Sectors
Overweight - Downgrade Alert Between Friday of this week and Monday of next, roughly 75% of the S&P banks index, representing the nation's largest lenders, will be reporting their Q3 earnings results. Our loan growth and earnings models continue to point significantly higher, particularly the former which is near a 30-year high, a result of a booming economy and record low unemployment. The question becomes whether or not the market cares; the S&P banks index delivered earnings outperformances in both Q1 and Q2 of this year and still underperformed the broad market. Further, the spread between relative performance and yields is widening and even a steepening in the yield curve has not been enough to stimulate a banks rally. We put the S&P banks index on downgrade alert in mid-May when we locked in gains vs. the SPX of 6% and removed it from the high-conviction overweight list, and warned that were banks not to participate in the next bond market selloff we would pull the trigger and downgrade to neutral. Our patience is wearing thin as we await the market's reaction to what should be another solid earnings quarter. Bottom Line: Stay overweight banks, but stay tuned.
Highlights Asset allocation: Go long industrial commodities versus equities on a 6-month horizon. If an inflationary impulse is dominating, beaten-down industrial commodities have more upside than richly valued equities; and if a disinflationary impulse is dominating, its main casualty will be equities. Currencies: Take profits on long EUR/CNY. Maintain a broadly neutral stance to EUR, with short EUR/JPY counterbalancing long EUR/USD. Equity sectors: overweight basic materials versus the market. And within the basic materials sector, overweight basic resources versus chemicals. Chart of the WeekChina's 6-Month Credit Impulse Provides A Perfect Explanation For Commodity Inflation Feature Equity markets are entering the crossfire between two opposing forces: an inflationary impulse coming from the global economy; and a disinflationary impulse as higher bond yields threaten to deflate the very rich valuations of equities and other risk-assets. As this battle plays out in the coming months a good strategy is to go long commodities versus equities. The logic is simple: if the inflationary impulse from the economy is dominating, then beaten-down industrial commodities have more upside than richly valued equities; and if the disinflationary impulse from higher bond yields is dominating, then commodities have less downside than equities, because commodities have a much weaker valuation link with bond yields. Therefore, going long industrial commodities versus equities on a 6-month horizon should be a good strategy however the battle between inflationary and disinflationary impulses plays out. Inflationary Impulse Battles Disinflationary Impulse Chart I-2 shows the credit impulse oscillations in the euro area, U.S., and China since the start of the millennium, all expressed in dollars to allow a comparison between the three major economies. It is a fascinating chart because the change in the dominant oscillation - the one with the highest amplitude - perfectly illustrates the shift in global economic power and influence from Europe and the U.S. to China. Chart I-2The Shift In Economic Power From Europe And The U.S. To China Through 2000-08 the impulses in the euro area and the U.S. dominated. But during the global financial crisis that all changed: the credit stimulus from China dwarfed the responses from the western economies. Then through 2009-12 the impulse oscillations from the three major economies were briefly the same size, before China took on the undisputed mantle of dominant impulse, which it has held consistently since 2013. The world's three major economies are now all in 'up' oscillations according to their credit impulses. This means the global economy will experience an inflationary impulse for the next couple of quarters or so. However, battling the inflationary impulse is a disinflationary impulse. As the inflationary impulse pushes up bond yields, it threatens to deflate the very rich valuations of equities (and other risk-assets). Crucially, this disinflationary force is particularly vicious when bond yields are rising from ultra-low levels. We have described this dynamic exhaustively in previous reports, so we will not go into the detail here. But in a nutshell, both parts of an equity's required return - the risk-free component and the risk premium - go up together when bond yields are rising from ultra-low levels. Meaning that rising yields deflate equity valuations exponentially (Chart I-3).1 Chart I-3At Low Bond Yields The Valuation Of Equities Changes Exponentially But Which Inflationary Impulse? At our recent investment conference in Toronto, the three speakers on the China panel gave three different conclusions on China: aggressively bullish, moderately bullish, and bearish! The aggressive bull pointed out that the 3-month credit impulse has gone vertical (Chart I-4); the moderate bull pointed out that the 6-month credit impulse appears to be turning up (Chart I-5); while the bearish argument was that the level of the 12-month credit and fiscal impulse remains depressed. Chart I-4The 3-Month Impulse Is Up Sharply... Chart I-5But