Skip to main content
Skip to main content

Semiconductors

Highlights Portfolio Strategy The ongoing capex upcycle, resurgent credit growth, easy Chinese policy trifecta, upbeat signals from high frequency financial market data and depressed technicals, all suggest that a re-rating phase looms in the S&P industrials sector. Leading indicators of chip end-demand are flashing green, at a time when the chip liquidation phase is clearing excess supplies. It no longer pays to be bearish the S&P semiconductors index.             Recent Changes Lift the S&P semiconductors index to neutral today; it is now also on upgrade alert. Table 1 Feature The SPX continued to grind higher last week, and is now within reach of the key 2,800 level. We expect stiff resistance to persist at that mark; 2,800 has served as a barrier on several occasions last year as we highlighted in recent research (please refer to Chart 1 from the January 28 Weekly Report).1  Year-to-date, we have identified three pillars that would propel the market higher – a more dovish Fed alongside a softer U.S. dollar, a year-over-year increase in SPX EPS for calendar 2019 and a positive resolution to the U.S./China trade spat. As the S&P 500 has come full circle and returned to the early December level, this slingshot recovery suggests that there is positive progress on all three pillars. However, our sense is that the bond market now has to remain tamed in order to cement these equity market gains and vault to fresh all-time highs, likely in the back half of the year. Chart 1 highlights this goldilocks macro backdrop. Chart 1Staying Divorced For A While In other words, as U.S. GDP downshifts from last year’s fiscal easing-induced sugar-high back down to trend growth and most importantly avoids recession, equities should excel. Why? Not only will this entice the Fed to stand pat for longer, but the 10-year Treasury yield will also remain on a lower trajectory than previously anticipated. Crudely put, a neither too-hot nor too-cold economic backdrop will allow equities to reflate away. As such, there are high odds that stocks stay divorced from bond yields for a while longer, and we interpret this bond market backdrop as reflationary rather than recessionary. Meanwhile on the Chinese front, following news of the PBoC’s quasi QE that we highlighted in early February as a positive SPX and cyclicals over defensives catalyst,2 it appears that Chinese authorities could not stomach a below 50 print in the Chinese manufacturing PMI for long and are aggressively opening the fiscal taps anew (Chart 2). Chart 2Chinese reflation... This enormous lending/fiscal stimulus complements ongoing monetary easing and the recent PBoC’s quasi QE, and should ensure that the Chinese economy at least steadies. The upshot is that global growth should also stabilize and put an end to its yearlong deceleration (Chart 3).        Chart 3... Should Aid Global Growth In addition, as U.S. and Chinese negotiation teams race to the finish line in order to get some sort of a deal done before the March 1st deadline, it is clear that a positive outcome is already discounted by the stock market as the SPX enjoys one of the best starts to the year in recent memory. Once this trade policy uncertainty permanently dies down, then last year’s worst performing sectors that were hit hard by the trade dispute will turn into this year’s stock market champions (Chart 4). Chart 4Trade War Hit Deep Cyclicals The Most In that light, we reiterate our cyclical over defensive portfolio bent and this week we highlight that a deep cyclical sector stands to benefit greatly from China’s reflation and the apparent resolution of the U.S./China trade spat; another tech subsector weighed down by the trade tussle is also going to enjoy a reversal of fortune and it no longer pays to be bearish. Don’t Write Off Mighty Industrials Year-to-date, industrials stocks are the best performing GICS1 sector, outperforming the SPX by a massive 650bps (Chart 5). While such a breakneck pace is unsustainable and a short term breather is likely, from a cyclical perspective more gains are in store in this still underowned sector. In this report we highlight the top five reasons it still pays to be overweight this deep cyclical sector. Capex upcycle. The capex upcycle theme remains intact and while there has been some softness recently in the national accounts reported investment outlays, it is highly unlikely that spending plans will grind to a halt similar to the late-2015/early-2016 episode (third panel, Chart 6). Capital goods producers have since replenished their cash coffers and remain committed to develop their capital expenditure projects. Importantly, leading indicators of capex corroborate this backdrop; regional Fed surveys suggest that capital outlays will remain firm for the rest of the year (second panel, Chart 6). Chart 6Capex Upcycle Supports Industrials Resurgent credit growth. Loan growth is on fire in the U.S. and commercial and industrial loan growth is leading the pack, galloping higher and breaching the 10%/annum mark. Bankers are providing the needed fuel to bring to fruition industrials capex plans and, given that historically loan growth and relative profit growth have been positively correlated, the current message is upbeat (Chart 7). Chart 7Loan Growth Fueling The Fire Chinese easy policy trifecta: credit, fiscal & monetary. Beyond the positive resolution in the U.S./China trade dispute, China has opened up its central bank liquidity tap to complement ongoing easy monetary policy. Tack on the recent monster loan origination and reaccelerating infrastructure spending and factors are falling into place for a pick up in end demand, which is a boon for U.S. capitals goods producers (Chart 8). Chart 8Heed The Chinese Reflation Message... Upbeat signal from high frequency EM related financial market data. Emerging market stocks have been outperforming the MSCI ACW Index since early-October and even in absolute terms have troughed in late-October. The ultimate leading EM indicator, EM FX, put in a bottom in early September, sniffing out some sort of reflationary impulse. Meanwhile, momentum in the CRB raw industrials commodity index has also troughed, confirming the high-frequency EM data points. As a reminder, industrials stocks and the global commodity complex move in lockstep, and we heed the positive message all these financial market indicators are emitting (Chart 9). Chart 9...EM Financial Variables Concur Downtrodden sector sentiment and compelling valuations. Despite this year’s rebound in industrial equities, sour investor sentiment appears deeply ingrained. Relative EPS breadth and oversold technical conditions are contrarily positive. Relative valuations are also beaten down and still offer a compelling entry point (Chart 10). Even on a forward P/E basis industrials are trading at a 4% discount to the broad market and below the historical average. Finally, industrials profit and revenue expectations for the coming 12-months are forecast to trail the broad market according to the sell-side community. Were our thesis to pan out, these would represent low hurdles for capital goods producers to surpass. Chart 10Underowned And Unloved Nevertheless, there is a key macro variable, the U.S. dollar, that is a risk to our sanguine S&P industrials sector view. Chart 11 shows that the greenback and industrials sector fortunes are tightly inversely correlated. Not only is an appreciating U.S. dollar deflationary for global commodities that are priced in the reserve currency, but it also weighs on industrials P&Ls via negative translation effects. As a reminder, roughly 40% of industrials sales are international. Chart 11Rising Greenback Is A Risk Netting it all out, the ongoing capex upcycle, resurgent credit growth, easy Chinese policy trifecta, upbeat signals from high frequency EM related financial markets and depressed technicals, all suggest that a re-rating phase looms in the S&P industrials sector.         Bottom Line: Stay overweight the S&P industrials sector. The Chip Cycle Is Turning It no longer pays to be bearish chip stocks; lift the S&P semiconductors index to neutral from underweight today. There are high odds that the chip cycle will soon take a turn for the better. Global chip sales have been decelerating for 17 months and are now on the cusp of contraction (Chart 12). Over the past two decades, steep contractions have been associated with recession. Given that BCA’s view does not call for recession this year, it is highly unlikely for global semi sales to suffer a major setback. While we do not rule out a brief and shallow dip below zero similar to the 2011/12 and 2015/16 parallels, leading indicators of global semi sales suggest that a trough is near. Chart 12Global Semi Cycle... Namely, BCA’s Global Leading Economic Indicator (GLEI) diffusion index is in a V-shaped recovery signaling that global growth is close to a nadir (middle panel, Chart 12). Similarly the U.S. dollar is decelerating which is a boon to global growth and conducive to higher global chip sales (trade-weighted U.S. dollar shown inverted, bottom panel, Chart 12). With regard to U.S. domiciled semi producers, a depreciating currency provides tremendous leverage to profits as foreign sourced revenues are roughly 80% of the total or twice as high compared with the SPX. Table 2, shows the one year trailing internationally- and China-derived revenues of the ten largest firms in the S&P semiconductors index, representing over 95% of the index. On a weighted basis, 80% of sales are sourced from overseas, including 36% of total sales coming from China. Clearly, global growth in general and Chinese growth in particular are key drivers of semi top line growth. Thus, any positive U.S./China trade dispute resolution would provide more relief for the S&P semi index. Table 2Semi Sales Geographical Exposure Moreover, electronics activity is an excellent gauge for semi end-demand. The all-important Chinese electronics imports have ticked up recently. In the U.S., consumer outlays on electronics are firing on all cylinders. Taken together, there is tentative evidence that global semi demand will soon bottom (Chart 13). Chart 13...Is Turning Importantly, the global semi inventory liquidation is ongoing and this supply backdrop should help balance the market. Already Asian DRAM prices, our pricing power gauge for the semi industry, are contracting, underscoring that the semi market is clearing (second & third panels, Chart 14). Importantly, global semi billings that tend to lead global semi sales by a few months have also ticked higher of late (top panel, Chart 14). Chart 14Improving Supply/Demand Dynamics Unfortunately, none of these positive catalysts are picked up by sell-side analysts. In fact, despite the recent rebound in relative share prices, 12-month forward EPS and revenue expectations remain in free fall. Net EPS revisions are as bad as they get, and have sunk near previous troughs that have coincided with durable relative share price rallies (second panel, Chart 15). Chart 15Analysts Have Thrown In The Towel On the relative technical and valuation fronts, pessimism reigns supreme. Our Technical Indicator hovers near one standard deviation below the historical mean and our Valuation Indicator is probing all-time lows. Interestingly, the S&P semi index sports a higher dividend yield than the SPX currently, underscoring that semi stocks are cheap (Chart 16). Chart 16Compelling Valuations And Technicals Our Chip Stock Timing Model (CSTM) does an excellent job in capturing all these moving parts and is currently sending a bullish signal (Chart 17). We heed the signal from our CSTM and are compelled to lift exposure to neutral. Chart 17Prepare To Deploy Capital Bottom Line: Lift the S&P semiconductors index to neutral and it is now also on our upgrade watch list; we are looking for an opportunity to boost to overweight on a pullback, stay tuned. Finally, from a risk management perspective we are enticed to increase our trailing stop to 15% in our tactical overweight in the S&P semi equipment index, in order to protect gains. The ticker symbols for the stocks in the S&P semiconductors index are: BLBG: S5SECO – INTC, AVGO, TXN, NVDA, QCOM, MU, ADI, XLNX, AMD, MCHP, MXIM, SWKS, QRVO.   Anastasios Avgeriou, Vice President U.S. Equity Strategy anastasios@bcaresearch.com   Footnotes 1      Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, “Trader’s Paradise” dated January 28, 2019, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 2      Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, “Don’t Fight The PBoC” dated February 4, 2019, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. Current Recommendations Current Trades Size And Style Views Favor value over growth Favor large over small caps
