China
Highlights Supply constraints and unstoppable demand growth – the result of stricter regulations requiring higher loadings in autocatalysts to treat toxic pollution in automobile-engine emissions – will continue to push palladium’s price higher, despite a near-vertical move higher that began in 2H19. South Africa’s power grid is in a state of near-collapse, which will add volatility to mining operations focused on platinum-group metals – chiefly palladium, platinum and rhodium. South Africa accounts for 36% of global palladium production and 73% of platinum production, which makes it difficult to make the case that platinum could be substituted for palladium as its price rises. Palladium stocks are at risk of being further depleted globally as demand from automobile manufacturers in China, the US and Europe remains robust. This will keep palladium forward curves backwardated for the foreseeable future. While pressure to find alternatives for palladium will grow as prices rise, in absolute terms the additional cost resulting from higher prices for the metal – ~ $400 per vehicle – is not yet enough to draw significant investment to this effort. Feature Palladium markets are fundamentally tight and unresponsive to macroeconomic uncertainty. Table 1Top 5 Best Performing Commodities In 2019, for the third year in a row, palladium prices outperformed other major commodities, returning an impressive 54% over the year (Table 1). This is the result of a massive 13% increase in demand for the metal – powered by strong autocatalyst demand for gasoline-powered cars in China and Europe, even as collapsing auto production globally and elevated trade uncertainty continue to dog automobile sales (Chart 1). This apparent contradiction is explained by stricter vehicle emissions regulations in major consuming markets – chiefly the Euro 6d, China 6 and US Tier 3 regimes – and power shortages in South Africa, which are introducing considerable volatility on the supply side in the second-largest producing country for the metal. Chart of the WeekSurging Autocatalyst Palladium Demand Again this year, palladium markets are fundamentally tight and unresponsive to macroeconomic uncertainty. Palladium prices soared 39% YTD, its fastest 40-day increase since 2010. Unlike other commodity markets, palladium is completely disregarding the COVID-19 outbreak that originated in China late last year. Favorable supply-side fundamentals continue to drive the palladium rally: The metal’s decade-long physical supply deficit intensified in 2019 and we expect it to widen this year (Chart 2, panel 1). On the demand side, Chinese consumption is at risk. China is the world’s largest auto manufacturing market. Hubei Province – COVID-19’s epicenter – is a large car manufacturing hub, accounting for ~ 10% of the country’s annual automobile output. In the wake of COVID-19, the country’s car production is expected to fall 10% in 1Q20. In addition, the virus had infected more than 80,000 people globally, and has spread rapidly outside Hubei into Asia, Europe, the Middle East, Africa, and North America, raising the odds of a pandemic. Interestingly, speculative positioning and ETF investment demand is subdued, and is not inflating prices (Chart 2, panel 2). Chart 2Palladium Deficit To Widen This Year Palladium Demand Soars As Auto Production Collapses Strong global automobile catalyst demand drove the rally in palladium prices last year. This occurred as car production fell by 9%, 8%, and 15% in US, China, and India – an unusual divergence in fundamentals. The culprit: Technical changes to autocatalysts from stricter emissions regulations. In China, the latest phase of car emissions regulations – China 6 – was gradually introduced in high-population centers, which also suffer from high levels of pollution. These centers accounted for ~ 60% of annual Chinese car sales in 2019. China 6 represents a major shift in emissions regulations and will make the Chinese auto fleet compliant with Europe’s best practices. As a result, palladium loadings in conforming light-duty gasoline vehicles reportedly increased by ~20% in 2019. This pushed China’s autocatalyst consumption up by 570k oz despite the drop in annual car sales, which created the rare dislocation between the country’s car production and palladium prices (Chart 3). We expect this trend to continue this year: China 6 is on track to be enforced countrywide – i.e., the remaining 40% of car sales – by mid-year, providing an additional ~ 10% boost in loadings of the metal. Chart 3Stricter Regulations Support Prices Amid Falling Car Production In Europe, the introduction of Euro 6c legislation in September 2018 and the extension to all new vehicles of Euro 6d-TEMP regulations in September 2019 – mainly the real driving emissions (RDE) testing procedure adopted in the wake of the Volkswagen “dieselgate” scandal in 2015 – pushed palladium loading in autocatalysts up by ~ 25% from 2017 to 2019.1 The regulations became stricter in January 2020, putting additional stress on manufacturers to comply with the new standards, which will continue to support higher palladium loadings. We expect the COVID-19 outbreak to delay the recovery in global gasoline-powered vehicle production and consumption to 2H20. Lastly, in the US – which remains an important market for autocatalyst palladium demand (Chart 4) – the ongoing implementation of the Tier 3 legislation will continue to gradually increase palladium content in autocatalysts until 2025. For 2020, we do not expect this to significantly boost loadings per vehicle and are factoring in 2% growth. These legislative changes in major automotive markets produced a structural break in our palladium demand model (Chart 5). After adjusting our estimates for greater palladium content in gasoline aftertreatment systems, our model suggests that demand provides strong support to palladium prices, but also suggests other factors – i.e. supply and inventory – are at play. Chart 4North America's Auto Sector Remains A Large Share Of Palladium Demand Chart 5Higher Palladium Loadings Largely Explains Last Year's Price Surge In the US and Europe, consumers can absorb higher vehicle sales despite being close to saturated in terms of vehicle ownership. We expect the COVID-19 outbreak to delay the recovery in global gasoline-powered vehicle production and consumption to 2H20. In China, we expect the government will overstimulate its economy to meet its long-term goal of doubling its GDP and per capita income by 2020.2 Automobile ownership and vehicle sales there are low vs. DM economies, suggesting more upside for sales in China (Chart 6). In the US and Europe, consumers can absorb higher vehicle sales despite being close to saturated in terms of vehicle ownership. Car sales move in cycles around long-term demographic trends: The longer the current economic expansion, the further above-trend car sales can rise (Chart 7). Chart 6China: Structural Outlook For Autos Is Bright China Car Consumption Will Rebound In 2H20... Chart 7... Likewise For Europe And US Bottom Line: The combination of stricter environmental regulations in key gasoline-powered automobile markets and the post-coronavirus rebound in global auto consumption will push the palladium market further in deficit this year as it faces an inelastic supply, critically low inventories and low substitutability over the short-term (more on this below). Palladium Supply In 2020: Weak growth And Low Price-Elasticity Palladium supply is highly constrained. The largest supplies are concentrated in Russia (42%), South Africa (36%) and North America (14%). From 2015 to 2019, supply and capex grew by a very subdued 7% and 15.2% respectively, completely disregarding the 200% rise in prices (Chart 8, panel 1). This illustrates palladium supply’s extremely low price-elasticity.3 Palladium supply growth will remain muted for the foreseeable future, as Eskom begins long-delayed maintenance to refurbish its derelict generation fleet. Primary supplies declined by close to 2% last year on falling shipments from Russia and record electricity load-shedding – i.e. blackouts – in South Africa (Chart 8, panel 2).4 As tight as palladium markets are fundamentally, South Africa’s crippled power grid – long in need of upgrading and repair – has been, and remains, a key driver of short-term platinum-group metals (PGM) prices.5 Following the breakdown of close to 25% of the country’s generating capacity, Eskom – the nation’s utility monopoly responsible for ~ 90% of its electricity generation – has been forced to implement rolling blackouts to balance power supply and demand and prevent permanent damage to the country’s power grid. Palladium supply growth will remain muted for the foreseeable future, as Eskom begins long-delayed maintenance to refurbish its derelict generation fleet. Consequently, Stage 6 load-shedding events likely will become more frequent. These efforts are complicated by massive debt – ~ $30 billion – which has required government bailouts and forced the company to take loans from a Chinese industrial bank. Chart 8Top Palladium Producers' Capex Price-Elasticity Is Low This is playing havoc with PGM supplies. During the unmatched Stage 6 load-shedding in December 2019 – cutting power to 37% of grid users – PGM supplies were reduced by 50%. Stockpiles covered the loss, but persistent blackouts lasting years could push markets into an actual shortage of palladium as inventories would rapidly be depleted. This is a significant risk: Eskom itself warned rolling blackouts will persist for the next 18 months.6 Elevated local currency PGM prices are postponing announced shafts closures, as miners seek to profit from