Technology
Highlights The decade-long US equity market outperformance versus the rest of the world could be nearing its end. We are upgrading EM stocks from underweight to neutral within a global equity portfolio. We reiterate the change in our US dollar outlook from bullish to bearish. The concentration risk in EM (specifically in North Asia) mega-cap stocks, poor fundamentals in EM outside North Asia, and a potential flare-up in US-China tensions are the reasons why we are reluctant to be overweight EM stocks. Feature We recommended the short EM equities / long S&P 500 position in late 2010,1 and have reiterated this strategy consistently over the past decade. Since its inception, this trade has produced a 193% gain with extremely low volatility (Chart 1). We recommend taking profits on this position for the reasons elaborated in this report. Chart 1Book Profits On Our Short EM Stocks / Long S&P 500 Strategy Chart 2Equity Strategy Of the Decade: The Risk-Reward Is No Longer Attractive Consistently, we are upgrading EM stocks from underweight to neutral within a global equity portfolio. Our decade-long equity sector theme – introduced in our June 8, 2010 report2 – has been to underweight resources and overweight technology and healthcare (Chart 2). This sector strategy has been one of the reasons for underweighting EM and favoring the US market in a global equity portfolio over the past decade. Going forward, the risk-reward of this sector strategy is no longer attractive. Regarding EM absolute performance, we recommend that absolute-return investors remain on standby for a correction before going long the EM equity benchmark. The End Of US Equity Outperformance The decade-long US equity market outperformance versus the rest of the world could be nearing its end.It is widely known that this decade’s US equity outperformance was largely due to FAANGM stocks (Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Netflix, Google and Microsoft). The FAANGM rally meets many of the criteria for a bubble, as we elaborated in our July 16 report. Our FAANGM equity index – an equal-weighted average of the six stocks – has increased almost 20-fold in real (inflation-adjusted) terms since January 2010 (Chart 3). Chart 3Each Decade = One Mania Its rise is on par with the magnitude of the bull market in the Nasdaq 100 index through the 1990s, or of Walt Disney. through the 1960s, and it well exceeds other bubbles, as illustrated on Chart 3. All price indexes are shown in real (inflation-adjusted) terms. FAANGM stocks have greatly benefited from the recent “work from home” and other societal shifts and have been outperforming through the March financial carnage. It has made them unassailable in the eyes of investors. Yet, even great companies have a fair price, and considerable price overshoots will not be sustainable in the long term. We sense that a growing number of investors deem the US FAANGM and EM mega-cap stocks to be invincible. When some stocks are regarded as unbeatable, their top is not far. Therefore, it is highly unlikely that the FAANGM will outperform in the next selloff. Rather, the odds are that they will underperform because these stocks are extremely expensive, overbought, over-hyped and over-owned. The decade-long US equity market outperformance versus the rest of the world could be nearing its end. Apart from technology and FAANGM, US equities are facing a mediocre profit outlook. As long as the pandemic is not contained, America’s consumer and business confidence will remain lackluster, and, as a result, a recovery in their spending will be subdued. Chart 4US Stocks Are Not Cheap After Removing Market-Cap Bias Notably, the broad US equity market is also expensive. The equal-weighted US equity index is trading at a 12-month forward P/E ratio of 21 (Chart 4, top panel). The risks associated with domestic politics are rising in the US. Social, political and economic divisions have been magnified by both the pandemic and the economic downtrend. Social and political tensions will likely flare up around the November elections. Our colleagues from the Geopolitical team argue that a contested election is possible and could lead to a crisis of presidential legitimacy in the US. Finally, the US equity market cap has reached 58% of the global market cap, the highest on record. Gravity forces are likely to kick in sooner than later, capping US equity outperformance. Bottom Line: The tailwinds supporting the US equity outperformance are fading. We are booking gains on the short EM stocks / long S&P 500 strategy. Consistently, we are also closing the short EM banks / long US banks and short Chinese banks / long US banks positions. They have produced a 75% gain and an 11% loss, respectively. Downgrading The US Dollar Outlook = Upgrading The EM View We had been bullish on the US dollar and bearish on EM currencies since early 2011 (Chart 5, top panel), but on July 9 made a major change in our currency strategy: we switched our shorts in EM currencies away from the US dollar to against an equal-weighted basket of the euro, Swiss franc and the yen. Since then, the EM ex-China equal-weighted currency index has rebounded versus the US dollar, but has depreciated against the basket of the euro, CHF and JPY (Chart 5, bottom panel). Chart 5EM Currencies Have Bottomed Versus The US Dollar But Not Against Other Safe-Heavens While the US dollar could rebound in the short term, especially versus EM currencies, any rebound will likely prove to be short-lived. From now on, the strategy for the greenback should be selling into strength. Here