Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Fixed Income

Special Report This is the final report of the year from BCA’s Global Fixed Income and US Bond Strategies. Our regular publication schedule will resume on January 7, 2020. We wish you a happy, healthy and prosperous new year.   Highlights Interest Rate Policy: The Fed’s next interest rate move will be a hike, but it probably won’t occur until 2021. It will not occur until either long-maturity TIPS breakeven inflation rates reach our target band of 2.3%-2.5% or financial asset valuations reach extreme levels. We provide several indicators to monitor to assess the timing of the next Fed hike. Balance Sheet Policy: The era of balance sheet shrinkage is over. The Fed will continue to grow its balance sheet in 2020, and will also tweak regulations to make banks more indifferent between holding Treasury securities and reserves. Strategic Review: The exact form of any new policy strategy is uncertain, but we expect the Fed to make an announcement in mid-2020 that makes it clear that it will explicitly target above-2% inflation for some unspecified period of time in order to re-anchor inflation expectations and make up for past inflation misses. Feature Last week, both our Global Fixed Income Strategy and US Bond Strategy services published their key fixed income views for 2020.1  Those reports presented investment ideas that we think will be profitable next year, but only discussed Fed policy to the extent that it informs those views. This Special Report delves into exactly what we expect to see from the US Federal Reserve in 2020. Specifically, we consider what the Fed will do with its interest rate and balance sheet policies in 2020, and also what might result from the Fed’s ongoing strategic review. Interest Rate Policy The final FOMC meeting of 2019 took place last week, and we learned that the Fed’s reaction function underwent a significant dovish shift between the September and December meetings. Currently, only 4 FOMC participants expect to lift rates in 2020 while the remaining 13 expect the funds rate to stay in its present range between 1.5% and 1.75% (Chart 1). Back in September, 9 participants thought the fed funds rate would be above 1.75% by the end of 2020. Chart 1Fed Will Stay On Hold In 2020, Market Still Priced For Cuts The yield curve is still discounting a slight decline in the funds rate next year, and the Fed will of course deliver more rate cuts if economic growth deteriorates. However, given our positive global growth outlook for 2020, we think rate cuts are unlikely.2 Rather, we expect a flat fed funds rate next year followed by rate hikes in 2021. The Fed’s reaction function underwent a significant dovish shift between the September and December meetings.  If our economic view pans out, then getting a sense of what will be required for the Fed to lift rates is the most pressing monetary policy issue. On that front, we continue to believe that inflation expectations and financial conditions are the two most important factors to monitor.3  Recent remarks from Fed officials have only strengthened our conviction in that view. Inflation Expectations & The Fed’s Phillips Curve Model Last week, when Chair Powell was asked what it will take to lift rates again, he said that he wants to see “a significant move up in inflation that’s also persistent”. This scripted response reveals a lot about the Fed’s reaction function in 2020, and about the importance of inflation expectations. To see why, let’s consider the Expectations-Augmented Phillips Curve, the typical model that the Fed uses to assess trends in inflation. An example of this sort of model, taken from a 2015 Janet Yellen speech, is presented in Box 1.4 Box 1The Fed's Inflation Model According to the Fed’s model, core inflation is determined by: (i) inflation expectations, (ii) resource utilization and (iii) relative import prices. But inflation expectations are especially important because they determine inflation’s long-run trend. As explained by former Chair Yellen: Chart 2The Importance Of Inflation Expectations … economic slack, changes in imported goods prices, and idiosyncratic shocks all cause core inflation to deviate from its longer-term trend that is ultimately determined by long-run inflation expectations. This is what Chair Powell means when he says he wants to see a “persistent” move up in inflation. He wants to make sure that inflation expectations return to levels that are consistent with the Fed’s target in order to re-anchor inflation’s long-run trend. The widespread consensus that the “Phillips Curve is flat” makes inflation expectations even more important in the minds of Fed policymakers. When people say that the “Phillips Curve is flat”, they mean that there is very little relationship between resource utilization and inflation. In other words, the coefficient b4 in Box 1 is very small. Logically, if the relationship between resource utilization and inflation is weak, then expectations become an even more important driver of core inflation. As Fed Vice Chair Richard Clarida recently said:5 A flatter Phillips Curve makes it all the more important that inflation expectations remain anchored at levels consistent with our 2 percent inflation objective. Simply put, the Fed needs to see a re-anchoring of inflation expectations before it lifts rates. Our sense is that this will be achieved when both the 10-year and 5-year/5-year forward TIPS breakeven inflation rates reach a range between 2.3% and 2.5%. We are not yet close to those levels. The 10-year and 5-year/5-year forward TIPS breakeven rates currently sit at 1.71% and 1.79%, respectively (Chart 2). Meanwhile, household survey measures from the University of Michigan and the New York Fed also show very low inflation expectations (Chart 2, bottom 2 panels). With all this in mind, the big question for monetary policy is how long will it take for inflation expectations to rise back to “well anchored” levels? Will it occur next year, or not until 2021? How Long Until Inflation (And Inflation Expectations) Return To Target? Chart 3High Inflation No Longer A Worry We have long held the view that inflation expectations adapt only slowly to changes in the actual inflation data.6 In other words, inflation expectations are low today because actual inflation has been consistently below the Fed’s target for much of the past decade. This makes it very difficult for people to believe that inflation will be high in the future. In fact, when asked what CPI inflation is likely to average over the next 10 years, most forecasters think it will be in a range between 2% and 2.5%, consistent with the Fed’s target.7 This is similar to what forecasters thought in 2004 when TIPS breakeven rates were well-anchored within our target band (Chart 3). The main difference between 2004 and today is that in 2004 a sizeable minority thought inflation might average above 2.5% over the next 10 years. Now, almost nobody expects a significant overshoot of the Fed’s inflation target, and a sizeable minority think inflation will undershoot. The lesson we take from these survey responses is that in order for TIPS breakeven inflation rates to reach our 2.3%-2.5% target, more people need to expect a significant overshoot of the Fed’s 2% inflation target. This will only happen if actual inflation rises to the Fed’s target, or above, and stays there for a significant period of time. Long enough to bring the fear of high inflation back to the forefront of investors’ minds. To further quantify this notion, our Adaptive Expectations Model of the 10-year TIPS breakeven inflation rate pegs current fair value for the 10-year breakeven at 1.94% (Chart 4). The model’s fair value is primarily determined by the 10-year rate of change in core CPI, meaning that a prolonged period of year-over-year core inflation near (or above) the Fed’s target will be required before our model’s fair value pushes above 2.3%. So how long will it take before core inflation is sustainably running at, or above, the Fed’s target? While we expect core inflation to continue along its slow upward trend. It probably won’t be high enough to push long-maturity TIPS breakevens into our target range until 2021, or late-2020 at the earliest. Chart 4Adaptive Expectations Model Chart 5Trimmed Means Are Rising... At present, core PCE inflation is running at a year-over-year rate of 1.59%, considerably below the Fed’s 2% target. One point in favor of rising core inflation is that trimmed mean price measures are accelerating more quickly than core measures (Chart 5). This will tend to drag core inflation higher over time. However, there is still a long way to go before core inflation reaches the Fed’s target and many leading inflation indicators have moderated this year (Chart 6):   Chart 6...But Many Headwinds Remain Unit labor cost growth rebounded in the past few quarters, but has yet to break out of its post-crisis range (Chart 6, top panel). The New York Fed’s Underlying Inflation Gauge rolled over sharply in 2019 (Chart 6, panel 2). NFIB surveys of planned and reported price increases have also turned down (Chart 6, bottom 2 panels). Considering the main components of core inflation, we find that the strong month-over-month core inflation prints of June, July and August were driven mostly by accelerating goods prices (Chart 7). Goods inflation has reversed course since then, and should continue to be a drag on core inflation going forward. This is because core goods inflation follows import price inflation with a long lag, and some import price deflation is already baked in (Chart 8). Chart 7CPI Components Chart 8Expect Some Import Price Deflation On the flipside, we have also seen core services inflation (excluding shelter and medical care) inflect higher during the past six months (Chart 7, panel 4). Continued strength in this component is essential if overall core inflation is going to move up. Shelter is the largest component of core inflation and we expect it to trend sideways as we head into 2020. The rental vacancy rate has flattened off at a low level, and the Apartment Market Tightness Index is just barely in net tightening territory (Chart 9). Neither indicator is sending a strong signal in either direction. Chart 9Shelter Inflation Trending Sideways All in all, we see core inflation and TIPS breakeven rates moving slowly higher in 2020. But it will take some time before inflation is strong enough to push long-maturity breakeven rates into our target range of 2.3%-2.5%. Given the importance placed on re-anchoring inflation expectations, the Fed won’t hike rates again until our TIPS breakeven target is met. We don’t expect this to occur until 2021, or late-2020 at the earliest. The Financial Conditions Wildcard Chart 10The Importance Of Financial Conditions We mentioned above that the Fed’s interest rate policy will be determined by two factors: inflation expectations and financial conditions. In a perfect world, financial market valuations will stay at reasonable levels and inflation expectations will determine the timing of the next Fed rate hike. However, we must also consider what is likely to happen if it takes a very long time for inflation expectations to reach our target. The longer it takes, the longer that monetary conditions will be accommodative, and any extended period of easy money could lead to an asset bubble. Eventually, if valuations look bubbly enough, there may be a case for the Fed to sacrifice a bit on its inflation target and attempt to deflate a potentially de-stabilizing bubble in financial markets. This is not just a hypothetical situation. As Governor Lael Brainard remarked last December:8 The last several times resource utilization approached levels similar to today, signs of overheating showed up in financial-sector imbalances rather than in accelerating inflation. With greater focus on financial stability than in the past, it is conceivable that we could eventually see Fed tightening to head off an asset bubble. But we are not close to such bubbly conditions yet (Chart 10). The Financial Conditions component of our Fed Monitor is close to neutral, and while corporate bond spreads are tighter than average, they are well above the lows seen in the mid-2000s. Meanwhile, the S&P 500’s forward multiple is not yet back to its early-2018 level, let alone the highs of the late 1990s (Chart 10, bottom panel). Bottom Line: The Fed’s next interest rate move will be a hike, but it probably won’t occur until 2021. It will not occur until either long-maturity TIPS breakeven inflation rates reach our target band of 2.3%-2.5% or financial asset valuations reach extreme levels. Balance Sheet Policy 2019 was a tumultuous year for the Fed’s balance sheet policy. At the start of the year, the Fed was continuing the process of balance sheet shrinkage that started in October 2017. The goal was never to return the Fed’s balance sheet to its pre-crisis size. Policymakers had already decided that they would shift permanently to a floor system of monetary policy implementation. A floor system is one where the central bank supplies more reserves to the banking system than are demanded, pushing interest rates down toward a floor that is set by the Fed. In this case, the floor is the Fed’s overnight reverse repo facility (ON RRP). Using this facility, the Fed agrees to borrow any excess cash at the ON RRP rate in return for a security from the Fed’s balance sheet as collateral. To implement this policy correctly, the Fed’s balance sheet must remain large so that bank reserves are plentiful. The Fed thought that it was supplying more reserves than the banking system demanded, but banks found themselves hoarding liquidity for a few days in September. Everything was going smoothly until September when this strategy hit a snag. The Fed thought that it was supplying more reserves than the banking system demanded, but banks found themselves hoarding liquidity for a few days in September. The result was that the fed funds rate shot higher, and actually printed outside the Fed’s target band for one day (Chart 11).9 Chart 11The Fed Briefly Lost Control Of Rates In September Clearly, the Fed had actually not been supplying the banking system with more reserves than it wanted, otherwise overnight liquidity would have remained plentiful throughout September. Even more vexing is that surveys of primary dealers and market participants all showed that reserve supply was comfortably above demand (Chart 12), even though this turned out not to be the case. Chart 12The Fed Was Blindsided Though there are many questions that still need to be answered, the Fed quickly took action and intervened in the repo market to increase the daily reserve supply. It also re-started T-bill purchases at a rate of $60 billion per month, ending the period of balance sheet shrinkage. Then just last week, the Fed announced a program of term repo agreements that will increase overnight liquidity heading into the volatile year-end period. After all that, the Fed’s balance sheet is once again growing as we head into 2020. But there is much uncertainty about how the balance sheet will evolve during the next 12 months.  A Two-Pronged Strategy In 2020 the Fed will attack its balance sheet problems on two fronts. 