Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Cyclicals vs Defensives

Renewed strength in the U.S. equity market sponsored by another round of global monetary easing has revived the debate about whether it is finally time to transition out of our alpha-generating defensive portfolio strategy. A number of strategists and media outlets have championed the view that yield proxies and non-cyclical sectors are expensive, and no longer offer an attractive reward/risk trade-off, particularly within the context of the recent easing in credit spreads, commodity price relief and the dip in the U.S. dollar. However, it is crucial to distinguish between absolute and relative measures when analyzing valuations. In absolute terms, nearly every sector and group is expensive, given that the broad market is trading at historically rich multiples. Our metrics do not support the notion that defensive sector outperformance has overly skewed relative valuations. Defensive sector strength has been almost entirely earnings driven (top panel), as measured by the steady upward march in relative forward earnings estimates. Our relative valuation gauge for defensives is barely above neutral despite multiyear outperformance. At the same time, cyclical sectors have experienced a steady decline in relative forward profit estimates, which has kept our valuation gauge close to neutral when the energy sector is excluded. The implication is that forecasting a cyclical sector comeback based on a valuation basis could lead investors down the wrong path. Instead, the lack of a major valuation anomaly means that relative performance should continue to be dictated by relative profit trends, please see the next Insight.
Special Report

Renewed strength in the U.S. equity market sponsored by another round of global monetary easing has revived the debate about whether it is finally time to transition out of our <i>alpha</i>-generating defensive portfolio strategy. This <i>Special Report</i> examines the critical factors shaping this investment decision.

The Fed's decision to scale back intended interest rate hikes reflects economic reality.

While we are neutral the broad industrials sector (please see yesterday's Insight) and sub-surface exposure should remain selective, we continue to recommend an above benchmark weighting in the BCA defense index. Following years of global government austerity, rising global fiscal thrust should boost demand for defense capital goods. Tack on a rise in geopolitical risk in a number of volatile regions in the world, and the outlook for defense spending significantly brightens. In more detail, China/Japan nervousness (with Australia recently joining the chorus of rising defense spending in the pacific) and escalating middle east/Russia tensions are a harbinger of rising defense spending budgets globally. The prime beneficiaries of this cyclical turn in demand are U.S. defense manufacturers/contractors. Already, U.S. defense new orders are surging, signaling that relative performance momentum has more upside (middle panel). Importantly, the U.S. defense capital goods shipments-to-inventories ratio is also expanding at a healthy clip (bottom panel). The implication is that busy defense factory activity should underpin revenue and profit growth. Bottom Line: Stay overweight the BCA defense index. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: LMT, GD, RTN, NOC, LLL.

Economic disappointment represents a serious obstacle for stocks. Stay with non-cyclical plays, including telecom services and health care. Upgrade the managed care group, and stay clear of banks, regardless of cheap valuations.

With the broad market struggling to find a floor in the midst of a disappointing earnings season, it still pays to play defense. This week's ISM releases reinforce that a defensive over cyclical portfolio bias is still warranted. The bottom panel of the chart shows the relative employment outlook for ISM manufacturing versus ISM services, with the pendulum swinging in favor of services industries. This relative employment ratio heralds more pain for cyclical vs. defensive equities, as most defensive sectors are services-oriented while deep cyclicals are manufacturing-intensive. Meanwhile, the bond market continues to flag elevated financial stress. Cyclical junk bond yields have been shooting higher, especially compared with defensive junk yields, reflecting relative deteriorating balance sheets. The implication is that relative share prices have more room to fall (top panel). Bottom Line: we continue to recommend a defensive versus deep cyclical portfolio tilt.