Policy
Highlights Central Banks: The sharp sell-off in global bond markets last week was triggered by more upbeat comments on growth and inflation by several major central bankers, most notably ECB President Mario Draghi. ECB Tapering: Draghi's positive views on the European economy are generally accurate, which puts the ECB on a path to taper its asset purchases next year. Bunds vs. JGBs: Bund yields have more upside in the next 3-6 months as the market reprices a smaller amount of ECB bond buying. Downgrade core European government bonds to underweight (2 out of 5) and upgrade low-beta Japan to maximum overweight (5 out of 5). Feature "The threat of deflation is gone and reflationary forces are at play." - Mario Draghi Chart of the WeekA Co-Ordinated Tightening On The Horizon? Bond market volatility awoke with a vengeance last week, as investors digested a string of hawkish comments from previously dovish central banks. A surprisingly optimistic speech from European Central Bank (ECB) President Mario Draghi set the tone, triggering the biggest single day rise in German bond yields in over two years. This was followed up by comments from Bank of England (BoE) Governor Mark Carney and Bank of Canada Governor Stephen Poloz suggesting that higher rates may be needed soon in the U.K. and Canada, triggering sell-offs in Gilts and Canadian bonds. Even U.S. Treasury yields rose alongside the global move, without any positive U.S. data or more hawkish Fed commentary. This move to a more hawkish tone - or, at least, a less dovish message - is consistent with the current strength of the global economy, as well as the robust performance of risk assets so far in 2017. Policymakers are now being forced to adjust their biases to reflect the more positive backdrop, forcing a repricing of interest rate expectations with most developed economies hovering around full employment (Chart of the Week). A "coordinated" move to tweak policy rates higher suggests bond yields have more room to rise - especially after the decline since March that has driven most government bond yields to expensive levels. The bigger risk for global bonds, however, will come from a likely shift in ECB policy towards a reduction in the size of their current bond purchase program. As we saw last week, even a mere mention of a need to shift to a less accommodative monetary stance was enough to cause Bund yields to nearly double in a matter of days. We have been positioned for a renewed rise in bond yields through our recommended below-benchmark portfolio duration stance. We are also positioned for a bear-steepening of government bond yield curves in our model bond portfolio, as our recommended duration exposures are concentrated in shorter-maturity bonds. With central banks only looking to catch up to the underlying state of the global economy, rather than aiming to more aggressively tighten policy to cool off growth, there is more potential for longer-dated bond yields to rise relative to shorter-maturity debt - especially with market-based inflation expectations now looking too low in most countries. In other words, expect more bear-steepening of global yield curves (ex-Japan) in the next few months. Dissecting Draghi's Speech The jump in global yields last week was broad based, both across countries and when broken down into valuation components. The "high-yielders" among developed markets (U.S., Canada, U.K.), saw modest increases in inflation expectations and term premia, while rate hike expectations jumped sharply in Canada and the U.K. (Chart 2). Among the "low-yielders" (Germany, Japan), the 22bps jump in Bund yields came through higher term premia, with only very modest moves higher in rate hike or inflation expectations (Chart 3). Japanese yields didn't move at all, consistent with the view that the Bank of Japan is the one central bank that does not need to become less accommodative with Japanese core inflation back down to 0%. Chart 2Global Yields Starting To Perk Up A Bit... Chart 3...Led By Europe Mario Draghi's speech, which set off last week's yield spike, was such a shock to markets because of the upbeat description of the underlying strength of the Euro Area economy. It is important to consider where this speech was given - in front of global policymakers at the annual ECB Forum on Central Banking in Portugal (the ECB equivalent to the Fed's annual Jackson Hole conference). The head of the central bank that has been providing the highest degree of monetary stimulus among the major economies over the past couple of years told his global peers that the need for such an extreme accommodative policy stance was now diminished. This is a message shared by the BCA Central Bank Monitors, which are pointing to a need for tighter monetary policy everywhere except Japan (Chart 4). Chart 4Tighter Monetary Policy Is Required Is such a high-conviction view from the ECB justified? Let's do a little "truth check" on some of Draghi's most relevant comments from his speech: "All the signs now point to a strengthening and broadening recovery in the Euro Area." TRUE. Most reliable cyclical indicators - PMIs, consumer confidence, business confidence - are all at, or beyond, pre-2008 crisis levels (Chart 5). The German IFO index hit a record high in June, while data has been strengthening across all the major Euro Area economies (even Italy). "We can be more assured about the return of inflation to our objective than we were a few years ago. [However,] inflation dynamics are not yet durable and self-sustaining. So our monetary policy needs to be persistent." TRUE. The Euro Area unemployment rate at 9.5% now sits within hailing distance of the OECD's estimate of the full employment "NAIRU" rate of 9%. Already, core inflation and wage growth are stabilizing in the Euro Area (Chart 6), suggesting that the estimated full employment rate may be an accurate measure. The ECB is forecasting that the unemployment rate will fall to 8.4% by 2019, which would be below the OECD NAIRU level, and the ECB is now forecasting that Euro Area core inflation will rise to 1.8% within two years. That would likely be close enough to the ECB's official inflation target (headline inflation at or just below 2%) for a potential rate hike by then, but not before. Chart 5European Growth Looks Very Healthy Chart 6Full Employment Is In Sight "The past period of low inflation is [...] on the whole temporary and should not cause inflation to deviate from its trend over the medium term." MOST LIKELY TRUE. The steep fall in European inflation in 2014 triggered deflation fears, and prompted the ECB to finally engage in an asset purchase program just as the Fed was ending its' own "QE". Much of that decline was related to the sharp downturn in global energy prices. Draghi also noted in his speech that, by the ECB's own estimates, around two thirds of the undershoot of Euro Area inflation in 2015/16 came from the impact of lower energy prices. He also mentioned that past fall in oil prices and other "global shocks" are likely to still be restraining core inflation to some degree via pass-through effects in parts of the economy that are more energy-intensive. Draghi did also point out that the current low oil prices are mainly supply driven (a view that BCA's commodity strategists whole-heartedly agree with) and, therefore, can be "looked through" by a central bank. That may be dangerous view to take with wage inflation still subdued in Europe, but it seems clear that core inflation has indeed bottomed out and is in the process of a slow grind higher (Chart 7). This is also helping to stabilize inflation expectations in Europe to some degree, although it is far too early for the ECB to declare victory over "low-flation." "Political winds are becoming tailwinds. There is newfound confidence in the reform process, and newfound support for European cohesion, which could help unleash pent-up demand and investment." TRUE. The 2017 political calendar appeared daunting at the start of the year, with elections scheduled in the Netherlands, France and Germany anti-euro candidates scoring better-than-expected in the polling data. The ECB even cited political uncertainty as one of the reasons for extending its asset purchase program to the end of 2017, in case there was a surprise win by a "Euro-skeptic" party. The electoral losses by Geert Wilders in the Netherlands and Marine Le Pen in France were strong signals that the anti-establishment wave that had washed over the U.K. and U.S. last year would not spill over into Europe. There is a new potential risk in Italy, where fresh parliamentary elections are expected to be called sometime in the first half of 2018. The polling numbers are tight there, with pro- and anti-euro parties showing roughly equal levels of support. Yet with the Italian economy showing some improvement alongside the rest of Europe, and with Italian banks under less immediate pressure after some successful recent rescue packages for struggling lenders (Chart 8), there is less risk of an anti-euro uprising in the polls in Italy next year. Chart 7From Deflation Fears To Reflation Cheers Chart 8Italy Is No Constraint To An ECB Taper At a minimum, the ECB likely would not factor politics into any decision on tapering its asset purchases starting in 2018. Chart 9Taper Tantrum 2.0? "As the economy continues to recover, a constant policy stance will become more accommodative, and the central bank can accompany the recovery by adjusting the parameters of its policy instruments - not to tighten the policy stance, but to keep it broadly unchanged." TRUE. The Fed was making similar arguments when they moved away from QE bond purchases and, eventually, the timing of the first rate hike. Using words like how the U.S. economy had "healed" from the financial crisis by enough to start removing some policy accommodation. In some respects, the European economy is in much better shape than when the Fed began its own taper in 2014. In Chart 9, we present an idea that we published earlier this year, showing the comparison of Europe now versus the U.S. pre-Fed taper. This is a "cycle-on-cycle" analysis, where the European and U.S. data are lined up to the peak of our months-to-hike indicator, noting the timing of the first rate hike priced into OIS curves after the period of 0% policy rates. The chart shows that the current Euro Area economy is about two percentage points closer to full employment than the U.S. was just before the infamous 2013 Taper Tantrum. The Fed began signaling that major policy shift with core inflation below its 2% target, at similar levels to the current European core inflation rate. A look at the subsequent moves in bond yields and term premia (bottom two panels) suggests that Europe could be on the verge of its own Taper Tantrum in the next few months. Summing it all up, we conclude that the optimism on the European growth and inflation outlook expressed by Draghi is justified. Barring a sudden collapse in the economy or inflation over the summer, the ECB looks to be on course to announce a tapering of its bond purchases, starting in 2018, at the upcoming September policy meeting. Bottom Line: The sharp sell-off in global bond markets last week was triggered by more upbeat comments on growth and inflation by several major central bankers, most notably ECB President Mario Draghi. We see Draghi's positive views on the European economy to be generally accurate, which puts the ECB on a path to taper its asset purchases next year. Downgrade Core European Government Bonds To Underweight Our expectation heading into 2017 was that core European bonds would outperform U.S. Treasuries in the first half of the year as the Fed delivered more rate hikes and the ECB maintained a highly dovish tone at least through the April/May French presidential elections.1 After that, assuming the French election went according to our expectations with a Le Pen loss, the ECB would then turn its attention to potential "taper talk" that would trigger an underperformance of core Europe versus Treasuries. The U.S. Treasury rally since March defied our forecast, even though the Fed did actually hike rates twice! While we still see more Fed tightening and higher U.S. yields as the base case in the latter half of the year, the European story is playing out as we expected. We are sticking to our plan after last week's developments, and we are downgrading core European bonds (Germany, France, Italy) to a recommended underweight ranking (2 out of 5). Importantly, we've likely seen the low in European yields even if there is no tapering in 2018. In Chart 10, we update an analysis we did earlier this year, looking at the projected size of the ECB's monetary base under various asset purchase scenarios for next year: The ECB stops "cold turkey" on December 31 and buys no additional bonds in 2018; The ECB tapers its €60bn/month of bond buying to zero by June 2018; The ECB tapers its €60bn/month of bond buying to zero by December 2018; The ECB announces no taper and keeps on buying at €60bn/month throughout 2018. In the bottom two panels of Chart 10, we show the growth rate of the ECB's monetary base versus the German Bund yield and the term premium. The projections for the growth rates are based off the four scenarios laid out above. In all cases, the growth in the expansion of the ECB monetary base (and its balance sheet) will slow next year - even if there is no tapering. Importantly, the euro is unlikely to spike versus the U.S. dollar in the event of a tapering, as relative money supplies and policy interest rates will remain USD-bullish (Chart 11). Chart 10The ECB Effect On Bunds Will Soon Fade Chart 11A Taper-Fueled Rise In The Euro Has Its Limits This is the dirty little secret about central bank asset purchase programs. They must be delivered in even bigger sizes than before to have the same impact on asset prices and, eventually, economic growth and inflation. Chart 12UST-Bund Spread Looks Too Low We now feel comfortable shifting to a reduced recommended country allocation to core Europe in our model bond portfolio. We have been maintaining a below-benchmark duration stance in core Europe for the past couple of months, by placing less recommended exposure in the longer maturity "buckets" in our portfolio and overweighting the shorter-maturity buckets. Now, we are comfortable cutting the allocation to core Europe across all buckets based on our views on the ECB. What should be upgraded if we are downgrading Europe? As mentioned, we had expected to upgrade U.S. Treasuries at this point in the year, but the disappointing run of U.S. data (especially versus Europe) drove the Treasury-Bund spread sharply lower (Chart 12). Given our view that the U.S. economy and inflation will rebound in the latter half of this year and prompt the Fed to deliver more hikes, we see the Treasury-Bund spread as too low to recommend shifting out of core Europe into the U.S. Instead, we see a better case to upgrade the most defensive country in the developed bond universe - Japan. There is a clear divergence between recent growth and inflation data in the Euro Area versus Japan, most notably with core inflation returning to 0% in Japan (Chart 13). The JGB-Bund spread looks to be at critical support levels that could trigger a quick tightening, especially if there are more upside data surprises in Europe or disappointments in Japan (Chart 14). Chart 13Europe & Japan Are Diverging Chart 14Reduce Core European Exposure In Favor Of JGBs Bottom Line: Bund yields have more upside in the next 3-6 months as the market reprices a smaller amount of ECB bond buying. Downgrade core European government bonds to underweight (2 out of 5) and upgrade low-beta Japan to maximum overweight (5 out of 5). Robert Robis, Senior Vice President Global Fixed Income Strategy rrobis@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see BCA Global Fixed Income Strategy Special Report, "How To Think About Global Bond Investing In 2017", dated December 20 2016, available at gfis.bcaresearch.com. Recommendations Duration Regional Allocation Spread Product Tactical Trades Yields & Returns Global Bond Yields Historical Returns The GFIS Recommended Portfolio Vs. The Custom Benchmark Index