Highlights Portfolio Strategy Chinese reflation, the ongoing global capex upcycle, and the Fed induced cap on the greenback with the knock-on effect of higher commodity prices, all signal that it still pays to overweight S&P cyclicals at the expense of S&P defensives.  Sustained EM stock outperformance, a soft U.S. dollar, improving semi equipment operating metrics, along with compelling relative valuations and technicals, all suggest that there are high odds that the recent semi equipment run up has more upside.   Recent Changes There are no changes in the portfolio this week. Feature The SPX consolidated the 350 point advance since the Christmas Eve trough last week, setting the stage for a durable advance in the coming months. The Fed stood pat last Wednesday, and signaled a much more dovish policy stance going forward. Chairman Powell was clearly humbled by last December’s convulsing equity market and abrupt tightening in financial conditions. On that front, in the latest FOMC statement the explicit mention of patience is significant: “the Committee will be patient as it determines what future adjustments to the target range for the federal funds rate may be appropriate”. A definitively more dovish Fed, which will help restrain the greenback, remains one of the three key catalysts for a durable equity market advance as we have highlighted in recent research.1 Encouragingly, our proprietary Equity Capitulation Indicator (ECI) has bottomed at two standard deviations below the historical mean (Chart 1). Over the past two decades, such a depressed level in our ECI has marked previous equity market troughs including the early-2016, 2011, 2002 and 1998 iterations. Only the GFC episode was lower, falling to three standard deviations below the mean. Clearly the late-December selling frenzy registers as another investor capitulation point and, if history at least rhymes, more gains are in store for the broad equity market. Chart 1Capitulation Chart 2 shows some other measures of breadth that corroborate our ECI’s message: investors hit the panic button and exited equities in droves in Q4. The upshot is that with selling exhausted, stocks can now stage a durable recovery as long as profits continue to expand. As a reminder, the continuation of the earnings juggernaut is the second key catalyst we identified two weeks ago.2 Midway through earnings season, SPX EPS have held up well with growth approaching 16%. For calendar 2019 we expect mid-single digit EPS growth in line with the signal from our macro driven S&P 500 EPS growth model (please refer to Chart 4 from the mid-January Weekly Publication).3 Chart 2Selling Is Exhausted A positive resolution to the U.S./China trade spat is the third catalyst we highlighted recently in order for equities to break out to fresh all-time highs.4 Related to this, China’s reflation efforts are equally important. On that front, news of quasi QE from the PBOC suggests that the Chinese authorities remain committed to injecting liquidity into their economy.5 Already, the PBOC balance sheet, with over $5.5tn in assets, is expanding anew. Empirical evidence suggests that SPX momentum and the ebb and flow of the PBOC balance sheet are joined at the hip, and the current message is positive (second panel, Chart 3). Chart 3Heed The PBoC Message Beyond the PBOC balance sheet expansion, the Chinese six-month credit impulse is also in a sling shot recovery. This Chinese credit backdrop is enticing and moves more or less in tandem with the SPX six-month impulse (top panel, Chart 4). Chart 4Reflating Away Two forces explain these relationships. First, China’s rise to become the second largest economy in the world along with its insatiable appetite for commodities and durable goods. Second, 40% of S&P 500 sales are international and an increasing share now originates in emerging markets in general and in China in particular. Keep in mind that the S&P cyclicals/defensives ratio is not only a high beta play on the SPX itself (top panel, Chart 3), but also an S&P global versus domestic gauge. Thus, both of these Chinese indicators also enjoy a positive correlation with the cyclicals vs. defensives tilt (bottom panels, Charts 3 & 4). With that in mind, this week we are drilling deeper into why we continue to prefer S&P cyclicals over S&P defensives and also highlight a highly cyclical index we went overweight in mid-December that has gone parabolic. Double Down On Cyclicals Vs. Defensives Early-October 2017 marks the initiation of our cyclical vs. defensive preference. Initially, this tilt jumped and peaked in mid-2018 returning 18% since inception. Since then, it has given up all of those gains and then some before troughing with the market on Christmas Eve, suffering a 6% drop since inception. Currently, the ratio has moved full circle and is back to where it was when we first recommended this portfolio bent (Chart 5). Chart 5Full Circle Should investors commit capital to this tilt at this stage of the cycle and given the current global macro backdrop? The short answer is yes. Charts 3 & 4 show that China’s reflation efforts and the fate of the S&P cyclicals/defensives ratio are closely correlated. In addition to the PBOC’s expanding balance sheet and rising Chinese credit impulse, Chinese monetary easing also benefits S&P cyclicals at the expense of S&P defensives. The Chinese reserve requirement ratio (RRR) has plummeted to the lowest point since the GFC and Chinese interest rates are also plumbing multi-year lows (RRR shown inverted, top panel, Chart 6). Chart 6China Flashing Green Tack on a resurgent currency with the CNY briefly breaking 6.70 with the U.S. dollar, and factors are falling into place for a playable rally in the cyclicals/defensive ratio. Likely, the Chinese are trying to appease President Trump by underpinning the yuan, but the Fed’s recent more dovish stance on interest rate hikes is also pushing the greenback lower. Taken together, this is a boon for the commodity exposed U.S. cyclicals that also garner a significant share of their sales from abroad (bottom panel, Chart 6). Commodity prices troughed last September, staying true to their leading properties and have been in recovery mode ever since (top panel, Chart 7). Now that the Fed has capped the U.S. dollar, more gains are in store for commodities and that is a boon for commodity producers’ top line growth prospects. Chart 7Capex Remains Healthy The demand backdrop is also enticing at the current stage of the business cycle, not only domestically, but also in China. Capital outlays remain upbeat and despite some recent turbulence, U.S. capex intentions are near multi-year highs (third panel, Chart 7). In China, recent piece meal fiscal easing announcements are far from negligible; already infrastructure spending has jumped after contracting late last year (second panel, Chart 7). Were these announcements to get supplemented by a bigger and more comprehensive package, then commodity-levered equities will excel further. A look at the relative balance sheet health of cyclicals versus defensives is revealing. Cyclicals are paying down debt and their cash flow continues to improve, still recovering from the late-2015/early 2016 global manufacturing recession. On the flipside, defensives are piling on debt. All four safe haven sectors have been degrading their balance sheets (relative net debt-to-EBITDA shown inverted, middle panel, Chart 8). Interest coverage sends a similar message: cyclicals are in excellent health both in absolute terms and compared with defensives (top panel, Chart 8). Chart 8B/S Improvement Continues Sell-side analysts have not yet taken notice of the macro tide that is turning in favor of cyclicals over defensives. Relative forward profit growth has collapsed to nil and net EPS revisions are at previous nadirs (fourth & fifth panels, Chart 9). Chart 9Oversold And Unloved In sum, if our thesis pans out that China will continue to reflate, global capex will remain vibrant, the greenback will drift lower (U.S. dollar shown inverted, top panel, Chart 9) courtesy of a dovish Fed that will push the broad commodity complex higher, then a significant valuation rerating looms for the cyclicals/defensives tilt (second panel, Chart 9). Bottom Line: Continue to the prefer S&P cyclicals to S&P defensives. We also reiterate our recent long S&P materials/short S&P utilities pair trade.6 Semi Equipment: Buy Into Strength In mid-December we boosted the S&P semi equipment index to overweight from underweight and since then this niche chip subindex has outperformed the broad market by 17%.7 Semi equipment stocks are high beta (bottom panel, Chart 10) and, while we are recommending to buy into strength, from a portfolio risk management perspective, today we are also setting a trailing stop at the 10% return mark in order to protect profits in this tactical (three-to-six month time horizon) position. Chart 10Buy Into Strength... These high-octane highly-cyclical tech stocks move in lockstep with other volatile asset classes. Rebounding emerging market (EM) stocks and FX confirm the S&P semi equipment breakout, and signal additional gains in the coming months (Chart 11). Not only do they share the high-beta status, but also semi equipment stocks garner 90% of their sales outside U.S. shores and 21% of total revenues come from China (please refer to Table 3 in our December 17, 2018 Weekly Report). Thus, the tight inverse correlation with the greenback and positive correlation with the outperforming EM stocks comes as no surprise (Chart 11). Chart 11...But Expect Heightened Vol Importantly, Taiwan and Korea are chip manufacturing hubs and semi equipment stocks are levered plays on the macro backdrops of these two economies. Recent data suggests that a turn is in the making in two key indicators in these countries, respectively. Taiwanese tech capex has likely troughed at a depressed level (middle panel. Chart 12), and Korean electronic components manufacturing capacity is now contracting for the first time since late-1997 (bottom panel, Chart 12). The latter is significant as this abrupt and sizable reining in of productive capacity will soon help arrest the fall in chip prices, which serves as an excellent pricing power proxy for the semi equipment industry. Chart 12Green Shoots Historically, relative forward profit growth and DRAM price momentum are joined at the hip. Therefore, were DRAM prices to exit deflation on the back of constrained Korean capacity, that would be a boon for relative profit prospects (second panel, Chart 13). Chart 13Analysts Have Thrown In The Towel Despite these marginal positive developments, sell-side analysts’ pessimism reigns supreme. Industry revenue and profit growth expectations trail the broad market by a wide margin and net EPS revisions remain as bad as they get. The upshot is that these lowered profit and sales growth bars will be easy to surpass in 2019 (Chart 13). With regard to technicals and valuations, oversold conditions bounced, as we posited in mid-December using history as a guide, but still remain depressed (middle panel, Chart 14). Valuations are compelling with the S&P semi equipment forward P/E trading at a roughly 40% discount to the overall market (fourth panel, Chart 13). Chart 14Technicals Remain Depressed Finally, earnings season has revealed that the bifurcated semiconductor market has staying power with semi equipment stocks (we are overweight) outperforming their ailing semi producer brethren (we remain underweight). Netting it out, sustained EM stock outperformance, a soft U.S. dollar, improving industry operating metrics, along with compelling relative valuations and technicals, all suggest that there are high odds that the recent semi equipment run up has more upside. Bottom Line: Maintain the overweight stance in the S&P semi equipment index for a while longer, but set a trailing stop at the 10% relative return mark in order to protect profits in this tactical (three-to-six month time horizon) position. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5SEEQ – AMAT, LRCX, KLAC.   Anastasios Avgeriou, Vice President U.S. Equity Strategy anastasios@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1      Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, “Dissecting 2019 Earnings” dated January 22, 2019, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 2      Ibid. 3      Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Report, “Catharsis” dated January 14, 2019, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 4      Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, “Dissecting 2019 Earnings” dated January 22, 2019, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 5      Please see Bloomberg Article, “PBOC Sets Up Swap Tool to Aid Bank Capital via Perpetual Bonds” dated January 24, 2019, available at www.bloomberg.com. 6      Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Report, “Trader’s Paradise” dated January 28, 2019, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. 7      Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Report, “Signal Vs. Noise” dated December 17, 2018, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. Current Recommendations Current Trades Size And Style Views Favor value over growth Favor large over small caps
Special Report Highlights On the bright side, Malaysia’s structural backdrop is improving notably, especially in the semiconductors segment. Yet the cyclical growth outlook remains downbeat. While we are maintaining a market-weight allocation to Malaysian equities within an EM equity portfolio, we are putting this bourse on our upgrade watch list. As a play on the ameliorating structural outlook, we recommend an overweight position in Malaysian small-cap stocks relative to the EM universe – both the small-cap and overall equity benchmarks. Feature Malaysian stocks have performed quite poorly in recent years: the equity index, in U.S. dollars, is close to its 2016 lows in absolute terms, and relative to the emerging markets (EM) benchmark, it is not far from the lows of last decade (Chart I-1). Chart I-1Malaysian Stocks & Commodities Prices: Tight Relationship Odds are that a structural bottom in this bourse’s relative performance versus the EM index may have been reached. Hence, we are putting Malaysian equities on our upgrade watch list while maintaining a market-weight allocation due to tactical considerations. On the negative side, the past credit excesses have not been recognized and provisioned for by Malaysian commercial banks. The latter account for a notable 34% of the MSCI Malaysia index, and they will be a drag on this bourse's performance. Absolute performance also still hinges on global growth, commodities prices and the overall direction of Asian/EM markets. We are still negative on these parameters. Critically, there are various signs indicating an ameliorating structural backdrop in Malaysia. The country is undergoing notable improvements in the semiconductor sector, thereby reducing its dependence on commodities and increasing its exposure to a high-value industry. To capitalize on this theme of an improving structural backdrop, we are recommending an overweight position in Malaysian small-cap stocks relative to the EM universe – both the small-cap and overall equity benchmarks. Shifting Away From Commodities And Toward Electronics Parting Ways With Commodities Malaysia and its financial markets have been very exposed to commodities prices over the past 15 years or so (Chart I-1, top panel). Nevertheless, the country seems to be shifting away from its considerable reliance on the resource sector and moving into other value-added segments: in particular, semiconductors and technology. Such a structural shift – if successful – would be an extremely positive development as it would lead to rising productivity gains and higher per capita income growth. In short, the country would be able to achieve higher rates of sustainable non-inflationary growth, feeding into a sustainable bull market in Malaysian equities. Several points are noteworthy in this regard: The real output of crude and petroleum products as well as palm oil are declining sharply relative to the economy’s real total output (Chart I-2). Chart I-2Malaysia's Commodities Output Is Falling In Importance Exports volumes of palm oil, crude oil and natural gas have all been falling relative to Malaysia’s total overseas shipment volumes (Chart I-3). Chart I-3Commodities Export Volumes Are Declining In Relative Terms Crude oil, gas, and palm oil now account for 4%, 5%, and 7% of total exports in value terms, respectively. Crucially, not only is the importance of commodities in the overall Malaysian economy diminishing in volume terms, it is also falling in nominal terms due to low resource prices. For instance, net export revenues from fuel (i.e. crude oil, petroleum and natural gas) have fallen from US$18 billion in 2013 to US$5 billion today (Chart I-4, top panel). Chart I-4Commodities' Net Export Revenues Are Also Diminishing Meanwhile, net exports of palm oil (and other plant-based fats) have dropped from US$20 billion to US$10 billion (Chart I-4, bottom panel). Improvement In High-Value-Added Manufacturing There are also some positive structural signs taking place in the Malaysian economy that are signaling an improvement in productivity and competitiveness: Malaysian export volumes of machinery and transport equipment are expanding in absolute terms as well as relative to overall export volumes (Chart I-5, top and middle panels). Chart I-5Malaysia's Machinery Exports Are Rocking Remarkably, Malaysian aggregate export volumes are quickly regaining lost global market share (Chart I-5, bottom panel). Further, the ratio of exports to imports has hit a structural bottom and is slowly picking up in volume terms (Chart I-6). Chart I-6Malaysian Overall Exports Are Regaining Lost Market Share This suggests some improvements in the competitiveness of domestic industries is slowly underway. Meanwhile, Malaysian high-skill and technology intensive exports as a share of global high-tech exports seem to have made a major bottom in U.S. dollar terms and will begin to rise (Chart I-7). Chart I-7Bottom In Malaysia's High-Tech Global Share? Advanced education enrollment is high and improving – and is only outpaced by Korea and China in emerging Asia (Chart I-8). Importantly, Malaysia has among the best demographics of mainstream developing countries. The working age population as a share of the total population will continue to be high all the way to 2040. Chart I-8Malaysians Like Going To School Malaysian expenditures on R&D have also been on the rise, outpacing a lot of other countries in the region (Chart I-9, top panel). R&D expenditures in Malaysia could also be catching up to Singapore’s (Chart I-9, bottom panel). Chart I-9Malaysia's Expenditure On R&D Is Rising In line with these positives, net FDIs into Malaysia have been rising briskly (Chart I-10). Importantly, these investments have been driven by European companies, meaning the latter are transferring valuable technological know-how to Malaysia. Chart I-10Net FDIs Are Rising The Malaysian ringgit is cheap (Chart I-11) and has reached almost two-decade lows against many Asian currencies. This makes Malaysia increasingly more competitive. Chart I-11The Ringgit Is Cheap Finally, our colleagues from the Geopolitical Strategy team believe that the recently elected Pakatan Harapan government will improve governance and transparency, which had significantly deteriorated under Najib Razak’s rule. A Marriage To Electronics Malaysia is attempting to reestablish itself as a major semiconductor hub in the region. Remarkably, after declining for 15 years, semiconductor exports are finally rising as a share of GDP (Chart I-12) and Malaysian semiconductor exports are outperforming those of its neighbors. Chart I-12Malaysian Semiconductor Exports Are Booming The Malaysian government since 2010, has identified the semiconductor sector as a key area for development and prosperity. In turn, it has been introducing programs and setting up institutions to support the industry. The 2019 budget reinforces the government’s priority to develop the sector. Several anecdotal observations confirm that Malaysia is moving up the value chain in the semiconductor industry, and is going beyond simple testing and assembly: Growing the semiconductor cluster: The Malaysian Institute of Microelectronic Systems (MIMOS) has established a shared services platform for advanced analytical services in the semiconductor industry to provide support to Malaysian semiconductor companies. The Economic Industrial Design Centre (EIDC) is also providing support to SMEs in order to enhance their efficiency. Similarly, the Semiconductor Fabrication Association of Malaysia (SFAM) has been partnering with local universities to enhance their engineering programs and offer training, internships and research opportunities for students. Developing home-grown semiconductors: In 2015, Malaysian public institutions in partnership with private companies developed the Green Motion Controller (GMS), an integrated circuit that reduces energy consumption. This semiconductor is an energy efficient controller that carries applications in hybrid cars and air conditioners, among other things. Nanotechnology: NanoMalaysia – a nanotechnology commercialization agency – is providing services to SMEs and start-ups to help increase their competitiveness by enabling them to upgrade to more efficient production methods. Light-emitting Diode (LED) manufacturing: Malaysia is becoming a hub for the manufacturing of energy efficient LED chips. This is the result of OSRAM’s – a German light manufacturer – large investment in a high-tech production facility. There are early signs already that the above developments are beginning to bear results. Chart I-13 shows that the difference between exports and imports of semiconductors (in U.S. dollars) have been surging. This shows Malaysia is able to add greater value to the semiconductors it imports and then re-exports. Chart I-13Malaysia Adds Value To The Semis It Imports Bottom Line: Commodities are declining in importance to the Malaysian economy. Meanwhile, Malaysia’s structural backdrop is improving as the semiconductor and hardware technology segments are rising in prominence. Cyclical Weakness Despite the positive structural backdrop, Malaysia’s