The 6-Month Impulse Is Just Turning So which narrative should we use? The answer is the one that provides the best explanatory power for the cycles that we actually observe in the economic and financial market data. As we described in our Special Report The Cobweb Theory And Market Cycles, the theory and evidence powerfully identifies the 6-month credit impulse as the one with the best explanatory power for the oscillations that we actually observe in the economy and markets - because the 6-month period aligns most closely with the lag between credit demand and credit supply.2 In any case, as we use the 6-month impulse to powerful effect in Europe, consistency demands that we must use the 6-month impulses in U.S. and China too. For the sceptics, the Chart of the Week should finally obliterate any lingering doubts. China's 6-month impulse gives a spookily perfect explanation for the industrial commodity inflation cycle. The important takeaway right now is that if the 6-month impulse is turning up, so will industrial commodity inflation. What Does All Of This Mean For Investors? This brings us to our central message. As we have just seen, an up-oscillation in 6-month impulses, especially in China, will lift industrial commodity inflation. But it will likely have a much smaller influence on developed market equities which, in these circumstances, will be under the strong constraining spell of higher bond yields. On this basis the asset allocation recommendation is to go long industrial commodities versus equities on a 6-month horizon (Chart I-6). Chart I-6Go Long Commodities Vs. Equities Interestingly, technical analysis also supports this recommendation over the next three months or so. Our tried and tested measure of excessive trending and groupthink suggests that the recent underperformance of industrial commodities relative to developed market equities is extreme and at a point which indicates a countertrend move, or at least a trend exhaustion (Chart I-7). Chart I-7The Underperformance Of Industrial Commodities Is Technically Stretched For currencies, the foregoing analysis and charts means it is time to take profits in our long position in the euro versus the Chinese yuan. This leaves us with a broadly neutral exposure to the euro, with a short position versus the yen counterbalancing a long position versus the dollar. As for European equities, many years ago they were a pure play on events in Europe. Today, this might still be true for European 'tail-events' such as the euro sovereign debt crisis, or a potential 'no deal' Brexit. However, for the most part, European equity markets are tightly integrated with global equity markets - at least in direction if not level. Given that industrial commodity inflation takes its cue from the 6-month credit impulse - especially in China - it is hardly surprising that the European basic materials sector follows exactly the same cycle, both in absolute terms (Chart I-8) and relative to the broader equity market (Chart I-9). Therefore the equity sector recommendation is to overweight basic materials versus the market. Chart I-8China's 6-Month Credit Impulse Drives Europe's Basic Material Equities In Absolute Terms... Chart I-9...And In Relative Terms Interestingly, there is also a play within the basic materials sector. The basic resources sector which represents the miners and extractors of raw materials should fare better than the chemicals sector which uses these raw materials as an input (Chart I-10). Hence, overweight basic resources versus chemicals. Chart I-10Overweight Basic Resources Vs. Chemicals Readers may argue that most of the foregoing charts illustrate the same cycle. But that's precisely the point! Never forget that financial markets follow the Pareto principle: the most important 20 percent of analysis explains 80 percent of the moves across all asset classes across all geographies across all times. The key to successful investing is to find the most important 20 percent of analysis. Dhaval Joshi, Senior Vice President Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see the European Investment Strategy Weekly Reports 'Trapped: Have Equities Trapped Bonds?' September 13, 2018 and 'The Rule Of 4 For Equities And Bonds' August 2, 2018 available at eis.bcaresearch.com 2 Please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report 'The Cobweb Theory And Market Cycles' January 11, 2018 available at eis.bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading Model* It was a busy week for our trades. Long basic resources versus chemicals achieved its profit target, but short U.S. telecom versus U.S. autos hit its stop-loss. Meanwhile, short trade-weighted dollar reached the end of its 65 day holding period broadly flat. All three trades are now closed. In line with the main body of the report, this week's trade recommendation is to go long industrial commodities (represented by the CRB industrials index) versus equities (represented by the MSCI World Index in USD). The profit target is 2% with a symmetrical stop-loss. For any investment, excessive trend following and groupthink can reach a natural point of instability, at which point the established trend is highly likely to break down with or without an external catalyst. An early warning sign is the investment's fractal dimension approaching its natural lower bound. Encouragingly, this trigger has consistently identified countertrend moves of various magnitudes across all asset classes. Chart 11 The post-June 9, 2016 fractal trading model rules are: When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. Use the position size multiple to control risk. The position size will be smaller for more risky positions. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report "Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model," dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading Model Recommendations Equities Bond & Interest Rates Currency & Other Positions Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Interest Rate Chart II-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations
Underweight Utilities stocks are the ultimate loser from a backup in interest rates as they serve as premier fixed income proxies in the equity space and we are compelled to trim exposure to below benchmark. The niche S&P utilities sector yields 3.5% and when the competing risk free asset is near 3.2% and rising, investors prefer to shed, at the margin, riskier high-yielding equities and park the proceeds in U.S. Treasurys (top and second panels). Apart from the tight inverse correlation utilities have with interest rates, they are also a defensive sector that outperforms the broad market when the economy is in retreat. Currently a plethora of recent economic releases are signaling that the U.S. economy is overheating. The bottom panel of our chart illustrates the safe haven status of utility stocks (ISM survey shown inverted). Despite the above, spiking natural gas prices and a supportive electricity demand backdrop from a roaring economy present risks to our view; rising interest rates and a vibrant U.S. economy should nevertheless overwhelm. Bottom Line: We downgraded the S&P utilities sector to underweight yesterday; please see yesterday's Weekly Report for more details.
The S&P utilities sector yields 3.5% but when the yield offered by the competing risk free asset nears 3.2% and is rising, investors prefer to shed riskier high-yielding equities and park the proceeds in U.S. Treasurys. While arguably most of the bad news…
Against such a backdrop, the coming quarters should see sectors that benefit from rising interest rates and that also serve as inflation hedges outperform. This means we favor "FIT" stocks, which refers to financials, industrials and selected technology…
Highlights Portfolio Strategy A playable sector rotation opportunity has emerged, as we first argued at the recent BCA investment conference: Financials, industrials and select tech subgroups will lead the next phase of the market advance, a result of the bond market selloff gaining steam into year-end and beyond. In contrast, rising interest rates, a vibrant U.S. economy, softening operating metrics and high indebtedness signal that it is time to shed utility stocks. Recent Changes Trim the S&P Utilities sector to underweight today. Table 1 Feature On the eve of earnings season, the SPX remains close to an all-time high. The most recent spate of investor optimism was driven by President Trump cementing another deal last week, this time with Canada. While the renaming of NAFTA to USMCA is a step in the right direction (i.e. a deal was struck), a deal with China remains the elephant in the room. On that front, U.S. hawkish trade rhetoric should remain in vogue and any deal will have to wait until at least after the election, if not until Q1/2019. Up to now Trump's trade hawkishness has not infiltrated U.S. profits, but we continue to closely monitor IBES reported profit growth expectations. Following up from last week, the rest of the world is bearing the brunt of the U.S. trade-related rhetoric according to our profit growth models, a message sell-side analysts' forecasts also corroborate (we use forward EBITDA in order to gauge trend profit growth and filter out the tax-induced jump in U.S. EPS, Chart 1). Meanwhile, at the margin, seasonality can prop up stocks. While September - a historically negative return month, but not this year - is behind us, stock market crash-prone October is upon us, and thus a pick-up in volatility would not come as a surprise. Beyond October's dreaded crash history, the Presidential cycle has piqued our interest, especially years two and three. Building on our sister Geopolitical Strategy publication's research,1 and given the upcoming midterm elections, we created a cycle-on-cycle profile of SPX returns during these two middle Presidential cycle years (Chart 2). Chart 1U.S. Has The Upper Hand Chart 2Seasonality Boost Until Midyear 2019? In more detail, we analyzed 17 cycles starting in 1950 using S&P 500 daily data (reconstructed S&P 500 prior to 1957). During these iterations, only two two-year periods ended in the red, 1974/75 and 2002/03. The first coincided with a recession and the second took place in the aftermath of the dotcom bust. In addition, two other cycles produced roughly 5% two-year returns, 1962/63 and 1966/67. Finally, 1954/55 was the outlier when the SPX went parabolic and nearly doubled. While every cycle is different, it is clear from Chart 2 that the Presidential cycle should continue to underpin