the favorable pricing environment (Chart 9). But insufficient electricity capacity will weigh on mine supply growth over the next few years as companies hold-back on much-needed long-term investments. The final units of Eskom’s Medupi and Kusile projects are expected to be completed over the next two years – adding 4800MW to its installed capacity. This can partially alleviate South Africa’s electricity difficulties, but these units are not enough to support a rebound in economic and mine production growth. South Africa is in profound need of large-scale investments in its power sector. Close to 5000MW of power capacity is scheduled to shut down over the next five years (Chart 10). Chart 9Favorable Domestic Metal Prices For South African Miners Chart 10South Africa Needs Additional Power Generation Capacity After years of pressure from mining companies, South Africa’s minister of Mineral Resources and Energy announced it would allow companies to generate unlimited electricity for their own activities. The current political and economic climate is not constructive for meeting this challenge. The World Bank recently slashed South Africa’s 2020 GDP growth forecast to 0.9% from 1.5% previously on the back of electricity and infrastructure constraints impeding domestic growth and weak external demand. Likewise, rating agency Moody's signaled – ahead of its review of South Africa’s Baa3 credit rating in March – it could downgrade the country to speculative grade, citing the detrimental impact of recurring power outages on manufacturing and mining output. After years of pressure from mining companies, South Africa’s minister of Mineral Resources and Energy announced it would allow companies to generate unlimited electricity for their own activities. This will provide much-needed help to the country’s power sector. According to the Minerals Council South Africa, mining companies could bring an additional ~ 1500MW capacity online in the next 9 to 36 months. But doubts remain with regard to the timeline for companies to obtain the necessary licenses and if these can easily be acquired. Johnson Matthey expects supply growth in Russia – the largest producer – will be capped this year as Nornickel’s processing of old mines' copper concentrate – which boosted the company’s palladium supply over the past few years – is finalized. Still, a paltry 1% gain is possible from expected efficiency gains at existing mines, according to Nornickel. The company also announced it will increase production at its Talnakh and South Cluster mines, but this additional supply will only reach markets gradually as processing capacity constraints won’t be resolved until 2023, according to Johnson Matthey. Bottom Line: Growth prospects in the top two palladium-producing countries are weak in 2020. This will not suffice to meet the soaring autocatalyst demand. Higher recycling and inventory releases – both incentivized by higher prices – will be needed to balance the market. Palladium Stockpiles Are Dangerously Low We expect palladium prices will move higher on the expanding deficit, and backwardation in the forward curve will persist to incentivize the release of inventories to market (Chart 11). Yet, global palladium stockpiles have been declining since 2014 and are now at critically low levels, raising the risk of a disrupting shortage of the metal:7 ETF and exchange inventories now stand at a paltry 600k oz (Chart 12). These are the most price-elastic stocks and will get close to zero as prices increase. Chart 10Expect Backwardation To Persist Chart 12Price-Sensitive Stockpiles Are Dangerously Low Exhaustion of inventory would spike prices until demand destruction or additional supply – both inelastic in the short-run – are able to balance the market. The Russian Ministry of Finance’s reserves – a state secret – are now almost exhausted, according to Russia’s Norilsk Nickel, the largest supplier of physical palladium in the world. Last year, Norilsk Nickel held an estimated 1mm oz of the metal in its Global Palladium Fund, and signaled it is increasingly using its reserves to balance markets and provide needed liquidity. Earlier this year, the company released 3 MT of palladium to the market from stocks. Complete exhaustion of inventory would spike prices until demand destruction or additional supply – both inelastic in the short-run – are able to balance the market. Don’t Count On Substitution, Yet Switching to platinum requires significant capital- and resource-intensive R&D and appears to be beyond the current capabilities of automakers. We expect platinum prices to rise in 2020 supported by improving fundamentals, growing safe-haven demand, and markets pricing in increasing anticipation of substitution from palladium to platinum. Unlike palladium, platinum is also affected by safe-haven demand and gets bid up with gold and silver prices in periods of high uncertainty (Chart 13). With gold prices now above $1,600/oz, platinum will benefit from safe-haven flows due to its relative price advantage (Chart 14). Chart 13Safe-Haven Flows Support Platinum Prices Chart 14Platinum Is Cheap Relative To Gold We believe substitution will commence over the coming years, but this is a gradual process. Substitution from expensive palladium to low-priced platinum in industrial applications is the largest risk to our positive view on the palladium-to-platinum (Pd-to-Pt) ratio (Chart 15). This started in smaller and more price-elastic segments (e.g. dental, jewelry and diesel autocatalyst). However, to have a real impact on overall demand and thus the price ratio, substitution needs to take place in gasoline autocatalyst technology. The discount has been at a level consistent with substitution for more than a year, but the urgency to upgrade current designs to meet new environmental legislation and RDE regulations in China, Europe, and the US is the main focus of automakers this year. Switching to platinum requires significant capital- and resource-intensive R&D and appears to be beyond the current capabilities of automakers scrambling to meet the latest anti-pollution regulations globally. Moreover, large-scale substitution will take place only if automakers’ cost-benefit analysis points to significant long-term profits from switching. That said, platinum’s supply security remains a risk in the long-term: South Africa accounts for 73% of global production and our analysis suggests output growth there likely will remain weak over the next few years, especially as Eskom rebuilds its failing power grid. This lack of diversity increases sourcing risks for automakers, who, not without reason, would not want to switch over to platinum only to find that supply is also in doubt down the road. The overall platinum market is 26% smaller than that of palladium. Assuming a one-for-one substitution of Pd to Pt in gasoline catalyzers, a 1.2mm oz reduction in Pd demand – the amount required to reduce palladium’s deficit to zero – would send platinum markets to a 1.4mm oz deficit.8 Without substantial production growth, platinum prices would spike, reducing the profitability of investing in these new catalysts. Thus, substitution will eventually impact the price ratio, but will not be large enough to overturn absolute price level trends. In addition, the amount of PGMs in the typical autocatalyst – ~ 5 grams – adds $400 to the cost of the average automobile (Chart 15, lower panel). We do not believe this cost drives automakers' decisions, which is another reason the substitution of Pt for Pd likely will remain a topic of discussion more than action. Chart 15Palladium's Price Surge Adds ~0 Per Gasoline Car Bottom Line: We believe substitution will commence over the coming years, but this is a gradual process and it will not happen on a meaningful scale this year. Thus, we expect the continuation of relative demand and inventory trends will provide a favorable setting for the Pd-to-Pt ratio this year (Chart 16). Chart 16Pd-to-Pt Price Ratio Will Increase Again in 2020 Hugo Bélanger Associate Editor Commodity & Energy Strategy HugoB@bcaresearch.com Robert P. Ryan Chief Commodity & Energy Strategist rryan@bcaresearch.com Commodities Round-Up Energy: Overweight Brent and WTI crude oil lost 5% and 4% this week, as fears of a global pandemic in the wake of the COVID-19 outbreak gripped markets. Reports of outbreaks in Asia ex-China, the Middle East and Europe fueled these concerns. Against this backdrop, OPEC 2.0 will be meeting in Vienna March 5 and 6 to consider cuts of 600k b/d recommended by its technical committee earlier this month. We continue to expect the full coalition to approve these cuts at the upcoming meetings. Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates reportedly are considering an additional 300k b/d of cuts to offset the global demand hit delivered by COVID-19. The IEA estimates the COVID-19 outbreak will reduce Chinese refining throughput by 1.1mm b/d, and will reduce the call on OPEC crude by 1.7mm b/d in 1Q20. Base Metals: Neutral Iron ore prices weakened, following global equities lower, as the COVID-19 outbreak spread around the world. However, traders continue to report lower stocks of iron ore, which should keep prices supported, according to MB Fastmarkets (Chart 17). We remain long December 2020 high-grade iron ore (65% Fe) vs. short the benchmark 62% Fe contract on the Singapore Commodity Exchange, which we initiated November 7, 2019. This recommendation was up 5.3% as of Tuesday’s close, when we mark to market. Precious Metals: Neutral After retreating slightly from its run toward $1,700/oz earlier this week, gold remains well supported by safe-haven demand (Chart 18). In addition, actual and expected policy stimulus – e.g., Hong Kong's “helicopter money” drop of USD 1,200 to all permanent residents over the age of 18 – and expectations of additional central bank easing globally to offset the global spread of COVID0-19 will keep gold and precious metals generally supported. Markets should start pricing in higher inflation expectations as additional stimulus starts to roll in. Ags/Softs: Underweight Global grain markets could be set to rally sharply, as unusually wet weather in the Middle East and East Africa spawned by higher-than-usual cyclone activity produces perfect breeding conditions for desert locusts in the region over the next two months. According to National Geographic, by June the locusts could increase their populations “400-fold compared with today, triggering widespread devastation to crops and pastures in a region that’s already extremely vulnerable to famine.” This could put more than 13mm people in East Africa at risk of “severe acute food insecurity,” and imperil millions more. Chart 17China's Iron Ore Stocks Tight Chart 18Safe Havens Gold, USD Well Bid Footnotes 1 Please see New legislation planned in response to dieselgate, published by Autocar June 9, 2016. See also Johnson Matthey’s February 2020 Pgm Market Report. 2 Our view of strong Chinese fiscal and monetary stimulus was discussed in detail in our February 13, 2020 weekly report titled Iron Ore, Steel Poised For Rally. 3 Historically produced as an inferior byproduct from nickel, gold, and platinum mines, the price incentive from palladium alone isn’t enough to generate the needed investments in new mine production. According to Nornickel, this is slowly changing, palladium is an increasingly large part of mining companies’ revenues, making the metal a valuable co-product. This could improve mines investments’ responsiveness to movement in palladium prices over the medium term. 4 According to Eskom, “Load shedding is aimed at removing load from the power system when there is an imbalance between the electricity available and the demand for electricity. If we did not shed load, then the whole national power system would switch off and no one would have electricity.” The company’s load-shedding program includes 8 stages, where each stage represents the removal of 1000MW of demand – e.g., stage 5 removes 5000MW. This is done by shutting down specific sections of the grid. 5 The PGMs are ruthenium, rhodium, palladium, osmium, iridium, and platinum. 6 Things got worse after the December load-shedding event. Less than a month later, Reuters noted more than two times the power shed in December went “offline because of plant breakdowns. 7 This can be seen in the close to 12mm oz. decline in UK and Switzerland – home of the largest secured vaults of Palladium and Platinum – net imports. 8 Technological improvement in palladium catalysts has made the metal more efficient in for gasoline-powered engines vs. platinum. It has superior properties in terms of thermal durability and NOx reduction. Thus, the conversion could be greater than 1-to-1 and would imply a smaller share of palladium autocatalyst substitution could be absorbed by existing platinum supplies. Investment Views and Themes Recommendations Strategic Recommendations Tactical Trades TRADE RECOMMENDATION PERFORMANCE IN 2019 Q4 Commodity Prices and Plays Reference Table Trades Closed in 2020 Summary of Closed Trades
Dear Client, I participated in a webinar earlier this week with my fellow BCA Research strategists to discuss the coronavirus outbreak and other timely issues. A replay can be accessed from this link. In lieu of our regular report next week, we will be sending you a Special Report from Matt Gertken, BCA’s Research Chief Geopolitical Strategist. Matt will discuss the state of the Democratic Party’s presidential nomination process in the wake of “Super Tuesday” and address the market implications. Best regards, Peter Berezin, Chief Global Strategist Highlights The decline in the number of new infections in China suggests that the coronavirus can be contained, provided that governments are both able and willing to impose severe quarantine measures on their own citizens. It is far from clear whether all countries can introduce such measures. And even among those who can, the economic damage from prolonged work stoppages could end up being too much to bear. The spike in supplier delivery times in various purchasing manager indices suggests that the global supply chain is already showing signs of strain. If the outbreak morphs into a global pandemic, a recession on the scale of the 2008/09 downturn would likely ensue. The only economic consolation from such an outcome is that once everyone is in the same boat, the need for mass quarantines and business shutdowns will diminish. While stock valuations have improved markedly over the past week, we would still recommend that investors refrain from significantly adding to equity positions at the moment. Once COVID-19 cases start popping up all over the US, stocks could come under further pressure. That said, we would only become more constructive on the near-term outlook for global equities if prices were to fall another 5%-to-8% from current levels or if the risks of a pandemic recede. The Power Of Exponential Change Humans tend to think in linear rather than exponential terms. Thus, it is easy to forget that when dealing with exponential growth, what appears exceedingly slow at first can become exceedingly fast later on. Take the example of the COVID-19 outbreak. Suppose that R0 is 2, meaning that someone who contracts the virus will spread it to two other people on average. Also suppose that it takes one week to pass it on to someone else. In week 1, one person is infected; in week 2, two new people are infected; in week 3, four new people; in week 4, eight new people, and so on. If only a small percentage of people who are infected get sick enough to have to go to the hospital, it might not be until after the end of week 8, when 128 new people have been infected, that the authorities become aware of the epidemic. Once we reach this stage, the only two options left are to impose extreme quarantine measures in an effort to drive Ro below 1, or stand back and let the outbreak run its natural course. Not surprisingly, most governments have chosen the first approach in the hopes of limiting the outbreak to a few regional clusters. A vigilant approach also buys some time to develop a vaccine. Time will tell if this strategy succeeds. On the positive side, the number of new infections in China continues to trend lower. Outside of Hubei, only 66 new cases have been reported since February 22nd. This has allowed an increasing number of Chinese companies to resume operations. It is also encouraging that a few countries such as Japan, Singapore, and Thailand, which at one point seemed on track to experience major epidemics, have gotten the problem under some degree of control. Chart 1The Number Of New Cases Has Declined In China, But Has Jumped In South Korea, Italy, And Iran On the negative side, the number of cases in South Korea, Iran, and Italy has surged (Chart 1). In South Korea, there are now 1261 confirmed cases, up from 31 early last week. South Korea’s population is less than 4% of China’s. If the current trend continues, the infection rate in Korea could surpass that of China over the next two weeks. The situation in Iran appears to be out of control. Two people from Iran have already tested positive in Canada. Bahrain has recorded 33 cases linked to Iran. In perhaps one of the most surreal moments of the crisis, Iranian deputy health minister Iraj Harirchi, who had been charged with leading the nation’s efforts to stem the epidemic, was filmed wiping his brow one day before it was confirmed he had contracted the virus. None of this prevented President Rouhani from declaring that Iran must “not allow enemies to convert the coronavirus into a weapon in their hand in order to disrupt work and production in Iran”. He went on to denounce the US for failing to “pay attention to the 16,000 American victims who died after having the influenza virus.” Worse Than The Swine Flu? Looking at the global data in aggregate, the number of confirmed cases is increasing in a manner more similar to the swine flu (H1N1) outbreak in 2009/10 than the SARS outbreak in 2003 (Chart 2). The H1N1 virus ended up infecting 61 million people in the US and between 700 million-to-1.4 billion globally. Chart 2COVID-19: More Like Swine Flu Than SARS? Unlike SARS, the COVID-19 coronavirus appears to be extremely contagious and can be spread by people who show few or no symptoms. SARS was generally spread only by people who were already visibly ill. In terms of fatality rates, COVID-19 is not as lethal as SARS, but appears to be at least ten times as fatal as H1N1. At present, there are no effective vaccines for coronaviruses. While concerted efforts are underway to develop a vaccine for COVID-19, most medical professionals agree that it will take at least a year before one is widely available. Unfortunately, given the exponential dynamic described above, most of the people on the planet could be infected by then. Pandemic Risk No one knows what the probability of a pandemic is, but it is clearly not zero. As workers return to their jobs in China, the outbreak may flare up again, leading to a new wave of business closures. Countries that do not have the will or the means to quarantine their citizens on a massive scale may find themselves unable to keep the virus at bay. Investors are finally waking up to this reality. As we discussed in last week’s report entitled “Markets Too Complacent About The Coronavirus,” even in a