1) Increase Reserve Supply First, it will purchase T-bills in order to increase the supply of reserves. Chart 13 shows how the Fed’s securities holdings and bank reserves will evolve in the first half of 2020, assuming that the Fed buys $60 billion of T-bills per month. We also assume that maturing MBS roll over into Treasury securities and that currency in circulation grows at a rate of 5% per year. Table 1 gives a breakdown of what the Fed’s balance sheet looks like today and what it will look like at the end of June, according to our assumptions. Chart 13The Fed's Balance Sheet Over Time But increasing the reserve supply will be a bit more difficult than that. For one thing, Table 1 shows that the Treasury Department’s General Account at the Fed is expected to grow by another $106 billion. All else equal, this will drain $106 billion of reserve supply. The Treasury depleted its cash holdings down to $130 billion in August, as it took extraordinary measures to stay under the debt ceiling. But now that the debt ceiling has been suspended until July 2021, the Treasury has been re-building its cash stores, targeting a level of $410 billion. Table 1Fed’s Balance Sheet: Projections Second, Table 1 assumes that Fed repos stay flat at $213 billion. But if the Fed decides to extricate itself from the repo market in the first half of 2020 then, all else equal, reserve supply will shrink by $213 billion. So far the Fed has provided very little guidance about its future presence in the repo market, but we expect it to err on the side of caution. That is, the Fed will not completely unwind its repo operations until it is confident that reserve supply is comfortably above demand. What we can say for certain is that the Fed will try to increase the reserve supply in early-2020. Then, at some point during the year, it will decide that the reserve supply is high enough and it will shift to purchasing only enough securities to keep pace with growth in non-reserve liabilities, holding reserve supply flat. It is unknown when that shift will occur, but whenever it does, the Fed’s balance sheet will still be growing, just more slowly. We can say decisively that the era of balance sheet shrinkage is over. At some point in 2020 the Fed will probably also introduce a standing repo facility. This will act as the mirror image of the current ON RRP, providing a ceiling on interest rates. The facility will promise to supply overnight cash at a stated rate in return for Treasury collateral. If reserve supply is sufficiently high, then the standing repo facility is irrelevant. It would merely be a safety measure in case of periods like last September when reserve demand spiked. 2) Decrease Reserve Demand Other than increasing reserve supply, the Fed will also take steps in 2020 to reduce the amount of reserves demanded by the banking sector. It will do this by tweaking some banking regulations that possibly encouraged banks to hoard reserves in September. The Liquidity Coverage Ratio is the regulation that requires banks to hold enough high-quality liquid assets (HQLA) to cover 30 days of cash outflows in a stressed scenario. Bank reserves and Treasury securities both count as HQLAs, as do other fixed income securities with a haircut. In theory, the Liquidity Coverage Ratio shouldn’t prevent banks from swapping reserves for Treasuries in the repo market. But banks also undergo frequent internal stress testing, in preparation for the Fed’s periodic stress tests, and those internal tests may place a premium on reserves over Treasuries. It is very likely that, in 2020, the Fed will take steps to make banks increasingly indifferent between holding reserves and Treasury securities. This should reduce overall reserve demand and make cash more freely available in the overnight repo market. Investment Implications With all that said, we place very little importance on the Fed’s balance sheet policy in terms of what it means for asset returns. Our longstanding view is that asset purchases were only an effective policy tool because they reinforced the Fed’s forward guidance about changes in the funds rate. In fact, any perceived correlation between changes in the size of the Fed’s balance sheet and financial asset prices is only because balance sheet policy was moving in the same direction as interest rate policy. That is, during the past few years, periods of Fed asset purchases have always coincided with easier interest rate policy and periods of balance sheet shrinkage have always coincided with tighter interest rate policy. It is the interest rate policy that determines movements in asset prices, not the balance sheet. Finally, in 2019, we witnessed a period when balance sheet policy diverged from interest rate policy and we were able to test our thesis. Between December 2018 and July 2019, the Fed was shrinking its balance sheet but also easing its forward rate guidance and preparing for rate cuts. Outstanding bank reserves fell by $124 billion, but the expected 12-month change in the fed funds rate fell from +11 bps to -88 bps. It is very likely that, in 2020, the Fed will take steps to make banks increasingly indifferent between holding reserves and Treasury securities. What happened during this period? Bond yields declined and the dollar depreciated (Chart 14). Meanwhile, risk asset prices shot higher (Chart 15). In other words, markets behaved as you would expect if the Fed were easing policy, clearly taking their cues from interest rate policy not the balance sheet. Chart 14Rates Policy Trumps Balance Sheet Part I Chart 15Rates Policy Trumps Balance Sheet Part II Bottom Line: The era of balance sheet shrinkage is over. The Fed will continue to grow its balance sheet in 2020, and will also tweak regulations to make banks more indifferent between holding Treasury securities and reserves. But more importantly, the Fed’s balance sheet policy is now completely de-linked from its interest rate policy. That being the case, investors should largely ignore trends in the Fed’s balance sheet and focus on interest rate policy as the main driver of asset returns. The Fed’s Strategic Review The Fed is currently undertaking a strategic review of its monetary policy strategy, tools and communications practices. Chair Powell has said that he expects the review to be completed by the middle of 2020, and it is likely that some important changes will be announced. According to the Fed, the review is taking place because “the US economy appears to have changed in ways that matter for the conduct of monetary policy.” Specifically, the Fed believes that the neutral fed funds rate – the rate consistent with stable inflation – is structurally lower. The Fed is concerned that this increases the risk of the fed funds rate being pinned at its effective lower bound (ELB), making it more difficult to consistently hit its inflation target. The review is about considering different strategies and tools that the Fed could use to more consistently hit its 2% inflation target in the future, but the 2% target itself is not up for discussion. The Fed has already decided that 2% inflation is most consistent with its price stability mandate. Policy Strategy Chart 16A Big Miss One thing that’s clear is that most Fed participants agree that some changes to policy strategy are necessary. There is widespread concern about the fact that the Fed has not hit its inflation target during the past decade. The Fed officially adopted a 2% target for PCE inflation in January 2012, but inflation has not come close to those levels since. Headline and core PCE have increased at average annual rates of only 1.3% and 1.6%, respectively, since 2012 (Chart 16). At the July and September FOMC meetings, the Fed discussed several different strategies that could make it easier to hit its inflation target. Most of the proposals fall into the category of “makeup strategies”, strategies where the Fed tries to make up for a period of below-2% inflation by targeting above-2% inflation for a stretch of time. In theory, most Fed members agree that such strategies make sense. From the September FOMC minutes:10 Because of the downside risk to inflation and employment associated with the ELB, most participants were open to the possibility that the dual-mandate objectives of maximum employment and stable prices could be best served by strategies that deliver inflation rates that over time are, on average, equal to the Committee’s longer-run objective of 2 percent. Promoting such outcomes may require aiming for inflation somewhat above 2 percent when the policy rate was away from the ELB, recognizing that inflation would tend to be lower than 2 percent when the policy rate was constrained by the ELB. The main problem with these sorts of makeup strategies is what Fed Governor Lael Brainard calls the time-inconsistency problem.11 For example, if inflation has been running well below – or above – target for a sustained period, when the time arrives to maintain inflation commensurately above – or below – 2 percent for the same amount of time, economic conditions will typically be inconsistent with implementing the promised action. In other words, when it comes time to deliver on its past promises, the Fed may not want to. But if it fails to deliver, it makes any future promises less impactful. Governor Brainard thinks that this problem can be mitigated by adopting a more flexible approach. That is, rather than following a strict rule that says that the Fed must aim for average inflation of 2 percent over a specific timeframe, it could simply opportunistically change its target inflation range based on the circumstances. She gives the following example: For instance, following five years when the public has observed inflation outcomes in the range of 1-1/2 to 2 percent, to avoid a decline in expectations, the Committee would target inflation outcomes in a range of, say, 2 to 2-1/2 percent for the subsequent five years to achieve inflation outcomes of 2 percent on average overall. We think it is very likely that something similar to Brainard’s plan will be announced when the review is completed in 2020. There is widespread consensus that the Fed should temporarily target an overshoot of its 2 percent inflation target to ensure that inflation expectations stay anchored near target levels. Opportunistically shifting the inflation target to 2%-2.5% on a temporary basis seems like the easiest way to communicate that goal. ELB Tools In addition to potential changes to policy strategy, the Fed has also been talking about potential policy tools that could be deployed the next time that interest rates reach the ELB. Policymakers took up this question in detail at the October FOMC meeting and generally agreed that the combination of forward guidance and asset purchases had been effective at delivering policy accommodation at the lower bound. Now that the committee is comfortable with these tools, we would expect them to be deployed very quickly the next time that the fed funds rate reaches zero. In all likelihood, if the funds rate reaches zero again, the Fed will quickly announce a round of asset purchases and pledge to keep rates on hold until some economic outcome – likely related to inflation – is met. The Fed also discussed the possibility of cutting rates into negative territory, but there is very little appetite for negative rates policy in the US. From the October FOMC minutes:12 All participants judged that negative interest rates currently did not appear to be an attractive monetary policy tool in the United States. Participants commented that there was limited scope to bring the policy rate into negative territory, that the evidence on the beneficial effects of negative interest rates abroad was mixed, and that it was unclear what effects negative rates might have on the willingness of financial intermediaries to lend and on the spending plans of households and businesses. If, during the next ELB phase, the combination of forward rate guidance and asset purchases does not appear to be working quickly enough, we think it’s most likely that the Fed will follow the Bank of Japan and simply extend these policies further out the yield curve. For example, the Fed would set a cap on some intermediate-maturity Treasury yield (say the 2-year yield), and pledge to buy as many securities as necessary to keep the yield below that cap. This potential tool was discussed at the October FOMC meeting, and it received a more favorable response than the negative rates policy. Results Of The Strategic Review The exact form of any new policy strategy is uncertain, but we expect the Fed to make an announcement in mid-2020 that makes it clear that it will explicitly target above-2% inflation for some unspecified period of time in order to re-anchor inflation expectations and make up for past inflation misses. This will make it even more important to use inflation expectations as our guide for detecting shifts in Fed policy, rather than the actual inflation data. In many ways, the Fed’s reaction function has already moved toward targeting expectations. The results of the 2020 strategic review will make that even more explicit. There is less urgency to announce any potential new tools for conducting policy at the ELB, and we do not expect much in that regard. Other than some ideas for further study.   Ryan Swift US Bond Strategist rswift@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Please see Global Fixed Income Strategy Special Report, “2020 Key Views: Delay Of Reckoning”, dated December 10, 2019, available at gfis.bcaresearch.com and US Bond Strategy Special Report, “2020 Key Views: US Fixed Income”, dated December 10, 2019, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 2 For details on BCA’s economic outlook for 2020 please see The Bank Credit Analyst, “Outlook 2020: Heading Into The End Game”, dated November 22, 2019, available at bca.bcaresearch.com 3 Please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “The New Battleground For Monetary Policy”, dated March 26, 2019, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 4  https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/yellen20150924a.htm 5  https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/clarida20190926a.htm 6 Please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “Adaptive Expectations In The TIPS Market”, dated November 20, 2018, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 7 CPI inflation runs about 0.4%-0.5% above PCE inflation, so the Fed’s 2% PCE target translates to a 2.4%-2.5% target for CPI. 8  https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/brainard20181207a.htm 9 This September episode is discussed in detail in the US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “What’s Up In US Money Markets?”, dated September 24, 2019, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 10 https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/fomcminutes20190918.htm 11 https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/brainard20191126a.htm 12 https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/files/fomcminutes20191030.pdf
Consistent with our bullish view on global equities, we expect corporate bonds to outperform sovereign debt in 2020. Despite the weakness in manufacturing, US banks further eased terms on commercial and industrial loans in Q3, according to the Fed’s Senior…