cyclical outlook remains challenging. Our view on commodities and global trade continues to be negative. Not only are commodities prices deflating but semiconductor prices are also falling, and their global shipments are weakening (Chart I-14). Chart I-14Cyclical Weakness In Global Semiconductor Cycle The epicenter of the global trade slowdown, however, will be in Chinese construction activity. Consequently, industrial resources prices are more vulnerable than electronics in this global growth downturn. The above deflationary forces would negatively shock Asia’s growth outlook, and consequently Malaysian growth as well: The top panel of Chart I-15 shows that Malaysian narrow money growth has already rolled over decisively and is foreshadowing weaker bank loan growth. Chart I-15Malaysian Domestic Growth Set To Weaken Slower bank loan growth will weaken purchasing power and impact domestic consumption. The middle panel of Chart I-15 shows that car sales – having surged this summer because of the abolishment of the GST – are weakening anew. Malaysian companies and banks have among the largest foreign currency debt loads (Table I-1). We expect more currency depreciation in Malaysia, as we do in EM overall. This will make foreign currency debt more expensive to service, and consequently dampen companies’ and banks’ appetites for expansion. Table I-1Malaysia's External Debt Breakdown Finally, the real estate sector remains depressed. Property volume sales are contracting and have dropped to 2008 levels, and housing construction approvals are slumping (Chart I-16). Chart I-16Malaysia's Property Sector Is Depressed While this means that cleansing has been taking place in the property sector, the banking sector has not recognized NPLs and remains the weakest link in the Malaysian economy. Specifically, the top panel of Chart I-17 illustrates that the NPLs in the banking system still stand at a mere 1.5%. This is in spite of the fact that since 2009, non-financial private sector credit to GDP has risen significantly. Therefore, the true level of NPLs is probably considerably higher. Chart I-17Malaysian Banks Are Under-Provisioned Further, Malaysian banks have been lowering provisions to boost profits (Chart I-17, bottom panel). This is unsustainable. As growth weakens, Malaysian banks will see their NPLs rise and will need to raise provisions. Chart I-18 demonstrates that if provisions rise by 20%, bank operating earnings will contract and bank share prices would fall. Chart I-18Malaysian Banks' Share Prices Will Fall Bottom Line: Malaysia’s cyclical growth outlook is still feeble, with the banking system being the weakest link. Banks’ large weight in the equity index makes this bourse still vulnerable in the coming months. Optimal Macro Policy Mix Fiscal Consolidation… Fiscal policy is set to be tighter as per the Malaysian government budget announced on November 2 and its preference to pursue fiscal consolidation to reduce the deficit. The budget projects only a slight increase in expenditures in 2019, which means it will likely slowdown from 8% currently (Chart I-19). Chart I-19Government Expenditure Growth Will Soften The government will also recognize public-sector liabilities not presently shown on its balance sheet and strengthen both transparency and administrative efficiency. Critically, the budget also includes strategies to support the entrepreneurial part of the economy. Overall, this budget bodes very well for the structural outlook. Yet it will not support growth cyclically. …To Be Offset By Easy Monetary Policy Despite continued currency weakness, the Malaysian monetary authorities will not be in a hurry to raise interest rates to defend the ringgit. This is in contrast with other central banks in the region like Indonesia and the Philippines. This is presently an optimal policy mix for Malaysia and is positive for the stock market’s relative performance versus its counterparts in many other EMs. Malaysia’s structural inflation is low: core inflation hovers around zero. Therefore, the central bank will neither raise interest rates nor sell its foreign exchange reserves to defend the currency. Both currency depreciation and low interest rates are needed to mitigate the downturn in exports as well as offset fiscal consolidation. In the meantime, the ringgit is unlikely to depreciate in a sudden and vicious manner but rather will likely fall gradually. First, the current account will remain in surplus, even as global trade contracts. The basis is that if Malaysian exports fall, imports will simultaneously follow. The country imports a lot of intermediate goods to then process and re-export. Second, Malaysia is unlikely to witness pronounced capital flight as occurred in 2015. The new government has increased confidence in the economy among both locals and foreigners. In addition, net portfolio investments have been negative for a while. This means that a large amount of foreign capital has exited already, reducing the risk of further outflows. What’s more, foreign ownership of local currency bonds has fallen from 33% in June 2016 to 24% today. Moreover, at 28% of market cap, foreign ownership of equities is among the lowest in EM. These also limit potential foreign selling. Bottom Line: Policymakers are adopting a wise policy mix for the economy at the current juncture: tight fiscal and easy monetary policies. This is structurally positive, even if it does not preclude cyclical weakness. Investment Conclusions Weighing structural positives versus the cyclical growth weakness and the unhealthy banking system, we are maintaining a market-weight allocation to Malaysian stocks within the EM universe, but are placing this bourse on our upgrade watch list. We need to see a selloff in bank stocks before we upgrade it to overweight. Within Malaysian equities, we recommend shorting/underweighting banks and going long/overweighting small cap stocks. To capitalize on Malaysia’s improving structural growth outlook, we recommend buying Malaysian small caps, but hedging positions by shorting the EM aggregate or small-cap indexes. The ringgit is poised to depreciate further versus the U.S. dollar along with other EM/Asian currencies. We continue to short the ringgit versus the greenback. With respect to sovereign credit and local government bonds, dedicated portfolios should currently have a market-weight allocation. The negative cyclical growth outlook is offset by the right macro policy mix and improving growth potential.   Ayman Kawtharani, Associate Editor ayman@bcaresearch.com​​​​​​​ Equity Recommendations Fixed-Income, Credit And Currency Recommendations
The dramatic decline in semi equipment stocks has not been arrested in the Q3 earnings season, despite relatively positive results. We think the overall negative sentiment around global tech stocks in general and valuation high-flyers in particular has been…
Highlights The long term direction for the pound is higher... ...but as the EU withdrawal bill passes through the U.K. parliament, expect a very hairy ride. The stock markets in Norway, Sweden and Denmark are driven by energy, industrials, and biotech respectively. Upgrade Sweden to neutral and downgrade Denmark to underweight. Think of semiconductors as twenty-first century commodities. Overweight the semiconductor sector versus broader technology indexes. Chart of the WeekBritish Public Opinion On Brexit Is Shifting Feature The Brexit drama is playing out exactly as scripted (Chart I-2). Chart I-2The Pound Is Following The Brexit Drama In July, we wrote: "The U.K. government's much hyped 'Chequers' proposal for Brexit risks getting a cold shower... the EU27 will almost instantaneously reject the proposed division between goods and services as 'cherry-picking' from its indivisible four freedoms - goods, services, capital, and people... the rejection will be based not just on the EU's founding principles, but also on the practical realities of a modern economy - specifically, the distinction between goods and services has become increasingly blurred." 1 Hence, the Chequers proposal to avoid a hard border between Northern Ireland and the Irish Republic is just wishful thinking: "The Irish border trilemma will remain unsolved, leaving a 'backstop' option of Northern Ireland remaining in the EU single market - an outcome that will be politically unpalatable." 2 What happens next? Understanding Brexit In a sense, Brexit is very simple. The EU27 sees only three options for the long-term political and economic relationship between the U.K. and the EU. Remain in the EU (no Brexit). Plug into an off-the-shelf setup, either the European Economic Area (EEA), European Free Trade Association (EFTA), or a permanent customs union, which already establish the EU relationship with Norway, Iceland, Liechtenstein, and Switzerland (soft Brexit). Become a 'third country' to the EU like, for example, Canada (hard Brexit). The first option, to stay in the EU, is politically impossible unless a new U.K. referendum overturned the original referendum's vote to leave. The second option, to join the EEA, EFTA, or permanent customs union is very difficult for Theresa May - because it is strongly opposed by many of the Conservative government's ministers and members of parliament who regard the option as 'Brino' (Brexit in name only). However, in a significant recent development, the opposition leader Jeremy Corbyn has committed the Labour party to a Brexit that keeps the U.K. in a permanent customs union.3 The third option, to become a 'third country', would very likely require some sort of border in Ireland. As already discussed, the only way to avoid a border would be a perfect alignment between the U.K and EU on tariffs and regulations for goods and services. But then, there would be little point in becoming a third country. Here's the crucial issue. The EU27 does not know which option the U.K. will eventually take, yet it must provide an 'all-weather' safeguard for the Good Friday peace agreement, requiring no border between Northern Ireland and the Irish Republic. Therefore, the EU27 will need the withdrawal agreement to commit: either the whole of the U.K. to a potentially permanent customs union with the EU; or Northern Ireland to a potentially permanent customs separation from the rest of the U.K. - in effect, breaking up the U.K by creating a border between Britain and Northern Ireland. Clearly, the hard Brexiters and/or Northern Ireland unionist MPs will vote down a withdrawal bill which contains either of these commitments, thereby wiping out Theresa May's slender majority. The intriguing question is: might Labour MPs - or enough of them - vote for a potentially permanent customs union to get the soft Brexit they want? Labour would be torn between the national interest and the party interest, as it would be missing a golden opportunity to topple the Conservative government. If the withdrawal bill musters a majority, it would remove the prospect of a 'no deal' Brexit and the pound would rally - because it would liberate the Bank of England to hike interest rates more aggressively (Chart I-3 and Chart I-4). If the bill failed, the government and specifically Theresa May would be badly wounded. She might call a general election there and then. Chart I-3Absent Brexit, U.K. Interest Rates Would Be Higher Chart I-4Absent Brexit, U.K. Interest Rates Would Be Higher If May limped on, parliament would nevertheless have the final say on whether to proceed with a no deal Brexit. And the parliamentary arithmetic indicates that a clear majority of MPs would vote against proceeding over the cliff-edge. At this point with the government paralysed, the only way to unlock the paralysis would be to go back to the people. Either in