best-case scenario where the virus is successfully corralled over the next month or so, sequential global growth will still fall to zero in the first quarter. If the outbreak is not contained and a full-fledged pandemic ensues, the world is likely to experience a recession on the scale of the 2008/09 downturn. Table 1COVID-19 Fatality Rates By Age The only economic consolation from such an outcome is that once everyone is in the same boat, the need for mass quarantines and business shutdowns will diminish. Table 1 shows preliminary age-specific estimates of the fatality rate from the COVID-19 virus, provided by the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention (China CDC).1 The results are based on 44,672 confirmed cases. Stocks Won’t Get Much Relief From Bonds Given that investors have known about the risks from the coronavirus for some time, why did it take so long for stocks to buckle? Part of the answer has to do with the sigh of relief investors breathed after the number of new COVID-19 cases peaked in China. As in the SARS episode, the peak in new cases marked a bottom in risk assets (Chart 3). Unfortunately, now that the number of cases has accelerated outside of China, this sanguine narrative has been dashed. Chart 3AJust As In The SARS Episode, Stocks Bottomed Around The Same Time The Number Of Infections Peaked... Chart 3B… But The Number Of New Cases Outside China Has Surged While the news flow about the coronavirus has been the dominant driver of stocks, there has also been another important factor at work. As Chart 4 shows, global bond yields have dropped sharply since the start of the year. Up until this week, equity investors clung to the hope that falling yields would cushion the blow to growth and earnings. They also figured that a decline in the discount rate applied to future cash flows would boost equity valuations. Not surprisingly, growth stocks, which are most sensitive to changes in the discount rate, led the charge higher (Chart 5). Chart 4Global Bond Yields Are Back Near Record Lows Chart 5Growth Stocks Have Outperformed On Falling Yields These rosy expectations could still be realized if the global outbreak is quickly contained. If it is not, there is not much more central banks can do. Easier monetary policy can help offset demand shocks. However, it cannot do much about supply shocks. Stocks sold off in late 2018 because investors concluded that the Fed had erred in raising interest rates four times over the course of nine months. As soon as the Fed pivoted in a more dovish direction, equities rallied. This time is different. The Fed is not responsible for the current sell-off; the virus is. Thus, while the Fed would almost certainly cut rates if the outbreak turns into a pandemic, this would have less of a soothing effect than it did in early 2019. Supply Chains At Risk The modern global economy is powered by an intricate division of labor. Widespread work stoppages across many countries would eviscerate the global supply chain. Ironically, investors were worried at the start of the year that manufacturing inventories were too high. As it turned out, excess inventories have proven to be a blessing rather than a curse because they have allowed companies to weather the supply shock longer than they could have otherwise. The grace period will expire soon. According to the latest PMI data, supplier delivery times have soared in the major economies. The latest Markit Flash Eurozone PMI noted “a marked lengthening of supplier delivery times, with delays for inputs the most widespread since December 2018, attributed in many cases to supply chain issues arising from the COVID-19 outbreak.” In the UK, Markit reported that UK manufacturers had disclosed the “the largest month-on-month slide in supply chain performance since the survey began in 1992, exceeding the previous record seen during the UK fuel protests in September 2000.” Monetary policy will come in handy only after the outbreak subsides. The dislocations caused by the virus could push many businesses towards the brink of bankruptcy. This could trigger a feedback loop of reduced spending, less hiring, and even lower spending. Timely stimulus would short-circuit this vicious cycle. That said, given that interest rates are already close to zero in most countries, much of the burden of preventing an extended downturn will have to fall on fiscal policy. It's Not Just About The Risk-Free Rate Chart 6Risk-Off Has Been On Fire What about the valuation boost to stocks from falling bond yields? It is certainly true that, all things equal, lower bond yields are good for stocks. However, all things are rarely equal. We need to ask why yields have fallen. The value of the stock market does not just depend on the risk-free rate. It also depends on the additional return investors demand to hold stocks – the so-called equity risk premium – as well as expected earnings growth. If bond yields decline because skittish investors pile into safe-haven US Treasuries, while simultaneously cutting their earnings projections, this will almost certainly result in lower equity prices. What we have seen this past week is a classic risk-off event (Chart 6). Gold has surged to the highest level since 2013. Term premia in government bond markets have plunged. Tech stocks have underperformed other sectors despite the ostensible support from lower bond yields. The US dollar has rallied, even as interest rate differentials have moved against the greenback (Chart 7). Chart 7The Dollar Has Rallied, Even As Interest Rate Differentials Have Moved Against The Greenback What are investors to do? While stock valuations have improved markedly over the past week, we would warn against deploying significant fresh capital to equities at the moment. Stocks were technically overbought going into this correction. Some degree of profit taking was likely no matter what transpired. Once COVID-19 cases start popping up all over the US, stocks could come under further pressure. Hence, we would only become more constructive on the near-term outlook for global equities if prices were to fall another 5%-to-8% from current levels or if the risks of a pandemic recede. Peter Berezin Chief Global Strategist peterb@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1The Novel Coronavirus Pneumonia Emergency Response Epidemiology Team, "The Epidemiological Characteristics of an Outbreak of 2019 Novel Coronavirus Diseases (COVID-19) — China, 2020[J]," China CDC Weekly, 2020, 2(8): 113-122. Global Investment Strategy View Matrix MacroQuant Model And Current Subjective Scores Strategic Recommendations
Yesterday, BCA Research's China Investment Strategy service concluded that Chinese policymakers, dealing with an unprecedented public health crisis, are returning to aggressive fiscal and monetary easing. The odds are rising that the magnitude of the upcoming…
According to BCA Research's China Investment Strategy service, the aggressive containment measures seem to be effective inside China, as manufacturing is resuming. The likely magnitude of the growth shock might be smaller than investors fear as the evidence…
Highlights In the past week, it is becoming evident that the Chinese leadership is willing to abandon its financial de-risking agenda in exchange for a rapid economic recovery. Monetary conditions are already more accommodative than during the last easing cycle in 2015/2016. The recently announced policy initiatives on infrastructure, housing, and automobile sectors also resemble policy supports that led to a V-shaped economic recovery in 2016. As manufacturers in regions other than Hubei are returning to work and their production capacity continues to rise, the outbreak-induced economic shock may be smaller than investors currently fear. Hence, the odds are rising that the upcoming “insurance stimulus” may end up overshooting the short-term economic shock. As such, we maintain a constructive view on Chinese stocks over the next 6-12 months. Feature A surge in the number of COVID-19 infections outside of China (including South Korea, Japan, Iran, and Italy) risks delaying a global economic recovery, and has cast doubt on the outlook for the global economy beyond Q1 (Chart 1). Chart 1Pandemic Threats Expanding Globally Despite the sharp uptick in global investor concern, our constructive view on Chinese stocks remains unchanged for the next 6-12 months. Our view on Chinese risk assets is based on a simple arithmetic framework that we described last year when the trade war tensions between the US and China were escalating. In short, when gauging the net impact of an economic shock, investors should determine which of the following two scenarios is most likely: Scenario 1 (Bearish): Stimulus – Shock ≤ 0 Scenario 2 (Bullish): Stimulus – Shock > 0 While this framework is quite simplistic, the point is to underscore that economic shocks are almost always met with a policy response, and the goal is to determine whether this response is sufficient enough to offset the impact of the shock. If the Chinese leadership underestimates the severity of the shock and undershoots on the stimulus, this would be bearish for Chinese stocks (Scenario 1). In the current situation, however, even if the near-term economic outlook is deeply negative, investors should maintain a bullish cyclical (i.e. 6-12 month) outlook for China-related assets as long as the impact of China’s reflationary efforts more than offsets the negative shock to aggregate demand (Scenario 2). Major Stimulus Around The Corner? It is becoming evident that the Chinese policymakers, when dealing with an unprecedented public health crisis, are returning to aggressive fiscal and monetary easing. In