  Dear Client, In lieu of our regular report next week, I will be hosting a webcast on Wednesday, December 18th at 10:00 AM EST, where I will discuss the major investment themes and views I see playing out for 2020. This will be the last Global Investment Strategy report of 2019, with publication resuming early next year. On behalf of the entire Global Investment Strategy team, I would like to wish you a Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays, and a Healthy New Year! Best regards, Peter Berezin, Chief Global Strategist   Overall Investment Strategy: Global growth should accelerate in 2020. Favor stocks over bonds. A more defensive stance will be appropriate starting in late 2021. Equities: Upgrade non-US equities to overweight at the expense of their US peers. Cyclical stocks, including financials, will outperform defensives. Fixed Income: Central banks will stay dovish, but bond yields will nevertheless rise modestly thanks to stronger global growth. Favor high-yield corporate credit over investment grade and sovereigns. Currencies: The US dollar will weaken in 2020 against EUR, GBP, CAD, AUD, and most EM currencies. The dollar will be flat against the yen and the Swiss franc. Commodities: Oil and industrial metals prices will move higher. Gold prices will be range-bound next year, but should rally in 2021 once inflation finally breaks out. GIS View Matrix   I. Global Macro Outlook Stronger Global Growth Ahead We turned bullish on global equities last December after temporarily moving to the sidelines in the summer of 2018. Last month, we increased our procyclical bias by upgrading non-US stocks within our recommended equity allocation at the expense of their US peers. The decision to upgrade non-US equities stems from our expectation that global growth will strengthen in 2020. Global financial conditions have eased sharply this year, largely due to the dovish pivot by many central banks. Monetary policy affects the economy with a lag. This is one reason why the net number of central banks cutting rates has historically led global growth by about 6-to-9 months (Chart 1). Chart 1The Effects Of Easing Monetary Policy Should Soon Trickle Down To The Economy In addition, there is mounting evidence that the global manufacturing cycle is bottoming out (Chart 2). The “official” Chinese PMI produced by the National Bureau of Statistics rose above 50 in November for the first time since May. The private sector Caixin manufacturing PMI has been improving for five consecutive months. The euro area manufacturing PMI increased over the prior month, led by gains in Germany and France. Chart 2A Fairly Regular Three-Year Manufacturing Cycle Chart 3The Auto Sector Is Showing Signs Of Life (I)   The PMI data for the US has been mixed. The ISM manufacturing index weakened in November. In contrast, the Markit PMI rose to a seven-month high. Despite its shorter history, we tend to give the Markit PMI more credence. It is based on a larger sample of companies and has sector weights that closely match the actual composition of US output. As such, the Markit PMI is better correlated with hard data on manufacturing production, employment, and factory orders. The auto sector has been particularly hard hit during this manufacturing downturn. Fortunately, the industry is showing signs of life. The Markit euro area auto sector PMI has rebounded, with the new orders-to-inventory ratio moving back into positive territory for the first time since the autumn of 2018. US banks stopped tightening lending standards for auto loans in the third quarter. They are also reporting stronger demand for vehicle financing (Chart 3). In China, vehicle production and sales are improving on a rate-of-change basis (Chart 4). Both automobile ownership and vehicle sales in China are still a fraction of what they are in most other economies, suggesting further upside for sales (Chart 5). Chart 4The Auto Sector Is Showing Signs Of Life (II) Chart 5China: Structural Outlook For Autos Is Bright     Trade War Uncertainty The trade war remains the biggest risk to our sanguine view on global growth. As we go to press, rumors are swirling that the US and China have reached a “Phase One” trade deal that would cancel the scheduled December 15th tariff hike and roll back as much as half of the existing tariffs. If this were to occur, it would be consistent with our expectation of a trade truce. Nevertheless, it is impossible to be certain about how things will unfold from here. The best we can do is think through the incentives that both sides face and assume they will act in their own self-interest. For President Trump, the key priority is to get re-elected next year. Trump generally gets poor grades from voters on most issues. The one exception is the economy. Rightly or wrongly, the majority of voters approve of his handling of the economy (Chart 6). An escalation of the trade war would hurt the US economy, especially in a number of Midwestern states that Trump needs to win to remain president (Chart 7). Chart 6Trump Gets Reasonably High Marks On His Handling Of The Economy, But Not Much Else Chart 7Economic Health Of The US Midwest Matters For Trump A resurgence in the trade war would also hurt Trump’s credibility. The point of the tariffs was not simply to raise revenue; it was to get China to the negotiating table. As a self-described master negotiator, President Trump now has to produce a “great” deal for the American people. If he had finalized an agreement with China a year or two ago, he would currently be on the hook for showing that it resulted in a smaller trade deficit. But with the presidential election only a year away, he can semi-credibly claim that the trade balance will only improve after he is re-elected. For their part, the Chinese would rather grapple with Trump now than face him after the election when he will no longer be constrained by re-election pressures. China would also like to avoid facing someone like Elizabeth Warren or Bernie Sanders, who may insist on including stringent environmental and human rights provisions in any trade deal. At least with Trump, the Chinese know that they are getting someone who is focused on commercial issues. Contrary to most media reports, there is a fair amount of overlap between what Trump wants and what the Chinese themselves would like to achieve. For example, as China has moved up the technological ladder, many Chinese companies have begun to complain about intellectual theft by their domestic rivals. Thus, strengthening intellectual property protection has become a priority for Chinese officials. Along the same vein, China aspires to transform the RMB into a reserve currency. A country cannot have a reserve currency unless it also has an open capital account. Hence, financial market liberalization must be part of China’s long-term reform strategy. These mutual interests between the US and China could provide the basis for a trade truce. The Changing Nature Of Chinese Stimulus Chart 8China: Credit Growth Is Only A Few Percentage Points Above Nominal GDP Growth If a détente in the trade war is reached, will this prompt China to go back to its deleveraging campaign? We do not think so. For one thing, there can be no assurance that a trade truce will last. Thus, China will want to maintain enough stimulus as an insurance policy. In addition, credit growth is currently running only a few percentage points above nominal GDP growth (Chart 8). With the ratio of credit-to-GDP barely rising, there is little need to bring credit growth down much from current levels. This does not mean that the Chinese authorities will allow credit growth to increase significantly further. Instead, the authorities will continue shifting the composition of credit growth from the riskier shadow banking sector to the safer formal banking sector, while increasingly leaning on fiscal policy to buttress growth. One of the developments that has gone largely unnoticed by investors this year is that China’s general government deficit has climbed from around 3% of GDP in mid-2018 to 6.5% of GDP at present (Chart 9). Some of this stimulus has been used to finance tax cuts for households. Some of it has also been used to finance infrastructure spending, which requires imports of raw materials and capital goods. As a result of this fiscal easing, the combined Chinese credit/fiscal impulse has risen to a two-year high. It leads global growth by about nine months (Chart 10). Chart 9China Has Been Stimulating, Fiscally Chart 10Chinese Stimulus Should Boost Global Growth   Europe On The Upswing Chart 11Euro Area Growth: The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly Chart 12German Economy: Some Green Shoots The weakness in euro area growth this year has been concentrated in Germany and Italy. France and Spain have actually grown at a trend-like pace (Chart 11). Germany should benefit from stronger global growth and a recovery in automobile production next year. The recent rebound in the German PMI, as well as improvements in the expectations components of the IFO, ZEW, and Sentix surveys are all encouraging in this regard (Chart 12). Italy should also gain from an easing in financial conditions and receding political risks (Chart 13). The Italian 10-year government bond yield has fallen from a high of 3.69% in October 2018 to 1.23% at present. Chart 13Easing Financial Conditions And Less Political Uncertainty Will Help Italy Chart 14Euro Area Fiscal Thrust   Fiscal policy across the euro area is also turning more stimulative. The fiscal thrust in the euro area rose to 0.4% of GDP this year mainly due to a somewhat larger budget deficit in France (Chart 14). The thrust should remain positive in 2020. Even in Germany, fiscal policy should loosen. Faster wage growth in Germany is eroding competitiveness relative to the rest of the euro area (Chart 15). That could force German policymakers to ratchet up fiscal stimulus in order to support demand. Already, the Social Democrats are responding to poor electoral performance by adopting a more proactive fiscal policy, hoping to stop the loss of votes to the big spending Greens. Chart 15Germany: Faster Wage Growth Eroding Competitiveness Relative To The Rest Of The Euro Area Chart 16Boris Johnson Won't Pursue A No-Deal Brexit   The UK economy should start to recover next year as Brexit uncertainty fades and fiscal policy turns more stimulative. Exit polls suggest that the Conservatives will command a majority government following today's election. There is not enough appetite within the Conservative party for a no-deal Brexit (Chart 16). As such, today's victory will allow Prime Minister Boris Johnson to push his proposed deal through Parliament. It will also allow him to fulfill his pledge to pass a budget that boosts spending.   Japan: Own Goal Japan has been hard hit by the global growth slowdown, given its close ties to its Asian neighbors, namely China. Add on a completely unnecessary consumption tax hike, and it is no wonder the economy has been faltering. Despite widespread weakness, there have been some very preliminary signs of improvement of late: The manufacturing PMI ticked up in November, while the services PMI rose back above 50. Consumer confidence also moved up to the highest level since June. Furthermore, Prime Minister Abe announced a multi-year fiscal package worth approximately 26 trillion yen. The headline number grossly overstates the size of the stimulus because it includes previously announced measures as well as items such as land acquisition costs that will not directly benefit GDP. Nevertheless, the package should still boost growth by about 0.5% next year, offsetting part of the drag from higher consumption taxes.  US: Chugging Along Despite the slowdown in global growth, a stronger dollar, and the trade war, US real final demand is on track to grow by 2.5% this year (Chart 17). This is above the pace of potential GDP growth of 1.7%-to-2%. Chart 17Underlying US Growth Remains Above Trend The Fed’s 75 basis points of rate cuts has moved monetary policy even further into accommodative territory. Not surprisingly, residential housing – the most interest rate-sensitive part of the economy – has responded favorably (Chart 18). While the tailwind from lower mortgage rates will dissipate by next summer, we do not anticipate much weakness in the housing market. This is because the inventory levels and vacancy rates remain near record-low levels (Chart 19). The shortage of homes should buttress both construction and prices. Chart 18US Housing: On Solid Ground (I) Chart 19US Housing: On Solid Ground (II)   Strong labor and housing markets will support consumer spending, which represents nearly 70% of the economy. Business capital spending should also benefit from lower rates, receding trade tensions, and rising wages which are making firms increasingly eager to automate. II. Financial Markets Global Asset Allocation We argued in the section above that global growth should rebound next year thanks to easier financial conditions, an upturn in the global manufacturing cycle, a detente in the trade war, and modest Chinese stimulus. Chart 20 shows that stocks usually outperform bonds when global growth is accelerating. This occurs partly because corporate earnings tend to rise when growth picks up. BCA’s US equity strategy team expects S&P 500 EPS to increase by 5% next year if global growth merely stabilizes. An acceleration in global growth would surely lead to even stronger earnings growth. On the flipside, investors also tend to price out rate cuts (or price in rate hikes) when growth is on the upswing, resulting in lower bond prices (Chart 21). Chart 20Stocks Usually Outperform Bonds When Global Growth Is Accelerating Chart 21Improving Global Growth Boosts Earnings Growth...And Expectations Of Rate Hikes Relative valuations also favor stocks over bonds. Despite the stock market rally this year, the MSCI All-Country World Index currently trades at a reasonable 15.8-times forward earnings. This is below the forward PE ratio of 16.7 reached in January 2018 and even below the forward PE ratio of 16.4 hit in May 2015. Analysts expect global EPS to increase by 10% next year, below the historic 12-month expectation of 15% (Chart 22). In contrast to most years when analyst forecasts prove to be wildly overoptimistic, the current EPS forecast is likely to be met. Chart 22Analyst Expectations Are Not Wildly Optimistic Chart 23Equity Risk Premium Remains Quite Elevated   If one inverts the PE ratio, one can calculate an earnings yield for global equities of 6.3%. One can then calculate the implied equity risk premium (ERP) by subtracting the real long-term bond yield from the earnings yield. As Chart 23 illustrates, the ERP remains quite elevated by historic standards. Some observers might protest that the ERP is elevated mainly because bond yields are so low. If low bond yields are discounting very poor economic growth prospects, perhaps today’s PE ratio should be lower than it actually is? The problem with this argument is that growth prospects are not so bad. The IMF estimates that global growth will be slightly above its post-1980 average over the next five years (Chart 24). While trend growth is falling in both developed and emerging economies, the rising share of faster-growing emerging markets in global GDP is helping to prop up overall growth. Chart 24The Trend In Global Growth Has Remained Steady Thanks To Faster-Growing EM Sector And Regional Equity Allocation US stocks have outperformed their overseas peers by 10% year-to-date and by 137% since 2008. About half of the outperformance of US equities since the Great Recession was due to faster sales-per-share growth, a third was due to stronger margin growth, and the rest was due to relative PE expansion (Chart 25). Chart 25Faster Sales Growth, Rising Margins, And Relative PE Expansion Helped Drive US Outperformance Over The Past Decade It is worth noting that the outperformance of US stocks is a fairly recent phenomenon. Between 1970 and 2008, European equity prices and EPS actually rose slightly faster than in the US (Chart 26). EM stocks also outperformed the US in the decade leading up to the Global Financial Crisis. Chart 26US Earnings Have Not Always Outpaced Their Peers We expect US stocks to rise in 2020 by about 5%-to-10%, but to lag their foreign peers in common-currency terms. There are four reasons for this: Sector skews favor non-US equities. Cyclical stocks tend to outperform defensives when global growth is strengthening and the US dollar is weakening (Chart 27). Cyclical sectors are overrepresented outside the US. We would include financials in our definition of cyclicals. Faster global growth next year will lift long-term bond yields. Since central banks are unlikely to raise rates, yield curves will steepen. Steeper yield curves will boost net interest margins, thus helping bank shares (Chart 28). European banks are more dependent on the spread between lending and borrowing rates than US banks, since the latter derive more of their profits from fees. Non-US stocks are quite a bit cheaper than their US peers. The forward PE for US equities currently stands at 18.1, well above the forward PE of 13.6 for non-US equities. Other valuation measures reveal an even bigger premium on US stocks (Chart 29). Differences in sector weights account for about a quarter of the valuation gap between the US and the rest of the world. The rest of the gap is due to cheaper valuations within sectors. Financials, for example, are notably less expensive in the rest of the world, particularly in Europe (Chart 30). The valuation gap between the US and the rest of the world is even starker if we compare earnings yields with bond yields. Since bond yields are lower outside the US, the implied equity risk premium is significantly higher for non-US stocks. Profit margins have less scope to rise in the US than in the rest of the world. According to MSCI data, net operating margins currently stand at 10.3% in the US compared to 7.9% abroad. Unlike in the US, margins in Europe and EM are still well below their pre-recession peaks (Chart 31). While US margins are unlikely to fall next year thanks to stronger global growth, rising wage growth will negatively impact profits in some labor-intensive industries. Labor slack is generally greater abroad, which should limit cost pressures. Uncertainty over the US election is likely to