Highlights The Q2 earnings season will be above average and the BCA Earnings model predicts EPS growth to hit 18% later this year before moderating in 2018. Are the NIPA and S&P profit measures sending different signals? Business capital spending remains in an uptrend despite businesses' reluctance to spend ahead of changes in corporate tax policy. The commercial real estate sector (CRE) is beginning to show early signs of stress. Repealing Dodd-Frank faces procedural hurdles and would yield few political benefits, even for Republicans in an environment of populism. Feature Q2 Earnings Season Is Here Chart 1Strong Earnings Growth##BR##In 2017 Will Support Equities The Q2 earnings season will be above average and the BCA Earnings model predicts EPS growth to hit roughly 18% later this year on a 4-quarter moving total basis, before moderating in 2018 (Chart 1). The consensus is anticipating an 8% year-over-year increase in EPS in Q2 2017 versus Q2 2016, and 11% for 2017. Energy, technology, and financials, all are forecast to lead the way in earnings growth in Q2, but utilities and telecom will be the laggards. The favorable profit picture for Q2 and the rest of the year reflects the rebound in oil prices, which are expected to boost energy sector EPS by 671%. The positive picture also mirrors the sweet spot of rising top-line growth and still muted labor costs, which are driving a countercyclical rally in profit margins. The focus in Q2 for investors and corporate executives will be on the improving economic conditions in Europe and EM, the U.S. dollar and the sustainability of margins. Guidance from CEOs and CFOs on trends in 2H 2017 and beyond are more important than the actual Q2 results. Note that guidance can be tracked using Chart 2. Investors should guard against managements' over-optimism because earnings growth forecasts almost always move lower over time. Chart 22017 EPS Estimates Rebounding And 2018 Stable In Q2, firms with high overseas sales should benefit from the improved growth profile in Europe and Japan. Global GDP growth projections for this year and next have steadily escalated, in sharp contrast with prior years when forecasters have relentlessly lowered GDP estimates. On the other hand, the U.S. dollar should be a modest drag on earnings in Q2; the dollar is up 2% versus a year ago against a broad basket of currencies. Moreover, in the most recent Beige Book (May 31) mentions of a "strong dollar" were unchanged compared with a year ago, indicating that the stronger currency has faded as a primary concern of managements in recent months. Our view is that the dollar will appreciate by another 10%. This appreciation would trim EPS growth by roughly 2.5 percentage points, although most of this would occur in 2018 due to lagged effects. Another upleg in the dollar, on its own, should not provide a substantial headwind for the stock market. Indeed, the dollar would only climb in the context of robust U.S. economic growth and an expanding corporate top line. Investors are skeptical that margins can advance for the fourth consecutive quarter in Q2. Our view is that we are in a temporary sweet spot for margins and that should continue for the next quarter or two, but the secular "mean reversion" of margins will resume beyond that time. Bottom Line: Look for another solid performance for earnings and margins in Q2 and the rest of 2017, supporting our stocks-over-bonds stance for this year. However, investors should position their portfolios for decelerating earnings and compressed profit margins in 2018. Will The Real Profit Margin Stand Up While the markets focus on Q2 earnings, margins and corporate guidance for the next month or so, we take a broader view. For some time we have highlighted the importance of the mini-cycle in U.S. earnings growth; the corporate sector is in a catch-up phase following last year's profit recession, a trend that extends beyond the energy patch. EPS growth has surged this year on the back of slightly stronger sales and rising S&P 500 margins. The National Accounts (NIPA) data, on the other hand, paint a different picture. Earnings growth for the entire corporate sector fell sharply in the first quarter and margins continued to slide. If the NIPA data are telling the true story, then the equity market is in trouble because it suggests that the earnings outlook is much weaker than what is discounted in stock prices. There are many definitional differences that make it difficult to reconcile the NIPA and S&P data.1 Nonetheless, we can make some general observations. Chart 3 presents the four-quarter growth rate of NIPA profits2 and a proxy for aggregate S&P earnings. For the latter, we multiplied earnings-per-share by the divisor to obtain an estimate of the level of aggregate earnings in dollar terms (i.e. not on a per-share basis). The bottom panel of Chart 3 compares the level of profits, each indexed to be 100 in 2011 Q1. The charts highlight that while there have been marked differences in annual growth rates between the two measures, the levels were close to the same point in the first quarter of 2017. The dip in NIPA profit growth in Q1 was not reflected in the S&P measure. It appears that this is partly due to different profiles for profit growth in the energy and financials sectors. However, it does not appear that the difference in margins is linked to a significant divergence in aggregate profits. Most of the margin divergence is related to the denominator of the calculation (Chart 4). The NIPA denominator is corporate sector Gross Domestic Product (GDP). This is a value-added concept that is different from sales. It is not clear why, but GDP has grown much faster than sales since the end of 2014. We believe that the S&P data are painting a more accurate picture because sales are straight forward to measure, while value-added is complicated to construct. The slow growth of sales is not a bullish point for stocks. Nonetheless, it does not appear that financial engineering has distorted bottom-up company data to such an extent that the S&P data are falsely signaling strong profit growth. We expect the secular mean-reversion of margins to re-assert itself in the S&P data, perhaps beginning early in 2018. Nonetheless, the profit backdrop remains positive for stocks for now. The same is true in the Eurozone and Japan, where margins are also rising. It is worrying that a much of this year's advance in U.S. equity markets has been concentrated in only a few stocks, but that belies the breadth of the profit recovery (Chart 5). The proportion of S&P industry groups with rising earnings estimates is 75%, reflecting broad-based upgrades. Chart 3S&P And NIPA##BR##Profit Comparison Chart 4Denominator Explains##BR##S&P/NIPA Margin Divergence Chart 5Positive Earnings Revisions##BR##Are Broadly Based Such widespread participation is consistent with ongoing upward revisions to 12-month forward earnings estimates. Bottom Line: The solid earnings backdrop is why we remain overweight stocks versus bonds and cash. Stay extra vigilant for warning signs of a bear market in view of the poor valuations. Valuation has never been good leading indicator for bear markets, but it may provide information on the risks. Capital Spending Check Up Business capital spending remains in an uptrend. Investors are concerned that the below expectations readings on capex in recent months may be the start of a new trend for a significant part of the economy. We look at it another way. Managements are postponing investment decisions until they get more clarity on federal tax policy. In short, corporations are struggling with how much and when spend, rather than whether to invest at all. The key supports for sustained corporate spending remain despite the tepid May durable goods report. C&I loan growth has ticked back up and our model (based on non-residential fixed investment, small business optimism and the speculative-grade default rate) suggests lending is poised to move higher on a 12-month basis (Chart 6). Our research shows that sustainable capital spending cycles get underway only when businesses see evidence that consumer final demand is on the upswing. While consumer expenditures were soft (+1.1% annualized gain) in Q1, household spending in Q2 accelerated and is on track to post 3%+ growth. We expect household spending to continue to improve in the second half of 2017.3 Moreover, the recent readings on core durable goods orders and shipments show that the uptrend that began in mid-2016 persists, despite the recent monthly wiggles in the data (Chart 7). Chart 6Model Points To##BR##Further Improvement Chart 7Capital Spending##BR##Remains In An Uptrend CEO confidence recently soared to a 13-year high in Q1, adding to the positive backdrop for capex. The last reading on this survey was taken in the first quarter of 2017 when managements eagerly anticipated that business-friendly legislation was pending. The next survey (due in mid-July) may show a bit more restraint from CEOs given the lack of legislative progress in Washington (Chart 7, top panel). Bottom Line: The fundamentals supporting solid business spending remain in place. However, our positive capex outlook in the U.S. could be blemished if the Republicans fail to deliver on their promises to cut taxes and boost infrastructure spending. Stressing The Commercial Real Estate Market The commercial real estate sector (CRE) is beginning to show early signs of stress. The recent softening in CRE does not suggest that recession is imminent, but investors should understand whether a sustained drop in CRE prices poses a risk to the global financial system. At best, business spending on construction is coincident with the overall economy, but most often lags due to long lead times required on projects (Chart 8). Chart 8Commercial Real Estate Lags Our colleagues in the Global Investment Strategy service4 highlighted the risks to the CRE market, noting that CRE-related debt is rising, prices have surpassed pre-recessionary levels, vacancy rates outside of the industrial sector are bottoming, and rent growth is losing steam (Chart 9). Likewise, we share Boston Fed President Rosengren's5 concern that if CRE's recent tailwinds (muted inflation, low financing rates, declining unemployment rate, robust economic growth in the U.S. relative to overseas developed economies, and favorable demographics) turn to headwinds, then the impact on the market and the wider economy may have a disproportionate impact on CRE. The BCA Beige Book Real Estate Monitor corroborates a softening in recent quarters. The monitor takes the real estate (both commercial and residential) comments from each Beige Book and uses the approach outlined in our April 17 publication6 (Chart 10). Chart 9Commercial Real Estate##BR##Indicators Softening Chart 10Introducing The##BR##Beige Book CRE Monitor Stretched CRE valuations may exacerbate any price declines in CRE if the markets sense that the tide is turning. Falling prices may lead to a drop in the value of collateral-backing CRE loans, which in turn, could cause lenders to restrict credit in the sector and spark an additional downturn in prices. Moreover, Table 1 highlights the risk that GSE reform may cause two large holders of CRE debt to begin to curtail lending. Small banks have more absolute exposure to CRE loans than large banks, according to the table, and overall, banks' share of CRE lending (53%) is nearly four times as high as GSE's exposure. Table 1Holders Of Commercial Real Estate Loans CRE's risks are evident in the latest round of bank CCAR stress tests. The Fed modeled a 15% drop in CRE prices through Q4 2018 in its "adverse" scenario and a 35% drop in the same period in its "severely adverse" scenario. The Fed7 found that under these scenarios, common equity Tier 1 capital ratio at the participating firms would drop from 12.5% (Q4 2016) to 9.2% and 7.2% respectively by Q1 2019. Bottom Line: Commercial real estate has benefitted from a Fed-led tailwind since the end of the 2007-2009 recession. That said, some of the tailwinds are turning to headwinds and investors should be prepared for a reversal in this sector sometime in the second half of 2018 as economic and earnings growth slows, which could set the stage for a recession in 2019. That said, it is a positive sign for the economy that the commercial real estate sector is one of the few areas showing any signs of stress, implying that the conditions for a recession in the next 6 to 12 months remain low. Is Dodd-Frank Dead? The Republicans' Financial CHOICE Act, which would roll back key aspects of the landmark Dodd-Frank Wall Street reform, has hurdles to overcome before its passage through the U.S. Senate. Two of BCA's publications have examined the impact on consumers, investors and financial markets. BCA's Geopolitical Strategy8 service noted that Republicans want to overturn Dodd-Frank to increase the financial sector's profits, credit growth, economic growth and animal spirits. A repeal would also satisfy the Republicans' ideological goal to reduce state involvement, which grew due to the law. Also, the CBO estimates that the proposed rewrite would cut the budget deficit by a net $22.3 billion over 10 years, in line with the GOP's political bent. The CHOICE Act would create an "escape hatch" to allow banks to maintain a capital-to-asset ratio of over 10% to bypass Dodd-Frank regulations. Financial companies that do not meet the 10% leverage ratio could either raise funds or remain subject to Dodd-Frank oversight, including required capital ratios, stress tests, living wills and other regulations. Critically, the 10% leverage ratio for those banks that opt out of Dodd-Frank would not be calculated using risk-weightings for different assets (whereas Dodd-Frank requires both risk-weighted and non-risk-weighted capital ratios to be maintained). Therefore, banks that opt out would be able to take on greater risk while still fulfilling minimum capital requirements. The intent is to boost lending, earnings and growth. According to the Geopolitical Strategy, if the bill becomes law, U.S. banks comprising an estimated $1.5 trillion in assets would become less restricted and eligible to adopt riskier trading practices. The greatest impact will be in areas with a higher concentration of small community banks and credit unions. These banks, with under $10 billion in assets, face the most difficulty in meeting Dodd-Frank's requirements and yet tend to meet the 10% leverage ratio (Chart 11). Chart 11Banks With $1.5 Trillion Could Gain Risk Appetite Other aspects of the bill would: Repeal the FDIC's liquidation fund: The private sector would take over responsibility for managing liquidations. Eliminate the Volcker Rule: Banks would be able to trade riskier assets on their own accounts and forge closer relationships with private equity and hedge funds. Audit the Fed: The Government Accountability Office (GAO) would audit the Fed's board of governors and regional banks, including their handling of monetary policy. Reshape the Consumer Financial Protection Board: The agency would have its powers neutered and funding dependent on the Congress, rather than transfers from the Fed. Cut penalties for violating regulations. Chart 12Small Banks Benefit##BR##From Bank Deregulation Investors could capitalize on financial sector reform by favoring small U.S. bank equities over large bank stocks. The share price of small banks relative to large banks, which rallied in the aftermath of Trump's election only to subsequently fall back, has recently perked up (Chart 12). Relative earnings have been flat in the same period. If Dodd-Frank is partially watered down, then these banks should see earnings improve, and drive up their share prices. BCA's U.S. Equity Strategy is positive on global bank equities. In particular, U.S. banks have better fundamentals than their counterparts in Europe and Japan - more capital, higher net interest margins, lower or equal NPL ratios. They also stand to benefit from relatively faster rising interest rates. BCA's Fiscal Note Financial Sector Index suggests that the flow of legislative and regulatory proposals is becoming less onerous on the financial sector. Chart 13 is an aggregation of the favorability scores, which assess whether the bill would be favorable to the financial sector. It provides a snapshot of the regulatory environment for the financial sector at any point. Chart 13Financial Sector Scrutiny Softening Bottom Line: Repealing Dodd-Frank faces procedural hurdles and would yield few political benefits, even for Republicans in an environment of populism. However, a bill focused on lightening the regulatory load on small banks has a chance of passing if tacked on to the budget process. Large banks would remain subject to closer scrutiny and stricter international standards. The post-election rally for bank stocks is mostly over. Investors have an opportunity to favor small banks versus large ones. John Canally, CFA, Senior Vice President U.S. Investment Strategy johnc@bcaresearch.com Mark McClellan, Senior Vice President The Bank Credit Analyst markm@bcaresearch.com 1 The first problem is that the S&P data are expressed on a per-share basis. Moreover, the NIPA data adjusts for inventory and depreciation allowance. S&P margins are calculated using sales in the denominator, while we generally use GDP as the denominator for calculating NIPA profits. 2 The NIPA data shown include financials and profits earned overseas, as is the case for the S&P. 3 Please see BCA's U.S. Investment Strategy Weekly Report, "Still In The Sweet Spot", June 19, 2017, available at usis.bcaresearch.com. 4 Please see BCA's Global Investment Strategy Weekly Report "The Timing Of The Next Recession," published June 16, 2017, available at gis.bcaresearch.com. 5 "Trends In Commercial Real Estate", Eric S. Rosengren, at Risk Management for Commercial Real Estate Financial Markets Conference, NYU Stern School of Business, May 9, 2017. 6 Please see BCA's U.S. Investment Strategy Weekly Report, "The Great Debate Continues", published April 17, 2017, available at usis.bcaresearch.com. 7 https://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/files/2017-ccar-assessment-framework-results-20170628.pdf 8 Please see BCA's Geopolitical Strategy Weekly Report "How Long Can The "Trump Put" Last?," published June 14, 2017, available at gps.bcaresearch.com.