the SPX, if history is an accurate guide, especially given our forecast of no recession in the coming 9-to-12 months. In fact, the S&P could rise another 10%, in line with our 2019 expectation, predicated upon a 10% increase in profits and a lateral multiple move. Interestingly, according to the median Presidential cycle-on-cycle roadmap, while the back half of 2019 is likely to prove more challenging, the first half of next year should enjoy most of the returns (Chart 2). An assessment of recent data releases in the U.S. and abroad is also revealing. Chart 3 shows that the domestic economy is firing on all cylinders. Consumer confidence and sentiment hit multi-decade highs recently. Similarly, the job market remains vibrant and small business euphoria reigns supreme. Not only are small business owners optimistic on all employment-related subcomponents of the NFIB survey, but SME capex intentions are also as good as they get. The ISM manufacturing survey ticked down from the August peak, but remains close to 60. Its close sibling, the ISM services survey, vaulted into uncharted territory. All of this is reflected in the still-growing U.S. leading economic indicator and signals that the U.S. equity market remains on a solid footing. Outside U.S. shores, the bearish narrative is well established with EMs, especially the U.S. dollar debt-saddled fragile five that have to contend with twin deficits, sinking in a bear market. China's debt load is also coming under intense scrutiny as U.S. tariffs are all but certain to weigh on Chinese output growth. Nonetheless, there is a chance that the EMs have depreciated their currencies by enough to engineer a modest rebound (bottom panel, Chart 4). In other words, absent the currency peg straightjacket that dominated the region in the late-1990s, free-floating FX devaluations may serve as a relief valve in order to boost exports. The latest Korean MARKIT manufacturing PMI spiked above the boom/bust line to a multi-year high signaling that already humming Korean factories (industrial production is accelerating) will likely remain busy in the coming months. Other hard economic data also confirm these greenshoots: Korean manufacturing exports are expanding smartly. In particular, exports to China are soaring. Reaccelerating manufacturing selling prices also corroborate this budding Korean recovery (third panel, Chart 4). Chart 3U.S. Is On Fire Chart 4Reflationary Impulse? While it is premature to call an end to the EM carnage, most of the bad news on global export volumes and prices may be nearing an end and the EMs may even export some of their inflation to the U.S. Play The Sector Rotation Into Financials And Industrials... In recent research, we have been highlighting that inflation is slowly rearing its ugly head and there are high odds that the selloff in the bond market gains steam into year-end and beyond2 (as a reminder BCA's fixed income publications continue to recommend below-benchmark portfolio duration). Against such a backdrop, sectors that benefit from rising interest rates and that serve as inflation hedges should outperform in the coming quarters. The "FIT" market refers to financials, industrials and select technology stocks. In more detail, we expect a sector rotation, especially into financials and industrials that have been laggards and remain compellingly valued (Chart 5). With regard to financials, Chart 6 shows that this early cyclical sector enjoys a positive correlation with interest rates and inflation expectations, and a catch up phase in relative share prices looms in the coming quarters. Chart 5Rotate Into Financials... Chart 6...And Industrials Industrials stocks also benefit from rising inflation and interest rates as large parts of this deep cyclical sector are levered to the commodity cycle (Chart 7). In other words, industrials stocks are an indirect inflation hedge and trouble surfaces only when capital goods producers cannot pass rising input costs down the supply chain or to the consumer. But, we are not there yet. Keep in mind that during the last cycle, relative (and absolute) industrials performance peaked prior to relative energy stock prices. Similarly, the relative industrials stock price ratio troughed in early 2009 before their deep cyclical brethren put in a (temporary) bottom a year later (Chart 8). Chart 7Industrials Lead Chart 8Undervalued True, energy stocks are also going to perform well if our thesis of higher interest rates/inflation pans out in the coming quarters and especially if BCA's Commodity & Energy Strategy service's view of a looming oil price spike materializes (Chart 9). Thus, we sustain the high-conviction overweight stance in the broad sector and reaffirm our recent upgrade to an above benchmark allocation in the S&P oil & gas exploration & production (E&P) subgroup.3 We also reiterate our recent market-neutral and intra-commodity pair trade: long S&P oil & gas E&P / short global gold miners.4 This trade is off to a great start up 10.3% since inception and will benefit further from an inflationary impulse. Chart 9Energy Remains A High-Conviction Overweight While tech stocks have really delivered and led the market advance year-to-date, a bifurcated tech market should remain in place with capex levered S&P software and