Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Cyclicals vs Defensives

BCA’s defense index has been on a tear recently. The unfortunate structural increase in terrorist activity will embolden governments around the world to step up defense spending (top panel), at a time when the pressure to move away from austerity toward expansionary fiscal policy is already intense. Defense industry revenues have already begun to outpace those of the overall S&P 500, and a structural upturn in military expenditures will provide confidence that this is the start of a prolonged uptrend, as occurred throughout most of the last decade. From a cyclical perspective, we have shown that the shipments-to-inventories (SI) ratio at the wholesale, manufacturing and retail levels are collapsing, but the defense capital goods SI ratio is moving in the opposite direction (middle panel), reinforcing the case for ongoing earnings outperformance. Bottom Line: The re-rating phase in BCA’s defense index is still in the early innings. Stay overweight. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: LMT, GD, RTN, NOC, LLL.

Equity and Treasury market positioning support the notion of a bounce in risk assets, possibly egged on by dollar weakness.

While we continue to maintain a defensive over cyclical portfolio structure, yesterday's Weekly Report identified a number of catalysts that could eventually change our view: broad-based and sustained U.S. dollar weakness, particularly against a basket of EM currencies in countries with large current account deficits would, the Chinese manufacturing sector stops deflating, global PMIs firm, global export volumes and prices top contracting, an end to U.S. over global profit dominance and/or inflation expectations turn higher around the world. So far, these potential catalysts have only shown signs of stabilization rather than strength, underscoring that it is premature to position for a recovery in cyclical sector profits. Stay defensive, and please see yesterday's Weekly Report for more details.

Economic disappointment will become the key theme in the second half of the year, driving a return to non-cyclical market leadership and a recovery in the growth vs. value ratio.

Despite the broad market's rebound toward the top end of the 18-month long trading range, defensive sectors have held their own against cyclical sectors of late. We expect non-cyclical dominance to reassert itself, regardless of the short-term direction of the overall market. Financial conditions are tighter than warranted by underlying economic activity, as demonstrated by the Chicago Fed's Financial Conditions Index. Ergo, positioning for economic reacceleration is high risk. Moreover, the yield curve continues to narrow (second panel, curve shown as 2 minus the 10-year Treasury yield), reinforcing that growth rates will stay too low to lift the deflationary pall over cyclical sectors, particularly if the Fed retains its tightening bias. Even the global manufacturing surveys continue to underwhelm (bottom panel). Overall, the message is that the uptrend since 2011 in the defensive/cyclical share price ratio will remain intact.
Special Report

This week <i>U.S. Equity Strategy</i> is sending you the latest <i>BCA Special Report</i>, where Mark McClellan and Anastasios Avgeriou tackle the questions of "Global Earnings Recession: How Deep? How Long?"

Cyclical sectors are manufacturing-dependent, whereas defensive sectors are services-oriented, highlighting that cyclicals are more levered to the inventory cycle's ebbs and flows. The latest durable goods report made for grim reading. Both the new orders-to-inventories and shipments-to-inventories (S/I) ratios remain tepid. This corroborates the reading from the S/I ratios in the wholesale, retail & manufacturing sectors, where all are steadily sinking, underscoring that forecasting a rise in manufacturing output on the basis of an inventory cycle is overly optimistic. The implication is that additional pain looms for the cyclicals/defensives relative performance (middle panel). Moreover, diverging debt dynamics are weighing on the cyclicals/defensives ratio. Relative interest coverage and net debt-to-EBITDA are sending a distress signal (not shown). Tack on a narrowing in relative profit margins (bottom panel) and the continuing deterioration in relative top-line growth which according to our sales models has more staying power (please see chart 7 from the March 29 Special Report), and the ingredients are in place for a resumption in the downtrend in the relative share price ratio. Relative profit trends will drive the next phase in the cyclicals/defensives ratio and defensives retain the upper hand (top panel). Bottom Line: Continue to favor defensives over deep cyclicals.
Special Report

This week <i>Global Alpha Sector Strategy</i> in conjunction with <i>Emerging Markets Strategy</i> is sending out a <i>Special Report</i> on EM deep cyclical sectors, discussing debt and cash flow dynamics, identifying how far advanced the capital expenditure down cycle is, and determining if recent EM deep cyclical strength should be bought or faded.

Equities are back in overshoot territory. We added the health care sector to our high-conviction overweight list, boosted managed care to overweight and put health care equipment on downgrade alert. Buy cable stocks.

While recent financial stress relief has triggered a short covering rally in deep cyclical sectors, this will only be sustainable if macro forces shift in support of profit outperformance. However, our cyclical vs. defensive macro drivers have not yet confirmed the glimmers of light offered by financial variables. Global purchasing manager surveys at both the manufacturing and services levels are still sinking, with many in recessionary territory. While there are pockets of strength, in aggregate, manufacturing is very weak. Global trade is still extremely weak. The Baltic Dry index is hitting new lows, and export growth in key manufacturing regions such as Taiwan, Korea and China is contracting at a double-digit rate. The takeaway from ongoing weakness in trade is that EM currencies have not weakened enough to allow exports to stabilize their growth prospects, likely because developed countries are not spending their low oil price dividend. Our Emerging Asian LEI has failed to make any strides despite the dramatic pullback in their currencies. That dynamic reflects both weak export markets and monetary policy constraints driven by fears of capital flight. That is unnerving, because it means that the necessary deleveraging has not been allowed to occur. These factors will continue to constrain cyclical sector profits, especially relative to defensives, arguing for maintaining a defensive portfolio bias. Please see yesterday's Special Report for more details.