fact, the odds are rising that the magnitude of the upcoming stimulus may resemble that of 2015/2016, and has an increasing possibility to overshoot in the next 6-12 months. In the past week, there has been a clear shift of policy focus from “financial de-risking” to “mitigating the economic damage from shocks at all costs”, as indicated by high-profile policy announcements. In an unprecedented large-scale teleconference on February 23,1 President Xi stated that China will not lower its economic growth target for this year, and that fiscal policy will be “more proactive” while monetary policy was upgraded from “prudent” to “flexible and moderate". Chart 2PBoC Looks Set For Massive Stimulus Xi also pledged to “introduce new policy measures in a timely manner”. China’s central bank, the PBoC, issued a statement signaling further cuts ahead in the bank reserve requirement ratio rate and interest rate.2 The PBoC has already aggressively eased monetary conditions in the past two weeks, and both the central bank policy and average lending rates are now lower than they were during the last massive easing cycle in 2015/2016 (Chart 2). Other policy initiatives also suggest the Chinese authorities are stepping up coordinated efforts to boost the economy, beyond short-term and targeted financial support. The stimulative measures now span from infrastructure to housing and automobile sectors, the exact “three prongs” that supported a V-shaped economic recovery in 2016.3 This is in sharp contrast with last year, when Chinese policymakers largely resisted resorting to large-scale stimulus, despite immense pressure from the US-China trade war and tariff impositions.4 The ongoing COVID-19 epidemic seems to have forced China to return to its old economic playbook, as the Xi administration is clearly unwilling to tolerate economic hardships driven by an endogenous crisis. The ongoing epidemic seems to have forced China to return to its old economic playbook, as the Xi administration is clearly unwilling to tolerate economic hardships driven by an endogenous crisis. As we predicted in November last year,5 China was to frontload additional fiscal stimulus in Q1 this year to secure an economic recovery, which started to bud in Q4 last year. The increase in January’s credit numbers confirms our projection: local government bond issuance picked up significantly from last year while the contraction in shadow bank lending continued to ease, signaling a less restrictive policy bias on both the monetary and fiscal fronts (Chart 3). Chart 3Stronger Fiscal Support Likely To Soon Follow The exact economic and monetary expansion growth targets will be officially set at the National People’s Congress meeting, which has been postponed from its usual schedule on March 5. Compared with the 6.1% real GDP growth achieved in 2019, we now think a growth target of 5.6% would be conservative for this year. According to an estimate by BCA’s Global Investment Strategy,6 China’s real GDP growth in Q1 could slow to 3.5% on a year-over-year basis. To achieve 5.6% growth, China would need at least 6.3% average real growth (year-over-year) for the next three quarters, 0.3 percentage points higher than in the second half of 2019. The growth in credit expansion, infrastructure spending and government expenditures will need to significantly outpace last year in the next 6-12 months. Bottom Line: The government appears to be willing to abandon its financial de-risking agenda to secure economic recovery. There is an increasing possibility that the stimulus may overshoot the economic shock this year. China’s Economic Engine Warms Up There are increasing signs that the scale of the upcoming stimulus may match that of the 2015/2016 cycle. The likely magnitude of the shock, on the other hand, might be smaller than investors fear as the evidence is mounting that production is returning to normality in China. Despite a lack of employees and raw materials, industrial activity in regions outside of Hubei is resuming. Chart 4…Small Companies Are Not Far Behind A survey of China’s 500 top manufacturers by China Enterprise Confederation7 indicated that most of the 342 respondents had resumed production as of February 20. They also reported that more than half of their employees had returned to work and the average capacity utilization rate had reached nearly 60% (Table 1). Furthermore, the China Association of Small and Medium Enterprises8 survey of 6,422 small businesses showed that as of February 14, more than half of the companies have resumed operations (Chart 4). By February 21, the daily coal consumption in China’s six largest power plants has reached 62% of the consumption from the same period last year (adjusted for Lunar Year calendar), 14 percentage points higher than February 10 - the first day officially scheduled for people to return to work.9 Table 1Large Manufacturers Have Reached More Than Half Of Their Production Capacity… The resurgence in the number of new infections has not slowed those regions down from reopening businesses, particularly along the manufacturing belt in China’s coastal regions (Chart 5). China’s leadership has repeatedly urged local governments to relax aggressive containment measures to allow production to resume. Unless the number of new cases in China picks up again, we expect business operations in regions outside of Hubei to continue re-opening in the coming weeks. Chart 580% Of China’s Coastal Regions Are Back To Work Most manufacturers in regions other than Hubei are returning to work and are running at about half of last year’s production capacity. Bottom Line: The aggressive containment measures seem to be effective inside China. Most manufacturers in regions other than Hubei are returning to work and are running at about half of last year’s production capacity. We expect the rate to improve. This will mitigate the impact of the virus outbreak on the Chinese economy. “Scenario 2” Implies An Upturn In The Corporate Earnings Cycle The impact of the COVID-19 outbreak on China’s economy may be smaller than investors currently fear. The country is also in a better economic condition than in 2015/2016. If the Chinese leadership believes an “insurance stimulus” is warranted and allows credit growth in 2020 to reach near 28% of GDP, as in 2015-2016, then the stimulus will more than offset the outbreak-induced economic shock from Q1 and lead to a meaningful rise in this year’s corporate earnings (Chart 6): China’s households and corporates are actually more willing to spend now than in 2015-2016. We agree that China’s households and companies are both highly leveraged, and re-leveraging may further diminish their debt-servicing ability and willingness to invest or spend. Debt as a share of Chinese household disposable income has climbed by 33 percentage points compared with five years ago (Chart 7). The increase in debt load makes Chinese households particularly vulnerable to income reductions. But this supports our view that policymakers will make every reflationary effort to avoid massive layoffs. Additionally, the willingness to spend among Chinese households is not less than during the down cycle in 2015-2016 (Chart 7 bottom panel). Chart 6A 2015/2016-Style Stimulus Will Likely Triumph Over Short-Term Economic Shocks Chart 7Chinese Households Are More Indebted, But Are Also More Willing To Spend Than In 2015/2016 The debt-to-GDP ratio and debt-servicing cost-to-income ratio in China’s non-financial private sector have trended sideways in the past five years (Chart 8). The corporate cash flow situation is only slightly worse than in 2015 (Chart 9). The virus outbreak and drastic containment measures will temporarily weaken the corporates’ cash positions, but this negative situation can be partially offset by tax, fee and interest relief measures.10 Chart 8Chinese Corporates Are In Fact Not More Indebted Than In 2015/2016... Chart 9...And Their Cash Flow Situation Is Only Slightly Worse Furthermore, China’s non-financial corporates’ marginal propensity to spend is actually higher than in 2015-2016 (Chart 10). This may be due to the more accommodative monetary backdrop than in 2015-2016. If Chinese authorities are to significantly step up their reflationary efforts, the easy monetary policy stance may be here to stay throughout 2020. Prior to the COVID-19 outbreak, the mild deflation in China’s PPI growth was already turning slightly positive on the heels of an improving economy. The historical relationship between China’s producer prices and industrial profits suggests that profit growth for both China’s onshore and offshore markets is highly linked to fluctuations in producer prices (Chart 11). An ultra-easy monetary policy, a weak RMB, and a more forceful boost to domestic demand will provide strong reflationary support to producer prices and industrial profits. Chart 10Chinese Corporates' Willingness To Spend Also Higher Than In 2015/2016 Chart 11A 2015/2016-Style Reflation Will Likely Lead To A Strong Rebound In Corporate Profits Bottom Line: Despite a short-term economic shock, China’s economy is at a better starting point than in 2015-2016. If monetary and fiscal easing in 2020 reaches the same magnitude as five years ago, then the economy and corporate profits will likely begin to respond to the stimulus. Investment Conclusions The clear sign of policy shift to shoring up the economy suggests that, our Scenario 2 is the most likely outcome. The fiscal and monetary easing initiatives seem to resemble those of 2015/2016. The short-term outbreak-induced economic shock, on the other hand, looks to be smaller than the market anticipates. Manufacturers in China continue to resume production in regions outside of Hubei, a trend we believe will go on unless there is a significant threat that the virus will break out again in these Chinese regions. This supports our constructive view on China-related assets over a 6-12 month time horizon. The fiscal and monetary easing initiatives seem to resemble those of 2015/2016, and will likely overshoot the short-term economic shock. There is a risk to our constructive view, though, that the more forceful policy response from the Chinese leadership may imply a greater than anticipated short-term economic shock from the outbreak. This would challenge our bullish stance on Chinese stocks in the next three months. Substantially weaker economic data in Q1 would likely trigger a selloff in Chinese risk assets, both onshore and offshore. However, a severe short-term economic shock, followed by a burst of stimulus, would create strong investment opportunities. If the scale of Chinese policymakers’ reflationary measures ramps up significantly in the coming months, they will likely overshoot the short-term economic shock. Another reflationary cycle would certainly have a positive impact on global investors’ sentiment and Chinese financial assets. Stay tuned. Jing Sima China Strategist jings@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 http://english.www.gov.cn/news/topnews/202002/23/content_WS5e5286cdc6d0… 2 http://www.pbc.gov.cn/goutongjiaoliu/113456/113469/3975864/index.html 3 Please see China Investment Strategy Weekly Report "Threading A Stimulus Needle (Part 2): Will Proactive Fiscal Policy Lose Steam?," dated July 24, 2019, available at cis.bcaresearch.com 4 Please see China Investment Strategy Weekly Reports "Threading A Stimulus Needle (Part 1): A Reluctant PBoC," dated July 10, 2019, "Threading A Stimulus Needle (Part 2): Will Proactive Fiscal Policy Lose Steam?," dated July 24, 2019, "Don’t Bottom-Fish Chinese Assets (Yet)," dated August 14, 2019 and "Mild Deflation Means Timid Easing," dated October 9, 2019. available at cis.bcaresearch.com 5 Please see China Investment Strategy Weekly Report "Questions From The Road: Timing The Turn," dated November 20, 2019, available at cis.bcaresearch.com 6 Please see Global Investment Strategy Weekly Report "Markets Too Complacent About The Coronavirus," dated February 21, 2020, available at cis.bcaresearch.com 7 http://www.cec-ceda.org.cn/view_sy.php?id=42633 8 http://www.ce.cn/xwzx/gnsz/gdxw/202002/18/t20200218_34298844.shtml 9 http://www.21jingji.com/2020/2-21/wOMDEzNzhfMTUzNjAwOA.html 10 China has announced targeted measures to defer or lower taxes and administrative fees. It will also provide interest rate subsidies to affected businesses. Cyclical Investment Stance Equity Sector Recommendations
China often uses a weaker currency as a key tool to minimize domestic deflationary pressures. Thanks to the weakness in the RMB, Chinese export prices to the US have fallen more than 5% in USD terms since 2014, yet, they have increased by 7% in RMB. This…
Highlights The coronavirus is a wild card that may have a significant impact on the global economy, … : The COVID-19 outbreak is unfolding in real time, half a world away, and its ultimate course is uncertain. For now, our China strategists think the worst-case scenarios are unlikely, but we will not remain constructive if the virus outlook materially worsens. … but as long as there is not a significantly negative exogenous event, the US economy will be just fine, … : From a domestic perspective, the US expansion is in very good shape. Easy monetary conditions will support a range of activities, and a potent labor market will give increasing numbers of households the confidence and wherewithal to ramp up consumption. … and if there’s no recession, there will not be a bear market: Recessions and equity bear markets coincide, with stocks typically peaking six months ahead of the onset of a recession. If the next recession doesn’t come before late 2021/early 2022, the bull market should remain intact at least through the end of this year. What We Do US Investment Strategy’s stated mission is to analyze the US economy and its future direction for the purpose of helping clients make asset-allocation and portfolio-management decisions. As important as the economic backdrop is, however, we never forget that we are investment strategists, not economic forecasters. We don’t belabor the state of every facet of the economy because neither we nor our clients care about 10- to 20-basis-point wiggles in real GDP growth in themselves. They do want us to keep them apprised of the general trend, though, and we are always trying to assess it. Ultimately, macro analysis benefits investors by providing them with timely recognition of the approach or emergence of an inflection point in the cycles that matter most for financial assets. We view investment strategy as the practical application of the study of cycles, and we are continuously monitoring the business cycle, the credit cycle, the monetary policy cycle and the squishy and only sporadically relevant sentiment cycle. This week, we turn our attention to the business cycle, and the ongoing viability of the expansion, which is already the longest on record at 128 months and counting. If it remains intact, risk assets are likely to continue to generate returns in excess of returns on Treasuries and cash. The Message From Our Simple Recession Indicator We have previously described our simple recession indicator.1 It has just three components, and all three of them have to be sounding the alarm to conclude that a recession is imminent. Our first input is the slope of the yield curve, measured by the difference between the yield on the 10-year Treasury bond and the 3-month T-bill.2 The yield curve inverts when the 3-month bill yield exceeds the 10-year bond yield, and a recession has followed all but one yield curve inversion over the last 50 years (Chart 1). The yield curve inverted from May through September last year, and the coronavirus outbreak (COVID-19) has driven it to invert again, but the unprecedentedly negative term premium (Chart 2) has made the curve much more prone to set off a false alarm. Chart 1An Inverted Curve May Not Be What It Used To Be ... Chart 2... When A Negative Term Premium Is Holding Down Long Yields The indicator’s second input is the year-over-year change in the leading economic index (“LEI”). When the LEI contracts on a year-over-year basis, a recession typically ensues. As with the inverted yield curve, year-over-year contractions in the LEI have successfully called all of the recessions in the last 50 years with just one false positive (Chart 3). The LEI bounced off the zero line thanks to January’s strong reading, and the year-ago comparisons are much easier than they were last year, but we are mindful that it is flirting with sending a recession warning. Chart 3Leading Indicators Are Wobbly, ... It takes more than tight monetary conditions to make a recession, but you can't have one without them. To confirm the signal from the yield curve and the LEI and make it more robust, we also consider the monetary policy backdrop. Over the nearly 60 years for which BCA’s model calculates an equilibrium rate, every recession has occurred when the fed funds rate has exceeded our estimate of equilibrium (Chart 4). Tight monetary policy isn’t a sufficient condition for a recession – expansions continued for six more years despite tight policy in the mid-‘80s and mid-'90s – but it is a necessary one. Our indicator will not definitively signal an approaching recession until monetary conditions turn restrictive. Chart 4... But The Fed Is Nowhere Near Inducing A Recession Bottom Line: In our view, the yield curve and the LEI both represent yellow lights, though the LEI has a greater likelihood of turning red, especially in the wake of COVID-19. Monetary policy is unambiguously green, however, and we will not conclude that a recession is imminent until the Fed deliberately attempts to rein in the economy. Bolstering Theory With Observation A potential shortcoming of our recession indicator is its reliance on a theoretical concept. The equilibrium (or natural) rate of interest cannot be directly observed, so our judgment of whether monetary policy is easy or tight turns on an estimate. To bolster our assessment of whether or not the expansion can continue, we have been tracking the drivers of the main components of US output. Going back to the GDP equation from Introductory Macroeconomics, GDP = C + I + G + (X - M), we look at the forces supporting Consumption (C), Investment (I) and Government Spending (G). (Because the US is a comparatively closed economy in which trade plays a minor role, we ignore net exports (X-M).) Consumption is by far the largest component, accounting for two-thirds of overall output, while investment and government spending each contribute a sixth. As critical as consumption is for the US economy, it is not the whole story; smaller but considerably more volatile investment is capable of plunging the economy into a recession on its own. The Near-Term Outlook For Consumption Chart 5Labor Market Slack Has Been Absorbed Consumption depends on household income, the condition of household balance sheets, and households’ willingness to spend. The labor market remains extremely tight, with the unemployment rate at a 50-year low, and “hidden” unemployment dwindling as the supply of discouraged (Chart 5, top panel) and involuntary part-time workers (Chart 5, bottom panel) has withered. The prime-age employment-to-population ratio trails only the peak reached during the dot-com era (Chart 6), which bodes well for household income. The historical correlation between the prime-age non-employment-to-population ratio and wage gains has been quite robust, and compensation growth has plenty of room to run before it catches up with the best-fit line (Chart 7). Chart 6Prime-Age Employment Has Surged, ... Chart 7... And Wages Will Eventually Follow Suit Chart 8No Pressing Need To Save, Or Pay Down Debt Households can use additional income to increase savings or pay down debt instead of spending it, but it doesn’t look like they will. The savings rate is already quite elevated, having returned to its mid-‘90s levels (Chart 8, top panel); households have already run debt down to its post-dot-com bust levels (Chart 8, middle panel); and debt service is less demanding than it has been at any point in the last 40 years (Chart 8, bottom panel). The health of household balance sheets, and the recent pickup in the expectations component of the consumer confidence surveys, suggest that households have the ability and the willingness to keep consumption growing at or above trend. Household balance sheets are healthy enough to support spending income gains; there's even room to borrow to augment them. The Near-Term Outlook For Investment Table 1GDP Equation Recession Probabilities Chart 9A Budding Turnaround We previously identified investment as the individual component most likely to decline enough to zero out trend growth from the other two components (Table 1), and it was a drag in 2019, declining in each of the last three quarters to end the year more than 3% below its peak. We expect it will hold up better this year, however, as the capital spending intentions components of the NFIB survey of smaller businesses (Chart 9, top panel) and the regional Fed manufacturing surveys (Chart 9, bottom panel) have both pulled out of declines. The trade tensions with China weighed heavily on business confidence in 2019, but the signing of the Phase 1 trade agreement lifted that cloud, and we expect that capex will revive in line with confidence once COVID-19 has been subdued. Government Spending In An Election Year Chart 10State And Local Revenues Are Well Supported Heading into the most hotly contested election in many years, we confidently assert that federal spending is not going to go away. Regardless of party affiliation, everyone in Congress sees the appeal of distributing pork to their constituents. Spending by state and local governments, which accounts for 60% of aggregate government spending, should also hold up well, as a robust labor market will support state income tax (Chart 10, top panel) and sales tax (Chart 10, middle panel) receipts. Healthy trailing home price gains will support property tax assessments, keeping municipal coffers full (Chart 10, bottom panel). Coronavirus Uncertainties The coronavirus epidemic (COVID-19) is unfolding in real time, generating daily updates on new infections, deaths and recoveries. Any opinion we offer on the economy’s future is conditioned on the virus' ongoing course. If it takes a sharp turn for the worse, with more severe consequences than we had previously expected, it is likely that we will downgrade our outlook. For now, we are operating under the projection that the virus will cause China’s first quarter output to contract sharply enough to zero out global growth in the first quarter. Our base-case scenario, following from the work of our China Investment Strategy service, is fairly benign from there. For now, we are expecting that the worst of the effects will be confined to the first quarter, and that the Chinese economy and the global economy will bounce back vigorously in the second quarter and beyond, powered by pent-up demand that will go unfilled until the outbreak begins to recede. Our China strategists continue to be heartened by Chinese officials' aggressive (albeit belated) measures to stem the outbreak, revealed in the apparent slowing of the rate of new infections in Hubei province, the epicenter of the outbreak (Chart 11, top panel), and in the rest of China (Chart 11, bottom panel). They also expect a determined policy response to offset the drag from the epidemic (Charts 12 and 13), as officials pursue the imperative of meeting their goal to double the size of the economy between 2010 and 2020. Chart 11Stringent Quarantine Measures May Be Gaining Traction Chart 12The PBOC Is Doing Its Part, ... Chart 13... By Easing Monetary Conditions If the economy is expanding, investors' bar for de-risking should be high. Bottom Line: Our China strategists’ COVID-19 view remains fairly optimistic, though it is subject to unfolding developments. Our US view is contingent on BCA’s evolving COVID-19 views. Investment Implications As we noted at the outset, we are not interested in the economy for the economy’s sake; we are only interested in its impact on financial markets. The key business-cycle takeaway for markets is that bear markets and recessions typically coincide, as it is difficult to get a 20% decline at the index level without a meaningful decline in earnings, and earnings only decline meaningfully during recessions. No recession means no bear market, and it also means no meaningful pickup in loan delinquencies and defaults. The bottom line is that it is premature to de-risk while the expansion remains intact. We reiterate our recommendation that investors should remain at least equal weight equities in balanced portfolios, and at least equal weight spread product within fixed income allocations, though we may turn more cautious as we learn more about the progression of COVID-19. Doug Peta, CFA Chief US Investment Strategist dougp@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Please see the August 13, 2018 US Investment Strategy Special Report, "How Much Longer Can The Bull Market Last?" available at usis.bcaresearch.com. 2 We use the 3-month/10-year segment instead of the more common 2-year/10-year because the 3-month bill is a cleaner proxy for short rates than the 2-year note, which incorporates estimates of the Fed’s future actions.
Highlights Global equities have benefited from the fact that the number of new coronavirus (COVID-19) cases continues to drift lower. Falling bond yields have also supported stocks. Nevertheless, risks remain. Even if the outbreak recedes, global growth is still set to fall to zero in the first quarter, before bouncing back over the remainder of the year. Thus, a near-term hit to corporate earnings now looks unavoidable. More worryingly, the possibility remains that the number of new cases will spike again as Chinese workers return to their jobs over the next few weeks. While we and others have compared the current outbreak to the SARS episode, a more relevant comparison could be the H1N1 (swine flu) outbreak of 2009-2010. Despite early efforts to contain it, 61 million Americans ended up catching the H1N1 virus, resulting in about 12,000 US deaths over a 12-month period. Globally, at least 150,000 people perished. It appears that the fatality rate from COVID-19 is significantly higher than for H1N1, though well below that of SARS and MERS. A full-blown pandemic with a fatality rate of 2% could lead to 20 million deaths worldwide. This would likely trigger a global downturn as deep as the Great Recession of 2008/09. The only consolation is that the recovery would be much more rapid than the one following the financial crisis. Although we are inclined to lean on the side of optimism, the truth is that neither we nor anyone else knows what the likelihood of such a pandemic scenario is. Thus, while we continue to maintain our positive 12-month view on global stocks, we recommend a more cautious near-term stance. Global Growth Set To Grind To A Halt In Q1 Based on the SARS example, we noted three weeks ago that risk assets were likely to bottom once the number of new coronavirus cases peaked. Sure enough, Chinese shares troughed on January 31st, just as the number of confirmed infections had begun to level off. The S&P 500 has been on a tear since then, hitting one record high after another (Chart 1). Falling bond yields have also supported stocks. Despite the decline in new infections, we think it is too early for investors to breathe a sigh of relief. For one thing, the economic data out of China remains abysmal. Real-time indicators of economic activity have been off-the-charts bad – much worse than what we saw during the SARS outbreak. While there has been some recovery in recent days, road congestion remains well below normal levels. In Shanghai, property sales are currently about four times lower than what is usual for this time of year. Movie ticket sales have all but disappeared. Daily coal consumption, which tracks electricity consumption, has fallen by 70% (Chart 2). More than three-quarters of companies surveyed last week by the American Chamber of Commerce in Shanghai said that they cannot run a full production line due to a lack of staff. Chart 1Just As In The SARS Episode, Stocks Bottomed Around The Same Time The Number Of Infections Peaked Chart 2Chinese Daily Activity Has Fallen Off A Cliff In our preliminary estimate of the impact of the virus on global growth, we penciled in zero growth for China on a quarter-over-quarter basis in Q1 of 2020, implying that the level of output in the first quarter would be the same as in the fourth quarter. Unfortunately, at this point, that looks far too optimistic. Chinese economic output will decline on a sequential basis. The only question is by how much. Despite the decline in new infections, we think it is too early for investors to breathe a sigh of relief. Chart 3 shows our updated baseline profile for global growth in Q1 and the remainder of this year. Assuming that production returns to normal over