S&P tech hardware, storage & peripherals indexes (both are high-conviction overweights) outperforming early cyclical tech groups, semi and semi equipment stocks (we remain underweight both semi subindexes). Bottom Line: A playable rotation into financials and industrials is in the offing especially if the selloff in the bond market accelerates on the back of an inflationary whim. We continue to recommend an overweight allocation to both the S&P financials and S&P industrials sectors. ...But Lights Are Out For Utilities Utilities stocks are the ultimate loser from a backup in interest rates as they serve as premier fixed income proxies in the equity space and we are compelled to trim exposure to below benchmark. The niche S&P utilities sector yields 3.5% and when the competing risk free asset is near 3.2% and rising, investors prefer to shed, at the margin, riskier high-yielding equities and park the proceeds in U.S. Treasurys (Chart 10). While arguably most of the bad news is already reflected in washed out technicals and bombed out short and even long-term profit expectations (Chart 11), the selling will only accelerate into yearend and 2019. Chart 10Higher Yields Bite Chart 11Oversold And Unloved... Apart from the tight inverse correlation utilities have with interest rates, they are also a defensive sector that outperforms the broad market when the economy is in retreat. Currently a plethora of recent economic releases are signaling that the U.S. economy is overheating. Chart 12 illustrates the safe haven status of utility stocks (ISM surveys shown inverted). On the operating front, despite the upbeat economic data, electricity capacity utilization remains anemic. Capacity growth is likely responsible for this weak resource utilization signal as utilities construction continues unabated (private construction shown inverted, top panel, Chart 13). Adding insult to injury, inventory accumulation is also weighing on the sector (turbine inventories shown inverted, middle panel, Chart 13). Chart 12...But More Pain Looms Chart 13Weak Operating Metrics Worrisomely, all these expansion plans have been financed with debt. While this is not typically an issue for stable cash flow generating utilities, the sector's net debt-to-EBITDA profile has gone parabolic, nearly doubling since the GFC and even overtaking the early 2000s when a California deregulation wave first led to exuberance and then an electricity crisis (Chart 14). Any letdown in cash flow growth will be disruptive, especially given that the sector has no valuation cushion (bottom panel, Chart 14). Nevertheless, there are some risks that could put our underweight position offside. Natural gas prices have spiked of late and given that they are the marginal price setter for the sector they could boost utility pricing power and thus profits (top & middle panels, Chart 15). As the U.S. economy is firing on all cylinders, electricity demand should remain brisk and provide an offset to the otherwise weakening utility operating backdrop (bottom panel, Chart 15). Chart 14Heavily Indebted And Pricey Chart 15Risks To Underweight View Netting it all out, rising interest rates, a vibrant U.S. economy, softening operating metrics and high indebtedness signal that the time is ripe to sell utility stocks. Bottom Line: Downgrade the S&P utilities sector to underweight. Anastasios Avgeriou, Vice President U.S. Equity Strategy anastasios@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see BCA Geopolitical Strategy Weekly Report, "Fade The Midterms, Not Iraq Or Brexit," dated September 12, 2018, available at gps.bcaresearch.com. 2 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, "Deflation - Reflation - Inflation," dated August 20, 2018, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 3 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, "Soldiering On," dated July 16, 2018, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 4 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, "Deflation - Reflation - Inflation," dated August 20, 2018, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. Current Recommendations Current Trades Size And Style Views Favor value over growth Favor large over small caps
Underweight In our previous Insight, we highlighted the S&P REITs index’s tight inverse correlation with UST yields, but it is far from the only group with this trait. The S&P telecom services index (now a subsector within the S&P communication services index, please see our recent Special Report1), with its predictable earnings stream and dividend payout, trades on the same basis. The spike in yields is thus a negative omen for telco stock prices. It is worth noting that the S&P telecom services index has been bucking its inverse correlation with UST yields since hitting their nadir in mid-2017 (second panel). We expect the beaten-up sector to reestablish the correlation, particularly since telecom’s share of the consumer’s wallet is at a decade low with momentum to continue lower. Bottom Line: Stay underweight the telecom services index. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5TELSX - T, VZ, CTL. 1 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Special Report, “New Lines Of Communication” dated October 1, 2018, available at uses.bcaresearch.com.