a general election or in a new referendum, the key issue for the public would be a choice between one of the three aforementioned options for the U.K./EU long-term relationship - because by then, it would be clear that those are the only options on offer. Based on a clear recent shift in British public opinion, the preference is more likely to be for a soft (or no) Brexit than to become a third country (Chart of the Week). Bottom Line: The long term direction for the pound is higher but, as the withdrawal bill passes through parliament, expect a very hairy ride. Understanding Scandinavian Stock Markets The Scandinavian countries - Norway, Sweden, and Denmark - have many things in common: their languages, cultures, and lifestyles, to name just a few. However, when it comes to their stock markets, the three countries could not be more different. Looking at the three bourses, each has a defining dominant sector (or sectors) whose market weighting swamps all others. In Norway, oil and gas accounts for over 40 percent of the market; in Sweden, industrials accounts for 30 percent of the market and financials accounts for another 30 percent; and in Denmark, healthcare accounts for 50 percent of the market (Table I-1). Table I-1The Scandinavian Stock Markets Could Not Be More Different! In a sense, the dominant equity market sectors in Norway and Sweden just reflect their economies. Norway has a large energy sector; Sweden specializes in advanced industrial equipment and machinery and it also has very high level of private sector indebtedness, explaining the outsized weighting in banks. However, Denmark's equity market - dominated as it is by Novo Nordisk, which is essentially a biotech company - has little connection with Denmark's economy. The important point is that the four dominant sectors - oil and gas, industrials, financials, and biotech - each outperform or underperform as global (or at least pan-regional) sectors. If oil and gas outperforms, it outperforms everywhere and not just locally. It follows that the relative performance of the four dominant equity sectors drives the relative stock market performances of Norway, Sweden, and Denmark. Norway versus Sweden = Energy versus Industrials (Chart I-5) Chart I-5Norway Vs. Sweden = Energy Vs. Industrials Norway versus Denmark = Energy versus Biotech (Chart I-6) Chart I-6Norway Vs. Denmark = Energy Vs. Biotech Sweden versus Denmark = Industrials and Financials versus Biotech (Chart I-7) Chart I-7Sweden Vs. Denmark = Industrials And Financials Vs. Biotech Last week, we upgraded some of the more classical cyclical sectors to a relative overweight. Our argument was that if an inflationary impulse is dominating, beaten-down cyclicals have more upside than the more richly-valued equity sectors; and if a disinflationary impulse from higher bond yields is dominating, its main casualty will be the more richly-valued equity sectors. On this basis, our ranking of the four sectors is: Industrials, Financials, Energy, Biotech. Which means the ranking of the Scandinavian stock markets is: Sweden, Norway, Denmark. Bottom Line: From a pan-European perspective, upgrade Sweden to neutral and downgrade Denmark to underweight. Understanding Semiconductors The best way to understand semiconductors is to think of them as twenty-first century commodities. In the twentieth century, many everyday goods and products contained a classical commodity such as copper. Today, the ubiquity of electronic gadgets, devices, and screens contains a twenty-first century equivalent: the microchip. Hence, semiconductors are to the tech world what classical commodities are to the non-tech world. They exhibit exactly the same cycle of relative performance. If, as we expect, beaten-down industrial commodities outperform, it follows that the beaten-down semiconductor sector will outperform broader technology indexes (Chart I-8). Chart I-8Semiconductors Follow The Commodity Cycle Bottom Line: Overweight the semiconductor sector versus technology. Dhaval Joshi, Senior Vice President Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com 1 For example, the sale of a car is no longer the sale of just a good. As car companies often structure the financing of the car purchase, a car purchase can be a hybrid of a good - the car itself, and a service - the financing package. Therefore, a single market for cars requires a single market for both goods and services. 2 The Irish border trilemma comprises: 1. the U.K./EU land border between Northern Ireland and the Irish Republic; 2. the Good Friday peace agreement requiring the absence of any physical border within Ireland; 3.the Northern Ireland unionists' refusal to countenance a U.K./EU border at the Irish Sea, which would entail a customs border between Northern Ireland and the rest of the U.K. 3 At the Labour Party's just-held 2018 conference, Jeremy Corbyn made a commitment to joining a permanent U.K./EU customs union. Fractal Trading Model* This week's recommended trade comes from Down Under. The 25% outperformance of Australian telecoms (driven by Telstra) versus insurers (driven by IAG and AMP) over the past 3 months appears technically extended, with a 65-day fractal dimension at a level that has regularly indicated the start of a countertrend move. Therefore, the recommended trade is short Australian telecoms versus insurers, setting a profit target of 7% and a symmetrical stop-loss. In other trades, long CRB Industrial commodities versus MSCI World Index achieved its profit target very quickly, leaving four open trades. For any investment, excessive trend following and groupthink can reach a natural point of instability, at which point the established trend is highly likely to break down with or without an external catalyst. An early warning sign is the investment's fractal dimension approaching its natural lower bound. Encouragingly, this trigger has consistently identified countertrend moves of various magnitudes across all asset classes. Chart I-9 The post-June 9, 2016 fractal trading model rules are: When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. Use the position size multiple to control risk. The position size will be smaller for more risky positions. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report "Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model," dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading Model Recommendations Equities Bond & Interest Rates Currency & Other Positions Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart I-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart I-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart I-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart I-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Interest Rate Chart I-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart I-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart I-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart I-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations
Underweight In yesterday's Daily Insight, we highlighted our neutral barbell portfolio in tech, staying overweight secular growth defensive tech sub-sectors (namely S&P software and S&P tech hardware, storage & peripherals, both of which are high-conviction overweights) and underweight the hyper-cyclical chip and chip equipment stocks. With respect to the latter, we think the macro environment has deteriorated. Three factors underpin our negative view on semi equipment's growth prospects and there is no light at the end of the tunnel yet. Bitcoin's (and other cryptocurrencies) collapse is dealing a blow, at the margin, to demand for semi equipment (second panel). Taiwan's financials statement-reported data on IT capex and national data on overall Taiwanese capital outlays corroborates this downbeat demand backdrop (third panel). Finally, the drubbing in EM currencies is sapping purchasing power from the consumer and also warns that things will get worse for U.S. semi equipment stocks before they get better (bottom panel). Bottom Line: Continue to avoid the S&P semis and S&P semi equipment indexes; see Monday's Weekly Report for more details. The ticker symbols for the stocks in these indexes are: BLBG: S5SECO - INTC, NVDA, QCOM, TXN, AVGO, MU, ADI, AMD, MCHP, XLNX, SWKS, QRVO, and BLBG: S5SEEQ - AMAT, LRCX, KLAC, respectively.
Highlights Portfolio Strategy Stick with a neutral weighting in the tech sector as rising interest rates, higher inflation and a firming greenback offset improving industry operating metrics on the back of the virtuous capex upcycle. Chip and chip equipment stocks will remain under pressure as global semi sales are under attack and leading indicators of semi demand suggest that more pain lies ahead at a time when chip selling prices are steeply decelerating. Recent Changes There are no changes to our portfolio this week. Table 1 Feature Equities regained their footing last week and remain perched near all-time highs. Investors are largely ignoring the trade-related uncertainty and are instead focusing on the upbeat economic backdrop. Both soft and hard data continue to send an unambiguously healthy signal for the U.S. economy, a potent tonic for corporate profitability. Chart 1EPS Will Do All The Heavy Lifting While a lot of parallels have been drawn between today and the late-1990s, our sense is that the current financial market and economic outlooks resemble more the mid-2000s. Chart 1 shows that, between 2004 and the stock market peak in late-October 2007, forward profit growth estimates peaked at over 20%/annum and the forward multiple drifted steadily lower. Nevertheless, stocks remained well bid and rose alongside forward EPS (top and third panels, Chart 1). In other words, despite decelerating forward profit growth estimates and a contracting forward multiple, expanding forward EPS did the heavy lifting, explaining all of the advance in the SPX. The similarities to today are eerie: while profit growth peaked in Q1/2018, 10% EPS growth is elevated for the tenth year of an expansion, and the forward multiple is coming in (Chart 1). On the policy front, the Bush tax cuts hit in the mid-2000s with the elimination of the double taxation of dividends and a drop in personal income tax rates, along with a one-time cash repatriation of corporate profits stashed abroad. With regard to the economic backdrop, capex was roaring and nominal GDP was firing on all cylinders as a housing bubble was getting inflated. The GDP deflator also hit a high mark. The ISM manufacturing survey eclipsed 61 in 2004 and non-farm payrolls were expanding smartly (Chart 2). But despite all that apparent overheating especially in the housing market, the real fed funds rate was near zero in 2004 (top panel, Chart 3). Finally, a number of financial market metrics were also similar to today. Oil prices were on their way to triple digits, high yield spreads were below 400bps and the VIX probed, at the time, all-time lows (Chart 3). However, one key difference between the mid-2000s and today is the strengthening U.S. dollar. The firming greenback remains a key risk to our positive equity market view (bottom panel, Chart 3), as it will eventually infiltrate EPS. Netting it all out, if history at least rhymes, an earnings-led advance in the SPX is the most likely outcome. Our sanguine cyclical (9-12 month) equity market view remains predicated on a 10%/annum increase in EPS and a sideways-to-lower move in the forward multiple. Meanwhile, wage inflation is slowly starting to rear its ugly head. In fact, we are surprised by the fits and starts in average hourly earnings growth. At this stage of the cycle, wage growth should start galloping higher as executives aggressively bid up the price of labor in order