limit the gains to US equities. All of the Democratic frontrunners have pledged to roll back the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act to one degree or another. A full repeal of the Act would reduce S&P 500 EPS by about 10%. While such a dramatic move is far from guaranteed – for starters, it would require that the Democrats gain control of both the White House and the Senate – it does pose a risk to investors. The same goes for increased regulatory actions, which Senators Sanders and Warren have both vocally championed. Chart 27Cyclicals Do Well Versus Defensives When Global Growth Is Strengthening And The US Dollar Is Weakening Chart 28Steeper Yield Curves Help Financials   Chart 29US Equities Are More Expensive Than Stocks Abroad Chart 30European Financials Trade At A Substantial Discount To Their US Peers     Chart 31Profit Margins Have Less Scope To Rise In The US Than In The Rest Of The World Within the non-US universe, euro area stocks have the most upside potential. In contrast, we see less scope for Japanese stocks to outperform the global benchmark because of uncertainties over the impact of the consumption tax hike on domestic demand. In addition, a weaker trade-weighted yen next year will annul the currency translation gains that unhedged equity investors can expect to receive from other non-US stock markets. Lastly, the passage of a new investment law that requires investors wishing to “influence management” to receive prior government approval could cast a pall over recent efforts to improve corporate governance in Japan. Fixed Income Chart 32Inflation Excluding Shelter Has Been Muted Chart 33Long-Term Bond Yields Will Move Higher As Faster Growth Pushes Up Estimates Of The Neutral Rate Central banks will remain on the sidelines next year. Inflation is still running well below target in most economies. Even in the US, where slack has largely been absorbed and wage growth has risen, core inflation excluding housing has averaged only 1.2% over the past five years (Chart 32). Nevertheless, long-term bond yields will still move higher next year as investors revise up their estimate of the neutral rate in response to faster growth (Chart 33). On a regional basis, BCA’s fixed-income experts favor low-beta bond markets (Chart 34). Japanese bonds have a very low beta to the overall Barclays Global Treasury index because inflation expectations are quite depressed and the Bank of Japan will actively intervene to prevent yields from rising. On a USD currency-hedged basis, the Japanese 10-year yield stands at a relatively decent 2.38%, above the yield of 1.79% on comparable maturity US Treasurys (Table 1). Chart 34Favor Lower-Beta Government Bond Markets In 2020 Table 1Bond Markets Across The Developed World In contrast to Japan, the beta of US Treasurys to the overall global bond index is relatively high, implying that Treasurys will underperform other sovereign bond markets in a rising yield environment. The beta for Germany, UK, Australia, and Canada lie somewhere between Japan and the US. Consistent with our bullish view on global equities, we expect corporate bonds to outperform sovereign debt in 2020 (Chart 35). Despite the weakness in manufacturing, US banks further eased terms on commercial and industrial loans in Q3, according to the Fed’s Senior Loan Officer Survey. Chart 35Stronger Growth Causes Corporate Spreads To Tighten At the US economy-wide level, neither interest coverage nor debt-to-asset ratios are particularly stretched (Chart 36). Admittedly, the picture looks less flattering if we focus solely on high-yield issuers (Chart 37). That said, a wave of defaults is very unlikely to occur in 2020, so long as the Fed is on hold and economic growth is on the upswing. Chart 36Corporate Debt: A Benign Top-Down View Chart 37Corporate Debt: More Concerning Picture Among High-Yield Issuers Chart 38US Corporates: Focus On High-Yield Credit Moreover, despite narrowing this year, high-yield spreads still remain above our fixed-income team’s estimate of fair value (Chart 38). They recommend moving down the credit curve and increasing the weight in Caa-rated bonds. These have underperformed this year largely because of technical factors such as their large exposure to the energy sector and relatively short duration. As oil prices rise next year, energy sector issuers will feel some relief. Moreover, unlike this year, rising long-term government bond yields in 2020 should also make shorter-duration credit more attractive. In contrast to high-yield spreads, investment-grade spreads have gotten quite tight. Investors seeking high-quality bond exposure should shift towards Agency MBS, which still carry an attractive spread relative to Aa- and A-rated corporate bonds. European IG bonds should also outperform their US peers thanks to faster growth in Europe next year and ongoing support from the ECB’s asset purchase program. Looking beyond the next 12-to-18 months, there is a strong chance that inflation will increase materially from current levels. The unemployment rate across the G7 has fallen to a multi-decade low, while the share of developed economies reaching full employment has hit a new cycle high (Chart 39). Chart 39ADeveloped Markets: Unemployment Rates Keep Trending Lower... And Full Employment Reaching New Cycle Highs Chart 39BDeveloped Markets: Unemployment Rates Keep Trending Lower... And Full Employment Reaching New Cycle Highs Chart 40The Phillips Curve Is Alive And Well   For all the talk about how the Phillips curve is dead, wage growth remains well correlated with labor market slack (Chart 40). Rising wages will boost real disposable incomes, leading to more spending. If economies cannot increase supply to meet higher demand, prices will rise. It simply does not make sense to argue that the price of apples will increase if the demand for apples exceeds the supply of apples, but that overall prices will not increase if the demand for all goods and services exceeds the supply of all goods and services. It will take at least until mid-2021 for inflation to rise above the Fed’s comfort zone. It will take even longer for rates to reach restrictive territory, and longer still for tighter monetary policy to make its way through the economy. However, at some point in 2022, the interest-rate sensitive sectors of the US economy will buckle, setting off a global economic downturn and a deep bear market in equities and credit. Enjoy it while it lasts. Currencies And Commodities The US dollar is a countercyclical currency, meaning that it usually moves in the opposite direction of the global business cycle (Chart 41). This countercyclicality stems from the fact that the US, with its large service sector and relatively small manufacturing base, is a “low beta economy.” Strong global growth does help the US, but it benefits the rest of the world even more. Thus, capital tends to flow out of the US when global growth strengthens, which puts downward pressure on the dollar. As global growth picks up in 2020, the dollar will weaken. EUR/USD should increase to around 1.15 by end-2020. GBP/USD will rise to 1.40. USD/CNY will move to 6.8. The Australian and Canadian dollars, along with most EM currencies, will strengthen as well. However, the Japanese yen and Swiss franc are likely to be flat-to-down against the dollar, reflecting the defensive nature of both currencies. Today's rally in the pound has raised the return on our short EUR/GBP trade to 10.5%. For now, we would stick with this position. Chart 42 shows that the pound should be trading near 1.30 against the euro based on real interest rate differentials, which is still well above the current level of 1.20. Chart 41The Dollar Is A Countercyclical Currency Chart 42Interest Rate Differentials Suggest More Upside For The Pound   The trade-weighted dollar will continue to depreciate until late-2021, and then begin to strengthen again as the Fed turns more hawkish and global growth starts to falter. Commodity prices tend to closely track the global growth/dollar cycle (Chart 43). Industrial metal prices will fare well next year. Oil prices will also move up. Globally, the last of the big projects sanctioned prior to the oil-price collapse in late 2014 are coming online in Norway, Brazil, Guyana, and the US Gulf. Our commodity strategists expect incremental oil supply growth to slow in 2020, just as demand reaccelerates. Gold is likely to be range-bound for most of next year reflecting the crosswinds from a weaker dollar on the one hand (bullish for bullion), and receding trade war risks and rising bond yields on the other hand. Gold will have its day in the sun starting in 2021 when inflation finally breaks out. Our key market charts are shown on the following page. Peter Berezin Chief Global Strategist peterb@bcaresearch.com Chart 43Dollar Weakness Is A Boon For Commodities   Key Financial Market Forecasts   MacroQuant Model And Current Subjective Scores Strategic Recommendations Closed Trades
Government bonds investors should focus their country exposure on lower-beta markets where yields are less correlated to moves in the overall level of global bond yields. We define a “high-beta” bond market as having a yield beta of 1.25 or higher, and a…
The combination of faster global growth and accommodative monetary policies laid out in the BCA Outlook 2020 report will delay the peak of the global credit cycle. This means investors should expect another year of corporate bond outperformance versus…
TIPS breakeven inflation rates are well below our target range of 2.3%-2.5%. It will take some time, and likely an overshoot of the Fed’s 2% inflation target, for them to reach that range as expectations adapt only slowly to rising core inflation. But even if…
Appropriate valuation measures show that high-yield corporate spreads are very attractive in the current environment, while investment grade corporate spreads are tight compared to our fair value estimates. From our analysis of the three phases of the cycle,…
Highlights We expect tensions from the Sino-US trade war to marginally ease in 2020, in the run-up to the US presidential election. The “Phase One” trade deal will likely be signed with a good possibility of some tariff rollbacks. Chinese policymakers will roll out more stimulus to secure an economic recovery in 2020, and external demand will improve. But we expect growth in both the domestic economy and exports to only modestly accelerate. During the next 6 to 12 months, investors should remain bullish on both Chinese A shares and investable stocks, while keeping in mind that relative outperformance, particularly for A-shares, could be frontloaded in the first half of the year. Despite sharply rising amount of defaults, Chinese onshore bonds are priced at a much higher premium than warranted by their default risk. We continue to favor Chinese onshore corporate bonds in both absolute terms and in relative to duration-matched government bonds. Feature BCA Research recently published its special year end Outlook report for 2020, which described the macro themes that are likely to drive global financial markets over the coming year. In this week’s China Investment Strategy report we elaborate on the Outlook, by reviewing our four key themes for China in the year ahead. Key Theme #1: Tension From The Trade War With The US Will Ease In 2020 Despite the harsh rhetoric and threats of retaliation from both the US and China, we expect that the real risks to the global economy from the Sino-US trade war will decline in 2020. In trade negotiations next year, both President Trump and President Xi will need to adjust to their respective constraints. Both President Trump and President Xi will need to adjust to their respective constraints next year. Trump must sustain a strong domestic economy to increase his re-election odds. He will cater to the US economy and financial markets, by trying to de-escalate trade tensions and keeping negotiations going with China. This means he is likely to hold off on tariffs on China, and quite possibly even agree to roll back tariffs to August 2019 or April 2019 levels (Chart 1). Chart 1Some Tariff Rollback Is Possible President Xi also faces economic constraints as the Chinese economy is on an unsure footing.  The buildup in leverage in the non-financial sector over the past decade has prevented Chinese policymakers from aggressively stimulating the economy by relying on the old debt-oriented policies. Chinese policymakers are concerned about employment stability.1 The private sector, which accounts for 80% of all job creation in China, has been disproportionally hit by the trade war and tariffs compared to the more domestically oriented state-owned enterprises. These economic constraints suggest that it is in China’s best interest to avoid any further friction with the US. Therefore, the “Phase One” trade deal will likely be signed, with a good possibility of some tariff rollbacks. Trade talks will continue in the run-up to the US presidential election, and any escalation will probably occur in non-trade, non-tariff areas. This means that policy uncertainty surrounding the Sino-US trade war will decline in 2020. Bottom Line: We expect tensions from the Sino-US trade war to marginally ease in 2020. However, the risk to this base case view is high and geopolitical uncertainty remains elevated, as suggested by our Geopolitical Strategy team.2 Trade war tensions could re-emerge, which potentially could end the global business cycle and equity bull market. Key Theme #2: Stimulus Versus Shock: Approaching An Inflection Point We presented some simple “arithmetic” in May showing that in order for investors to be bullish on Chinese stocks, the impact of China’s reflationary efforts needed to more than offset the negative shock to the economy from tariffs.3 In other words, a bullish Chinese equity scenario required Stimulus – Shock > 0. In terms of China’s real economy, 2019 essentially panned out to be a Stimulus – Shock =0 scenario, with a “half strength” reflationary response (measured by its credit impulse) barely offsetting the trade shock to the economy (Chart 2). So far on an aggregate level, the shock from tariffs on China’s economy has had a limited direct impact.  This is because exports to the US account for only 3.6% of China’s aggregate economy, whereas domestic capex accounts for more than 40% (Chart 3). Our calculation suggests a 10% annualized decline in export growth to the US would shave off 0.4 percentage points from China’s nominal GDP growth. Chart 2This Year, Measured Stimulus Has Just Offset Shocks To The Economy Chart 3Domestic Demand Much More Important Than Exports To The US Additionally, evidence suggests that a large portion of China’s exports to the US has been rerouted through peripheral countries, such as Taiwan and Vietnam (Chart 4). This fact explains why China’s exports have been in-line with the trend of global trade this year (Chart 5). Chart 4Chinese Exports Finding Alternative Routes To The US... Chart 5...And Total Exports Have Been Holding Up Chart 6China's Economic Slowdown Predates The Trade War It is important for investors to remember that China’s current economic slowdown predates the trade war and is due to its domestic financial deleveraging campaign that began in early 2017. The trade war exacerbated an existing downward trend in the economy, but was not the cause of it (Chart 6).  