Underweight The spike in UST yields have been weighing on fixed income-proxy sectors with REITs foremost among them. As noted in the top panel of the chart, excluding the inflating of the property bubble in advance of the GFC, REITs have had a very tight inverse correlation with UST yields; the resulting downward pressure on the S&P REITs index is thus very predictable. Such downward pressure could be overlooked if all was well on an operating basis but this is not the case. Non-residential construction continues to rise (albeit more slowly than last year) in the face of higher borrowing rates (second panel). Further, demand looks slack as occupancy rates clearly crested at the beginning of last year (bottom panel). As well, on the residential front, multi-family housing starts remain elevated which should prove deflationary to rents. Bottom Line: We reiterate our underweight recommendation on the S&P REITs index. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are BLBG: S5REITS - IRM, MAA, AMT, BXP, PLD, ESS, CCI, PSA, O, VTR, VNO, WY, EQIX, DLR, EXR, DRE, FRT, WELL, SBAC, HCP, GGP, KIM, EQR, UDR, REG, MAC, HST, SPG, AVB, AIV, SLG, ARE.
Underweight September was a tough month for the S&P hotels, resorts and cruise lines index. First, Carnival Corp, the largest cruise line operator warned that net revenue yield growth was slowing as prices for next year are flat; their share price (and those of their competitors) fell significantly. Next, the CEO of Marriott warned that the trade war was already having an impact on tourism, with Europe capturing a larger share of Chinese outbound travel. As with cruise lines, these comments weighed heavily on the hotel operators. Our negative thesis is unchanged with respect to cruise lines; we believe volume gains (the source of margin improvements) have peaked and, in the absence of better pricing, margins will suffer in the face of rising costs, particularly fuel (third panel). Further, despite recovering pricing in hotels, the splurging on new construction should mean a return to price competition (bottom panel), particularly if tourism from China is truly retrenching. Overall, we reiterate our underweight recommendation. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5HOTL - MAR, CCL, RCL, HLT, WYN, NCLH.