to fill job openings and bring expansion plans to fruition. A simple wage growth indicator comprising resource utilization and the unemployment gap suggests that wage inflation will really kick into higher gear in the coming 12 months (shown as a Z-score, Chart 4). Chart 2Eerie... Chart 3...Parallels With 2004 Chart 4Mind The Return Of Inflation Two weeks ago we highlighted that the S&P 500's profit margins are benefiting from lower corporate taxes and muted wage growth, a goldilocks backdrop. Despite evidence of a pending inflationary impulse, as long as businesses are successful in passing rising input costs down the supply chain and onto the consumer, then margins and EPS will continue to expand. Nevertheless, deconstructing the SPX's all-time high profit margins is in order. Chart 5 & Chart 6 show the 11 GICS1 sector profit margin time series using Standard & Poor's data, and Chart 7 is a snapshot of Q2/2018 profit margins for the 11 sectors and the broad market. Chart 5Sectorial Profit ... Chart 6...Margin Breakdown Chart 7Tech Is A Clear Outlier Five sectors (tech, industrials, materials, consumer discretionary and utilities) are enjoying record-high profit margins, and four (financials, consumer staples, telecom services and real estate) are on the verge of joining that club. This leaves two sectors with declining margin profiles: health care and energy. While most sectors are +/- five percentage points away from the S&P 500, the tech sector sports profit margins at twice the level of the SPX or eleven percentage points higher and is the clear outlier (Chart 7). The implication is that the broad market's EPS fortunes are closely tied to the high-flying tech sector that commands a 26% market cap weight. Thus, this week we are compelled to highlight the deep cyclical tech sector, and two of its hyper-sensitive and foreign exposed subcomponents. Tech On Steroids In late-August we published a chart on tech margins (which we are reprinting today) showing the upward force they have exerted on the broad equity market for the better part of the past decade (top panel, Chart 8). Naturally, stratospheric profits must underpin these parabolic margins. The middle panel of Chart 8 highlights that since 2006 tech EPS have almost quadrupled, pulling SPX profits higher. As a reminder, the S&P tech sector commands a 24% profit weight in the S&P 500, the highest since the history of this data series and almost double the weight during the previous cycle's peak (bottom panel, Chart 8). The implication is that in order for the broad market to suffer a severe blow, tech has to take a hit, and vice versa. Chart 8Secular Tech EPS Growth Has Boosted Margins Chart 9EPS Growth Model Flashing Green On the EPS front, our profit growth model has recently ticked higher from an already extended level, signaling that the profit outlook remains bright (Chart 9). The virtuous capex upcycle - BCA's key theme for the year - remains the key driver behind our EPS model. Chart 10 shows that the tech sector continues to make inroads in the overall capex pie, according to financial statement-reported data, and has now doubled its share since the GFC trough to roughly 12%. National accounts corroborate this data and underscore that pent up demand is getting unleashed, following a near 15-year hibernation period (bottom panel, Chart 10). The news on the operating front is equally encouraging. The San Francisco Fed's tech pulse index - an index of coincident indicators of technology sector activity1 - is reaccelerating. Tech new orders-to-inventories are also picking up steam and suggest that sell side analysts have set the relative EPS bar too low (Chart 11). Finally, the latest PCE report revealed that consumer outlays on tech goods are also gaining momentum, even relative to overall consumer spending. While this upbeat backdrop would point to an above benchmark tech allocation, three risks keep us at bay. First, the tech sector garners 60% of its revenues from abroad and thus the appreciating U.S. dollar is a significant profit headwind, especially for 2019 when the delayed negative FX translation effects will most likely emerge (third panel, Chart 12). Chart 10Capex On The Upswing... Chart 11...Underpinning Tech Operating Metrics... Chart 12...But Three Risks Keep Us At Bay Second, a rising U.S. inflation backdrop along with the related looming selloff in the bond market should knock the wind out of the tech sector's sails. Tech business models are built to withstand deflation and thrive in a disinflationary environment. Thus, when inflation re-emerges, tech stocks suffer (CPI and 10-year UST yield shown inverted, top two panels, Chart 12). Third, leading indicators of emerging Asian demand are souring rapidly and were the trade war to re-escalate, EM in general and tech-laden Korean and Taiwanese economic data in particular would retrench further (bottom panel, Chart 12). Bottom Line: We prefer to remain on the sidelines in the S&P information technology sector and sustain a barbell portfolio within the sector. As a reminder we continue to express our bullishness via two high-conviction overweight defensive tech sub-sectors, S&P software and S&P tech hardware, storage & peripherals (THSP), and our bearishness via avoiding their early cyclical peers, S&P semis and S&P semi equipment. Avoid Chip Stocks At All Costs While we are neutral the broad tech sector and prefer secular growth defensive tech sub-sectors, we continue to recommend shying away from chip and chip equipment stocks. Chart 13 shows the extreme sensitivity to changes in final demand of chip related stocks versus their defensive tech peers. In more detail, software and THSP indexes are in a secular advance with regard to EPS outperformance, whereas semis and semi equipment profits are hyper-cyclical with mean-reverting relative profit profiles. Granted, the commoditization of semiconductors explains this close correlation with the business cycle. But, as we highlighted last November when we put the semi equipment index on the high-conviction underweight list, extrapolating EPS growth euphoria far into the future was fraught with danger.2 In fact, late-November 2017 marked the peak in semi equipment performance versus the overall IT sector, confirming the early cyclical nature of chip stocks (Chart 14). Chart 13Bifurcated EPS Chart 14Good Times... Three factors have weighed heavily on this industry's growth prospects and there is no light at the end of the tunnel yet. Bitcoin's (and other cryptocurrencies) collapse is dealing a blow, at the margin, to demand for semi equipment (top panel, Chart 15). Taiwan's financials statement-reported data on IT capex and national data on overall Taiwanese capital outlays corroborates this downbeat demand backdrop (Chart 16). Finally, the drubbing in EM currencies is sapping purchasing power from the consumer and also warns that things will get worse for U.S. semi equipment stocks before they get better (bottom panel, Chart 15). Chart 15...Do Not Last Forever Chart 16Semi-Heavy Taiwan Emits A Grim Signal The outlook for their brethren, semi producers, is equally downtrodden. Global semi sales have crested and leading indicators of future semi revenue growth are sending a warning signal. Chinese imports of electronics have come to an abrupt halt, and the U.S. dollar's appreciation is also waving a red flag (second & bottom panels, Chart 17). BCA's calculated global leading economic indicator excluding the U.S. and BCA's calculated global ZEW Indicator of Economic Sentiment excluding the U.S. both herald a steep deceleration in global semi sales (Chart 17). On the pricing power front, using Asian DRAM prices as an industry pricing power gauge, DRAM momentum is on a trajectory to contract some time in Q1/2019. The implication is that semi earnings will surprise to the downside. Still expanding global chip inventories are not providing an offset and also confirm that semi EPS optimism is unwarranted (middle & bottom panels, Chart 18). Finally, another source of demand for chip stocks has reversed, as industry M&A activity has plummeted toward decade lows. Not only is this negative for pricing power, but inflated premia are also now working in reverse especially given this year's QCOM/NXPI and AVGO/QCOM flops (top panel, Chart 18). Our Chip Stock Timing Model (CSTM) does an excellent job encapsulating all these moving parts and is currently in the sell zone (bottom panel, Chart 19). Chart 17Global Semi Sales Trouble... Chart 18...Abound Chart 19Chip Stock Timing Model Says Sell Bottom Line: Continue to avoid the S&P semis and S&P semi equipment indexes. The ticker symbols for the stocks in these indexes are: BLBG: S5SECO - INTC, NVDA, QCOM, TXN, AVGO, MU, ADI, AMD, MCHP, XLNX, SWKS, QRVO, and BLBG: S5SEEQ - AMAT, LRCX, KLAC, respectively. Anastasios Avgeriou, Vice President U.S. Equity Strategy anastasios@bcaresearch.com 1 https://www.frbsf.org/economic-research/indicators-data/tech-pulse/ 2 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Weekly Report, "2018 High-Conviction Calls," dated November 27, 2017, available at uses.bcaresearch.com. Current Recommendations Current Trades Size And Style Views Favor value over growth Favor large over small caps
As the SPX and a slew of other indices have vaulted to fresh all-time highs, a deeper dive into profit margins is in order. While the S&P 500's profit margins are benefiting from the one-time fillip of lower corporate taxes in calendar 2018, it is important to remember that this is not affected by any massaging from CEOs/CFOs of the share count. In other words, given that "per share" cancel out of EPS/SPS, this margin number represents organic profit and revenue growth. The chart shows that SPX margins have recently slingshot to all-time highs. However, excluding tech they remain below the previous cycle's peak hit in mid-2007. While we are not fans of excluding sectors from our analysis, the magnitude and persistence of the tech sector's profit margin expansion is surprising. Tech sector profit margins are twice the SPX's margins, and tech stocks have been pulling SPX margins higher consistently for the past 8 years. The implication is that SPX EPS growth of 10% is likely in 2019, but the tech sector has to continue doing all the heavy lifting given the high profit and market cap weight in the SPX. Bottom Line: We remain neutral the broad tech sector and prefer the S&P software and S&P tech hardware, storage & peripherals indexes (both are high-conviction overweights) to the early cyclical tech indexes, S&P semis and S&P semi equipment subgroups (both are underweight). For additional details, please look forward to reading in this coming Tuesday's Weekly Report.
Underweight This week we have been highlighting winners & losers in a global trade war. With the vast majority of revenues coming from overseas and a high estimated import tariff exposure (please refer to Chart II-5 of the Special Report we published on Monday) semiconductor companies are a stand-out sector to avoid. The drubbing that EM currencies have taken this weak on fear of contagion from Turkey highlights this risk. Global semi sales have historically tracked EM currencies and a leg down for semiconductor sales seems to be the path of least resistance (second panel). The timing is unfortunate; global semiconductor inventories have been growing strongly for the past year and a decline in sales may force a costly inventory clear out. Tack on headline risk from security flaws in index heavyweight Intel's chips and the decision to avoid this early cyclical tech sub-index looks easy; stay underweight. The ticker symbols for the stocks in this index are: BLBG: S5SECO - INTC, QCOM, TXN, AVGO, NVDA, ADI, MU, SWKS, MCHP, XLNX, QRVO.
Special Report Highlights The regulatory or "stroke of pen" risk is rising on FAANG stocks - Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, and Google; The U.S. anti-trust regulatory framework was designed to curb anti-competitive actions but has evolved to focus mostly on consumer welfare and prices; A shift toward the original regulatory regime would threaten the FAANGs, particularly Google and Amazon; A trade war hit to tech earnings could be the catalyst for a more general selloff today - but this is not our base case; For now, the market will view regulatory risk as noise and tech stocks will likely enter a blow-off phase; We remain neutral, preferring S&P software and hardware while underweighting semiconductors. Feature "I don't know what Twitter is up to." Rep. Devin Nunes (R-California), Chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, July 29, 2018 "I have stated my concerns with Amazon long before the Election. Unlike others, they pay little or no taxes to state & local governments, use our Postal System as their Delivery Boy (causing tremendous loss to the U.S.), and are putting many thousands of retailers out of business." President Donald J. Trump, March 29, 2018 "If we will not endure a king as a political power, we should not endure a king over the production, transportation, and sale of any of the necessities of life. If we would not submit to an emperor, we should not submit to an autocrat of trade, with power to prevent competition and to fix the price of any commodity." Senator John Sherman, 1890 Social media companies have had a terrible week, with Twitter falling 21% on July 27th and Facebook 19% on July 26th. Facebook posted weaker than expected earnings, but investors appeared to be particularly concerned with a miss in monthly active users. The shortfall in active users may have been affected by the new EU privacy rules, which came into force in May. Twitter's fall from grace came even though its revenues were up 24% on the year, with a record profit of $100 million. However, its effort to delete "bots" and suspicious user accounts brought its user total down to 335 million, from 336 million, prompting fears that the platform was slowing down. Twitter's and Facebook's enormous price volatility, despite decent earnings figures, reveals that investors are jittery about the performance of technology stocks, epitomized by the so-called FAANGs - Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, and Google. They are right to be, given that there are three broad risks to these companies: The next big thing: Before Facebook, there was MySpace. It is not inconceivable that new platforms - for instance, ones that emphasize privacy or that redistribute a portion of advertising revenue with users - could replace current market leaders. Revenue model: Although they are perceived to be cutting-edge technology companies, social media firms generate vast amount of their revenue through advertising. Facebook and Google have captured 25% of global media advertising revenues.1 At some point, Internet companies will reach a ceiling on this revenue as the attrition rate of local newspapers slows, as foreign markets introduce local alternatives (RenRen or Weibo in China, VKontakte in Russia), and as non-tariff barriers to trade begin impacting their international expansion (China's Internet Security Law). Regulation: Finally, regulatory pressure could grow for a number of reasons. First, European concerns regarding user privacy could migrate to the U.S. where a majority of voters already believe that tech companies need greater oversight (Chart 1). In fact, Americans now see tech companies as having as pernicious an influence as energy companies (Chart 2). Second, the U.S. approach to anti-trust problems could evolve away from the current paradigm that focuses on delivering lower prices to consumers. Third, President Trump and his conservative allies could target social media companies with perceived liberal bias for purely political reasons. Chart 1Majority Of Americans Want Tech Regulated Chart 2Tech And Energy Companies Now In Same Boat We have no particular insight into the competitive landscape of social media, web browsing, and Internet retail industries, so we will leave the first two threats to the experts in the field. Instead, we will focus in this report on the third threat, the "stroke of pen" regulatory risk. From Standard Oil To The Chicago School - America's Anti-Trust Framework Today's anti-trust regulatory framework has significantly deviated from the original intent behind the 1890 Sherman Act. As Lina M. Khan argues in "Amazon's Antitrust Paradox," "Congress enacted antitrust laws to rein in the power of industrial trusts, the large business organizations that had emerged in the late nineteenth century. Responding to a fear of concentrated power, antitrust sought to distribute it."2 Railroad construction in the late nineteenth century, largely financed by the municipal debt of farm-belt states, evolved from a shrewd capex investment in a new technology to a mania. To boost sagging profits, railroad barons fixed their prices to reduce competition. State anti-trust laws that emerged out of this era, the so-called "Granger laws," sought to curb monopolistic behavior by giving states control over railroad operations. These state laws ultimately coalesced into federal legislation, the 1890 Sherman Act. No trust had a larger impact on the U.S. legal and regulatory infrastructure than the case of Standard Oil in the early twentieth century.3 Although the company faced criticism in the immediate aftermath of the 1880s recession - particularly from the famous muckraking journalist Henry Demarest Lloyd - the dam broke for Standard Oil when the oil-price bubble popped in Kansas in 1904. A Standard Oil subsidiary - the Prairie Oil and Gas Company - decided to purchase oil by a specific gravity test, forcing some of the Kansas oil from the market. At the time, the oil boom in Kansas had turned many into stockholders in some prospecting company. When oil prices fell, so did the fortunes of these locals. The shock of the price collapse radicalized Kansas politics at the turn of the twentieth century. An idea for a state-owned oil refinery picked up steam in the state despite being labeled socialist. Ultimately, Kansas' delegation in the U.S. House of Representatives requested that the Secretary of Commerce investigate the causes of the low price of crude oil in the state. After several disastrous performances of Standard Oil executives on witness stands and in testimony, the federal government filed a petition against the company in November 1906. A large fine followed in August 1907. The 1890 Sherman Act and subsequent anti-trust policies were grounded in the theory of economic structuralism. "This view holds that a market dominated by a very small number of large companies is likely to be less competitive than a market populated with many small- and medium-sized companies." Through the 1960s, courts blocked mergers - both horizontal and vertical - and policed markets not only for size, or effect on consumer welfare, but also for conflicts of interest.4 In the 1970s and 1980s, however, the Chicago School approach gained prominence. The Chicago School rested on "faith in the efficiency of markets, propelled by profit-maximizing actors."5 While economic structuralists believed that the structure of an industry leads to market outcomes, Chicago School saw structure as the outcome of market dynamics, which themselves are sacrosanct. Chicago School adherents focused primarily on price dynamics and consumer welfare, ignoring how economic structures could create barriers to entry and thus uncompetitive markets. The most influential economist behind the Chicago School was Robert Bork, who asserted in his highly influential The Antitrust Paradox that the "only legitimate goal of antitrust is the maximization of consumer welfare."6 That said, his definition of consumer welfare was incredibly broad and revealed a clear corporate, if not a pro-monopoly, bias.7 The influential Chicago School ultimately impacted the Supreme Court, which declared in 1979 that "Congress designed the Sherman Act as a 'consumer welfare prescription.'"8 The Reagan Administration subsequently rewrote the 1968 merger guidelines to shift the focus purely to consumer welfare in the form of preventing monopolistic price increases and output restrictions. The government also stopped bringing anti-trust cases under the 1936 Robinson-Patman Act, which prohibits price discrimination by retailers among producers and vice versa. Bottom Line: The U.S. anti-trust regulatory framework was designed to curb broad anti-competitive actions of trusts. As Lina Khan discusses in her seminal article, these actions "include not only cost but also product quality, variety, and innovation."9 However, through subsequent regulatory evolution, the Chicago School has taken hold of the U.S. anti-trust process, solely focusing on consumer welfare and prices. We can draw two immediate conclusions from this historical overview of U.S. anti-trust policy. First, the laws on the books have not changed since World War Two. Despite the laws remaining the same, the theory of how to apply them in courts of law has dramatically changed, as economic structuralism gave way to the Chicago School's focus on prices and consumer welfare. If President Reagan and the courts could change how these laws are administered in the 1980s, then so can subsequent administrations and courts in the future. Second, a long period of slow growth, income inequality, and economic volatility - such as the 1870s-80s - can produce a political impetus for anti-trust policy. This was certainly the case for Standard Oil in 1911, which became a nation-wide boogeyman despite most of its transgressions occurring in the farm belt states. While the U.S. has not experienced a recession in almost a decade, it will eventually - and besides, income inequality is a prominent theme once again and a potential source of consumer discontent.10 A narrative could emerge - particularly if politically expedient - that growth has been unequally distributed between the old economy and the twenty-first century technology leaders. Will FAANGs Be De-FAANGed? At BCA Research, we are neither regulatory nor policy experts. As such, we do not have insight into current regulatory activity involving social media companies, Google, or Amazon. The preceding section merely illustrates that the federal government's approach to the anti-trust process could change. Indeed, the Obama administration signaled that its approach could become more active. One quantitative approach that investors can use to assess the risk of anti-trust legislation is the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI). It is the most commonly accepted measure of market concentration, used by the Department of Justice in assessing whether a particular market is controlled by a single firm.11 Chart 3 shows our reconstruction of the HHI for the present-day era, with three examples from the past. Chart 3Market Concentration By Industry And Eras The 1911 refined petroleum sector harkens back to the aforementioned Standard Oil case; The 2001 Internet browser market refers to the United States v. Microsoft Corp that led to the June 2000 decision (later reversed on appeal) to break-up the software giant; The 1983 telecommunication sector illustrates the HHI for the telecom market at the time of the AT&T divestiture. The data is clear: of the five FAANG companies, only Google reaches a concerning level on the HHI measure. This has already made it a target of European authorities. On the other hand, competition within both streaming (Netflix, Amazon) and social networks (Facebook) appears relatively healthy. However, social networks could be at risk of European-style privacy protections. The EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), which came into force on May 2018, imposes considerable compliance burdens on any company handling user data. California has already signed its own version of the law - the Consumer Privacy Act - which will go into effect in January 2020. These laws give consumers the right to know what information companies are collecting about them and what companies that data is being shared with. They also allow consumers to ask technology companies to delete their data or not to sell it. While tech companies are likely to fight the new California law, we believe the writing is on the wall. The EU is by some measures the largest consumer market on the planet. California is certainly the largest U.S. market. It is unlikely that the momentum behind consumer protection will change, especially with the EU and California taking the lead. Given that advertising revenue is crucial to the business model of social media companies and Google, a significant uptick in privacy regulation could hurt their bottom line. On the other hand, as we discuss below, the new regulatory rules create massive barriers to entry for small firms looking to replace the tech giants. Furthermore, many of the targeted social media companies have run afoul of President Trump in particular and the broader conservative movement in general. As such, privacy advocates - who tend to lean left - and conservatives, who feel that their commentators are being silenced by Silicon Valley, could form a classic "bootleggers and abolitionists" coalition against the FAANGs (Chart 4). Finally, there is the question of Amazon. We do not construct an HHI for Amazon's place in the retail market because E-commerce only accounts for about 9.5% of total U.S. retail sales (Chart 5). Amazon has been leading the charge, but it still accounts for just under half of that 9.5% total figure (Chart 6). Chart 4Conservatives Distrust Tech Companies Chart 5E-Commerce: Steady Increase In Market Share Chart 6Amazon Dominates Amazon's strength is that, in the current anti-trust framework, it conforms fully to the "consumer welfare" priorities elucidated by the Chicago School. Amazon, by and large, lowers prices for consumers. However, several of its practices could be seen as predatory in the more expansive, economic structuralist, approach.12 In addition, President Trump has reserved most of his Twitter scorn on the firm, particularly because CEO Jeff Bezos owns the liberal-leaning Washington Post. Bottom Line: Investors are correct to fret that the "stroke of pen" risk is rising when it comes to FAANG companies. Google scores considerably higher than either Standard Oil or Microsoft on the Department of Justice HHI. Social media companies are already under the microscope by conservative legislators and voters, who perceive them to be biased. Liberals, on the other hand, support toughened-up privacy rules that could undermine the business model of social media companies. Amazon's market dominance is overstated. However, several of its business practices could come under greater scrutiny if any administration should revert back to the original reading of the 1890 Sherman Law. Technology Stocks Have Brought The S&P 500 Up; Could They Bring It Down? It is now a well-worn understanding that the reason why the S&P 500 has performed well is largely due to the performance of a few (enormous) technology stocks (see Chart 7 and Table 1) who have seen both earnings and valuation multiples expand amid one of the longest economic growth phases in history. The preceding section certainly suggests that frothy valuations and the rising regulatory impetus imply that future upside potential is swamped by downside risk. Chart 7FAANG Stocks + Microsoft Have##br## Dramatically Outperformed... Table 1...Generating 50% Of The##br## 2018 S&P 500 Return! If this negative scenario is what actually plays out in the market, the implications could be more severe than in the past. Indexed fund inflows have replaced actively managed fund outflows, as our colleagues in BCA's Global ETF Strategy recently pointed out (Chart 8).13 Considering the rise of these few technology stocks and their increasing weight in the S&P 500 and, necessarily, in the majority of ETFs, more people than ever before are invested in technology stocks, whether they know it or not. Accordingly, the performance of these stocks has become material to the household balance sheet, which is a driver of consumption and, hence, the economy. Thus, it may not be hyperbole to say the economy depends to some extent on Amazon maintaining a high valuation multiple. Chart 8ETF Inflows Offset Actively Managed Outflows Adding some weight to this thesis is the mounting concern over a global trade war. The technology sector in general is by far the most international (as defined by foreign-sourced revenues) of GICS 1 sectors. More specifically, the top three semiconductor & semiconductor equipment companies (INTC, NVDA & TXN), which collectively represent more than 50% of the weight of that index, generate on average only 17% of their revenues in the U.S. Moreover, the more dangerous and lasting trade risk emanates from the U.S.-China showdown, which centers on the technology sector. Should the worst trade outcomes occur, it is not unreasonable to see impaired technology earnings being the catalyst for a more general sell-off. We recommend underweight positions in both the S&P semiconductors and S&P semiconductor equipment indexes. We Think Not Despite the foregoing, we think a more likely scenario is actually a blow-off phase where technology stocks accelerate rather than decline in an increasingly restrictive regulatory environment. In a recent report analyzing sector performance in the last stages of the bull market, we noted that across seven iterations dating back to the 1960's, the information technology sector delivered a median 14% outperformance relative to the S&P 500 (Table 2).14 And, while returns in these stocks have been excellent this year, their gains seem modest compared to the performance in the 1999-2000 iteration. Table 2Tech Stocks Are Strong Late Cycle Performers Underpinning our expectations is the recent stock reactions to regulatory actions. Beginning with Facebook, in the week of March 26, 2018, the firm was hit with severely negative headlines. First, the Cambridge Analytica scandal pointed out that the firm may be caught on the wrong side of EU GDPR rules, followed by the firm being investigated for an EU antitrust suit for the online ad market; the stock fell 15% from the week prior. However, within two months, the stock had fully recovered and a further two months later the stock was up 18% from its starting point. Recently the stock has fallen significantly on the back of very weak guidance; the company noted that revenue growth would decelerate and operating margins would fall to the mid-30% range from the current mid-40% range. It is not unreasonable to think management may be sandbagging earnings growth to defray some of the elevated regulatory scrutiny into its outrageous profitability. Google too has seen negative regulatory headlines, having been hit with a $5 billion fine in the EU for abusing the dominance of the Android mobile operating system in July this year. The stock responded by closing higher and then rose a further 10% in the following two weeks. Overall, we think the market views regulatory risk as noise. For now. But What About The Earnings? Do They Matter? While the earnings implications of yet-to-be-proposed regulatory changes are unknowable, we believe even the pursuit of an answer is a red herring. As shown by Chart 9, the market does not appear to care about next year's earnings as valuation multiples have little consistency with either themselves or the broad market. The implication is that near-term earnings are of relatively little importance, at least compared to the long-term growth outlook. Chart 9Tech Valuations Are Meaningless Further, these companies are a collection of businesses that are not necessarily cohesive. For example, Facebook includes Instagram, WhatsApp and Oculus while Amazon Web Service is a non-retail business that delivers half of Amazon's profit. A reasonable case could be made that breaking up these companies into their components could actually unlock considerable value. Lastly, new regulation, particularly with respect to privacy and data protection, is likely to create significant barriers for new entrants as compliance costs will be relatively more onerous for those companies with fewer resources. Thus, incoming privacy legislation may neuter the impact of any anti-trust legislation. Be Wary With Technology But For The Right Reasons We fully expect more regulation to remain a significant part of the conversation with respect to FAANG stocks and further expect that conversation to promote higher than normal volatility in the sector. However, we also expect the market to mostly look through this risk; buying the dip has thus far been the right approach to headline risk in technology. We think there are better reasons to remain cautious with technology. As noted above, they are heavily international and a strengthening U.S. dollar will be a headwind to 2019 earnings to a greater extent than to the broad market (please see our June 4th Weekly Report for more details). Supporting the dollar, BCA expects higher interest rates in 2018 on the back of rising inflation. Overall, we prefer old tech (S&P software and S&P technology hardware, storage & peripherals, both which are high-conviction overweights) that is levered to our synchronized global capex upcycle theme. It also boasts high cash flow and low valuations. We are less sanguine about technology early cyclicals (S&P semiconductors and S&P semiconductor equipment) which we rate as underweight. Net, we think risks are balanced in the tech sector and maintain a neutral recommendation for the S&P information technology sector. BCA Geopolitical Strategy Housekeeping In light of several announcements regarding China's efforts to ease up on economic policy, we are closing several of our trades: Short China-exposed S&P 500 Companies versus U.S. financials and telecoms - opened on May 30 for a 7.13% gain; Long DXY - opened on January 31 for a 5.85% gain; Short GBP/USD - opened on February 14 for a 6.21% gain; Long Indian equities / short Brazilian equities - opened on March 6 for a 27.54% gain. Long French industrial equities / short German industrial equities - opened on May 16 for a 2.21% gain. We still believe that Chinese structural reforms will continue, weighing on domestic and global growth. In the face of ongoing U.S. fiscal stimulus, the interplay between the two major economies will therefore continue to produce a dollar-bullish environment. However, the dollar's stretched positioning and the Chinese reflation narrative could hurt the greenback while reflating global risk assets in the near term. We will therefore look for an opportunity to reassert our negative EM view. Over the next two weeks, our reports will focus on Chinese stimulus and ongoing structural reforms. Marko Papic, Senior Vice President Chief Geopolitical Strategist marko@bcaresearch.com Chris Bowes, Associate Editor U.S. Equity Strategy chrisb@bcaresearch.com 1 Please see WARC, "Mobile is the world's second-largest ad medium," dated November 30, 2017, available at warc.com. 2 Please see Lina M. Khan, "Amazon's Antitrust Paradox," The Yale Law Journal 126:710 (2017). 3 Please see Steven L. Piott, The Anti-Monopoly Persuasion (Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Press, 1985). 4 Khan 718. 5 Khan 719. 6 Please see Robert H. Bork, The Antitrust Paradox: A Policy at War with Itself (New York: Free Press, 1978). 7 By Bork's broad definition of "consumer welfare," even Jeff Bezos is a consumer whose rights have to be protected by anti-trust policy. "Those who continue to buy after a monopoly is formed pay more for the same output, and that shifts income from them to the monopoly and its owners, who are also consumers. This is not dead-weight loss due to restriction of output but merely a shift in income between two classes of consumers. The consumer welfare model, which views consumers as a collectivity, does not take this income effect into account," Bork, 32, our emphasis. 8 Please see Reiter v. Sonotone Corp., 442 U.S. 330, 342 (1979). 9 Khan 737. 10 Please see BCA Geopolitical Strategy Special Report, "Populism Blues: How And Why Social Instability Is Coming To America," dated June 9, 2017, available at gps.bcaresearch.com. 11 Please see The U.S. Department of Justice, "Herfindahl-Hirschman Index," available at justice.gov. 12 Please see Olivia LaVecchia and Stacy Mitchell, "Amazon's Stranglehold: How the Company's Tightening Grip Is Stifling Competition, Eroding Jobs, and Threatening Communities," Institute for Local Self-Reliance, dated November 2016, available at ilsr.org. 13 Please see BCA Global ETF Strategy Special Report, "Do ETF Flows Lead Currencies?" dated April 18, 2018, available at etf.bcaresearch.com. 14 Please see BCA U.S. Equity Strategy Special Report, "Portfolio Positioning For A Late Cycle Surge," dated May 22, 2018, available at uses.bcaresearch.com.