the coming weeks, it should be possible to limit the unannualized quarter-over-quarter decline in Chinese real GDP in Q1 to 1% (4% annualized). On a year-over-year basis (2020Q1 versus 2019Q1), this would drag Chinese growth down to 3.5%, the slowest pace in three decades. Relative to our earlier estimates, we expect larger spillover effects to the rest of the world, mainly stemming from the severe contraction in global tourism. Chart 3The Global Economy Will Come To A Standstill In Q1 The direct and indirect effects of the outbreak should be enough to push global growth down to zero on a quarter-over-quarter basis in Q1. Under our baseline scenario, growth will recover in the second quarter, leaving the level of global GDP down 0.5 percentage points for the year as a whole compared to what would have transpired if the virus had never emerged. The Calm Before The Storm? Even after this downgrade to our assessment, we still see the risks to global growth from the COVID-19 outbreak as being tilted to the downside. This largely reflects our concern that contrary to our baseline scenario, the outbreak could reintensify over the next few weeks as more Chinese workers return to their jobs. As the dire situation on the Diamond Princess cruiseliner docked in the port of Yokohama illustrates, the COVID-19 virus remains highly contagious. Despite numerous efforts by medical authorities to keep those on board at a safe distance from one another, 621 of the 3,011 passengers and crew aboard the ship who have been tested have been infected with the virus. Worryingly, the virus also appears to be contagious even when carriers are not showing any symptoms. Just this week, the Japanese media reported on a case where the son of an infected doctor tested positive for the virus even though he had last seen his father three days before the doctor started displaying symptoms. While the number of new infections has fallen in China, new clusters have appeared elsewhere. South Korea just reported 73 new cases in a little more than two days. Iran disclosed two deaths from the virus in Qom, a holy city just outside Tehran that receives 20 million visitors annually. This suggests that there are probably at least 100 infected people in the city. The World Health Organization has estimated RO, the average number of people someone with the COVID-19 virus will infect, to be between 1.4 and 2.5. A recent survey of 12 studies found a larger mean RO of 3.28.1 An RO above one would produce an exponential increase in the number of cases. Heavy-handed quarantine measures such as those imposed by China could probably drive RO below one. However, some governments may not be able to implement such measures, and even if they could, they might not be sustainable for months on end. The H1N1 (Swine Flu) Template? All this raises the possibility that the COVID-19 outbreak could end up resembling the H1N1 (swine flu) pandemic of 2009-10. Despite initial hopes, early efforts to contain the H1N1 outbreak failed. The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention calculated that 61 million Americans caught the virus over the course of the proceeding 12 months, resulting in over 12,000 deaths. Globally, an estimated 700 million-to-1.4 billion people contracted the virus. A paper published in the Lancet put the number of fatalities worldwide at 151,700-to-575,400.2 The reason one hears less about H1N1 than SARS is that the latter killed 5%-to-10% of those who contracted it, whereas the former killed 0.01%-to-0.08%. Based on very preliminary evidence, it appears that the fatality rate from COVID-19 is significantly higher than for H1N1, though well below that of SARS, and lower still than for MERS, a particularly nasty strain of the coronavirus that killed about one-third of those who contracted it. That said, COVID-19’s true fatality rate remains highly uncertain. In Hubei province, the fatality rate is running at 3.1%. Elsewhere in China, it stands at 0.9%. Outside China, the fatality rate appears to be 0.5%. Part of the gap between Hubei and elsewhere may be due to greater underreporting of mild and moderate cases in the stricken province. However, it is also likely that Hubei’s higher fatality rate reflects the tremendous pressures its medical system is currently under. If the COVID-19 outbreak were to morph into a pandemic, such pressures would only escalate since medical resources from less-afflicted areas could no longer be deployed to fight every local breakout. The Economic Impact Of A Pandemic: Deep But Brief Chart 4The Private-Sector Surplus In Developed Economies Is In Good Shape Assuming the COVID-19 virus infects a billion people with a fatality rate of 2%, this would translate into 20 million deaths worldwide. Such a pandemic would rattle the global economy, leading to a recession as deep as the one in 2008/09. Demand for most items other than necessities would collapse. Business and leisure travel would fizzle. The global supply chain would seize up. The only consolation is that the recession would likely be followed by a vigorous “V-shaped” recovery. Sluggish “U-shaped” recoveries tend to occur when there are many imbalances that need to be worked off. For example, the recovery in the US following the Great Recession was impeded by the need for households to pare back debt and for the excess supply of newly built homes to be run down. Today, the larger developed economies are in decent shape. The private-sector financial balance in advanced economies – the difference between what the private sector earns and spends – stands at a surplus of 3.4% of GDP. In 2007, the private-sector financial balance fell to 0.4%, hitting a deficit of 2% in the US. The private-sector balance also deteriorated sharply in the lead-up to the 2001 recession (Chart 4). Chinese debt levels have soared over the past decade. However, it is worth noting that China’s private-sector financial surplus reached 7.1% of GDP in 2019 – higher than in Japan or Germany (Chart 5). Rather than suffering from excess debt levels, China suffers from excess savings. It is these excess savings that have forced the authorities to push state-owned companies and local governments to engage in debt-financed investment spending in order to prop up aggregate demand and employment. It is also these savings that will allow the government to stimulate the economy to prevent an outright economic collapse. Chart 5The Private Sector Spends Less Than It Earns In Most Economies Life Goes On… For Most Chart 6'Til Death Do Us Part While it would take time, as horrific as a pandemic would be, most people would eventually adjust to living in a world where one’s longevity is less assured than it is today. That is the world in which humanity lived for centuries. It is also the world that prevailed during the Cold War. Keep in mind that in the US, an average 59 year-old man has a 1% chance of dying at some point within one year, and a 6% chance of dying over five years (Chart 6). Death is a part of life. As the virus circulates throughout the population, some people will perish. However, the vast majority will acquire immunity either by fighting off the disease or, if a vaccine becomes available later this year or in 2021, by being inoculated. All this will bring the pandemic to an end. Investment Conclusions No one knows if the COVID-19 outbreak will recede or whether it will morph into a true pandemic. As macro strategists, all we can do is run through various scenarios and try to figure out the likely market impact. Chart 7Global Manufacturing Was On The Upswing Before The Outbreak Occurred If the number of new infections continues to decline, investors will likely look through the Q1 plunge in growth. Judging from the purchasing manager indices, global growth had already turned the corner in the weeks before the viral outbreak (Chart 7). With pent-up demand having accumulated in the intervening weeks, growth would bounce back in the second quarter. Under this benign scenario, equities still have upside, while bond yields will start rising again. As a countercyclical currency, the US dollar would also give up some of its recent gains. In a pandemic scenario, the recovery in growth will obviously be delayed. And when output does recover, it will be from significantly lower levels. Markets will end up going through their own version of Kubler-Ross' five stages of grief: denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance. Unfortunately, before we reach the acceptance stage, global equities could easily fall by 20% from current levels. On balance, while we continue to lean on the side of optimism by maintaining our positive 12-month view on global stocks, we recommend a more cautious near-term stance until there is greater clarity as to how the outbreak will evolve. Peter Berezin Chief Global Strategist peterb@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1Ying Liu, Albert A Gayle, Annelies Wilder-Smith, and Joacim Rocklöv, “The reproductive number of COVID-19 is higher compared to SARS coronavirus,” Journal of Travel Medicine, February 2020. 2 Please see Sundar S. Shrestha, et al., “Estimating the Burden of 2009 Pandemic Influenza A (H1N1) in the United States (April 2009–April 2010),” Clinical Infectious Diseases (52:1), January 2011; Peter Doshi, “The 2009 Influenza Pandemic,” The Lancet Infectious Diseases (13:3), March 2013; and Heath Kelly, et al., “The Age-Specific Cumulative Incidence of Infection with Pandemic Influenza H1N1 2009 Was Similar in Various Countries Prior to Vaccination,” PLoS ONE 6(8), August 2011. Global Investment Strategy View Matrix MacroQuant Model And Current Subjective Scores Strategic Recommendations Closed Trades