Highlights Set your overall investment strategy with two 'rules of 4' based on 10-year bond yields: If either the Italian BTP or the sum of the U.S. T-bond, German bund and JGB stays above 4 percent, then sell equities and buy bonds. If both the Italian BTP and the sum of the U.S. T-bond, German bund and JGB are in the 3-4 percent range, then remain broadly neutral. If both the Italian BTP and the sum of the U.S. T-bond, German bund and JGB fall below 3 percent, then buy equities and sell bonds. Stay neutral to Italy's MIB and Italian banks for the time being. Among the mainstream European equity markets our top pick remains France's CAC. Feature Many people believe that Italy has one of the world's most indebted economies, but this widely-held belief is wrong. Although Italy's public indebtedness is high, Italy's private indebtedness is one of the lowest in the world (Chart of the Week). This means that Italy's total indebtedness is less than that of France and the U.K., and broadly similar to that of the U.S. (Chart I-2 - Chart 1-5).1 Chart of the WeekItaly's Private Sector Indebtedness Is One Of The Lowest In The World Chart I-2Italy: Total Indebtedness = 260% Of GDP Chart I-3France: Total Indebtedness = 305% Of GDP Chart I-4U.K.: Total Indebtedness = 280% Of GDP Chart I-5U.S.: Total Indebtedness = 250% Of GDP The Myth Of Italian Indebtedness An economy's debt sustainability depends on its total indebtedness, and not on its public indebtedness or its private indebtedness in isolation. Debt becomes unsustainable when the marginal extra euro of debt results in misallocation of resources and mal-investment. At this point, the extra debt adds nothing to growth or, worse, it subtracts from growth. Therefore, debt reaches its sustainable limit when the economy has exhausted all productive uses for it. But it does not matter whether these productive uses are funded with private debt or with public debt. For example, successful economies require investment in high-quality healthcare and education. Some economies fund this with private debt, while others fund it with public debt. This means that if productive private indebtedness is low, there is more scope for productive public indebtedness. The crucial point is that Italy has extremely low private indebtedness, which means that it can afford relatively high public indebtedness before reaching the limit of debt sustainability. Right now, this is especially true because the Italian banking system remains dysfunctional, preventing the private sector from borrowing (Chart I-6). Under these circumstances, the Italian government can borrow the private sector's excess savings and debt repayments and put them to highly productive use - which will paradoxically reduce the deficit in the long term. Chart I-6Italy's Private Sector Is Not Borrowing Hence, the M5S/Lega government is following excellent economic policy in proposing a modest increase in the fiscal deficit in 2019. An appropriately sized and targeted fiscal stimulus is exactly what Italy needs right now. But this excellent economic policy will take time to bear fruit and show up in Italy's growth and deficit data. Italy's big problem is that bond vigilantes do not wait, they shoot first and ask questions later. Italy Is Especially Vulnerable To Bond Vigilantes Italy is also a world leader in running primary surpluses (Chart I-7 and Table I-1). In plain English, this means that the Italian government spends considerably less than it receives, if interest payments are excluded. Chart I-7Italy Is A World Leader In Running Primary Surpluses Table I-1Italy Has Consistently Run Primary Surpluses Put differently, Italy's government deficit results not from its operational spending relative to its income, but from the interest payments on its debt. This makes Italy especially vulnerable to the bond vigilantes. If the bond vigilantes distort Italy's interest rate, they can tip the Italian government into financial distress, even if that distress is not justified by the economic fundamentals. Is this a real risk? Sadly, yes. The euro debt crisis was essentially a liquidity crisis which resulted from bond vigilantes running amok. When irrational markets refuse to lend to sovereigns at a fair interest rate, maturing debt has to be refinanced at a penalising interest rate, causing an undeserved deterioration in the government's finances. Thereby, the irrational fear of insolvency becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. Italy has an additional problem. When Italian bond prices decline, it erodes the value of the banking system's euro 350 billion portfolio of BTPs and weakens the banks' fragile balance sheets. If a bank's equity capital no longer covers its net non-performing loans (NPLs), investors get nervous. In this regard, the largest Italian banks now have euro 160 billion of equity capital against euro 130 billion of net NPLs, implying a cushion of euro 30 billion (Chart I-8). Chart I-8Italian Banks' Equity Capital Exceeds ##br##Net NPLs By Euro 30 Bn... So the markets would start to worry about Italian banks' mark-to-market solvency if their bond portfolios sustained a loss of €30 billion. We estimate this equates to the 10-year BTP yield breaching and remaining above 4 percent (Chart I-9).2 Chart I-9...The Excess Would Disappear If The 10-Year BTP Yield Stayed Above 4% The ECB solved the euro debt crisis at a stroke by committing to act as lender of last resort to distressed