Highlights Economic Outlook: Global growth will remain strong over the next 12 months, but will start to slow in the second half of 2018, potentially setting the stage for a recession in 2019. Overall Strategy: Investors should overweight equities and spread product for now. However, be prepared to pare back exposure next summer. Fixed Income: Maintain below benchmark duration exposure over the next 12 months. Underweight U.S. Treasurys, stay neutral Europe, and overweight Japan. Equities: Remain overweight developed market equities relative to their EM peers. Within the DM sphere, favor the euro area and Japan over the U.S. in local-currency terms. In the EM universe, Chinese H-shares have significant upside. Currencies: The selloff in the dollar is overdone. The broad trade-weighted dollar will appreciate by 10% before peaking in mid-2018. The yen still has considerable downside against the dollar, as does the euro. Commodities: Oil will rally over the coming months as global inventories decline. Gold will continue to struggle, before exploding higher towards the end of this decade. Feature I. Global Macro Outlook End Of The Global Manufacturing Recession Global growth estimates have been trending higher over the past 12 months, having bottomed last summer. Ironically, the collapse in oil prices in late 2014 was both the main reason for the deterioration in global growth as well as its subsequent rebound. Plunging oil prices led to a massive decline in capital spending in the energy sector and associated industries. In the U.S., energy capex dropped by 70% between Q2 of 2014 and Q3 of 2016. The economic fallout was even more severe in many other economies, especially emerging markets such as Russia and Brazil. The result was a global manufacturing recession and a pronounced slump in international trade (Chart 1). When thinking about oil and the economy, the distinction between levels and rates of change is important: While rapidly falling oil prices tend to be bad for global growth, lower oil prices are good for it. By the middle of 2016, the damage from the oil crash had largely run its course. What was left was a massive windfall for households, especially poorer ones who spend a disproportionate share of their paychecks at the pump. Industries that use oil as an input also benefited. Simply put, the oil crash went from being a bane to a boon for the global economy. A Solid 12-Month Outlook We expect global growth to remain firm over the next 12 months. Financial conditions in most countries have eased substantially since the start of the year thanks to rising equity prices, lower bond yields, and narrower credit spreads (Chart 2). Our empirical analysis suggests that easier financial conditions tend to lift growth with a lag of 6-to-9 months (Chart 3). This bodes well for activity in the remainder of this year. Chart 1The Manufacturing Recession Has Ended Chart 2Financial Conditions Have Eased Globally A number of "virtuous cycles" should amplify the effects of easier financial conditions. In the U.S., a tight labor market will lead to faster wage growth, helping to spur consumption. Rising household spending, in turn, will lead to lower unemployment and even faster wage growth. Strong consumption growth will also motivate firms to expand capacity, translating into more investment spending. Chart 4 shows that the share of U.S. firms planning to increase capital expenditures has risen to a post-recession high. Chart 3Easier Financial Conditions Will Support Growth Chart 4U.S. Firms Plan To Boost Capex The euro area economy continues to chug along. The purchasing manager indices (PMIs) dipped a bit in June, but remain at levels consistent with above-trend growth. The German Ifo business confidence index hit a record high this week. Corporate balance sheets in the euro area are improving and credit growth is accelerating. This is helping to fuel a rebound in business investment (Chart 5). The fact that the ECB has no intention of raising rates anytime soon will only help matters. As inflation expectations begin to recover, short-term real rates will fall. This will lead to a virtuous circle of stronger growth, and even higher inflation expectations. The Japanese economy managed to grow by an annualized 1% in the first quarter. This marked the fifth consecutive quarter of positive sequential growth, the longest streak in 11 years. Exports are recovering and both the manufacturing and non-manufacturing PMIs stand near record-high levels (Chart 6). Chart 5Euro Area Data Remain Upbeat Chart 6Japanese Economy Is Rebounding Chart 7China: Slight Slowdown, But No Need To Worry The Chinese economy has slowed a notch since the start of the year, but remains robust (Chart 7). Real-time measures of industrial activity such as railway freight traffic, excavator sales, and electricity production are rising at a healthy clip. Exports are accelerating thanks to a weaker currency and stronger global growth. Retail sales continue to expand, while the percentage of households that intend to buy a new home has surged to record-high levels. The rebound in Chinese exports and industrial output is helping to lift producer prices. Higher selling prices, in turn, are fueling a rebound in industrial company profits (Chart 8). A better profit picture should support business capital spending in the coming months. Meanwhile, the Chinese government's "regulatory windstorm" - as the local press has called it - has largely bypassed the real economy. In fact, medium and long-term lending to nonfinancial corporations, a key driver of private-sector capital spending and physical commodity demand, has actually accelerated over the past eight months (Chart 9). Chart 8China: Higher Selling Prices Fueling A Rebound In Profits Chart 9China: Credit To The Real Economy Is Accelerating All Good Things Must Come To An End We remain optimistic about global growth over the next 12 months. Unfortunately, things are likely to sour in the second half of 2018, possibly setting the stage for a recession in the U.S. and several other countries in 2019. The odds of a recession rise when economies approach full employment (Chart 10). The U.S. unemployment rate now stands at 4.3% and is on track to break below its 2000 low of 3.8% next summer. A cursory look at the data suggests that the unemployment rate is usually either rising or falling (Chart 11). And once it starts rising, it keeps rising. In fact, there has never been a case in the postwar era where the three-month average of the unemployment rate has risen by more than one-third of a percentage point without a recession ensuing. Chart 10Recessions Become More Likely When The Labor Market Begins To Overheat Chart 11Even A Small Uptick In The Unemployment Rate Is Bad News For The Business Cycle Modern economies contain numerous feedback loops. When unemployment starts increasing, this fuels a vicious cycle where rising joblessness saps confidence and incomes, leading to less spending and even higher unemployment. History suggests that it is almost impossible to break this cycle once it starts. The Fed is well aware of the risks of letting the unemployment rate fall to a level where it has nowhere to go but up. Unfortunately, calibrating monetary policy in a way that achieves a soft landing is easier said than done. Changes in monetary conditions affect the economy with a lag of about 12-to-18 months. Once it has become obvious that a central bank has either loosened or tightened monetary policy too much, it is often too late to right the ship. The risks of a policy error are particularly high in today's environment where there is significant uncertainty about the level of the long-term neutral rate. Question marks about the future stance of fiscal policy will also complicate the Fed's job. We expect the Trump administration to succeed in passing legislation that cuts both personal and corporate income taxes later this year or in early 2018. The bill will be "fully funded" in the sense that there will be offsetting spending cuts, but these will be back-loaded toward the end of the 10-year budget window, whereas the tax cuts will be front-loaded. This will generate a modest amount of fiscal stimulus over the next few years. That being said, the proposed changes to health care legislation could more than neutralize the effects of lower tax rates. The Senate bill, as currently worded, would lead to substantial cuts to Medicaid relative to existing law, as well as deep cuts to insurance subsidies for many poor and middle-class families. Our base case is that Republicans in Congress fail to pass a new health care bill, thus leaving the Affordable Care Act largely unscathed. However, if they succeed, the overall stance of federal fiscal policy would likely shift from being somewhat accommodative, on net, to somewhat restrictive. This would expedite the timing of the recession. How Deep A Recession? If the U.S. does succumb to a recession in 2019, how bad will it be? Here, there is both good news and bad news. The good news is that financial and economic imbalances are not as severe today as those that existed in the lead-up to the past few recessions. The Great Recession was preceded by a massive housing bubble, associated with overbuilding and a sharp deterioration in mortgage lending standards (Chart 12). Today, residential investment stands at 3.9% of GDP, compared to a peak of 6.6% of GDP Q1 of 2006. Lending standards, at least judging by FICO scores, have remained fairly high over the course of the recovery. In relation to income and rents, home prices are also much lower today than they were a decade ago. Likewise, the massive capex overhang that preceded the 2001 recession is largely absent at present. Chart 12No New Bubble In The U.S. Housing Sector Chart 13Consumer Credit: Making A Comeback... The bad news is that cracks in the economy are starting to form. In contrast to mortgage debt, student debt has gone through the roof and auto loans are nearly back to pre-recession levels as a share of disposable income (Chart 13). Not surprisingly, this is starting to translate into higher default rates (Chart 14). The fact that this is happening when the unemployment rate is at the lowest level in 16 years is a cause for concern. Meanwhile, the ratio of corporate debt-to-GDP has risen above 2000 levels and is closing in on its 2007 peak (Chart 15). Chart 14...With Defaults Starting To Rise In Some Categories Chart 15U.S. Corporate Sector Has Been Feasting On Credit We are particularly worried about the health of the commercial real estate (CRE) market. CRE prices currently stand 7% above pre-recession levels in real terms, having risen by a staggering 82% since the start of 2010 (Chart 16). U.S. financial institutions hold $3.8 trillion in CRE loans, $2 trillion of which are held by banks. As a share of GDP, the outstanding stock of CRE bank loans in most categories is near pre-recession levels (Chart 17). Chart 16Commercial Real Estate Prices Have Surpassed Pre-Recession Levels Chart 17CRE Debt Is Rising The retail sector is already under intense pressure due to the shift in buying habits towards E-commerce. Vacancy rates in the apartment sector have started to tick higher and rent growth has slowed (Chart 18 and Chart 19). The number of apartment units under construction stands at a four-decade high, despite a structurally subdued pace of household formation (Chart 20). Most of these units are likely to hit the market in 2018, which will result in a further increase in vacancy rates. Vacancies in the office sector are also likely to rise, given the recent increase in the number of new projects in the pipeline. On the flipside, demand growth for new office space is set to weaken, as a tighter labor market leads to slower payroll gains. Chart 18Vacancy Rates Are Bottoming Outside The Industrial Sector... Chart 19...While Rent Growth Is Losing Steam If vacancy rates across the CRE sector start rising in earnest, real estate prices will fall, leading to a decline in the value of the collateral backing CRE loans. This could prompt lenders to pull back credit, causing prices to fall further. Seasoned real estate investors are no strangers to such vicious cycles, and if the next one begins late next year when growth is slowing because the economy is running out of spare capacity and financial conditions are tightening, it would further add to the risks of a recession. Chart 20Apartment Supply Is Surging, But Will There Be Enough Demand? Gauging The Global Spillover Effects What repercussions would a U.S. recession have for the rest of the world? Simply based on trade flows, the answer is "not much." U.S. imports account for less than 5% of global ex-U.S. GDP. Thus, even a significant decline in U.S. spending abroad would not make much of a dent in overseas growth. More worrisome are potential financial spillovers. As the IMF has documented, these have been the dominant drivers of the global business cycle in the modern era.1 Chart 21Global Debt Levels Are Still High Correlations across global markets tend to increase when risk sentiment deteriorates. Thus, if U.S. stocks buckle in the face of rising recessionary risks, risk assets in other economies are sure to suffer. The fact that valuations are stretched across so many markets only makes the problem worse. A flight towards safety could trigger a pronounced decline in global equity prices, wider credit spreads, and lower property prices. This, in turn, could lead to a sharp decline in household and corporate net worth, resulting in tighter financial conditions and more stringent lending standards. Elevated debt levels represent another major source of vulnerability. Total debt as a share of GDP is greater now than it was before the Great Recession in both advanced and emerging markets (Chart 21). High debt burdens will prevent governments from loosening fiscal policy in countries that are unable to issue their own currencies. The monetary transmission mechanism also tends to be less effective in the presence of high debt. This is especially the case in today's environment where the zero lower-bound on nominal interest rates remains a formidable challenge. The presence of these fiscal and monetary constraints implies that the severity of the next recession could be somewhat greater than one might expect based solely on the underlying causes of the downturn. II. Financial Markets Overall Strategy The discussion above implies that the investment outlook over the next few years is likely to be of the "one step forward, two steps back" variety. The global economy is entering a blow-off stage where growth will get better before it gets worse. We are bullish on global equities and spread product over the next 12 months, but expect to turn bearish on risk assets next summer. Until then, investors should position for a stronger dollar and higher bond yields. We recommend a slight overweight allocation to developed market equities over their EM peers. Within the DM sphere, we favor the euro area and Japan over the U.S. in local-currency terms. In the EM universe, Chinese H-shares stand out as offering an attractive risk-reward profile. Comparing government bonds, we are underweight U.S. Treasurys, neutral on European bonds, and overweight Japan. These recommendations are broadly in line with the output of our in-house quantitative models (Table 1 and Chart 22). Table 1BCA's Tactical Global Asset Allocation Recommendations* Chart 22Message From Our U.S. Stock Market ##br##Timing Model Equities Earnings Are Key Earnings have been the main driver of the global equity bull market. In fact, the global forward P/E ratio has actually declined slightly since February, despite a 3.9% gain in equity prices (Chart 23). Strong global growth should continue to boost corporate earnings over the next 12 months. Consensus bottom-up estimates call for global EPS to expand by 14% in 2017 and a further 11% in 2018. The global earnings revision ratio moved into positive territory earlier this year for the first time in six years (Chart 24). Chart 23Earnings Have Been The Main Driver ##br##Of The Global Equity Bull Market Chart 24Global Earnings Picture ##br##Looks Solid Global monetary conditions generally remain favorable. Our U.S. Financial Conditions Index has loosened significantly. Historically, this has been a bullish signal for stocks.2 Excess liquidity, which we define as M2 growth less nominal GDP growth, is also still well above the zero line, a threshold that has warned of a downturn in stock prices in the past. Chart 25Individual Investors Are Not Overly Bullish On U.S. Equities But... Sentiment is stretched, but not excessively so. The share of bullish respondents in the AAII's weekly poll of individual investors stood at 29.7% this week (Chart 25). This marked the 18th consecutive week that optimism has been below its long-term average. Market Vane's survey of traders and Yale's Investor Confidence index paint a more complacent picture, as do other measures such as the VIX and margin debt (Chart 26). Nevertheless, as long as earnings continue to grow and monetary policy remains in expansionary territory, sentiment can remain