In 2020, while we expect a ceasefire in the trade war and a potential rollback of tariffs would ease the shock to China’s economy, we also believe that more pro-growth policy support is underway.4 From an investment perspective, this means both China’s economic conditions and corporate earnings will improve, supporting a bullish cyclical outlook for China-related assets. Still, several reasons point to the overall scale of stimulus being less than that of 2015-16, and the upside to China’s export growth will likely be limited given elevated geopolitical uncertainties. Therefore, it is unrealistic to expect a material acceleration in Chinese economic growth in 2020: China is still falling short of its target to double urban income by 2020. Chart 7A 6% Growth Next Year May Just Make The Cut Next year will mark the final year for Chinese policymakers to accomplish the goal of “Doubling GDP by 2020”. Without the recent upward revision to the level of its 2018 nominal GDP by 2.1%, China's economy would have to expand by at least 6.1% in 2020 to achieve the goal. The upward revision allows a lower economic growth rate in 2020 to reach the goal (Chart 7). China is still falling short of its target to double urban income by 2020 (Chart 8). While keeping economic growth and employment stable remains a top priority, the recent slight improvement in employment should provide some relief to Chinese policymakers (Chart 9). Chart 8China Is Falling Short Of Urban Income Target... Chart 9...But There Is Some Relief In The Labor Market     Monetary policy will remain accommodative, with room for further cuts to interest rates and the reserve requirement ratio (RRR). Nonetheless, we think Chinese policymakers will only allow monetary policy to loosen incrementally and modestly, while keeping a lid on corporate leverage. According to a recent article published by Yi Gang, the governor of China’s central bank, the PBoC will be keen to avoid another boom-bust cycle.5  Fiscal stimulus will continue to take the center stage in supporting growth in 2020, as noted in our November 20th China Investment Strategy Weekly.6  We expect that the National People’s Congress in March 2020 will approve higher quotas on issuing local government bonds, and loosened capital requirements will likely further boost local governments’ infrastructure project funding and expenditures. Transportation and urban development infrastructure projects will likely to continue receiving the most policy support in 2020. Other areas such as environmental protection, education, and social security will continue to be the Chinese government’s focus. These areas are unlikely to translate into immediate economic growth, but will improve China’s long-term economic and social structures. In contrast, compared to the 2015-2016 cycle, housing construction will receive less fiscal support (Chart 10). Overall, we expect the Chinese government to set next year’s real GDP growth target between 5.5 - 6.0%, a half of a percentage point lower than the growth target for 2019. Despite slower real output growth, nominal GDP and economic conditions will bottom in the first quarter of 2020, subsequently pushing up core inflation and reversing an ongoing deflation in the industrial sector (Chart 11). Chart 10Transportation And Urban Development Projects Are Again In Favor Chart 11Nominal Output Will Tick Up Soon   Bottom Line: Chinese policymakers will roll out more stimulus to secure an economic recovery in 2020, and external demand will improve. But we expect growth in both the economy and export to only modestly accelerate. Key Theme #3: Improved Earnings Outlook Supports A Cyclically Bullish View On Chinese Stocks A combination of further policy support, improved earnings and decreased trade tensions should provide tailwinds to Chinese stocks in 2020. Chinese stocks will outperform the global benchmark over a cyclical time horizon (6- to 12-months), for the following reasons:   Valuations are depressed relative to global averages: the forward P/E ratios of both China’s onshore A-shares and offshore investable stocks are well below the global benchmark (Chart 12).  While the forward P/E ratio of the A-share index is hovering around 12 times, the investable market has particularly suffered a setback from uncertainties surrounding the trade war. Even taking into account that structural weakness in the Chinese corporate earnings growth justifies for a lower multiple than the global average, both Chinese onshore and offshore stocks are offering even deeper discounts than their peaks in 2018, compared to global benchmarks. Chart 12Valuations Of Chinese Stocks Are Depressed Chart 13Chinese Corporate Earnings Closely Track Economic Conditions Both the economy and earnings growth will improve: We expect the Chinese economy to bottom in the first quarter of 2020. Given the close correlation between the coincident economic activity and earnings cycle, we expect earnings to also improve in 2020 (Chart 13).  Improved corporate earnings next year will be the catalyst for the currently cheap multiples in Chinese stocks to re-rate, and re-approach their early 2018 high. Our Earnings Recession Probability Model shows that the probability of an upcoming earnings recession has dropped to 35% from its peak of 85% in early 2019 (Chart 14).  Additionally, Chart 15 highlights that the 12-month forward EPS momentum has turned modestly positive. Chart 14Probability Of An Upcoming Earnings Recession Has Significantly Dropped Chart 1512-Month Forward EPS Momentum Has Turned Modestly Positive There are, however, a few caveats to our bullish cyclical view on Chinese stocks. First, while it is not our base case view, geopolitical risks, particularly the Sino-US trade war, could end the global business cycle and equity bull market in 2020. Within the context of falling global stocks, we think Chinese domestic A shares would passively outperform global benchmarks, as A shares are mostly driven by China’s domestic credit and economic growth, and are less sensitive to trade frictions. But investable stocks would clearly underperform in this scenario. The odds are decent that all of the outperformance of Chinese stocks in 2020 will be frontloaded in the first half of the year. Secondly, the odds are decent that all of the outperformance of Chinese stocks in 2020 will be frontloaded in the first half of the year. We expect credit growth, infrastructure spending and the economy to improve in the first quarter. If the “Phase One” trade deal is also signed during that period, onshore A shares and investable stocks will significantly outperform their global counterparts in the first and possibly the early part of the second quarter. However, in the second half of next year, if the Chinese economy stabilizes but stimulus does not ramp up further, then the upside potential in both bourses may be capped as investors will question whether Chinese stocks will continue to gain ground in relative terms. We will closely monitor Chinese credit growth and trade negotiations throughout 2020 to determine if there is more eventual upside potential to economic growth, and thus Chinese earnings prospects, than we currently believe.  While we recommend a cyclically bullish stance towards Chinese stocks for next year, our tactical (i.e. 0-3 month) stance remains neutral. We expect to align our tactical and cyclical stances soon, and are awaiting confirmation of a hard data improvement alongside a breakout of key technical conditions to do so.7 Bottom Line: During the next 6 to 12 months, investors should remain bullish on both Chinese A shares and investable stocks within a global equity portfolio. However, investors should also keep in mind that the relative outperformance, particularly for the A-share market, could be frontloaded in the first half of 2020. Key Theme #4: We Continue To Favor Chinese Onshore Bonds, Despite Default Concerns  Chart 16Global Investors Are Piling Into The Chinese Bond Market Despite sharply rising defaults, Chinese onshore bonds are still priced at a much higher premium than warranted by their default risk. This view is increasingly shared by global investors, as evident in the capital flows into China’s onshore bond market (Chart 16). While the total amount of bond defaults in the first eleven months of 2019 was an astonishing 120.4 billion yuan, they account for only half percent of China’s total onshore bonds issued.  A 0.5 percent default rate is in line with global ex-US, and 160 bps below the default rate in the US (Chart 17). Yet, Chinese corporate bond spreads are about 150-175 bps higher than their US counterparts, an overpriced risk premium in our view (Chart 18). Recently, despite mounting defaults, China’s corporate bond spreads have continued to narrow. This suggests that investors do not expect the record-high level of defaults in the past two years to damage China’s corporate sector in the near future. Moreover, China’s monetary policy remains ultra-loose, liquidity conditions have been largely stable, RMB devaluation and capital outflows have both been under control, and the Chinese economy is expected to bottom in the next quarter. Chart 17Chinese Default Rate Well Below Global Average Chart 18The Risk Premium Assigned To Chinese Corporate Bonds Seems Overdone Bottom Line: We continue to favor Chinese onshore corporate bonds in both absolute terms, and in relative to duration-matched government bonds.   Jing Sima China Strategist jings@bcaresearch.com     Footnotes 1    “China to take multi-pronged measures to keep employment stable,” State Council Executive Meeting, December 4, 2019. 2   Please see Geopolitical Strategy Special Report "2020 Key Views: The Anarchic Society," dated December 6, 2019, available at gps.bcaresearch.com 3   Please see China Investment Strategy Weekly Report "Simple Arithmetic," dated May 15, 2019, available at cis.bcaresearch.com. 4, 6, 7   Please see China Investment Strategy Weekly Report "Questions From The Road: Timing The Turn," dated November 20, 2019, available at cis.bcaresearch.com. 5   https://www.chainnews.com/articles/745634370915.htm Cyclical Investment Stance Equity Sector Recommendations
Highlights Global growth will rebound in 2020, led by the US and China, putting upward pressure on global bond yields. Maintain below-benchmark overall duration exposure. Central banks will stay dovish until policy reflation has clearly turned into inflation, limiting how high bond yields can climb in 2020 but sowing the seeds for a far more bond-bearish backdrop in 2021. Expect mild bear-steepening pressure on global yield curves, led by rising inflation expectations. Accommodative monetary policy and faster growth will delay the peak in the aging global credit cycle. Stay overweight global corporate debt versus sovereign bonds. Returns on global fixed income will be far lower in 2020 than in 2019, given rich valuation starting points. Country and sector selection will be more important in driving fixed income outperformance. For sovereign bonds, favor countries where yields are less sensitive to change in overall global yields; for credit, favor sectors with lower interest rate durations and lower spread volatility. Feature BCA Research’s Outlook 2020 report, outlining the main investment themes for next year from the collective mind of our strategists, was sent to all clients in late November.1 In this report, we discuss the broad implications of those themes for the direction of global fixed income markets in 2020. In a follow-up report to be published in the first week of the new year, we will translate those themes into specific recommended allocations and weightings within our model bond portfolio framework. A Summary Of The 2020 Outlook Chart 1Expect A Cyclical Rise In Global Yields In 2020 The main conclusions from the Outlook 2020 report were cyclically bullish looking out over the next twelve months, but more cautious beyond that. The downturn in global growth seen in 2019 is projected to end in response to several headwinds that have become tailwinds: a small wave of Chinese stimulus and reflation; more stimulative global monetary policies; the substantial easing of global financial conditions as risk assets have rallied worldwide; a fading drag on global manufacturing from inventory destocking; both China (weak growth) and the US (the 2020 US election) have good reasons to de-escalate the trade war in 2020. This backdrop should push global bond yields moderately higher in 2020, while maintaining a backdrop that is once again favorable for risk assets on a relative basis versus government debt (Chart 1). A critical element to this story is the supportive monetary policy backdrop. Central banks worldwide, led by interest rate cuts from the US Federal Reserve and a resumption of asset purchases from the European Central Bank (ECB), are now running more stimulative policies in response to this year’s global manufacturing slump and elevated level of political uncertainty. Policymakers will maintain accommodative monetary policy through 2020 to try and bring depressed inflation expectations back up to central bank targets. This will create a “sweet spot” for global risk assets, with improving economic growth and accommodative monetary policy. A repeat of the spectacular total return numbers seen across the majority of asset classes in 2019 is unlikely, but global equity and credit markets should solidly outperform government bonds. Yet all that monetary stimulus does not come without a price. Policymakers will maintain accommodative monetary policy through 2020 to try and bring depressed inflation expectations back up to central bank targets. This will create a “sweet spot” for global risk assets, with improving economic growth and accommodative monetary policy.  A revival of inflationary pressures in 2021 will force central banks to raise rates much more aggressively. Combined with a China that remains wary of promoting excess leverage, this will drive the current prolonged global business cycle expansion to its recessionary endgame, taking equity and credit markets down with it. This will eventually trigger a new decline in global bond yields as policymakers shift back to easing mode, but from much higher levels than today. Our Four Main Key Views For Global Fixed Income Markets In 2020 The following are the main implications for global fixed income investment strategy based off the conclusions from the 2020 BCA Outlook: Key View #1: Maintain below-benchmark overall duration exposure. The pickup in global growth that we expect in 2020 has its roots in two locations: China and the US. For China, policymakers are keenly aware that the current growth slowdown cannot continue, as it has already pushed nominal GDP growth below 8% (Chart 2). For an economy as highly leveraged as China, slowing nominal growth is lethal and must be avoided to prevent a surge in private sector defaults and rising unemployment. Already, China has delivered significant policy stimulus in 2019: the reserve requirement ratio has been cut by 400bps; taxes have been cut by 2.8% of GDP; capital spending at state-owned enterprises has increased; the currency has depreciated; and, more recently, monetary policy has been eased via traditional interest rate cuts. These measures have eased our index of Chinese monetary conditions and triggered a surge in the China credit impulse, which leads Chinese import growth (i.e. China’s most direct impact on the global economy) by nine months. There are signs that Chinese growth is already bottoming out, as evidenced by the recent pickup in the China manufacturing PMI. Expect more signs of improvement in the first half of 2020. The BCA global leading economic indicator (LEI) has been rising since January of this year, and the global LEI diffusion index is signaling that the upturn will continue in 2020 (Chart 3). With global financial conditions at highly stimulative levels thanks to the robust performance of risk assets in 2019, the backdrop is already conducive to faster global growth. BCA’s geopolitical strategists are of the view that a “détente” in the US-China trade war is still the most likely base case scenario, which would go a long way in reducing the growth-inhibiting effects of elevated uncertainty (bottom panel). Chart 2A Boost To Global Growth From China In 2020 Chart 3Lower Uncertainty + Easy Financial Conditions = Faster Growth As for the US, the lagged impact of the Fed’s 75bps of rate cuts this year has boosted domestic liquidity conditions in a pro-growth fashion. The BCA US Financial Liquidity Indicator, which leads not only US growth but also leads the BCA global LEI and commodity prices by 18 months, is already signaling that US economic momentum is set to bottom out in early 2020 (Chart 4). This signal is in addition to the leading properties of US financial conditions (middle panel), which suggests a reacceleration of real GDP growth back above trend is about to unfold. Chinese policy reflation has typically been a good leading indicator for US capex and is heralding a rebound in investment spending (bottom panel). The pickup in global growth would also help revive the dormant euro zone economy, which has been hit hard though plunging export demand and overall weakness in the manufacturing sector. The entire slump in euro area real GDP growth since the start of 2018 can be attributed to plunging net exports, while domestic demand has held steady (Chart 5). The increase in the China credit impulse and our global LEI diffusion index – both leading indicators of euro area export growth – are signaling that euro area export demand is already in the process of bottoming out (bottom two panels) and should gain momentum in the first half of 2020. Chart 4US Growth Is Poised To Accelerate Chart 5The Drag On European Growth From Trade Will Soon End This better growth backdrop will put moderate upward pressure on global bond yields in 2020. This better growth backdrop will put moderate upward pressure on global bond yields in 2020. Key View #2: Expect mild bear-steepening pressure on global yield curves, led by rising inflation expectations. While we expect bond yields to drift higher in the next 6-12 months, the upside will be capped with central banks likely to stay dovish until policy reflation has clearly turned into higher inflation. Interest rate markets will not begin to price in expectations of tighter monetary policy without evidence of actual inflation picking up. The Fed, ECB, Bank of Japan and other central banks have all stated publicly that they will maintain current accommodative policy settings until realized inflation has sustainably returned to target levels, typically around 2%. This would be a major change in the modus operandi of these policymakers, who have typically signaled rate hikes based simply on forecasts of higher inflation. The implication is that interest rate markets will not begin to price in expectations of tighter monetary policy without evidence of actual inflation picking up (Chart 6). Chart 6Central Banks Will Stay Dovish Until Inflation Sustainably Accelerates A critical ingredient for global inflation to begin moving higher again is a softer US dollar (USD). The year-over-year growth rate of the trade-weighted USD is correlated to global export price inflation and commodity price inflation, more generally (Chart 7). The typical drivers of the USD are all pointing in a more bearish direction: Chart 7The USD Is Critical For Global Reflation Chart 8Global Real Yields & Inflation Expectations Will Drift Higher In 2020 the Fed has cut interest rates multiple times since the summer and is expanding its balance sheet via repo operations and treasury bill purchases; global (non-US) growth is bottoming out, and capital tends to flow out of the USD into more cyclical currencies in Europe and EM when global growth is accelerating; elevated policy uncertainty, which tends to attract inflows into the safety of the USD, is starting to diminish. The combination of improving global growth and a softer USD would normally be enough to generate a significant increase in global bond yields. Yet we do not expect the sort of move higher in the real component of bond yields signaled by our global LEI diffusion index in 2020 (Chart 8, top panel). While real yields should move higher alongside faster growth, if there is no expected tightening of monetary policy as well, the move in real yields will be more limited. The grind higher in global bond yields that we expect in 2020 will come first through faster inflation expectations and, much later in the year, higher real bond yields when central bankers (starting with the Fed) begin to signal a need to turn more hawkish. The grind higher in global bond yields that we expect in 2020 will come first through faster inflation expectations and, much later in the year, higher real bond yields when central bankers (starting with the Fed) begin to signal a need to turn more hawkish. This suggests that inflation-linked bonds should perform reasonably well in countries where inflation is likely to accelerate the fastest, like the US. Faster inflation expectations will also result in some bear-steepening of global government bond yield curves in the first half of 2020 (Chart 9). There is very little curve steepening discounted in bond forward rates in the developed markets – a consequence of the general flatness of yield curves – which suggests that yield curve steepening trades could prove to be profitable in 2020. Chart 9Expect A Mild Bear-Steepening Of Global Yield Curves Chart 10The Fed Has Dis-Inverted The Treasury Curve In the case of the US, the Fed’s recent easing actions have pushed short-term interest rates below longer-term Treasury yields, removing the yield curve inversion that sparked recession fears among investors during the summer of 2019 (Chart 10). With the Fed likely to sit on its hands for most of next year, even as US growth and inflation are likely to improve, this will put additional bear-steepening pressure on the US Treasury curve. In Europe, bond markets have already discounted a very significant impact from the ECB restarting its Asset Purchase Program, which only began last month. Investment grade corporate bond spreads, as well as Italy-Germany government bond spreads, have narrowed substantially despite a weak euro area economy (Chart 11, bottom panel). Meanwhile, the term premium on 10-year German bunds is back to the deeply negative levels middle panel) seen when the ECB was expanding its balance sheet at a 30-40% pace, rather than the 5% pace implied by the current announced pace of purchases of 20 billion euros per month (top panel). This potentially leaves longer-term European yields exposed to the same bear-steepening pressures seen in other bond markets, even within the context of a renewed ECB bond-buying program. Chart 11European Bonds Already Discount A Very Dovish ECB Chart 12The Wild Card For Bonds Markets In 2020: Fiscal Policy A potentially big wild card for global bond markets next year will be fiscal policy, which can also exacerbate yield curve steepening pressures. Any sign of a push toward more government spending, particularly in Europe where there has been such reluctance to open the fiscal taps, would result in a sharper upward move in global bond yields than we are expecting. This is not because of a supply effect related to more government bond issuance that would require higher yields to attract buyers. It is because fiscal stimulus (Chart 12) would push growth to an even faster pace that would bring forward the date when inflation returns to policymaker targets and tighter monetary policy could commence. This would follow a similar path to the curve steepening dynamics described earlier, with a fiscal boost to growth pushing up longer-term inflation expectations before starting to push up short-term interest rate expectations. Key View #3: Stay overweight global corporate debt versus sovereign bonds. Investors should expect another year of corporate bond outperformance versus sovereign debt in the developed economies. The combination of faster global growth, somewhat higher inflation and accommodative monetary policies laid out in the BCA Outlook 2020 report will delay the peak in the aging global credit cycle. This means investors should expect another year of corporate bond outperformance versus sovereign debt in the developed economies. Low borrowing rates are already helping to extend the credit cycle by making it easier for highly indebted borrowers to service their debts. This can be seen in the US, where interest coverage ratios (using top-down data for the non-financial corporate sector) remain above the levels that have preceded previous recessions (Chart 13). Low borrowing rates are also helping indebted borrowers in Europe, particularly in Italy and Spain where the banking system is now far less exposed to non-performing loans than during the peak years of the 2011-12 European Debt Crisis (Chart 14). Chart 13Low Rates Helping Extend The US Credit Cycle Chart 14Low Rates Helping Ease Stress In European Banks Declining Non-Performing Loans Are A Positive For The European Periphery Chart 15A Cyclically Positive Backdrop For Global Corporates According to our checklist of indicators to watch for an end of the corporate credit cycle in the US – tight monetary policy, deteriorating corporate sector financial health, and tightening bank lending standards – only corporate financial health is flashing a warning signal according to our Corporate Health Monitor as we discussed in a recent report.2 In fact, our global Corporate Health Monitor is rolling over – a trend that should continue as growth improves in 2020 – which should support global corporate bond outperformance versus government debt next year (Chart 15). Key View #4: Returns on global fixed income will be far lower in 2020 than in 2019. Country and sector selection will be more important in driving fixed income outperformance in 2020. The start of 2020 looks far different in terms of fixed income valuations compared to the beginning of 2019. For example, the 10yr US Treasury yield started the year at 2.72% and is now 1.83%, while the 10yr German bund yield started this year at 0.24% and is now MINUS-0.31%. These lower yields reflect the slower pace of global economic growth and monetary policy easing delivered by the Fed and ECB. Yet at the same time, corporate credit spreads have narrowed in both the US (the high-yield index OAS is down from 526bps to 360bps) and the euro area (the investment grade index OAS is down from 152bps to 100bps). These massive rallies in global bond markets this year resulted in both lower government bond yields and tighter credit spreads - even with slower global growth that would normally be a trigger for wider spreads/higher risk premiums. Looking at the current valuation of government bond yields in the major developed markets from a long-run perspective, it is difficult to make the case that it is attractive. Medium-term real bond yields remain well below potential GDP growth rates, a consequence of central banks keeping policy rates well below neutral levels suggested by measures like the Taylor Rule (Chart 16). Chart 16Global Government Bonds Are Expensive Without the initial starting point of cheap valuations, fixed income return expectations for 2020 should be tempered. This means that rather than loading up on maximum duration risk and/or credit risk to capture big yield and spread moves, bond investors should be more selective in country, maturity and credit exposure to generate outperformance in 2020. Chart 17Favor Lower-Beta Government Bond Markets In 2020 For government bonds, that means focusing country exposures on lower-beta markets where yields are less correlated to moves in the overall level of global bond yields. Our preferred way to measure this is to look at the beta of monthly yield changes for the benchmark 10-year government yields of the major developed market countries to the overall Bloomberg Barclays Global Treasury index yield for the 7-10 year maturity bucket, over a rolling three-year window. We define a “high-beta” bond market as having a yield beta of 1.25 or higher, and a “low-beta” bond market as having a yield beta of 0.75 or lower. Under that definition, global bond investors should underweight higher-beta Canada, the US and Italy, and overweight low-beta Japan and Spain (Chart 17). Bond markets with betas between 1.25 and 0.75 (Germany, Australia, Sweden, the UK) can also be considered on their own fundamental merits. Of that list, we see Germany and Australia having a better chance of outperforming the UK and Sweden, given the greater odds that the Bank of England or Riksbank could signal a need to hike rates in 2020 compared to the ECB or Reserve Bank of Australia. Chart 18Stay Overweight Global Spread Product In 2020, But Be Selective For spread product, that means focusing exposure on sectors that are less risky, either defined by interest rate duration or spread volatility (i.e. spread duration). With credit spreads remaining near the low end of long-run historical ranges for nearly all major markets (Chart 18), it is hard to find examples of spread product being cheap in absolute terms. On a risk-adjusted basis, however, negatively-convex spread product like US and euro area high-yield debt and US agency MBS actually look more interesting in the rising yield environment we expect in 2020, since the interest rate durations of those fixed income sectors fell as bond yields declined in 2019. Thus, we recommend owning high-yield corporates over higher-duration investment grade corporates in the US and euro area, while also favoring US agency MBS over higher-quality credit tiers of US investment grade corporate credit.   Robert Robis, CFA Chief Fixed Income Strategist rrobis@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Please see The Bank Credit Analyst, “Outlook 2020: Heading Into The End Game”, dated November 22, 2019, available at bca.bcaresearch.com. 2 Please see BCA Research Global Fixed Income Strategy Weekly Report, “The Lowdown On Low-Rated High-Yield”, dated November 27, 2019, available at gfis.bcaresearch.com. Recommendations The GFIS Recommended Portfolio Vs. The Custom Benchmark Index Duration Regional Allocation Spread Product Tactical Trades Yields & Returns Global Bond Yields Historical Returns
Special Report Highlights Below-Benchmark Duration In 2020 H1. Improving global growth and the de-escalation of US/China trade tensions will put upward pressure on bond yields in the first half of 2020, making below-benchmark portfolio duration appropriate. US political risks could re-assert themselves as we head into 2020 H2, leading to a risk-off environment that causes bond yields to fall. We will likely recommend increasing portfolio duration in mid-2020 if the political situation plays out as we expect, or if the 5-year/5-year forward Treasury yield and 12-month Fed Funds Discounter reach our targets. Barbell Your Treasury Portfolio. The 2/10 Treasury slope will steepen modestly in the coming months, but will remain in a range between 0 bps and 50 bps in 2020. Any steepening will be concentrated in the real yield curve. The TIPS breakeven inflation curve is likely to flatten. Our valuation models suggest that a barbelled Treasury portfolio is the best way to position for this environment. Specifically, we recommend shorting the 5-year bullet and buying a duration-matched barbell consisting of the 2-year note and 30-year bond. Overweight Spread Product. Low inflation expectations will keep the Fed on hold in 2020. This accommodative monetary environment will keep defaults low and credit spreads tight. Spread product will outperform Treasuries in duration-matched terms. Favor High-Yield Versus Investment Grade. Appropriate valuation measures show that high-yield corporate spreads are very attractive in the current environment, while investment grade corporate spreads are tight compared to our fair value estimates. Overweight Mortgage-Backed Securities. Agency MBS look attractive compared to investment grade corporate bonds, especially in risk-adjusted terms. The risk of a refinancing surge in 2020 is minimal and mortgage lending standards are more likely to ease than tighten. MBS spreads have room to tighten in 2020. Overweight TIPS Versus Nominal Treasuries. TIPS breakeven inflation rates are well below our target range of 2.3%-2.5%. It will take some time, and likely an overshoot of the Fed’s 2% inflation target, for them to reach that range as expectations adapt only slowly to rising core inflation. But even if they don’t make it back to target, breakevens should still grind higher as the economy recovers in 2020. Feature BCA published its 2020 Outlook on November 22. That report lays out the main macroeconomic themes that our strategists see driving markets next year. This Special Report explains how investors can profit from those themes in US fixed income markets. Specifically, we offer six key US fixed income views for 2020. This report is limited to the six key investment views listed on page 1, and only discusses Fed policy in the context of how it influences those views. Next week we will publish a more comprehensive “Fed In 2020” report that will delve into our outlook for the Fed next year. Outlook Summary First, a brief summary of the main economic views presented in BCA’s 2020 outlook:1 The global manufacturing downturn that persisted throughout 2019 is quickly coming to an end. The following factors will cause global growth to rebound in early 2020: China eased economic policy significantly in 2019. Policymakers cut the reserve requirement ratio by 400 basis points, cut taxes by 2.8% of GDP, increased issuance of local government bonds to finance public infrastructure projects, and boosted capex at state-owned enterprises. The Fed cut rates by 75 bps, and other central banks also eased monetary policy in 2019. The global inventory purge that magnified the industrial sector’s pain in 2019 is exhausted. Both the US and China have incentives to de-escalate the trade war in the first half of 2020. Investors should remain invested in risk assets to take advantage of this favorable global macro environment. But 2020 is likely to be the last year of risk asset outperformance. Today’s accommodative monetary policy will revive inflationary pressures in 2021, and central banks will then be forced to lift rates much more aggressively. China will also continue to resist excess leverage. Neither the business cycle nor the equity bull market will withstand those final assaults in 2021. Key View #1: Below-Benchmark Duration In 2020 H1 Improving global growth and the de-escalation of US/China trade tensions will put upward pressure on bond yields in the first half of 2020, making below-benchmark portfolio duration appropriate. US political risks could re-assert themselves as we head into 2020 H2, leading to a risk-off environment that causes bond yields to fall. We will likely recommend increasing portfolio duration in mid-2020 if the political situation plays out as we expect, or if the 5-year/5-year forward Treasury yield and 12-month Fed Funds Discounter reach our targets. In prior research we identified the five macroeconomic factors that determine trends in US bond yields.2 They are: (i) global growth, (ii) the output gap, (iii) the US dollar, (iv) policy uncertainty and (v) sentiment. On global growth, the three measures that correlate most strongly with the 10-year Treasury yield are the Global Manufacturing PMI, the US ISM Manufacturing PMI and the CRB Raw Industrials index. As mentioned above, we expect all three of these indicators to move higher in the first half of 2020, but so far we have seen only tentative signs of a rebound. The Global PMI is back above 50 after bottoming at 49.3 in July, but the US ISM remains in contractionary territory and the CRB Raw Industrials index is in a downtrend (Chart 1). All three of these indicators will have to increase for our call to play out. The global manufacturing downturn that persisted throughout 2019 is quickly coming to an end. The same amount of economic growth is more inflationary when the output gap is small than when it is wide. For this reason, we also need some sense of the output gap to make a call on Treasury yields. We have found wage growth to be a useful indicator of the output gap, as evidenced by its strong correlation with the fed funds rate (Chart 2). As long as recession is avoided, strong wage growth will make it difficult for the Fed to aggressively cut rates. The upshot is that Treasury yields will not re-visit their mid-2016 lows until the next recession hits and wage pressures wane. For now, all leading wage growth indicators continue to point up (Chart 2, bottom 2 panels). Chart 1Factor 1: Global Growth Chart 2Factor 2: The Output Gap   The US dollar is the third important macro factor we consider. A strengthening dollar signals that US yields are de-coupling too far from yields in the rest of the world, making them more likely to fall back down. Conversely, an uptrend in US bond yields is likely to last longer in an environment of dollar weakness. The trade-weighted dollar has been rangebound during the past few months and bullish sentiment toward the dollar has declined significantly (Chart 3). This suggests that US yields have room to move higher. However, we will watch the dollar closely as bond yields rise in 2020 H1. A rapidly appreciating dollar would make us more inclined to fade any increase in US bond yields. The fourth factor we consider is policy uncertainty. It’s no secret that US Treasury securities benefit from flight to safety flows in times of heightened political stress. The tight correlation between the 10-year Treasury yield and the Global Economic Policy Uncertainty index demonstrates this nicely (Chart 4). In fact, it is now clear that uncertainty about the US/China trade war caused US yields to reach lower levels this year than was implied by the economic fundamentals alone. Chart 3Factor 3: The US Dollar Chart 4Factor 4: Policy Uncertainty   We see trade tensions continuing to die down as we head into the New Year. President Trump faces an election in November 2020, and he no doubt realizes that an incumbent President with a strong economy has a good chance of winning re-election. He therefore has a strong incentive to support economic growth. However, by the second half of next year, we see two potential political risks that could flare, causing bond yields to fall. First, if Trump finds himself behind in the polls by mid-summer, then he may change his strategy and re-escalate tensions with China or some other foreign policy target. Second, if one of the progressive candidates – Elizabeth Warren or Bernie Sanders – secures the Democratic nomination, stocks will likely sell off, precipitating a flight-to-quality into US bonds. All in all, we see the ebbing of policy uncertainty in the first half of 2020 helping to push bond yields higher. But risks could flare again in the 2020 H2, sending yields back down. Chart 5Factor 5: Sentiment The final factor we consider when forecasting bond yields is sentiment, and we find the Economic Surprise Index to be the most useful sentiment measure. Chart 5 shows that positive data surprises tend to coincide with rising Treasury yields and vice-versa. We also know that long periods of positive data surprises are more likely to be followed by disappointments, and vice-versa. Though the Surprise Index’s message can change quickly, it is currently close to neutral, sending no strong signal for bond yields. Considering our five macro factors together, we conclude that a rebound in global growth and waning political uncertainty will send bond yields higher in the first half of 2020. Investors should keep portfolio duration low in this environment. We may recommend increasing portfolio duration as we approach mid-year if political uncertainty looks set to rise, or if the dollar is appreciating strongly, or if yields reach the targets outlined below. Yield Target #1: The Golden Rule Of Bond Investing Our Golden Rule of Bond Investing asserts that you should keep portfolio duration low if you expect the Fed to be more hawkish than market expectations, and high if you expect the Fed to be more dovish.3 At present, the overnight index swap (OIS) curve is priced for 22 basis points of rate cuts over the next 12 months. While economic growth is poised to improve in 2020, the Fed is in no rush to tighten monetary policy with inflation expectations still low. We therefore expect the fed funds rate to stay flat next year. With the market still priced for cuts, this forecast implies that we should maintain below-benchmark portfolio duration, at least until our 12-month Fed Funds Discounter – the change in the fed funds rate priced into the OIS curve for the next 12 months – rises to zero or above. A rebound in global growth and waning political uncertainty will send bond yields higher in the first half of 2020. Investors should keep portfolio duration low in this environment. Table 1 uses our Golden Rule framework to forecast Treasury index returns in different monetary policy scenarios. Our base case of a flat fed funds rate is consistent with Treasury index total returns of +0.67% to +0.88% in 2020, and excess returns versus cash of between -0.91% and -0.70%. The Appendix at the end of this report discusses how our Golden Rule framework performed in 2019 and in years past. Table 1Treasury Return Projections Yield Target #2: Long-Run Fed Funds Rate Expectations Chart 6Target 2.25% To 2.5% A second catalyst for increasing portfolio duration would be if the 5-year/5-year forward Treasury yield converged with estimates of the longer-run neutral fed funds rate. Once recessionary risks move to the backburner, it would be logical for long-dated forward rates to converge to levels that are consistent with market expectations for the long-run neutral fed funds rate. Indeed, this is precisely what happened in 2014 and 2017/18, the last two periods of strong global growth (Chart 6). At present, the Fed’s median long-run neutral rate estimate is 2.5%. The New York Fed’s Survey of Market Participants estimates a range of 2.19% to 2.50% and its Survey of Primary Dealers estimates a range of 2.25% to 2.56%. A 5-year/5-year forward Treasury yield in the range of 2.25% to 2.5% would be a second catalyst for us to increase recommended portfolio duration. For Treasury yields to move sustainably above 2.5% in this cycle, it will be necessary for investors to revise their long-run neutral rate estimates higher. This could very well occur, but probably not within the next six months. Nonetheless, investors should pay close attention to the price of gold and the US housing market for signals that neutral rate estimates might undergo upward revisions. The gold price tends to rise when investors view monetary policy as becoming increasingly accommodative. This can occur because the Fed is cutting rates while neutral rate estimates are unchanged, or because neutral rate estimates are rising and the fed funds rate is unchanged. Chart 7 shows that a drop in the gold price foreshadowed downward revisions to the neutral rate in 2013. A further breakout in gold in 2020 could signal that the neutral rate needs to be revised higher again. The housing market will also provide important clues about the neutral fed funds rate. Last year, housing activity slowed considerably once the 30-year mortgage rate rose about 4% (Chart 8). Activity bounced back this year after rates fell, but it will be important to see what happens to housing once the mortgage rate rises back to 4% and above. If an above-4% mortgage rate leads to another downdraft in housing, it would send a strong signal that current neutral rate estimates are roughly correct. However, if housing activity continues to improve with a mortgage rate above 4%, it would suggest that upward neutral rate revisions are required. Chart 7Gold Leads The Neutral Rate... Chart 8...And So Does Housing   There is at least one good reason to think that housing activity might not slow once the mortgage rate rises above 4%. There is currently an excess of supply at the upper-end of the housing market, and a lack of supply at the low-end. This has resulted in price deceleration for new homes, as homebuilders shift construction to the lower-end of the market where demand is stronger (Chart 8, bottom panel). This supply side re-adjustment could make the housing market more resilient to higher mortgage rates in 2020. Key View #2: Barbell Your Treasury Portfolio The 2/10 Treasury slope will steepen modestly in the coming months, but will remain in a range between 0 bps and 50 bps in 2020. Any steepening will be concentrated in the real yield curve. The TIPS breakeven inflation curve is likely to flatten. Our valuation models suggest that a barbelled Treasury portfolio is the best way to position for this environment. Specifically, we recommend shorting the 5-year bullet and buying a duration-matched barbell consisting of the 2-year note and 30-year bond. In thinking about how the slope of the Treasury curve will respond as global growth improves in 2020, it’s useful to look at what happened in two recent episodes of strengthening global growth – 2012/13 and 2016/17. Charts 9A, 9B and 9C illustrate how the 2/10 slope responded in those periods, and show the breakdown between changes in the real and inflation components of yields. The actual slope changes are provided in Table 2. In 2012/13, the 2/10 slope steepened dramatically as global growth rebounded, with almost all of the steepening coming from the real yield curve. It’s not difficult to understand why. The economic outlook was improving, but the Fed was still two years away from lifting interest rates. As such, the Fed’s dovish forward guidance kept a firm lid on short-maturity yields even as long-dated yields rose. In contrast, we can look at the 2016/17 episode. The 2/10 slope steepened somewhat early in the 2016/17 global growth recovery, but ended up 45 bps flatter by the time that the Global PMI peaked. This time, both the real and inflation components contributed to curve flattening. The key difference in this episode was that the Fed was quick to turn more hawkish as growth improved. It lifted the funds rate four times, and short-dated yields rose more quickly than those at the long-end. If housing activity continues to improve with a mortgage rate above 4%, it would suggest that upward neutral rate revisions are required. What can be applied from these two episodes to today? One thing that’s clear is that the Fed will not be as quick to tighten policy as it was in 2016/17. As will be discussed in more detail in next week’s report, the Fed wants to keep policy accommodative until inflation expectations are firmly re-anchored around its target. We think the 5-year/5-year forward TIPS breakeven inflation rate needs to rise from its current 1.8% to above 2.3% before that goal is met. However, it’s also conceivable that inflationary pressures will emerge as soon as late-2020, necessitating rate hikes in 2021. If that’s the case, then short-dated yields will sniff that out in advance, imparting some flattening pressure to the curve. All in all, we’re looking for modest curve steepening in the first half of 2020. But with the Fed not completely out of the picture – as was the case in 2012/13 – the 2/10 slope will not rise above 50 bps. We would also recommend positioning for curve steepening via real yields. The cost of 2-year inflation protection is currently below the cost of 10-year inflation protection (Chart 9C), but will probably lead the 10-year higher as inflation expectations slowly adapt to the incoming data. We recommend TIPS breakeven curve flatteners. Chart 9ANominal 2/10 Slope Chart 9BReal 2/10 Slope Chart 9CInflation Compensation: 2/10 Slope Table 22/10 Slope Changes During Two Recent Global Growth Upturns Interestingly, we also do not recommend the typical 2/10 steepening trade of going long the 5-year bullet against a duration-matched 2/10 barbell. This is because the 2/5/10 butterfly already discounts a huge amount of 2/10 steepening. The 5-year bullet appears 6 bps expensive on our model, meaning that the 2/10 slope needs to steepen by 26 bps during the next six months for a long 5-year, short 2/10 trade to profit (Chart 10).4 Chart 102/5/10 Butterfly Valuation Model Against this valuation backdrop, we recommend owning a duration-matched barbell consisting of the 2-year note and the 30-year bond, while shorting the 5-year note. This heavily barbelled Treasury allocation adds positive carry to a bond portfolio, and will earn positive returns as long as the 5/30 slope steepens by less than 61 bps during the next six months.5 Further, recent correlations suggest that the 5-year yield will rise by more than either the 2-year or 30-year yields if the market starts to price-in fewer Fed rate cuts, as we expect. Table 3 shows that there has been a positive correlation between changes in the 2/5 Treasury slope and our 12-month discounter during the past six months, and a negative correlation between our discounter and the 5/30 slope. Table 3Correlation Of Monthly Changes In 12-Month Discounter With Monthly Changes In Treasury Curve Slopes Key View #3: Overweight Spread Product Low inflation expectations will keep the Fed on hold in 2020. This accommodative monetary environment will keep defaults low and credit spreads tight. Spread product will outperform Treasuries in duration-matched terms. In last year’s Key Views report, we presented a method for splitting the economic cycle into three phases based on the slope of the yield curve.6 We observed that spread product excess returns versus Treasuries tend to be highest in Phase 1 of the cycle, when the 3-year/10-year Treasury slope is above 50 bps. Spread product excess returns tend to be low, but still positive, in Phase 2 of the cycle when the slope is between 0 bps and 50 bps, and only turn negative in Phase 3 after the 3-year/10-year slope inverts. By our criteria, we remained in Phase 2 of the cycle throughout all of 2019 and spread product did in fact deliver small, but positive, excess returns relative to Treasuries. We expect to remain in Phase 2 throughout most (if not all) of 2020, and therefore advise investors to maintain overweight allocations to spread product versus duration-matched Treasuries. We are looking for modest curve steepening in the first half of 2020. The principal rationale for our call is that accommodative Fed policy will keep the yield curve positively sloped in 2020. It will also give banks the confidence to continue extending credit. And as long as lending standards are sufficiently easy, defaults will remain low and spreads will stay tight. Yes, there are some early indications that we might be transitioning into a Phase 3 environment, an environment that would merit a more defensive stance. For one thing, some parts of the Treasury curve inverted in August, though the specific measure we use in our credit cycle analysis – the monthly average of daily closes of the 3-year/10-year Treasury slope – remained above zero (Chart 11). Also, commercial & industrial (C&I) lending standards tightened in the third quarter. Chart 11Still In Phase 2 However, we expect both of these warning signs to dissipate in the near future. The yield curve has already re-steepened, and while loan officers indicated that they had tightened overall standards on C&I loans in Q3, they continued to loosen the terms on those loans (Chart 11, panel 3). But most importantly, we continue to observe inflation expectations that are far below the Fed’s comfort zone (Chart 11, bottom panel). As long as this is the case, the Fed will do its best to keep interest rates low and monetary conditions accommodative. In that environment, the yield curve should stay upward sloping and banks will keep the credit taps open. Phase 2 will stay in place and spread product will outperform Treasuries. The poor health of nonfinancial corporate balance sheets is another risk to our positive spread product view. We track corporate balance sheet health using both aggregate top-down data from the US Financial Accounts (Chart 12A) and by looking at the median firm in our own bottom-up sample of high-yield issuers (Chart 12B). In both cases, we see that debt-to-profit and debt-to-asset ratios are elevated, indicating that firms are carrying a lot of debt on their balance sheets relative to history. However, both samples also show that interest coverage ratios are strong. Solid interest coverage is the result of low interest rates and the Fed’s accommodative monetary policy. It tells us that defaults won’t occur until inflation expectations rise and the Fed turns more restrictive. That may not happen until 2021. Chart 12ACorporate Health: Top-Down Chart 12BCorporate Health: Bottom-Up   The downside is that an extended period of accommodative monetary policy and few defaults means that firms will continue to build up debt and whittle away the equity cushion in corporate capital structures. The end result will be greater losses during the next default cycle. Our Preferred Spread Sectors Within US spread product, we recommend an overweight allocation to high-yield corporate bonds to take advantage of the favorable macro environment. Within investment grade sectors, we advise only a neutral allocation to corporate bonds (see Key View #4), but recommend overweighting Agency Mortgage-Backed Securities (see Key View #5), Agency Commercial Mortgage-Backed Securities, Local Authority and Foreign Agency debt. Chart 13 shows a snapshot of the risk/reward trade-off between investment grade spread products. The vertical axis displays the option-adjusted spread as a simple proxy for 12-month expected excess returns. The horizontal axis displays our own risk measure called the Risk Of Losing 100 bps.7 This measure calculates the spread widening required for each sector to lose 100 bps or more versus duration-matched Treasuries, then adjusts for each sector’s historical spread volatility. Chart 13Excess Return Bond Map: Main Investment Grade Sectors Chart 13 imposes no macro view, but it does reveal that Foreign Agency debt offers an attractive expected return for its level of risk. Agency CMBS and Agency MBS also offer attractive expected returns for their respective risk levels. USD-denominated Sovereign bonds offer high expected returns, but are also the riskiest of the sectors in Chart 13. We recommend an underweight allocation to USD-denominated Sovereigns with the exception of Mexican and Saudi Arabian bonds, which look attractive on a risk/reward basis. Chart 14 replicates Chart 13 but with the USD-denominated Sovereign bonds of different countries. Only Mexico and Saudi Arabia stand out as being attractively priced. Chart 14Excess Return Bond Map: USD-Denominated EM Sovereigns Chart 15Favor Long-Maturity Munis We also maintain a positive outlook on Municipal bonds, particularly at the long-end of the Aaa-rated curve. Municipal / Treasury yield ratios look attractive compared to history, especially at long maturities (Chart 15). While many state and local governments face long-run problems related to underfunded pensions, these issues won’t be exposed until revenue growth falters in the next downturn. For now, state & local government balance sheets are healthy enough to keep muni upgrades outpacing downgrades (Chart 15, bottom 2 panels). Key View #4: Favor High-Yield Over Investment Grade Appropriate valuation measures show that high-yield corporate spreads are very attractive in the current environment, while investment grade corporate spreads are tight compared to our fair value estimates. We noted above that, despite the favorable macro environment for spread product, we recommend an overweight allocation to high-yield corporate bonds but only a neutral allocation to investment grade corporates. The reason for the disparity is valuation. Our preferred valuation measure is the 12-month breakeven spread. This is the spread widening required for the sector to lose money versus Treasuries on a 12-month horizon. This measure is superior to the simple index option-adjusted spread because it controls for time-varying index duration. We also re-calculate the investment grade and high-yield bond indexes so that they have constant distribution between the different credit tiers over time. Charts 16A and 16Bshow 12-month breakeven spreads for our re-constituted investment grade and high-yield indexes as percentile ranks versus history. The investment grade spread has been tighter only 11% of the time since 1995, while the high-yield spread has been tighter 67% of the time. Chart 16AIG Valuation Chart 16BHY Valuation   From our analysis of the three phases of the cycle, we also know that spreads tend to tighter in Phase 2 of the cycle than in Phases 1 or 3. Since we are currently in Phase 2, we would expect spreads to be near the bottom of their historical distributions. With this knowledge, we derive spread targets for each corporate credit tier based on the median breakeven spreads witnessed in prior Phase 2 periods. We then use current index duration to calculate option-adjusted spread targets for each credit tier and the overall investment grade and high-yield indexes (Charts 17A and 17B). Notice that all investment grade spreads are below their Phase 2 targets, while high-yield spreads are well above. Chart 17AIG Spread Targets Chart 17BHY Spread Targets   We also observe that Caa-rated spreads are extremely cheap relative to target, and have been widening rapidly. We are more inclined to view this as an opportunity to buy Caa-rated bonds than as a warning sign for overall corporate bond performance, as we discussed in a recent report.8 Key View #5: Overweight Mortgage-Backed Securities Agency MBS look attractive compared to investment grade corporate bonds, especially in risk-adjusted terms. The risk of a refinancing surge in 2020 is minimal and mortgage lending standards are more likely to ease than tighten. MBS spreads have room to tighten in 2020. We noted above that Agency MBS offer an attractive trade-off between risk and expected return. Specifically, Chart 13 shows that MBS offer expected returns that are similar to Aa and Aaa corporates, but with less risk of losing 100 bps versus Treasuries. For further evidence of the attractiveness of MBS spreads, we note that while the zero-volatility spread for conventional 30-year Agency MBS is not all that elevated compared to history, it is being held down by very low expected prepayment losses (aka option costs) (Chart 18). The OAS, the best proxy for MBS expected return, stands at 48 bps. This is reasonably elevated compared to history and very close to the spread offered by Aa-rated corporate bonds. Past periods when the MBS OAS was close to the Aa-rated corporate bond spread were followed by MBS outperformance (Chart 18, bottom panel). We recommend an overweight allocation to high-yield corporate bonds but only a neutral allocation to investment grade corporates. The reason for the disparity is valuation. We noted that expected prepayment losses are low, and this is for good reason. Mortgage refinancing activity will remain depressed throughout 2020. First, with the Fed likely to go on hold for 2020 and then lift rates in 2021, the mortgage rate is more likely to rise than fall. Higher mortgage rates will keep refis down. Second, most homeowners have already had multiple opportunities to refinance their mortgages during the past few years, as evidenced by the fact that the MBA Refinance Index didn’t rise that much in 2019, even as the mortgage rate declined 106 bps (Chart 19). Chart 18MBS Spreads Chart 19Refi Risk Is Minimal   Tightening bank lending standards for residential mortgages can also lead to wider MBS spreads, but lending standards are more likely to ease than tighten in 2020. FICO scores for approved mortgages have not come down at all since the financial crisis (Chart 19, panel 3), and loan officers consistently claim that lending standards are tighter than the average since 2005 (Chart 19, bottom panel). With standards already so tight, modest easing is more likely than rapid tightening. Key View #6: Overweight TIPS Versus Nominal Treasuries TIPS breakeven inflation rates are well below our target range of 2.3%-2.5%. It will take some time, and likely an overshoot of the Fed’s 2% inflation target, for them to reach that range as expectations adapt only slowly to rising core inflation. But even if they don’t make it back to target, breakevens should still grind higher as the economy recovers in 2020. Our target range for both the 10-year and 5-year/5-year forward TIPS breakeven inflation rates remains 2.3%-2.5%. But it could take quite some time for that target to be met. The reason is that inflation expectations adapt only slowly to changes in the actual inflation data. We explained this dynamic in a report from last year, and also created a fair value model for the 10-year TIPS breakeven inflation rate based on long-run trends in the actual inflation data.9 At present, our Adaptive Expectations Model pegs fair value for the 10-year breakeven rate at 1.9%, 20 bps above the current level of 1.7%, but well short of our end-of-cycle 2.3%-2.5% target (Chart 20). We could see the 10-year breakeven reaching 1.9% in the coming months as global growth recovers, but it will take a more sustained uptrend in the actual inflation data to move higher than that. A more sustained uptrend in actual inflation could take some time to develop. This year’s increase in core CPI inflation has been concentrated in the core goods component (Chart 21). This component of core inflation tracks import prices with a lag, and it is very likely to fall back down in 2020. Any sustained breakout in core inflation will require more strength from the core services (ex. Shelter and medical care) component (Chart 21, panel 3), something that hasn’t happened yet this cycle. Chart 20Adaptive Expectations Model Chart 21The Components Of Core CPI   Ryan Swift US Bond Strategist rswift@bcaresearch.com Appendix: The Golden Rule Of Bond Investing Our Golden Rule of Bond Investing says that we should determine what change in the fed funds rate is priced into the overnight index swap curve for the next 12 months, and then decide whether the Fed will deliver a hawkish or dovish surprise relative to that expectation. We contend that if the Fed delivers a hawkish surprise, then a below-benchmark portfolio duration positioning will pay off. Conversely, if the Fed delivers a dovish surprise, then an above-benchmark portfolio duration positioning will profit. Chart A1 shows how the Golden Rule has performed in every calendar year going back to 1990. We include year-to-date performance for 2019. In 30 years of historical data, our Golden Rule performed well in 22. It provided the wrong recommendation in 8 years, though 3 of those years were during the zero-lower-bound period between 2009 and 2015 when 12-month rate expectations were essentially pinned at zero.10 At the beginning of this year, the market was priced for 7 bps of rate cuts in 2019. The funds rate actually fell by 84 bps, leading to a dovish surprise of 77 bps. Based on a historical regression, we would expect a dovish surprise of 77 bps to coincide with a Treasury index yield that falls by 52 bps. In actuality, the index yield fell by 81 bps, more than our Golden Rule predicted. Chart A2 shows how close changes in the Treasury index yield have been to our Golden Rule’s prediction in each of the past 30 years. This regression between the change in Treasury index yield and the monetary policy surprise is the main source of error in our Treasury return forecasts. Based on our expected -52 bps index yield change, we would have expected the Treasury index to deliver 5.9% of total return in 2019 and to outperform cash by 3.4%. In actuality, the index earned 7.9% of total return and outperformed cash by 5.6%. Charts A3 and A4 show how index total and excess returns have performed relative to our Golden Rule’s expectations in each of the past 30 years. Chart A1The Golden Rule’s Track Record Chart A2Treasury Index Yield Changes Versus Fed Funds Surprises Chart A3Treasury Index Total Returns Versus The Golden Rule’s Predictions Chart A4Treasury Index Excess Returns Versus The Golden Rule’s Predictions   Footnotes 1    Please see The Bank Credit Analyst, “Outlook 2020: Heading Into The End Game”, dated November 22, 2019, available at bca.bcaresearch.com 2   Please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “Bond Kitchen”, dated April 9, 2019, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 3   Please see US Bond Strategy Special Report, “The Golden Rule Of Bond Investing”, dated July 24, 2018, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 4   For more details on our butterfly spread valuation models please see US Bond Strategy Special Report, “Bullets, Barbells And Butterflies”, dated July 25, 2017, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 5   The 2/5/30 valuation model is not shown in this report. Please see US Bond Strategy Portfolio Allocation Summary, “Mixed Messages”, dated December 3, 2019, for a recent update of all our yield curve models. 6   Please see US Bond Strategy Special Report, “2019 Key Views: Implications For US Fixed Income”, dated December 11, 2018, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 7   For further details on how this measure is calculated please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “A Perspective On Risk And Reward”, dated October 15, 2019, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 8   Please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “Caa-Rated Bonds: Warning Sign Or Buying Opportunity?”, dated November 26, 2019, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 9   For further details on our Adaptive Expectations Model please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “Adaptive Expectations In The TIPS Market”, dated November 20, 2018, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 10  We say the Golden Rule “worked” if a dovish surprise coincided with positive Treasury index excess returns versus cash, or if a hawkish surprise coincided with negative Treasury excess returns versus cash.