sovereigns at an 'undistorted' interest rate. Indeed, the commitment alone was enough to defeat the bond vigilantes without the ECB spending a single cent from its Outright Monetary Transaction (OMT) program.3 But recall that the ECB only threatened its firepower when the 2-year Spanish Bono yield had breached 6.5 percent and the 10-year yield had breached 7.5 percent. It follows that if the 10-year Italian BTP yield breached 4 percent, the yield would be high enough to hurt the Italian banks, but not nearly high enough for any powerful intervention from the ECB. Hence, the 10-year BTP yield at 4 percent is the level at which we would return to a pro-defensive strategy. Conversely, a level below 3 percent would create some margin of safety providing one precondition for a more pro-cyclical investment stance. In the meantime, the current level at 3.3 percent justifies a neutral cyclical stance to Italy's MIB and Italian banks. Among the mainstream European equity markets our top pick remains France's CAC. The Connection Between Bubbles And Liquidity Crises Bubble formation may seem to have no connection with a liquidity crisis but the two phenomena are closely related. Bubble formation is simply a brewing liquidity crisis resulting from irrational euphoria rather than irrational fear. A bubble forms when value investors stop investing on the basis of a valuation framework. Instead, they get lured into the momentum herd that is participating in a strong rally, and the additional buy orders fuel the euphoria. However, once all of the value investors have joined the momentum herd, and a value investor then suddenly reverts to type and puts in a sell order, the market will suffer a liquidity crisis. There are no buyers left! And finding one might require a substantial reversal in the price to attract an ultra-long-term deep value investor. As regular readers know, fractal analysis measures whether the herding behaviour in any financial instrument is becoming excessive. The analysis suggests that developed market equities are not yet at the tipping point of excessive euphoria that signalled the last two trend exhaustions in May 2017 and January 2018 (Chart I-10). But this does not mean that there are clear blue skies ahead. Chart I-10Developed Market Equities Are Not Yet At A Trend Exhaustion The danger is not that the rich valuation is irrationally excessive, but that it is hyper-sensitive to bond yields. At low bond yields, bonds offer no price upside but substantial price downside. Confronted with this increased riskiness of bonds, equity returns justifiably collapse to the feeble returns offered by bonds with no additional 'risk premium', giving equity valuations an exponential uplift. But if bond yields normalise, the process goes into vicious reverse - the rich valuation of equities must decline as exponentially as it rose. We have defined the danger point as when the sum of the 10-year yields on the U.S. T-bond, German bund, and JGB breaches and stays above 4 percent. In summary, set your overall investment strategy with two 'rules of 4' based on 10-year bond yields: If either the Italian BTP or the sum of the U.S. T-bond, German bund and JGB stays above 4 percent, then sell equities and buy bonds. If both the Italian BTP and the sum of the U.S. T-bond, German bund and JGB are in the 3-4 percent range, then remain broadly neutral. If both the Italian BTP and the sum of the U.S. T-bond, German bund and JGB fall below 3 percent, then buy equities and sell bonds. Dhaval Joshi, Senior Vice President Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com 1 Indebtedness defined as a share of GDP. 2 Assuming that the average maturity of Italian banks' BTPs is around 5 years. 3 The ECB's Outright Monetary Transaction (OMT) program was created in 2012 in response to the euro debt crisis and facilitates the ECB's lender of last resort function to solvent but illiquid sovereign borrowers. Fractal Trading Model* We are pleased to report that our long China/short India trade achieved its 9% profit target and is now closed. This week, we note that the underperformance of the Eurostoxx50 versus the Nikkei225 is technically stretched, with a 65-day fractal dimension approaching the limit which signaled a very recent trend reversal. Hence, this week's recommended trade is long Eurostoxx50 versus Nikkei225. The profit target is 3.5% with a symmetrical stop-loss. For any investment, excessive trend following and groupthink can reach a natural point of instability, at which point the established trend is highly likely to break down with or without an external catalyst. An early warning sign is the investment's fractal dimension approaching its natural lower bound. Encouragingly, this trigger has consistently identified countertrend moves of various magnitudes across all asset classes. Chart I-11 The post-June 9, 2016 fractal trading model rules are: When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. Use the position size multiple to control risk. The position size will be smaller for more risky positions. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report "Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model," dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading Model Recommendations Equities Bond & Interest Rates Currency & Other Positions Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Interest Rate Chart II-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations

