the surge in oil prices, which produced a 35% deterioration in the U.S. terms of trade over the course of the decade (Chart 9). Chart 8Two Centuries Of U.S. Tarriffs Chart 9Dollar Weakness In the 1970s: Blame Deteriorating Terms Of Trade And A Dovish Fed It is possible that the Fed will repeat the mistakes of the 1970s, but this is more of a risk for the 2020s than a near-term concern. U.S. real yields have actually risen substantially relative to those abroad since last September (Chart 10). Chart 10The Dollar Is Once Again Responding ##br##To Real Rate Differentials The outcome of this week's FOMC meeting was on the hawkish side. The median number of dots in the newly released Summary of Economic Projections now point to four rate hikes this year, up from three hikes in the March projections. In addition, the Fed increased estimates for both growth and core inflation for this year. The decision to hold press conferences following every FOMC meeting will also give the Fed greater scope to expedite the pace of rate hikes. Investment Conclusions After panicking over every Trump tweet promising more protectionism earlier this year, markets have taken the recent news of escalating trade tensions in stride. Investors presumably think that Trump will water down his rhetoric, as he has periodically done over the past few months. Such a benign outcome is entirely possible. Trump left a fig leaf at the G7 summit in the form of a challenge to other members to eliminate their tariffs in exchange for the U.S. doing the same. Reaching such a deal would not be easy, but incremental progress towards this goal could be achieved. The overall level of tariff barriers within developed countries is already quite low. The U.S. actually stands at the top end of the spectrum -- average U.S. tariffs of 1.6% are double that of Canada, for example -- so the rest of the G7 would be wise to call Trump's bluff and agree to talks to further scale back trade barriers (Chart 11). This could give risk assets some breathing space for the next year or so. Yet, such a rosy outcome is far from guaranteed. Protectionism is popular among American voters, especially among Trump's base (Chart 12). Trump's obsession with the level of the stock market was a constraint on his protectionist rhetoric, but now that investors are content to look the other way, that constraint has loosened. Chart 11Tariffs: Who Is Robbing The U.S.? Chart 12Free Trade Is Not In Vogue In The U.S., And Is ##br##Especially Disliked Among Trump Supporters The fact that Trump's macroeconomic policies are completely at odds with his trade agenda does not help matters. Fiscal stimulus will boost aggregate demand, which will suck in more imports. An overheated economy will prompt the Fed to raise rates more aggressively than it otherwise would, leading to a stronger dollar. All this will result in a wider trade deficit. What will Trump tell voters two years from now when he is campaigning in Michigan and Ohio about why the trade deficit has widened rather than narrowed under his watch? Will he blame himself or America's trading partners? No trophy for getting that answer right. The effect of a trade war on the stock market would be grave. Multinational firms have large footprints abroad, the result of decades of investment in global supply chains. Equities represent a claim on the existing capital stock, not the capital stock that might emerge after a trade war has been fought. A trade war would result in a lot of stranded capital, forcing investors to mark down the value of the companies in their portfolios. In light of these risks, we expect to downgrade our recommendation on global equities from overweight to neutral before the end of the year. Peter Berezin, Chief Global Strategist Global Investment Strategy peterb@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see Lydia Cox and Kadee Russ, "Will Steel Tariffs put U.S. Jobs at Risk?," EconoFact, February 26, 2018. Steel-consuming industries are defined as those that devote more than 5% of their total costs to steel. 2 Considering that 80% of U.S. currency in circulation consists of $100 bills, it is safe to say that much of this overseas stash of cash belongs to those who acquired it through ill-gotten means. 3 Please see Global Investment Strategy Weekly Report, "U.S.-China Trade Spat: Is R-Star To Blame?," dated April 6, 2018, available at gis.bcaresearch.com. 4 For this calculation, we assume that the fair value for EUR/USD is 1.32, which is close to the IMF's Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) estimate. The annual inflation differential of 0.4% is based on 30-year CPI swaps. This implies that the fair value for EUR/USD will rise to 1.49 after 30 years. If one assumes that the euro reaches that level by then, the common currency would need to trade at 1.49/(1.0191)^30=0.84 today. Tactical Global Asset Allocation Recommendations Strategy & Market Trends Tactical Trades Strategic Recommendations Closed Trades
Highlights In line with our House view, we expect the broad USD trade-weighted index (TWIB) to continue to appreciate over the next six to 12 months, as U.S. growth outpaces that of other DMs, and the Fed's pace of rate hikes outpaces that of other systemically important central banks. Ordinarily, this would be bad news for the overall commodities complex. However, most commodity prices disconnected from the U.S. dollar in 2015 - 16. This disconnect produced a not-often-seen positive correlation between commodities and the USD, which remained in place into 2017. Fundamentals are keeping oil and base metals correlations weaker vs. the USD. Precious metals and ags are most vulnerable to a stronger USD. Highlights Energy: Overweight. Cracks in Nigeria's Bonny pipeline system will further delay loadings already curtailed by a force majeure declaration, according to local sources. Elsewhere, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) apparently boosted production ahead of the regularly scheduled OPEC meeting in Vienna on June 22, as mounting losses in Venezuela and U.S. sanctions against Iran loom.1 KSA and Russia are pushing for higher production from OPEC 2.0 ahead of the Vienna meeting. Base Metals: Neutral. Although union negotiators took a conciliatory tone in discussions, contract terms between it and BHP Billiton in Chile's Escondida mine still have not been resolved. Among other things, the union proposed a salary increase of 5% and a $34,000 one-off bonus for workers.2 Precious Metals: Neutral. Gold prices held close to $1,300/oz going into this week FOMC meeting. Ags/Softs: Underweight: The USDA revised down its ending-stocks estimates for corn and soybeans for the 2017/18 and the 2018/19 crop years in its latest WASDE, which was released earlier this week. Feature Chart of the WeekUSD TWIB Vs. Chief Commodity Indices Broadly speaking, commodity prices are negatively correlated with the USD TWIB. The principal indices we follow - the CRB, Bloomberg and S&P GSCI index - all are cointegrated with the USD, i.e., they share a long-term trend, wherein commodity prices rise as the USD falls, and vice versa (Chart of the Week). Ordinarily, we would expect the near-term appreciation of the U.S. dollar to weigh on broad commodity indices' performance. These are not ordinary times. Surprisingly, what holds for these aggregate indices does not hold for individual commodity groups within the indices. We've ranked each commodity by industry group, and found that over the long term - and this is critical - oil and base metals are most sensitive to changes in the USD TWIB, while precious metals and ags are less sensitive. A 1% change in the U.S. dollar index leads to a change in the energy sub-index of the CRB of almost 5%, while a 1% change in the TWIB leads to a change of just under 4% for the base metals sub-index of the CRB. For the precious metals sub-index of the CRB, we would expect to see prices change by just under 3% for every 1% change in the dollar index, while for the ags sub-index of the CRB, broadly speaking, we could expect a change of just under 2.5%.3 USD's Complicated Relationship With Commodities To understand what's driving the broad indices and their component sub-indexes, we ran Granger-causality tests to get a better picture of what's driving what.4 On average, the U.S. dollar drives the broad indices, from a Granger-causality perspective. However, it does not drive the individual commodity sub-indexes in the same manner (Table 1). Table 1USD Vs. Commodities: What's Driving What? We found an interesting relationship between copper and oil: Copper's relationship with oil is stronger than its relationship with the USD - likely because both commodities respond to the same demand factors (e.g., global industrial growth), and that mining and refining copper are energy-intensive processes. We still see a long-term underlying common relationship with the U.S. dollar, but copper is more strongly tied to oil. Bottom Line: We ranked the four main commodity groups with respect to their historical sensitivity to the USD using two distinct metrics. Over the long haul, we found the order from most to least sensitive is (1) Energy, (2) Base Metals, (3) Precious Metals, (4) Ags. USD And Commodities Out Of Whack While most commodity indices exhibit strong and stable negative correlations with the U.S. dollar, many of these relationships were pushed out of their long-term equilibria in 2016, and, importantly, have remained out of whack for an unusually long period (Chart 2).5 In fact, we found most individual commodities and commodity groups haven't converged back to their long-term equilibrium correlation levels with the USD TWIB, and their respective divergences are once again moving higher (Chart 3). Chart 2CRB Sub-Indices Out Of Whack With USD Chart 3Short-Term Correlations Remain In Disequilibrium As we've shown in previous research, commodity prices can remain in disequilibrium with the dollar when important fundamental (supply - demand) shocks dominate price formation.6 Table 2 shows which commodity groups are most out-of-equilibrium since 2016 relative to their long-term historical correlation. Energy, especially oil, and base metals groups are at the top of this list. Despite the fact that both of these groups are the most sensitive to the USD, based on our long-term analysis discussed above, the fact that they remain in disequilibria with the USD suggests the increase in the U.S. dollar we expect over the next 6 months will have a limited impact on these commodities. This leaves ags and, notably, precious metals, most vulnerable to the USD appreciation foreseen in our House view. Table 3 shows how the sensitivities of the different commodity groups vs. the USD TWIB have changed from 2015 to now versus the 2000 to 2015 period preceding it.7 Moreover, we see that in the shorter period between 2015 and now, the base metals and oil sensitivities (in red) are not significant. Economically, this means prices have disconnected from the USD during this period, owing to the overwhelming influence of supply-demand fundamentals on the price-formation process. Table 2Rank Of Rolling Correlation Divergences##BR##In 6-Month Vs. 5-Year Rolling Correlations Table 3Fundamentals Overwhelm##BR##USD's Influence Since 2015 The most plausible explanation for this is base metals and oil markets experienced fundamental shocks over the period - especially since 2016, e.g. OPEC launching a market-share war in 2014 and surging production, followed by the OPEC 2.0 production cuts still in force in the market. In theory, and absent important fundamental (supply-demand) shocks in base metals and energy markets (e.g., a strike at major copper mines or an unexpected outcome at the OPEC 2.0 meeting next week), these correlations should converge back to the long-term equilibrium. However, the speed of convergence is unknown. As long as we observe a disequilibrium in the short-term correlations, we can assume that the disequilibrium will be maintained over the short term. The short-term correlation movements show most of the commodity groups were converging toward equilibrium in recent months, but have since reversed course, particularly oil (Chart 4 and Table 2). Chart 4Short- Vs. Long-Term Correlations Divergence We believe the historic correlation levels between base metals and oil prices and the USD TWIB gradually will be restored. However, a number of factors will have to be monitored in order to determine the timing and the level around which the correlations will stabilize - i.e., close to the 2008 - 2013 levels or to those of the 2000 - 2007 period (Chart 5). We found that the EM/DM business cycle - i.e., the relative performance of EM to DM economies - as well as the shape of the oil forward curve generally can act as mediating factors in restoring the correlations of the USD TWIB and commodity prices.8 The stronger EM economies are relative to DM economies, or the more in contango the oil forward curve is, the more negative the correlations between commodities, especially oil and base metals, and the USD TWIB. Obviously, should the opposite occur, we would expect the weaker correlations to persist, although this might not constitute a complete disequilibrium. The mediating factors we mentioned can diminish or enhance the USD - Commodity correlations, but that does not mean they completely break them down. Chart 5Oil Vs. USD TWIB Correlation Remains Out Of Whack Bottom Line: Commodity prices disconnected from the U.S. dollar in 2015 - 16, which led to a rare environment in which the correlations between the USD TWIB and commodities became positive. Surprisingly, this disconnect remained in place for an extended period, which led us to revise our USD-elasticity ranking of commodity groups. As long as the fundamental shocks in the energy and base metals groups continue to dominate price formation in these markets, precious metals and ags will remain the most vulnerable groups to U.S. dollar appreciation. Hugo Bélanger, Senior Analyst Commodity & Energy Strategy HugoB@bcaresearch.com Robert P. Ryan, Senior Vice President Commodity & Energy Strategy rryan@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see "More delays to Nigerian Bonny Light as crude pipeline closes," published by Naija247 in Nigeria on June 11, 2018, and "Saudis Start to Ramp Up Oil Output, Ahead of OPEC Meeting," published by The Wall Street Journal, June 8, 2018. See also BCA Research's Commodity & Energy Strategy Weekly Report, "OPEC 2.0 Guiding to Higher Output; Volatility Set To Rise ... Again," published on March 31, 2018. Available at ces.bcaresearch.com. OPEC 2.0 is the name we coined for the oil-producer coalition led by The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) and Russia. 2 Please see "Escondida Union to Copper Investors: Bet on Quick Wage Deal," published by bloomberg.com, June 7, 2018, and "BHP responds to contract proposal from union at Chile's Escondida mine," published by uk.reuters.com on 11 June 2018. 3 These elasticities are the average coefficients for each commodity group we calculated using two different cointegrating regressions - Dynamic Ordinary Least Square and Panel - covering Jan 2000 to now. 4 Granger-causality measures the extent to which changes in one variable cause (or allow one to predict) changes in another variable. This is based on the work of the 2003 Nobel laureate, Clive Granger, who began publishing on this in 1969. Please see "Investigating Causal Relations by Econometric Models and Cross-spectral Methods," Econometrica, Vol. 37, No. 3 (Aug., 1969), pp. 424-438. 5 We make sure the correlations we estimate use cointegrated random variables, which means the empirical results we get provide consistent estimates of actual population correlations. Please see Johansen, Soren (2007), "Correlation, regression, and cointegration of nonstationary economic time series," published by the Center for Research in Econometric Analysis of Time Series at the Aarhus School of Business, University of Aarhus. 6 Please see BCA Research Commodity & Energy Strategy Weekly Report titled "OPEC 2.0 Vs. The Fed," dated February 08, 2018, available at ces.bcaresearch.com. 7 These sensitivities are coefficients in cointegrating regressions, which, given the construction of the regressions, are elasticities. 8 Using threshold regressions, we found the USD impact on BM and energy prices is, on average, weaker when DM stock prices outperform that of EM and when the oil forward curve is backwardated. These two variables act as mediators to the USD-Commodity relationship, and can be used to project the strength of the relationship. Investment Views and Themes Recommendations Strategic Recommendations Tactical Trades Commodity Prices and Plays Reference Table Trades Closed in 2018 Summary of Trades Closed in 2017