elevated without being a significant threat to stocks. Overweight The Euro Area And Japan Over The U.S. Regionally, earnings revisions have been more positive in Europe and Japan than in the U.S. so far this year. Net profit margins are also lower in Europe and Japan, which gives these two regions more room for catch-up. Moreover, unlike the Fed, neither the ECB nor the BoJ are likely to raise rates anytime soon. As we discuss in greater detail in the currency section of this report, this should lead to a weaker euro and yen, giving European and Japanese exporters a further leg up in competitiveness. Lastly, valuations are more favorable in the euro area and Japan than in the U.S., even if one adjusts for differing sector weights across the three regions (Chart 27). Chart 26...There Are Signs Of Complacency Chart 27U.S. Valuations Seem Stretched Relative ##br##To Other Bourses Mixed Outlook For EM Earnings growth in emerging markets has accelerated sharply. Bottom-up estimates imply EPS growth of 20% in 2017 and 11% in 2018 for the EM MSCI index. Our EM strategists believe this is too optimistic, given the prospect of a stronger dollar, high debt levels across the EM space, poor corporate governance, and the lack of productivity-enhancing structural reforms. These problems warrant a slight underweight to emerging markets in global equity portfolios. Nevertheless, considering the solid backdrop for global growth, EM stocks should still be able to deliver positive real total returns over the next 12 months. Within the EM space, we favor Russia, central Europe, Korea, Taiwan, India, Thailand, and China. Chinese H-shares, in particular, remain quite attractive, trading at only 7.1-times forward earnings and 1.0-times book value. Favor Cyclicals Over Defensives ... For Now Looking at global equity sectors, upward revisions have been largest for industrials, materials, financials, and real estate. Revisions for energy, health care, and telecom have been negative. We expect cyclical stocks to outperform defensives over the next 12 months. Energy stocks will move from being laggards to leaders, as oil prices rebound. Financials should also do well, as steeper yield curves, increased M&A activity, and falling nonperforming loans bolster profits. Equity Bear Market Will Begin Late Next Year As growth begins to falter in the second half of 2018, stocks will swoon. U.S. equities are likely to fall 20% to 30% peak to trough, marking the first sustained bear market since 2008. Other stock markets will experience similar declines. Global equities will eventually recoup most of their losses at the start of the 2020s, but the recovery will be a lackluster one. As we have argued extensively in the past, global productivity growth is likely to remain weak.3 Population aging will deplete savings, leading to higher real interest rates. The next recession could also propel more populist leaders into power. None of these things would be good for stocks. Against today's backdrop of lofty valuations, global stocks will deliver a total real return in the low single-digit range over the next decade. Fixed Income Bonds Have Overreacted To The Inflation Dip We turned structurally bearish on government bonds on July 5th, 2016. As fate would have it, this was the very same day that the U.S. 10-year Treasury yield dropped to a record closing low of 1.37%. The dramatic bond selloff that followed was too much, too fast. We warned at the start of this year that bond yields were likely to climb down from their highs. At this point, however, the pendulum has swung too far in the direction of lower yields. Chart 28 shows that almost all of the decline in bond yields has been due to falling inflation expectations. Real yields have remained resilient, suggesting that investors' views of global growth have not changed much. This helps explain why stocks have been able to rally to new highs. The fall in inflation expectations has been largely driven by the decline in commodity prices. Short-term swings in oil prices should not affect long-term inflation expectations, but in practice they do (Chart 29). If oil prices recover in the second half of this year, as we expect, inflation expectations should shift higher as well. This will translate into higher bond yields. Chart 28Inflation Expectations Declined This Year, ##br##But Real Yields Remained Resilient Chart 29Low Oil Prices Drag Down##br## Inflation Expectations U.S. Treasurys Are Most Vulnerable Tightening labor markets should also boost inflation expectations. This is particularly the case in the U.S., where the economy is quickly running out of surplus labor. Some commentators have argued that the headline unemployment rate understates the true amount of economic slack. We are skeptical that this is the case. Table 2 compares a wide variety of measures of labor market slack with where they stood at the height of the business cycle in 2000 and 2007. The main message from the table is that the unemployment rate today is broadly where one would expect it to be based on these collaborating indicators. Table 2Comparing Current Labor Market Slack With Past Cycles 12-MONTH If the U.S. has reached full employment, does the absence of wage pressures signal that the Phillips curve is dead? We don't think so. For one thing, wage growth is not that weak. Our wage growth tracker has risen from a low of 1.2% in 2010 to 2.4% at present (Chart 30). In fact, real wages have been rising more quickly than productivity for the past three years (Chart 31). Unit labor cost growth is now just shy of where it was at the peaks of the last two business cycles (Chart 32). Chart 30Stronger Labor Market ##br##Is Leading To Faster Wage Growth Chart 31Real Wages Now Increasing Faster##br## Than Productivity Chart 32Unit Labor Cost Growth Close ##br##To Previous Two Peaks The evidence generally suggests that the Phillips curve becomes "kinked" when the unemployment rate falls towards 4%. In plain English, this means that a drop in the unemployment rate from 10% to 8% tends to have little effect on inflation, while a drop from 4.5% to 3.5% does. The experience of the 1960s is illustrative in that regard. Chart 33 shows that much like today, inflation in the first half of that decade was well anchored at just below 2%. However, once the unemployment rate fell below 4%, inflation took off. Core inflation rose from 1.5% in early 1966 to nearly 4% in early 1967, ultimately making its way to 6% by 1970. The Fed is keen to avoid a repeat of that episode. In a recent speech, New York Fed President and FOMC vice chairman Bill Dudley warned that "If we were not to withdraw accommodation, the risk would be that the economy would crash to a very, very low unemployment rate, and generate inflation ... Then the risk would be that we would have to slam on the brakes and the next stop would be a recession." If U.S. growth remains firm and inflation rebounds in the second half of this year, as we expect, the Fed will get the green light to keep raising rates in line with the "dots." The market is not prepared for that, as evidenced by the fact that it is pricing in only 27 basis points in rate hikes over the next 12 months. We are positioned for higher rate expectations by being short the January 2018 fed funds contract. The ECB And The BoJ Will Not Follow The Fed's Lead Could better growth prospects cause the ECB and the BoJ to follow in the Fed's footsteps and take away the punch bowl? We doubt it. Investors are reading too much into Mario Draghi's allegedly more "hawkish" tone. There is a huge difference between removing emergency measures and beginning a full-fledged tightening cycle. Labor market slack is still considerably higher in the euro area than was the case in 2008. Outside of Germany, the level of unemployment and underemployment in the euro area is about seven points higher than it was before the Great Recession (Chart 34). Chart 33Inflation In The 1960s Took Off ##br##Once The Unemployment Rate Fell Below 4% Chart 34Euro Area: Labor Market Slack##br## Is Still High Outside Of Germany At this point, the market is pricing in too much tightening from the ECB. Our months-to-hike measure has plummeted from a high of 65 months in July 2016 to 25 months at present (Chart 35). Investors now expect real yields in the U.S. to be only 16 basis points higher than in the euro area in five years' time.4 This is below the 76 basis-point gap in the equilibrium rate between the two regions that Holston, Laubach, and Williams estimate (Chart 36). Chart 35ECB: Markets Are Pricing In Too Much Tighteninh Chart 36The Neutral Rate Is Lowest In The Euro Area As for Japan, while the unemployment rate has fallen to a 22-year low of 2.8%, this understates the true amount of slack in the economy. Output-per-hour in Japan remains 35% below U.S. levels. A key reason for this is that many Japanese companies continue to pad their payrolls with excess labor. This is particularly true in the service sector, which remains largely insulated from foreign competition. In any case, with both actual inflation and inflation expectations in Japan nowhere close to the BoJ's target, this is hardly the time to be worried about an overheated economy. And even if the Japanese authorities were inclined to slow growth, it would be fiscal policy rather than monetary policy that they would tighten first. After all, they have been keen to raise the sales tax for several years now. The Bank Of England's Dilemma Gilts are a tougher call. The equilibrium rate is higher in the U.K. than in most other developed economies. Inflation has risen, although that has largely been a function of a weaker currency. Fiscal policy is turning more accommodative, which, all things equal, would warrant a more bearish view on gilts. The big wildcard is Brexit. Chart 37 shows that the U.K. is the only major country where growth has faltered this year. Worries over Britain's future relationship with the EU have likely contributed to the slowdown. Ongoing Brexit angst will keep the Bank of England on hold, justifying a neutral weighting on gilts. Stay Short Duration ... For Now In summary, investors should keep global duration risk below benchmark levels over the next 12 months. Regionally, we recommend underweighting U.S. Treasurys, overweighting Japan, and maintaining a neutral position towards euro area and U.K. government bonds. Reflecting these recommendations, we are closing our short Japanese, German and Swiss 10-year bond trade for a gain of 5.3% and replacing it with a short 30-year U.S. Treasury bond position. As global growth begins to slow in the second half of next year, global bonds will rally. However, as we discussed at length in our Q2 Strategy Outlook, the rally will simply represent a countertrend move in what will turn out to be a structural bear market.5 The 2020s, in short, could end up looking a lot like the 1970s. Spread Product: Still A Bit Of Juice Left While we prefer equities to high-yield credit on a risk-adjusted basis over the coming months, we would still overweight spread product within a global asset allocation framework. The option-adjusted spread of the U.S. high-yield index offers 200 basis points above the Treasury curve after adjusting for expected defaults, roughly in line with the mid-point of the historical data (Chart 38). Corporate defaults are likely to trend lower over the next 12 months, spurred by stronger growth and a rebound in oil prices. Chart 37U.K. Is Lagging Its Peers Chart 38Default-Adjusted Junk Spreads Are At Historical Average As with all our other views, the picture is likely to change sharply in the second half of next year. At that point, corporate spreads will widen, warranting a much more defensive stance. Currencies And Commodities The Dollar Bull: Down But Not Out Our long-standing dollar bullish view has come under fire over the past few months. The Fed's broad trade-weighted dollar index has fallen 4.6% since December. Momentum in currency markets can be a powerful force, and so we would not be surprised if the dollar remains under pressure over the coming weeks. However, over a 12-month horizon, the greenback will strengthen, as the Fed raises rates more quickly than expected while most other central banks stand pat. When all is said and done, the broad-trade weighted dollar is likely to peak next summer at a level roughly 10% higher than where it is today. That would still leave it substantially below prior peaks in 1985 and 2000 (Chart 39). The U.S. trade deficit has fallen from a peak of nearly 6% of GDP in 2005 to 3% of GDP at present (Chart 40). Rising shale production has reduced the demand for oil imports. A smaller trade deficit diminishes the need to attract foreign capital with a cheaper currency. Chart 39The Dollar Is Below Past Peaks Chart 40The U.S. Trade Deficit Has Halved Since 2005 Sentiment and speculative positioning towards the dollar have swung from extremely bullish at the start of the year to being more neutral today (Chart 41). In contrast, long euro speculative positions and bullish sentiment have reached the highest levels in three years. Our tactical short euro/long dollar trade was stopped out this week for a loss of 1.6%. However, we continue to expect EUR/USD to fall back towards parity by the end of the year. We also expect the pound to weaken against the dollar, but appreciate slightly against the euro. Now that the Bank of Japan is keeping the 10-year JGB yield pinned to zero, the outlook for the yen will be largely determined by what happens to yields abroad. If we are correct that Treasury yields - and to a lesser extent yields in Europe - rise, the yen will suffer. Commodity Currencies Should Fare Well Higher commodity prices should benefit currencies such as the Canadian and Aussie dollars and the Norwegian krone. Our energy strategists remain convinced that crude prices are heading higher. They expect global production to increase by only 0.7 MMB/d in 2017, compared to 1.5 MMB/d growth in consumption. While shale output continues to rise, this is largely being offset by falling production from conventional oil fields. Consequently, oil inventories should fall in the remainder of this year. If history is any guide, this will lead to a rebound in oil prices (Chart 42). Chart 41USD: Sentiment And Positioning ##br##Are Not Lopsided Anymore Chart 42Falling Oil Inventories Should Lead ##br##To Higher Crude Prices The outlook for industrial metals is not as upbeat as for oil, but metal prices should nevertheless rebound over the coming months. We suspect that much of the recent weakness in metal prices can be attributed to the regulatory crackdown on shadow banking activity in China. Many Chinese traders had used commodities as collateral for loans. As their loans were called in, they had no choice but to liquidate their positions. Today, speculative positioning in the commodity pits has returned to more normal levels (Chart 43). This reduces the risk of a further downdraft in commodity prices. BCA's China strategists expect the Chinese authorities to relax some of their tightening measures. This is already being seen in a decline in interbank lending rates and corporate bond yields (Chart 44). Chart 43Commodities: Long Speculative Positions Returning ##br##To More Normal Levels Chart 44China: Some Relief##br## After Recent Tightening Action? One key reason why the authorities have been able to let interest rates come down is because capital outflows have abated. Compared to late 2015, economic growth is stronger and deflationary pressures have receded. The trade-weighted RMB has also fallen by 7.5% since then, giving the economy a competitive boost. As such, the seeming can't-lose bet on further yuan weakness has disappeared. We still expect the RMB to depreciate against the dollar over the next 12 months, but to strengthen against most other currencies, including the euro and the yen. If the yuan remains resilient, this will limit the downside risk for other EM currencies. Nevertheless, at this point, much of the good news benefiting EM currencies has been priced in. Across the EM universe, in addition to the Chinese yuan, we like the Mexican peso, Taiwan dollar, Indian rupee, Russian ruble, Polish zloty, and Czech koruna. Lastly, a few words on the most timeless of all currencies: gold. We expect bullion to struggle over the next 12 months on the back of a stronger dollar and rising bond yields. However, once the Fed starts cutting rates in 2019 and stagflationary forces begin to gather steam in the early 2020s, gold will finally have its day in the sun. Peter Berezin, Chief Global Strategist Global Investment Strategy peterb@bcaresearch.com 1 For example, please see Box 4.1: Financial Linkages and Spillovers in "Spillovers and Cycles in the Global Economy," IMF World Economic Outlook, (April 2007). 2 Please see Global Investment Strategy Weekly Report, "The Message From Our Stock Market Timing Model," dated May 5, 2017, available at gis.bcaresearch.com. 3 Please see Global Investment Strategy Special Report, "Is Slow Productivity Growth Good Or Bad For Bonds?" dated May 31, 2017; Global Investment Strategy - Strategy Outlook, "First Quarter 2017 From Reflation To Stagflation, (Section: Supply Matters), First Quarter 2017 From Reflation To Stagflation, (Section: Supply Matters)," dated January 6, 2017; and Global Investment Strategy Special Report, "Weak Productivity Growth: Don't Blame The Statisticians," dated March 25, 2016, available at gis.bcaresearch.com. 4 U.S. minus euro area 5-year/5-year forward real bond yields. Real bonds yields are calculated as a difference between nominal yields and the CPI swap rate. Euro area yields refer to a GDP-weighted average of Germany, France, the Netherlands, Belgium, Austria, Italy, and Spain. 5 Please see Global Investment Strategy, "Strategy Outlook: Second Quarter 2017: A Three-Act Play," dated March 31, 2017, available at gis.bcaresearch.com. Tactical Global Asset Allocation Recommendations Strategy & Market Trends Tactical Trades Strategic Recommendations Closed Trades
Highlights Fed Policy Loop: Low inflation is preventing rate hike expectations from being revised higher, prolonging the current rally in spread product. We expect rate hike expectations to move up as inflation recovers, eventually leading to a correction in spread product. Such a correction will prove fleeting as long as inflation stays below target. High-Yield: High-yield valuation is consistent with its historical average, after accounting for expected default losses. Current valuation levels should translate into excess returns of just over 200 bps during the next 12 months. Aaa Spread Product: Non-agency CMBS offer the most spread pick-up of any Aaa-rated sector. However, we prefer to focus our Aaa-rated spread product allocation in Agency CMBS and credit card backed consumer ABS. Feature Chart 1The Fed Policy Loop In Action One of this publication's main themes during the past few years has been the Fed Policy Loop.1 In essence, the Loop describes the feedback mechanism between monetary policy and financial markets, a relationship that results from both investors' sensitivity to the Fed's policy stance and the Fed's reliance on financial conditions as a predictor of economic growth. In practice, the Loop works as follows: Easier Fed policy causes spread product to outperform Treasuries. Tighter credit spreads lead to easier financial conditions, which the Fed interprets as a sign that economic growth will accelerate. An improved economic outlook causes the Fed to step up the pace of tightening. Tighter Fed policy causes spread product to underperform Treasuries. Wider credit spreads lead to tighter financial conditions, which the Fed interprets as a sign that economic growth will moderate. A worse economic outlook causes the Fed to slow its expected pace of tightening. Rinse, repeat. Chart 2 provides a graphical description of the Loop, and its most recent iteration can be seen in Chart 1 above. Chart 1 shows that corporate bonds outperformed Treasuries leading up to the March rate hike, but then rate expectations rose too far. In mid-March the market was discounting a fed funds rate of 1.86% by the end of 2018. These overly stringent rate hike expectations caused corporate bonds to underperform, and this underperformance led rate hike expectations to be revised lower. The market now expects a fed funds rate of only 1.47% by the end of 2018, and these depressed rate expectations have fueled the rally in corporate bonds that started in mid-April. Normally at this stage of the Fed Policy Loop we would expect rate hike expectations to move higher until they eventually prompt a correction in corporate spreads. However, extremely disappointing core inflation prints during the past three months have caused the market to keep its rate hike expectations depressed. This has extended the most recent rally in spread product. This is why we have consistently pointed to core inflation and the cost of inflation protection embedded in long-maturity bond yields as the main factors to watch to determine how much life is left in the corporate bond trade. As long as inflation stays below target, the Fed absolutely needs it to rise. It will therefore be quick to respond to any tightening of financial conditions/widening of credit spreads. Table 1 shows average monthly excess returns for investment grade corporate bonds relative to duration-matched Treasuries. These returns are split into buckets based on the reading from the St. Louis Fed's Price Pressures Measure (PPM). The PPM is a composite of 104 economic indicators designed to measure the probability that inflation will exceed 2.5% during the next 12 months. As can be seen, average monthly excess returns are strongest when inflation pressures are low, but they gradually decline as inflation heats up and the Fed's reaction function becomes less supportive for markets. At present, the PPM gives a reading of only 4.8%. Table 1Investment Grade Corporate Bond Excess Returns* Under Different ##br## Ranges Of Price Pressures Measure** (January 1990 To Present) Similarly, Table 2 shows that it is difficult to get a long-lasting correction in an environment with low inflation pressures and a responsive Fed. This table shows the results of a "buy the dips" trading strategy where if the average junk spread widens by 20 basis points we buy the junk index versus duration-matched Treasuries and hold it for a period of 1, 2 or 3 months. Just as in Table 1, this strategy works well when inflation pressures are muted, but starts to fail as inflation ramps up. Table 2High-Yield Corporate Bond Returns* Achieved By Holding The Junk Index ##br## Following A 20 BPs Widening In High-Yield Corporate OAS** Under Different Ranges Of ##br## The St. Louis Fed Price Pressures Measure*** (February 1994 To Present) Beatings Will Continue Until Morale Improves So when will the Fed staunch the current rally? That depends on how quickly inflation rebounds,2 and also on how much emphasis Fed policymakers place on financial conditions versus the actual inflation data. At the moment, most indexes are sending the message that financial conditions are easier than average and that the Fed should continue to tighten (Chart 3). However, as was noted above, inflation gauges are sending the opposite signal (Chart 3, panel 2). For now, the Fed is downplaying low inflation as transitory. It decided to leave its median projected rate hike path unchanged at the June FOMC meeting. But the Fed's refusal to capitulate in the face of weaker inflation has caused the yield curve to flatten, the cost of inflation protection to plummet (Chart 3, bottom panel) and investors to grow increasingly concerned about a policy mistake (Chart 4). Chart 3Financial Conditions Are Supportive Chart 4Should The Fed Keep Tightening? This brings up an interesting flaw in the financial conditions approach to policymaking. Most indexes of financial conditions are at least partially driven by long-maturity Treasury yields (lower yields = easier financial conditions, and vice-versa). This makes some sense. Lower yields do in fact indicate that the financing back-drop is more supportive and tend to translate into higher growth in the future (Chart 5). Chart 5Financial Conditions Lead Economic Growth However, what if lower long-maturity Treasury yields are the result of excessively tight Fed policy? This would appear to be the case at the moment. Investors are revising their long-run inflation forecasts lower on the view that the Fed is not doing enough to allow prices to rise. In such a situation it would be incorrect to interpret lower Treasury yields as a signal that policy needs to tighten further. On the contrary, tighter policy would only exacerbate the downtrend in yields. For this reason we do not include the level of yields in the financial conditions component of our Fed Monitor (Chart 3, top panel). As a result, this financial conditions indicator is not as deep in "easing territory" as most other indicators. However, it is still above the zero line, suggesting that policy should be biased tighter at the margin. Bottom Line: Low inflation is preventing rate hike expectations from being revised higher, prolonging the current rally in spread product. We expect rate hike expectations to move up as inflation recovers, eventually leading to a correction in spread product. Such a correction will prove fleeting as long as inflation remains below the Fed's target. The key risk is that inflation stays low but the Fed continues to focus exclusively on "easy" readings from financial conditions indexes, and proceeds on its current tightening path. In that scenario cries of "policy mistake" will grow louder and spread product will sell off, converging with lower rate hike expectations. We view this scenario as a low-probability tail risk. Junk Valuation Update At 378 bps, the average spread on the Bloomberg Barclays High-Yield index is only 55 bps above its post-crisis low, but still more than 100 bps above the level where it tends to settle in the late stages of the economic cycle when the Fed is tightening policy (Chart 6, top panel). Higher debt levels than are typical for this stage of the cycle suggest that somewhat wider spreads are justified,3 but the idea that junk spreads are extremely tight compared to history does not hold up to scrutiny. Chart 6High-Yield Default-Adjusted Spread Our preferred measure of junk valuation, the default-adjusted high-yield spread, paints an even rosier picture. The second panel of Chart 6 shows an ex-post measure of the default-adjusted spread (the option-adjusted spread of the high-yield index less actual default losses over the subsequent 12 months). The most recent reading from this indicator is based on our forecast of default losses for the next 12 months, and is shown as a dashed line. The message from the default-adjusted spread is that, assuming our default loss forecast is correct, junk bonds currently offer compensation for default risk that is in line with the historical average. That level of compensation would be consistent with an excess return of just over 200 bps during the next 12 months (Chart 6, panel 3), and is contingent on the speculative grade default rate falling to 2.68%, in line with Moody's baseline forecast (Chart 6, bottom panel). We expect a decline in the default rate to materialize in the coming months as commodity sector defaults continue to work their way out of the data. Moody's did not record any commodity-related defaults in May, the first month this has occurred since January 2015. The risk going forward is that defaults start to emerge in the increasingly stressed retail sector. So far, Moody's has recorded two retail defaults this year. However, more are probably on the way. This will be especially true if inflationary pressures start to mount and the Fed tightens policy, giving banks less incentive to extend credit. We will be monitoring the situation in retail closely going forward. Bottom Line: High-yield valuation is consistent with its historical average, after accounting for expected default losses. Current valuation levels should translate into excess returns of just over 200 bps during the next 12 months. Aaa Roundup As can be inferred from the previous two sections, we are still reasonably comfortable taking credit risk in U.S. bond portfolios. However, this week we also look at the compensation offered by Aaa-rated spread product. For investors who desire some Aaa-rated allocation outside of the Treasury market, Chart 7 provides a snapshot of where the most additional spread is available. The first thing that jumps out is that Agency bonds offer very little spread compared to other Aaa-rated instruments. Agency residential mortgage-backed securities also offer relatively little compensation, unless one is willing to extend into premium coupons (4% and above). Agency CMBS, auto ABS and credit card ABS all offer more spread than Aaa-rated corporate bonds. Non-agency CMBS offer much more attractive spreads than the other Aaa sectors, but we see potential for capital losses in that segment, as is discussed below. Agency MBS Only agency MBS carrying coupons of 4% or above offer interesting compensation relative to other Aaa-rated sectors, and even there we see potential for spread widening in the coming months. Nominal MBS spreads are already very tight compared to history (Chart 8) and appear even tighter relative to trends in net issuance (Chart 8, panel 2). While refinancing activity will likely stay depressed (Chart 8, panel 3), we see potential for option-adjusted spreads to follow net issuance higher, even as the compensation for prepayment risk (option cost) remains low. A similar scenario played out in 2007 (Chart 8, bottom panel). The Fed's exit from the MBS market, which could occur as early as September, represents an additional upside risk for spreads. Chart 8MBS Spreads Biased Wider Chart 9Avoid Non-Agency CMBS CMBS As noted above, non-agency CMBS look very attractive compared to other Aaa-rated spread products. But we see potential for spread widening in this sector. Commercial real estate lending standards are tightening and property prices are decelerating, both should pressure non-agency CMBS spreads wider (Chart 9). Agency CMBS offer somewhat lower spreads than their non-agency counterparts. But this sector should be more insulated from spread widening. For one thing, Agency CMBS are mostly backed by multi-family loans. Multi-family property prices have been stronger than those in the retail or office segments (Chart 9, panel 3), and multi-family properties have also experienced much lower delinquencies (Chart 9, bottom panel). Consumer ABS Chart 10Credit Cards Greater Than Autos While Chart 7 shows that Aaa-rated auto ABS offer a slight spread advantage over Aaa-rated credit card ABS, we are inclined to view credit card ABS more favorably. Rising auto loan net loss rates pose a risk for auto ABS spreads, while credit card charge-offs remain historically low (Chart 10). Auto lending standards have also moved deep into "net tightening" territory, while credit card lending standards have dipped back into "net easing" territory. The small extra compensation available in auto ABS relative to credit card ABS does not seem to be worth the extra risk. Bottom Line: Non-agency CMBS offer the most spread pick-up of any Aaa-rated sector. However, we view the risk of a further widening in non-agency CMBS spreads as substantial. We prefer to focus our Aaa-rated spread product exposure in Agency CMBS and credit card backed consumer ABS. Both sectors offer reasonably attractive spreads, and should remain insulated from capital losses going forward. Ryan Swift, Vice President U.S. Bond Strategy rswift@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see U.S. Bond Strategy Weekly Report, "Caught In A Loop", dated September 29, 2015, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 2 Our view is that core inflation will rebound fairly quickly. For further details please see U.S. Bond Strategy Weekly Report, "Three Scenarios For Treasury Yields In 2017", dated June 20, 2017, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 3 For further details please see U.S. Bond Strategy Weekly Report, "Low Inflation And Rising Debt", dated June 13, 2017, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com Fixed Income Sector Performance Recommended Portfolio Specification
Highlights The rollover in the economic surprise index is not sending a near-term recession signal and should trough in the next month or so, as decent economic data begins to surpass now lowered expectations. Investors should be prepared for a mild recession in 2019, but odds of a recession are low in the next 12-18 months. Oil prices will move higher from the mid $40s per barrel as investors start to see the inventory drawdowns we expect in the coming months. We expect that the Fed will stick to its plan to begin shrinking its balance sheet in September and hike rates again in December. Still, a stubbornly low inflation rate in the next few months would likely see the Fed postpone any further tightening until early 2018. Small cap stocks have underperformed large caps this year, but investors should not interpret this as a sign of that start of sell-off in risk assets. Feature The Citi Economic Surprise Index (CESI) is not sending a near-term recession signal and should trough in the next month as decent economic data begin to surpass lowered economic expectations. The index is nearly two standard deviations below its mean after peaking in early March in the wake of the election and has been falling for 71 days. It typically takes 90 days for the surprise index to find a footing after readings above 40. Moreover, the mean reverting nature of the index suggests a rebound at two standard deviations, absent a recession that we do not foresee (Chart 1). Chart 1Economic Surprise Index Approaching A Turning Point CESI is composed of two components, whose composition and recent behavior are crucial to interpreting the weakness in the overall surprise metric. A positive reading on the "consensus change" index, which tracks economists' forecasts, means that expectations have improved relative to their one-year average. A positive reading on the "data change" component suggests that economic releases have been stronger than their one-year average. The overall surprise index combines these two elements/factors (Chart 2). Chart 2Post Election, Economic Expectations For Soft Data Hit An Eight Year High Lofty expectations, rather than poor data, account for much of CESI's weakness in the past three months. This is most pronounced in the soft economic surprise index, where outlooks moved sharply in the wake of the U.S. election when forecasters were swept up in Trump euphoria. By early March 2017, the economic consensus index for soft data was at its highest in seven years, topping out just shy of the all-time record set in late 2009. Prognosticators also ratcheted up their forecasts for the hard data, but not by nearly as much. The inevitable result of elevated expectations, combined with economic reports that signaled that overall growth remained close to 2%, was a prolonged spell of economic disappointment. This type of divergence between heightened expectations and weakness in the overall surprise index has occurred several times in the past 13 years (2004, 2010, 2011, 2012 and 2017). Each episode took place before a bottom in the economic surprise index and our view is that this time is no different (Chart 2). Despite the dismal surprise index, forecasts for U.S. and global GDP in 2017 and 2018 have held up, which is a positive sign for profits (Chart 3). The stability of these forecasts is in sharp contrast to 2012, 2013, 2015 and 2016 when global growth estimates sunk at the same time as the economic surprise index. As we stated in our recent report,1 GDP growth in 1H 2017 in the U.S. is on track to match the Fed's modest 2.1% target for the year. Moreover, in years when Q1 GDP is weak, 2H growth is faster than 1H growth 70% of the time. Chart 3U.S. & Global GDP Estimates For 2017 & 2018 Have Held Up Well Falling oil prices are another worry for investors concerned that global growth is on the wane. We take a different view and expect oil prices to increase in the coming months. In a recent report,2 our Energy Sector Strategy team noted that investors are confused about conflicting supply signals in oil markets. Traders do not see the physical shortage that the IEA/EIA/OPEC and BCA's top-down supply & demand analyses argue should prevail (Chart 4). Investors are cautious amid the uncertainty. We view the investment environment as overly pessimistic and anticipate that oil prices (and oil-focused upstream equities) will improve as inventory withdrawals escalate in the coming months. The latest 3.5% year-over-year reading on LEI for May points to low odds of a near-term recession (Chart 2, panel 3). However, BCA's Global Investment Strategy service has raised the possibility of a U.S. recession commencing in 2019. Financial markets would move ahead of a recession, thus investors should begin to adjust their portfolios3 for a recession scenario in the latter half of 2018, as economic and profit growth begins to weaken. Until then, we favor stocks over bonds, but we remain vigilant for any signs of imbalances that typically precipitate a recession. Our Global Investment Strategy service points out that in the post-war era the unemployment rate's three-month moving average has never risen by more than one-third of a percentage point without a recession. A good leading indicator of the unemployment rate is the weekly unemployment claims data, and they suggest continued tightening in the labor market (Chart 5). Chart 4We Expect The Oil Balance To Tighten Later This Year Chart 5Claims Not Even Close To Sending A Recession Signal A tighter labor market will lead to the familiar vicious cycle of a more aggressive Fed, a margin squeeze, slower and eventually falling profits, rising corporate defaults and layoffs. The resulting economic downturn would be mild compared with the 2007-2009 recession because the current imbalances are not as severe as those in 2007. Even so, with valuations stretched, the pain of the recession may be most felt in the financial markets, with a likelihood of a 20-30% equity bear market. Bottom Line: Despite signs to the contrary, the sweet spot that has buoyed risk assets remains in place: a beneficial combination of moderate economic growth, healthy corporate profit growth, stable margins, low inflation and a Fed prepared to only gradually hike rates. We remain overweight stocks versus bonds in the next 6-12 months. Threats to this risk-asset friendly environment include a further drop in core inflation, an over-aggressive central bank, and signs that negative economic shocks are leading to a significant markdown of global growth prospects. Is The Fed's Inflation Target Credible? The recent drop in oil prices has undermined our short-duration recommendation. But more than that, investors are questioning whether the Fed even has the ability to reach its inflation goals, following the surprising May CPI report and the softening in some of the wage data. Is it possible that the U.S. is following Japan's roadmap where even an over-heated labor market is insufficient to generate any meaningful inflation? The sharp flattening of the Treasury curve indicates that the bond market has already rendered its judgement. As we noted last week, the energy component pulled down the headline CPI rate again in May, but the softening of inflation this year is widespread in the index. This is contrary to Fed Chair Yellen's assertion that recent weak readings are due largely to special factors, such as wireless telecommunications prices. The deceleration in inflation began around the start of the year. The 3-month rate of change of the headline index fell by more than five percentage points between January and May, of which energy accounts for 3.3 percentage points. The deceleration in the core rate was a less severe, but still substantial, 2.8 percentage points. Table 1 presents the components of the CPI that made the largest contribution to the deceleration in core inflation. Motor vehicles, owners' equivalent rent, apparel, recreation, wireless telecom and medical care services accounted for 1.2 percentage points as a group. However, many other sectors contributed in a small way to the overall deceleration of core inflation in the first five months of the year. Table 1Key Drivers Of Core Inflation Deceleration In 2017 Some special factors were at play. The moderation in rent inflation likely reflects the bottoming of the vacancy rate. Discounting in the auto sector is not a surprise given weak sales. Wireless prices can be viewed as a special case as well. Nonetheless, the breadth and suddenness of the deceleration in core inflation across such diverse sectors, some unrelated to labor markets, commodity prices, the weak dollar or on-line shopping, is startling. The disinflation this year in the Fed's preferred measure, the PCE price index, is not as extended but the data lag the CPI by roughly a month. A diffusion index made up of the components of the PCE index is still in positive territory, unlike the CPI's diffusion index (Chart 6). Nonetheless, the CPI data suggest that core PCE inflation will edge lower when the May data are released at the end of June. There has also been a moderation in some of the wage inflation data, such as average hourly earnings (Chart 7). The slowdown has been fairly widespread across manufacturing and services. The good news is that the soft patch appears to be over; 3-month rates of change have firmed almost across the board (retail is a major exception). Chart 6CPI, PCE Diffusion##BR##Indices Are Mixed Chart 7Wages Have Accelerated##BR##Over Past Three Months There is no slowdown evident at all in the better-constructed Employment Cost Index (ECI) as of the first quarter (Chart 8). The related diffusion indexes also remain constructive. The ECI is adjusted to avoid compositional effects that can distort the aggregate index. We conclude from these and other wage measures that the Phillips curve is still operating. Admittedly, the curve appears to be quite flat, which means it is difficult to generate inflation even when the labor market overheats. Nonetheless, the relationship between the ECI and measures of labor market tightness, such as the quit rate, the "jobs plentiful" index and NFIB compensation plans, does not appear to have broken down (Chart 9). The percentage of U.S. states with unemployment below the Fed's estimate of full employment is above 70%. Anything over 60% in the past has been associated with wage pressure (Chart 10). The percentage jumped from 58% in March to 71% in April, blasting through the 60% threshold. Chart 8No Slowdown##BR##In ECI Data Chart 9Labor Market Tight Enough##BR##To Push Up Inflation The bottom line is that, while we are concerned about the breadth of the soft patch in the consumer price data, we are in agreement with the Fed that the labor market is tight enough to gradually push up inflation. We are willing at this point to chalk up the recent drop in core inflation partly to randomness in the data, and partly to lagged effects of the slowdown in real GDP growth in the first half of 2016 (Chart 11). The PPI for services and for core goods are not suggesting there is deflationary pressure in the pipeline (Chart 8). Chart 10Rise In State Level Diffusion Indices Consistent With Higher Compensation Costs Chart 11Inflation Lags Economic Growth By 18 Months What Will The Fed Do? The CPI data have rattled some on the FOMC. Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas President Kaplan, for example, believes that the Fed needs to be patient to ensure that the inflation pullback is temporary. However, the June FOMC Statement and Yellen's press conference suggested that the consensus is determined to stick with the current tightening timetable in terms of rate hikes and balance sheet adjustment. FOMC Vice Chairman Dudley echoed this view in comments he made last week to the press. The Fed has been quick to ease or back away from planned rate hikes at the first hint of trouble since the Lehman shock. However, it appears that the reaction function has changed, now that the labor market is at full employment. This is especially the case because financial conditions have eased further since the June rate hike. Unemployment will edge further below the full-employment level if the FOMC does not slow the economy. Policymakers know that the Fed has had little success in the past when it tried to nudge unemployment higher in order to relieve inflation pressure and achieve a soft landing; these attempts almost always ended in recession. Dudley added that "...pausing policy now could raise the risk of inflation surging and hurting the economy." Other FOMC members are worried that financial stability risk will rise if the low-rate environment extends much further. The bottom line is that we expect the Fed will stick with the game-plan for now. The FOMC will begin shrinking the balance sheet in September, but will wait until December for the next rate hike. That said, a stubbornly low inflation rate in the coming months would likely see the FOMC postpone the next rate increase into next year. Where Next For Bonds? Our fixed-income strategists see three possible scenarios for the bond market:4 Base Case: Weak recent inflation readings are nothing more than a lagged response to last year's deceleration in economic growth. U.S. growth accelerates in the second half, unemployment falls further and both wage growth and inflation pick up. Oil inventories begin to contract and prices head higher. The FOMC is vindicated in its inflation view and proceeds with the current rate hike and balance sheet adjustment agenda. Investors receive a "wake up call" from the Fed, bond prices get hit and recent curve-flattening trend reverses. Fed Capitulates: The U.S. labor market continues to tighten, but core PCE inflation is still close to 1½% by the September FOMC meeting. We would expect the Fed to lower its forecasted rate hike path, signaling that no further rate hikes are likely in 2017. Long-maturity real yields would fall in this scenario, although long-term inflation expectations could rise to the extent that the Fed's more dovish tilt will weaken the dollar and generate more inflation in the medium term. Nominal yields may not end up moving much in this scenario. A Policy Mistake: If core inflation remains low between now and the September FOMC meeting and the Fed continues to write-off low inflation as transitory, signaling its intention to stick to its current projected rate hike path, then the market would price-in a policy mistake scenario. The yield curve would flatten and long-maturity nominal yields would fall, led by tighter TIPS breakevens. In terms of likelihoods, we would characterize Scenario 1 as our base case scenario, Scenario 2 as unlikely and Scenario 3 as a tail risk. The bottom line is that short-duration positions have been a "pain trade" in recent weeks, but it appears to us that the rally is overdone. We remain short-duration. No Signal From Small Caps Chart 12Small Caps Are No Longer Expensive The underperformance of small cap stocks since December is not sending a signal about the broader equity market. In fact, small cap relative performance has a mixed track record calling the peak in large cap equities. We maintain our view from a 2014 report:5 There is no basis for concluding that small cap underperformance heralds a fragile economy, stock market weakness or heightened risk aversion. Investors should note the sector/compositional, domestic/international, cyclical/defensive, and valuation discrepancies between small and large cap stocks before drawing any conclusions about the signals from small caps. The S&P 500 small cap index has more exposure to financials, industrials and materials than its large cap cousins, and has lower weights in energy, staples and healthcare. This mix makes small caps more cyclically oriented. Moreover, small caps have less exposure to overseas economies and, therefore, less sensitivity to fluctuations in the U.S. dollar. Plus, our small cap valuation indicator has moved even further into undervalued territory since our discussion of small cap equities in this publication on April 246 (Chart 12). Chart 13Small Caps Are Not Great##BR##Market Prognosticators Small-cap stocks outperformed large cap by 12% from November 8 through December 8, 2016, but have lagged since, as investors unwound the Trump trade. The implication is that the recent sell-off in small caps is not a signal that the broader market is poised for a downturn. Instead, it reflects the market's view that Trump's pro-small business agenda has stalled. Moreover, history shows that the relative performance of small caps versus large caps is not a good predictor of the future performance of risk assets versus bonds. The small-to-large ratio sent plenty of mixed signals in the '80s and '90s when the economy was in a long expansion, fostered by low inflation and a gradualist Fed (Chart 13, panels 1 and 2). On the other hand, local peaks and troughs in small cap performance provided solid signals for turns in stock versus bond performance from the early '70s through the mid-80s, a period characterized by soaring inflation that is not present today (Chart 13, panel 1). Small-cap outperformance starting in late 2008 did presage an upturn in the stock-to-bond total return ratio in 2009, and captured a few of the risk on/risk off periods from 2010 through 2012, while the Fed engineered QE2, Operation Twist and QE3. More recently, the relative performance of small versus large has been range-bound and has not provided a consistent signal for turns in the overall market (Chart 13, panel 3). Bottom Line: The underperformance of small caps to large is a reaction to the market's perception that Trump's pro-small business agenda will disappoint, not a sign that U.S. growth is waning. While several planned policies of the Trump administration have been delayed, a legislative agenda that appears to be pro-business is in place. As such, our view is that it is too early to abandon a bullish bias towards small cap stocks, especially given the major improvement in relative valuation noted above. John Canally, CFA, Senior Vice President U.S. Investment Strategy johnc@bcaresearch.com Mark McClellan, Senior Vice President The Bank Credit Analyst markm@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see U.S. Investment Strategy Weekly Report "Can The Service Sector Save The Day?", June 5, 2017, available at usis.bcaresearch.com. 2 Please see Energy Sector Strategy Weekly Report, "Views From The Road", June 21, 2017, available at nrg.bcaresearch.com. 3 Please see Global Investment Strategy Weekly Report "The Timing Of The Next Recession", June 16, 2017, available at gis.bcaresearch.com. 4 Please see U.S. Bond Strategy Weekly Report "Three Scenarios For Treasury Yields In 2017", June 20, 2017, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com. 5 Please see U.S. Investment Strategy Weekly Report "On The Road Again", June 2, 2014, available at usis.bcaresearch.com. 6 Please see U.S. Investment Strategy Weekly Report "Spring Snapback", April 24, 2017, available at usis.bcaresearch.com.
Dear client, This week, we are sending you an abbreviated Weekly Report as we co-authored a Special Report on Wednesday with our sister Geopolitical Strategy service. In our Special Report, available on our website, we argue that Italy's flirtation with leaving the euro area is rooted in its positive experience with devaluations in the 1990s. However, we note that this time is different and devaluing the euro through exit will not be a panacea, as financial market linkages would cause a deep domestic recession that could be brought forward by the mere reality of a referendum on the topic. As such, we think that Italy is unlikely to leave the Euro Area, but that it will remain a drag on the Eurozone - one that will force the European Central Bank to stay a bit more dovish than warranted by conditions in the broader Euro Area. Best regards, Mathieu Savary, Vice President Foreign Exchange Strategy Feature Chart I-1The Dollar At A Critical Spot Since the end of last week, the dollar has staged a small rebound. This rebound was of the utmost importance as it materialized at an important level. Had DXY punched below the 96 level, the dollar could have sold off toward 93 in a matter of weeks. However, if the dollar can remain above 96, the greenback is likely to have formed a trough for the remainder of 2017 as it will rest above an important congestion zone that has been in place since early 2015 (Chart I-1). What are the odds of the greenback moving back to 93? We think that right now the balance of probability is in favor of a continued rebound. A call on DXY is first and foremost a call on the euro, as EUR/USD represents 60% of this index. We'll thus focus on the dynamics in this pair. Currently, nominal short rate differentials remain in the dollar's favor. As Chart I-2 illustrates, interbank rate spreads between the Euro Area and the U.S. are broadly supportive of the USD. Additionally, in both the late 1990s and in 2005-06, this spread had been much more negative than at present. BCA still expects the spread to grow more negative as the Federal Reserve continues on its intended policy path, while we also believe it will take a few more years before the ECB can begin lifting rates.1 Real rate differentials paint a similar picture. The euro's strength in the second quarter has emerged in spite of a move in real rate spreads in favor of the USD. As Chart I-3 shows, this divergence has mostly reflected dynamics at the short end of the yield curve, but over the past month and a half the real interest rate difference at the 10-year maturity has also diverged from the EUR/USD's path. Chart I-2EUR/USD Short Rate Differentials ##br##Can Grow Deeper Chart I-3EUR/USD Has Dissociated##br## From A Key Driver Technically, the dollar is beginning to look attractive against the euro as well. Our positioning indicator - based on sentiment, net speculative positions, and the euro's advanced/decline line - shows that investors are already positioned the most euro bullish since 2012 (Chart I-4). Our intermediate-term technical indicator is also at highly overbought levels, highlighting the euro's limited upside potential. Most importantly though, these moves have happened as the Euro Area economic surprise index massively beat the U.S. one (Chart I-4, bottom panel). This means that Europe's economic outperformance has been driving the euro's strength, unlike in 2015 when the surge in the European surprise index relative to the U.S. was reflective of the euro's 2014 collapse. This paints a picture where much good European news has been priced into EUR/USD during the recent rally. At current levels, the mean-reverting nature of the relative surprise index suggests that European surprises are unlikely to continue to beat U.S. ones by such a margin going forward. This means that the already overbought euro is likely to lose a key support. Finally, as we highlighted two weeks ago, global analysts have already ratcheted up their year-end estimates for EUR/USD (Chart I-5). Not only are their forecasts at levels that have in recent years been indicative of a peak, but the speed and magnitude of their adjustments has also been exceptional. This corroborates that the positive momentum in the Eurozone vis-à-vis the U.S. has already been internalized by market participants. If anything, this favorable relative economic momentum must only grow going forward for the euro to rally further. However, European LEIs have already rolled over relative to the U.S. as the latter looks set to exit its soft patch in the coming months (Chart I-6). Chart I-4Good News Already ##br##In The Euro Chart I-5Investors Have Already##br## Bought The Euro Chart I-6The Economic Tailwinds For The ##br##Euro Are Beginning To Fade Bottom Line: DXY has rebounded at a crucial level. If it can stay above 96, this would suggest that its correction is over. We are willing to make this bet as the euro - the key component of the DXY - has dissociated from rate differentials on strong optimism toward the economic outlook for Europe - at the exact time that investors have become more incredulous of the Fed's intentions. Due to these dynamics, EUR/USD is now massively overbought and at risk of a further pullback. Cutting Loose Short USD/JPY Last week, we closed our short USD/JPY position at a 4.2% gain. We did so because we see an increasingly less-supportive environment for the yen. To begin with, the U.S. Treasury notes' fair-value model used by our U.S. Bond Strategy service highlights that U.S. bond yields are currently quite expensive, and could be set to rise anew (Chart I-7). Because JGBs possess a very low beta relative to U.S. yields, an environment where global rates rise tends to be associated with rate differentials moving in favor of USD/JPY, often prompting a rally in the latter. Also, the Bank of Japan is keenly aware that it will be very difficult to achieve its 2% inflation target. The yen's recent strength has exerted a significant tightening in Japanese financial conditions that will drag down inflation (Chart I-8). Hence, the BoJ will continue to be among the most dovish central banks in the world. Additionally, while Japanese industrial production has been strong, it looks set to soften in the coming months, which will give further reason to the BoJ to talk down the yen: Japanese industrial production is very much a function of financial conditions. We are entering a window where the recent tightening in Japanese financial conditions should begin to bite industrial production. The growth rate of the Japanese shipments-to-inventories ratio has rolled over, historically a precursor of a slowdown in industrial production (Chart I-9). Chart I-7T-Notes Are Expensive Chart I-8Japanese FCI Points To Lower Inflation Chart I-9Japanese IP Will Turn Finally, the annual growth rate of Japan's industrial production is heavily influenced by China's economic dynamics, as EM represents 43% of Japanese exports. Two months ago, the Keqiang index - a barometer of strength for the Chinese economy based on credit growth, railway freight volumes, and electricity production - hit its highest level since June 2010, levels only recorded in early 2007, early 2005, and early 2004. Even though we do not anticipate it to crater, we do expect its recent rollover to deepen further in response to the recent wave of policy tightening in China. This should result in some weakness for Japan's industrial production. In practice there is little additional actions the BoJ can implement to ease policy further. However, because investors are currently so negative on the prospects for further Fed rate increases, with only 40 basis points priced in over the next 24 months, a re-assurance by the BoJ that easy policy is here to stay could put upward pressure on USD/JPY. While we remain worried about EM assets, we think that shorting the AUD or the NZD against the yen represents better portfolio protection than shorting USD/JPY. Bottom Line: USD/JPY has a generous amount of upside from here. Investors are too pessimistic regarding the Fed's ability to increase rates over the next 24 months. Meanwhile, the recent tightening in Japanese financial conditions is a headache for the BoJ, as it points to weaker inflation and a slowdown in industrial production. Hence, we expect the BoJ will try to talk down the yen over the coming months. EUR/NOK At An Interesting Spot Chart I-10If Brent Doesn't Fall Below,##br## EUR/NOK Is A Short The price action in EUR/NOK caught our eye this week. EUR/NOK is at a critical level and has rallied as investor optimism toward the Euro Area economy continues to grow. Meanwhile, oil prices have collapsed to US$45/bbl. Since Norway is an economy heavily geared to oil-price gyrations, this bifurcation created an ideal combination to generate a EUR/NOK rally. However, by discounting these developments, EUR/NOK has now entered massively overbought territory. Additionally, as Chart I-10 illustrates, the cross has only traded at higher levels at the depth of the financial crisis in the first quarter of 2009 and the early days of 2016. In both instances, Brent was trading below US$40/bbl. A selling opportunity could soon emerge. Our Commodity And Energy Strategy service continues to expect a deepening of the adjustment in global oil inventories as the OPEC 2.0 deal remains in vigor and compliance stays in place.2 This means a move below US$40/bbl for Brent is very unlikely, and the upside in EUR/NOK is extremely limited. While in the coming weeks a move in Brent to between US$44/bbl and US$42/bbl could happen, we think this limited downside points to an attractive risk-reward ratio to shorting this cross. We are currently long CAD/NOK and short EUR/CAD, with the latter having greater potential downside than EUR/NOK. However, due to Canada's deep integration with the U.S. economy, the EUR/CAD trade is often affected by dynamics in the U.S. dollar. Shorting EUR/NOK is thus a cleaner play on oil and removes much of the risk associated with the greenback's fluctuations. Finally, yesterday, the Norges Bank policy release displayed less dovish tone than anticipated by the market. This kind of surprise would create an additional support to being short EUR/NOK. Bottom Line: EUR/NOK looks set to weaken. Over the past 10 years, it has only traded above current levels when Brent prices were below US$40/bbl. Based on our commodity team's analysis, such a move is very unlikely. Thus, any short-term weakness in oil prices should be used to sell EUR/NOK. Mathieu Savary, Vice President Foreign Exchange Strategy mathieu@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see Foreign Exchange Strategy Weekly Report titled, "Central Banks Are Sticking To Their Guns", dated June 6, 2017, available at fes.bcaresearch.com 2 Please see Commodity & Energy Strategy Weekly Report titled "Time For "Whatever It Takes" In Oil?", dated June 2, 2017, available at ces.bcaresearch.com Trades & Forecasts Forecast Summary Core Portfolio Tactical Trades Closed Trades
Highlights The divergence between global bond yields and equity prices is not as puzzling as it may first appear. Thus far, lower inflation has dampened the need for central banks to tighten monetary policy. This has caused bond yields to fall, lifting stocks in the process. Looking out, the combination of faster growth and dwindling spare capacity will cause inflation to rise. This is particularly the case for the U.S., where the economy has already reached full employment. The "blow-off" phase for the U.S. economy is likely to last until mid-2018. The dollar and Treasury yields will move higher over this period. The euro and the yen will suffer the most against a resurgent greenback, the pound less so. China's economy will remain resilient, helping to boost commodity prices. This will support the Canadian and Aussie dollars. Stronger global growth will provide a tailwind to emerging markets. However, at this point, most of the good news is already reflected in EM asset valuations. Feature Stocks And Bonds: A Curious Divergence Chart 1Global Growth: Increasing Optimism One could be forgiven for thinking that equity and bond investors are living on different planets. Global bond yields have been trending lower thus far this year, while stocks have been setting new highs. Are bonds signaling an imminent slowdown which equity investors are willfully ignoring? Not necessarily. Almost all of the decline in bond yields has been due to falling inflation expectations. Real yields have remained reasonably steady, suggesting that growth worries are not foremost on investors' minds. The fact that consensus global growth estimates for 2017 and 2018 have continued to grind higher is consistent with this observation (Chart 1). A quiescent inflation picture has given investors more confidence that the Fed will not need to raise rates aggressively. This has pushed down bond yields, weakened the dollar, and fueled the rally in stock prices. The decline in headline inflation, in turn, has been largely driven by lower commodity prices. In the U.S., several one-off factors - including Verizon's decision to move to unlimited data plans, a temporary lull in health care inflation, and a drop in airline fares - have helped keep core inflation in check. The U.S. Economy: It Gets Better Before It Gets Worse Looking out, global growth is likely to remain firm. This should ultimately translate into higher inflation, particularly in the U.S., where the economy has already achieved full employment. Granted, as we discussed last week,1 the U.S. business cycle expansion is getting long in the tooth. However, history suggests that the transition between boom and bust is often accompanied by a revelry of sorts where things get better before they get worse. Call it a "blow-off" phase for the business cycle. The example of the late 1990s - the last time the U.S. unemployment rate fell below NAIRU for an extended period of time - comes to mind. Chart 2 shows that final domestic demand accelerated to 8.3% in nominal terms in Q1 of 2000. Personal consumption growth surged, reaching 8.4% in nominal terms and 5.7% in real terms. Obviously, there are many differences between now and then. However, there is at least one critical similarity: The unemployment rate stood at 4.3% in January 1999. This is exactly where it stands today. And if it keeps falling at its current pace, the unemployment rate will dip below its 2000 low of 3.8% by next summer. As was the case in the past, an overheated labor market will lead to faster wage growth. In the U.S., underlying wage growth has accelerated from 1.2% in 2010 to 2.4% at present (Chart 3). Chart 2The Late 1990s: An End-Of-Cycle Blow-Off Chart 3Stronger Labor Market Is Leading To Faster Wage Growth Granted, this is still well below the levels seen in 2000 and 2007. However, productivity growth has crumbled over the past decade while long-term inflation expectations have dipped. Real unit labor costs - a measure of compensation which adjusts for shifts in productivity growth and inflation - are rising at a faster rate than in 2007 and close to the pace recorded in 2000 (Chart 4). In fact, real wage growth in the U.S. has eclipsed business productivity growth for three straight years (Chart 5). As a result, labor's share of national income is now increasing. Chart 4Real Unit Labor Cost Growth: Back To Its 2000 Peak Chart 5Real Wages Now Increasing Faster Than Productivity What happens to aggregate demand when the share of income going to workers rises? The answer is that at least initially, demand goes up. Companies typically spend less of every marginal dollar of income than workers. This is especially the case in today's environment where the distribution of corporate profits has become increasingly tilted towards a few winner-take-all firms which, for the most part, are already flush with cash (Chart 6). Thus, a shift of income towards workers tends to boost overall spending. In addition, an overheated labor market typically generates the biggest gains for workers at the bottom of the income distribution. Wages for U.S. workers without a college degree have been rising more quickly than those with a university education for the past few years (Chart 7). Such workers often live paycheck-to-paycheck and, hence, have a high marginal propensity to consume. Chart 6A Winner-Take-All Economy Chart 7Tighter Labor Market Boosting Wages Of Less Educated Workers Let's Get This Party Started The discussion above suggests that U.S. aggregate demand could accelerate over the next few quarters. There is some evidence that this is already happening (Chart 8). Despite a moderation in auto purchases, real PCE growth is still tracking at 3.2% in the second quarter according to the Atlanta Fed's GDPNow model. And with the personal saving rate still stuck at an elevated 5.3%, there is scope for consumer spending to grow at a faster rate than disposable income. Chart 9 shows that the current saving rate is well above the level one would expect based on the ratio of household net worth-to-disposable income. Chart 8Solid Near-Term Outlook For U.S. Consumers Financial conditions have eased over the past six months thanks to lower Treasury yields, narrower credit spreads, a weaker dollar, and higher equity prices (Chart 10). Historically, an easing in financial conditions has foreshadowed faster growth (Chart 11). This could make the coming blow-off phase even more explosive than in past business cycles. Some commentators have noted that while financial conditions have eased, bank lending has slowed significantly. If true, this would imply that easier financial conditions are not boosting credit growth in the way one might expect. The problem with this argument is that it takes a far too limited view of the U.S. financial system. Although bank lending to companies has indeed slowed, bond issuance has soared. In fact, total nonfinancial corporate debt rose by $212 billion in the first quarter according to the Fed's Financial Accounts database, the largest increase in history (Chart 12). Chart 10Financial Conditions Have Been Easing... Chart 11...Which Will Support Growth Chart 12Nonfinancial Corporate Debt Surged In Q1 All Good Things Must Come To An End Unfortunately, the burst of demand that often occurs in the late stages of business cycle expansions contains the seeds of its own demise. Initially, when consumer spending accelerates, firms tend to react by expanding capacity. This translates into higher investment spending. However, as labor's share of income keeps rising, an increasing number of firms start incurring outright losses. This causes them to dismiss workers and cut back on investment spending. Such a souring in corporate animal spirits is not an immediate risk for the U.S. economy. Hiring intentions remain solid and businesses are still signaling that they expect to increase capital spending over the coming months (Chart 13). Profit margins are also quite high by historic standards, which gives firms greater room for maneuver. This will change over time, however. Margins are already falling in the national accounts data (Chart 14). History suggests that S&P 500 margins will follow suit. This raises the risk that capex and hiring will start to slow late next year, potentially sowing the seeds for a recession in 2019. We remain overweight global equities on a cyclical 12-month horizon, but will be looking to significantly pare back exposure next summer. Chart 13Corporate America Feeling Great Again Chart 14Economy-Wide Margins Have Slipped The Dollar Bull Market Is Not Over Yet Chart 15Historically, A Rising Labor Share Has Pushed Up The Dollar Until U.S. growth does decelerate, the path of least resistance for bond yields and the dollar will be to the upside. Chart 15 shows the strikingly close correlation between labor's share of income and the value of the trade-weighted dollar. As noted above, the initial effect of accelerating wage growth is to put more money into workers' pockets. This results in higher aggregate demand and, against a backdrop of low spare capacity, rising inflation. Historically, such an outcome has prompted the Fed to expedite the pace of rate hikes, leading to a stronger dollar. This time is unlikely to be any different. The market is currently pricing in only 21 basis points in Fed rate hikes over the next 12 months. This seems far too low to us. Other things equal, a stronger dollar implies a weaker euro and yen. Improved export competitiveness will lead to better growth prospects and higher inflation expectations in the euro area and Japan. Unless the ECB and the BoJ respond by tightening monetary policy, short-term real rates will fall. This, in turn, could put further downward pressure on the euro and the yen. The ECB And The BoJ Will Not Follow The Fed's Lead Many commentators have argued that better growth prospects will cause the ECB and the BoJ to follow in the Fed's footsteps and take away the punch bowl. We doubt it. Labor market slack is still considerably higher in the euro area than was the case in 2008. Outside of Germany, the level of unemployment and underemployment in the euro area is about seven points higher than it was before the Great Recession (Chart 16). If anything, the market has priced in too much tightening from the ECB. Our months-to-hike measure has plummeted from a high of 65 months in July 2016 to 28 months at present (Chart 17). Investors now expect real rates in the U.S. to be only 23 basis points higher than in the euro area in five years' time. This is well below the 76 basis-point gap in the equilibrium rate between the two regions that Holston, Laubach, and Williams estimate (Chart 18). Chart 16Euro Area: Labor Market Slack Is Still High Outside Of Germany Chart 17ECB: Markets Are Pricing In Too Much Tightening Chart 18The Neutral Rate Is Lowest In The Euro Area As for Japan, while it is true that the unemployment rate has fallen to 2.8% - a 22-year low - this understates the true amount of slack in the economy. Output-per-hour in Japan remains 35% below U.S. levels. A key reason for this is that many Japanese companies continue to pad their payrolls with excess labor. This is particularly true in the service sector, which remains largely insulated from foreign competition. In any case, with both actual inflation and inflation expectations in Japan nowhere close to the BoJ's target, this is hardly the time to be worried about an overheated economy. And even if the Japanese authorities were inclined to slow growth, it would be fiscal policy rather than monetary policy that they would tighten first. After all, they have been keen to raise the sales tax for several years now. The Pound Will Rebound Against The Euro, But Weaken Further Against The Dollar Chart 19Pound: Unloved And Underappreciated While we continue to maintain a strong conviction view that the euro and yen will weaken against the dollar, we are more circumspect about other currencies. Bank of England Governor Mark Carney played down speculation this week that the BoE would raise rates later this year, noting in his annual speech at London's Mansion House that "now is not yet the time to begin that adjustment." U.K. growth has been the weakest in the G7 so far in 2017, partly because of growing angst over the forthcoming Brexit negotiations. Nevertheless, U.K. inflation remains elevated and fiscal policy is likely to be eased in the November budget, as Chancellor Hammond confirmed in a BBC interview on Sunday. Sterling is already quite cheap based on our metrics (Chart 19). Our best bet is that the pound will weaken against the dollar over the next 12 months but strengthen against the euro and the yen. We are currently long GBP/JPY. The trade has gained 7.2% since we initiated it in August 2016. CAD Has Upside We went long CAD/EUR in May. Despite the downdraft in oil prices, the trade has managed to gain 2.6% thus far. We are optimistic on the Canadian dollar over the coming months. Our energy strategists remain convinced that crude prices are heading higher. They expect global production to increase by only 0.7 MMB/d in 2017, compared to 1.5 MMB/d growth in consumption. Consequently, oil inventories should fall over the remainder of this year. If history is any guide, this will lead to a rebound in oil prices (Chart 20). The Bank of Canada has also turned more hawkish. Senior Deputy Governor Carolyn Wilkins suggested last week that interest rates are likely to rise later this year. The market is now pricing in a 84% chance of a rate hike in 2017, up from only 18% earlier this month. The Canadian economy continues to perform well (Chart 21). Retail sales are growing briskly, the unemployment rate is close to its lowest level in 40 years, and goods exports are recovering thanks to a weak loonie and stronger growth south of the border. While the bubbly housing market remains a source of concern, this is as much a reason to raise interest rates - to prevent further overheating - as to cut them. Chart 20Falling Oil Inventories Should Lead To Higher Crude Prices Chart 21Canadian Economy: Chugging Along China Will Drive The Aussie Dollar And EM Assets After a very strong start to the year, Chinese growth has slipped a notch. Housing starts slowed in May, as did gains in property prices. M2 growth decelerated to 9.6% from a year earlier, the first time broad money growth has fallen into the single-digit range since the government began publishing such statistics in 1986. Still, the economy is far from falling off a cliff, as evidenced by the fact that the IMF upgraded its full-year 2017 GDP growth forecast from 6.6% to 6.7% last week. Real-time measures of industrial activity such as railway freight traffic, excavator sales, and electricity production remain upbeat. Export growth is accelerating thanks to a weaker currency and stronger global growth. The PBoC's trade-weighted RMB basket has fallen by over 8% since it was introduced in December 2015. Retail sales continue to expand at a healthy clip. The percentage of households that intend to buy a new home has also surged to record-high levels. This should limit the fallout from the government's efforts to cool the housing market. The rebound in exports and industrial output is helping to lift producer prices. Higher selling prices, in turn, are fueling a rebound in industrial company profits (Chart 22). A better profit picture should support business capital spending in the coming months. The government also remains cognizant of the risks of tightening policy too aggressively, especially with the National Party Congress slated for this autumn. The PBoC injected 250 billion yuan into the financial system last Friday. This was the single biggest one-day intervention since January, when demand for cash was running high in the lead up to the Chinese New Year celebrations. Fiscal policy has also been eased (Chart 23). So far, the "regulatory windstorm" of measures designed to clamp down on financial speculation has largely bypassed the real economy. Medium and long-term lending to nonfinancial corporations - a key driver of private-sector capital spending - has actually accelerated over the past eight months (Chart 24). Chart 22China: Higher Selling Prices Fuelling A Rebound In Profits Chart 23Fiscal Spending Is On The Mend Chart 24China: Credit To The Real Economy Is Accelerating The key takeaway for investors is that Chinese growth is likely to slow over the next few quarters, but not by much. Considering that fund managers surveyed by BofA Merrill Lynch in June cited fears of a hard landing in China as the biggest tail risk facing financial markets for the second month in a row, the bar for positive surprises out of China is comfortably low. If China can clear this bar, as we expect it will, it will be good news for the Aussie dollar and other commodity plays. Strong Chinese growth should provide a tailwind for EM assets. However, EM stocks and currencies have already had a major run, which limits further upside. The fact that serial-defaulter Argentina could issue a 100-year bond this week in an offering that was three times oversubscribed is a testament to that. The fundamental problems plaguing many emerging markets - high debt levels, poor governance, and lackluster productivity growth - remain largely unaddressed. Until they are, the long-term outlook for EM assets will continue to be challenging. Peter Berezin, Chief Global Strategist Global Investment Strategy peterb@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see Global Investment Strategy Weekly Report, "The Timing Of The Next Recession," dated June 16, 2017, available at gis.bcaresearch.com. Strategy & Market Trends Tactical Trades Strategic Recommendations Closed Trades