is why: As US inflation rises in the coming years and the Fed refuses to raise interest rates, US real rates will drop further and, as a result, the US dollar will depreciate. A central bank that is behind the inflation curve is bearish for a nation’s currency. The main reason for turning negative on the US dollar structurally is the rising determination by the Federal Reserve to stay behind the inflation curve in the years to come. This strategy will instigate an inflation outbreak. Falling real interest rates have caused a plunge in the US dollar, as well as a surge in precious metal prices, in recent weeks. In fact, risk-on currencies have lately underperformed safe-haven currencies, such as the CHF and JPY (Chart 6). This market move confirms that the dollar’s recent plunge is due to fears of its debasement, not to robust growth in the world economy and in EM/China. As US inflation rises in the coming years and the Fed refuses to raise interest rates, US real rates will drop further and, as a result, the US dollar will depreciate. Colossal debt monetization. The Fed is undertaking an immense monetization of public and private debt. The current situation, involving the Fed’s purchases of securities, is different from the one following the Lehman crisis. Back in 2008-2014, the Fed’s QE program did not produce an exponential rise in money supply. The US broad money supply (M2) was rising at a single-digit rate between 2009 and 2014 (Chart 7). Presently, US M2 growth has exploded to 24% from a year ago. Chart 6Risk-On Currencies Are Underperforming Safe-Heaven Ones Chart 7Helicopter' Money in the US The pace of US broad money growth is much higher than that of many advanced and developing economies. Chart 8 shows new money creation as a share of GDP across various economies. It demonstrates that Japan and the US are now experiencing the quickest rate of new money creation in the world. In short, even though debt monetization is occurring in many advanced and EM economies, the US is doing it on an unprecedented scale. Chart 8Money Creation As % Of GDP In 2Q2020 “Helicopter” money will eventually lift inflation. The latest surge in the US money supply has only partially offset the collapse in its velocity. Consequently, America’s nominal GDP has plunged. This stems from the following identity: Nominal GDP = Price Level x Output Volume = Velocity of Money x Money Supply Solving the above equation for inflation, we get: Price Level = (Velocity of Money x Money Supply) / (Output Volume) Going forward, the velocity of US money will likely recover, for it is closely associated with consumers’ and businesses’ willingness to spend. At that point, rising velocity of money and greater money supply will work together to exert upward pressure on nominal GDP. Meantime, the pandemic will probably reduce potential output. The outcome of higher nominal spending and reduced potential productive capacity will be higher inflation. In sum, US inflation will rise well above 2% in the coming years. Yet, the Fed will stay put amid rising inflation. The upshot will be a structural downtrend in the US dollar. Whilst there are many arguments against rising inflation, we are leaning toward the view that US inflation will begin rising as of next year. We will elaborate on this inflation outlook in our future reports. Rising political and social uncertainty in the US will weigh on the greenback. The failure by the US authorities to contain the spread of the pandemic will continue fueling political and social upheavals. This could culminate in a harshly contested presidential election and a reduction in the US dollar’s allure for foreign investors. Portfolio inflows into the US will turn into outflows. The stellar performance of US equities attracted portfolio inflows into the US over the last 10 years. These capital inflows, in turn, boosted the greenback. But these dynamics are about to be reversed. Chart 9The US's Net International Investment Position Is At A Record Low The top panel of Chart 9 shows that the US’s net international investment position in equities is at its lowest point since 1986. This means that foreign ownership of US stocks exceeds US resident ownership of foreign equities by a record amount. This reflects the fact that investors have by a large margin favored the US versus other bourses. As American share prices outperformed their international peers, both domestic and foreign investors have poured more capital into US equities. As the US relative equity performance reverses, equity capital will flow out of the US, thus dragging down the US dollar. Chart 10 shows that the trade-weighted dollar tracks the relative performance of the S&P500 versus the global equity benchmark in local currency terms. Regarding debt securities, the US’s net international investment position has widened to - US$8.5 trillion (Chart 9, bottom panel). Not all fixed-income investors hedge currency risk. As the dollar slides, there will be growing pressure on foreign fixed-income investors to hedge their dollar exposure or sell US and buy non-US debt securities. Chart 10A Top In The US$ = The End Of The US Equity Outperformance? Bottom Line: Immense public debt monetization leading to higher inflation down the road and the Fed falling behind the curve, will produce a lasting and considerable downtrend in the US dollar in the coming years. Why Not Overweight EM Stocks? There are a number of reasons why – for now – we are only upgrading EM equities to neutral, rather than to overweight within a global equity portfolio, and why we are still reluctant to recommend buying EM stocks for absolute-return investors: Concentration risk in EM mega-cap stocks. As US FAANGM share prices come under selling pressure, contagion will spill over to EM mega-cap stocks. The latter have been responsible for a large share of gains in the EM equity index and, conversely, their pullback will considerably impact the EM benchmark’s performance. The top six companies combined account for about 24% of the MSCI EM equity market cap. To compare, US FAANGM (Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, Google and Microsoft) also account for 24% of the S&P 500 market cap. Hence, the concentration risk in EM equity space is as high as in the US. Geopolitical risk. A potential flare up in in geopolitical tensions will weigh on Chinese, South Korean and Taiwanese stocks. Given that they make up about 65% of the MSCI EM index equity market cap, the EM benchmark will suffer in absolute terms and be unlikely to outperform the global equity index. Faced with decreased approval in regard to his handling of the pandemic, and to a lesser extent, the economy and other social issues, President Trump could well resort to geopolitics to “rally Americans behind the flag.” He may, for example, ramp up tensions with China in an attempt to make geopolitics and China the focal points of the forthcoming presidential election. China will certainly retaliate. The South China Sea, Taiwan, technology transfers, treatment of multinational companies in both China and the US, as well as North Korea, could be focal points of a confrontation. This will weigh on business confidence in Asia and on capital spending. In our opinion, markets are vulnerable to such geopolitical risks. Poor domestic fundamentals in EM outside China, Korea and Taiwan. Fundamental backdrops remain inferior in many EM economies outside the North Asian ones. The number of new infections continues to rise in India, Indonesia, The Philippines, Brazil, Mexico, Colombia and Peru. Many EM economies will only slowly return to normalcy. In certain countries, banking systems were already in poor health, and things have gotten much worse after the crash in economic activity. As to the positives for EM, they are as follows: Rising Chinese demand will boost EM exports to China and help revive their growth. EM equity valuations are very appealing versus the S&P 500 (Chart 11). The bottom panel of Chart 11 shows that EM’s cyclically-adjusted P/E ratio relative to that in the US is over one standard deviation below its mean. Based on the 12-month forward P/E ratio for an equal-weighted index, EM stocks are cheaper than US ones (please refer to Chart 4 on page 4). EM currencies are also cheap (Chart 12). While they might experience a short-term setback, as a global risk-off phase takes place, EM exchange rates have probably seen their lows versus the US dollar. Chart 11EM Stocks Offer Value Versus The S&P 500 Chart 12EM Currencies Are Cheap The US dollar’s weakness will mitigate risks for EM issuers of US dollar bonds and, thereby, induce more flows into EM sovereign and corporate credit markets. In short, EM local currency bonds will assuredly benefit from the US dollar’s slide. We have been neutral on both EM local currency bonds and EM sovereign and corporate credit, and are waiting for a correction before upgrading to overweight. In nutshell, little or no stress in EM fixed-income markets bodes well for EM share prices. Bottom Line: Risks to EM equity relative performance are presently balanced. A neutral allocation is warranted for now. EM relative equity performance versus DM is only slightly above its recent low (Chart 13, top panel). It is, therefore, a good juncture to move the EM equity allocation from underweight to neutral. In addition, both the EM equal-weighted and small-cap equity indexes are not yet signaling a broad-based and sustainable outperformance (Chart 13, middle and bottom panels). Chart 13EM Relative Equity Performance Is In A Bottom-Out Phase Some FAQs Question: Wouldn’t the US dollar rally if global stocks sell off? The greenback will likely attempt to rebound from current oversold levels when and as a global risk-off phase sets in. EM high-beta currencies could experience a non-trivial setback but will remain above their March lows. Yet, any rebound in the US dollar versus European currencies and the Japanese yen will be fleeting and moderate. On July 9, in anticipation of US dollar weakness, we booked profits on the short EM currencies/long US dollar strategy and recommended shorting several EM currencies versus an equal-weighted basket of the euro, CHF and JPY. This strategy remains intact for now. Our short list of EM currencies includes: BRL, CLP, ZAR, TRY, IDR, PHP and KRW. Odds are that EM stocks will likely be broadly flattish relative to those in DM amid the next sell off. Chart 14EM Stocks Have Been Low Beta Question: Aren’t EM stocks high-beta and won’t they underperform if, and as, global stocks sell off? The EM equity index has had a beta lower than one since 2013 (Chart 14). Odds are that EM stocks will likely be broadly flattish relative to those in DM amid the next sell off. Within the DM equity space, the US will likely underperform both Europe and Japan in common currency terms. Question: Which equity markets do you favor within the EM space? Our current overweights are China, Thailand, Russia, Peru, Pakistan and Mexico. Our underweights are Indonesia, India, Hong Kong, the Philippines, Turkey, South Africa, Chile and Brazil. Question: Which currencies and local currency bond markets do you recommend overweighting for dedicated EM managers? We recommended going long the Czech koruna versus the US dollar last week. Other currencies that we favor within the EM space are SGD, TWD, THB, MXN and RUB. As for local currency bonds or swap rates, our top picks are Mexico, Russia, Korea, India, China, Malaysia, Thailand, Peru, Ukraine and Pakistan. As always, the list of country recommendations for equities, fixed-income and currencies is available at the end of our reports (please refer to pages 14-15) or on the website. Arthur Budaghyan Chief Emerging Markets Strategist arthurb@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1Please see Emerging Markets Strategy Weekly Reports "Inflation, Overheating And The Stampede Into Bonds," dated November 30, 2010, and "Emerging Markets In 2011: Not The Best Play In Town," dated December 14, 2010. 2Please see Emerging Markets Strategy Special Report "How To Play Emerging Market Growth In The Coming Decade," dated June 8, 2010 Equities Recommendations Currencies, Credit And Fixed-Income Recommendations
Highlights For financials and energy to produce a sustained rally, there must be no relapse in global growth during the autumn and winter of 2020/21. However, with the coronavirus still in play and the usual flu and virus season yet to come, a key hurdle to overcome will be the physical reopening of schools and childcare facilities this September. Hence, for the time being, remain overweight healthcare and technology versus financials and energy. This implies underweight European stocks versus US stocks, and overweight Germany, France, Netherlands and Switzerland within Europe. Play good news in Europe by remaining long EUR, CHF, and SEK versus USD, and long US T-bonds and Spanish Bonos versus German Bunds and French OATs. Fractal trade: Short silver. Feature Chart Of The WeekDenmark's OMX Is At An All-Time High, While The FTSE 100 Is Languishing. Why? Once upon a time, the stock market existed as a barometer of the economy. Or at least, a good representation of the size and composition of profits in the host economy. But that time is long gone. Today, a tiny handful of companies are driving the performance of supposedly broad indexes such as the FTSE 100 and the S&P 500. Indeed, we should more accurately call the FTSE 100 the FTSE ‘10’ ignoring the other 90. And we should call the S&P 500 the S&P ‘5’ ignoring the other 495. Meaning that stock markets are no longer stock ‘markets’. Yet many analysts still try and explain the stock market’s performance through traditional top-down macro drivers such as GDP growth, profit margins across the host economy, and so on. The trouble is that when the stock market is dominated by a tiny handful of companies, this 20th century approach is doomed to fail. Today, we must take a more granular approach based on the type of companies that are dominating each stock market. Sector Concentration Is Driving Stock Markets The handful of companies that dominate each stock market tend to be the leaders in their global sector. This means that each stock market is defined by a sector concentration, which has often evolved by chance, based on where companies chose to start up and list. This sector concentration usually has little or no connection with the host economy. For example, Denmark’s OMX index is dominated by Novo Nordisk, a global biotech company. The FTSE 100 is heavily weighted to the oil majors Royal Dutch and BP as well as global bank HSBC, which have only a limited exposure to the UK economy. On the other side of the Atlantic, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Google and Facebook are massively over-represented in the S&P 500 compared with their contribution to the US economy. A crucial defining feature of a stock market turns out to be its exposure to healthcare and technology – whose profits are in major structural uptrends – versus the exposure to financials and energy – whose profits are in major structural downtrends (Charts 2 - 5). Chart I-2Healthcare Profits Are In A Structural Uptrend Chart I-3Technology Profits Are In A Structural Uptrend Chart I-4Financial Profits Are In A Structural Downtrend Chart I-5Energy Profits Are In A Structural Downtrend The stock market capitalisation in healthcare and technology stands at 52 percent for Denmark and 40 percent for the US, compared with just 20 percent for Europe and 12 percent for the UK. The flip side is that the stock market capitalisation in financials and energy stands at just 8 percent for Denmark and 11 percent for the US, compared with 21 percent for Europe and 30 percent for the UK. This explains, for example, why Denmark’s OMX is hitting all-time highs while the FTSE 100 is languishing (Chart of the Week). That said, the price of the growing stream of healthcare and technology profits can still fall if it is at an unjustifiably high level. And the price of the shrinking stream of financial and energy profits can still rise if it is at an unjustifiably low level. Hence, the key question is: what determines the prices of these two groups of sectors, one whose profits are in a major uptrend, the other whose profits are in a major downtrend? Healthcare And Tech Performance Hinges On The Bond Yield The price of a rapidly growing profit stream is weighted to the values of the large distant cashflows, making it highly sensitive to the discount rate applied to those distant cashflows. Whereas the price of a rapidly shrinking profit stream is weighted to the values of the large immediate cashflows, making it much more sensitive to the near-term evolution of the economy (Box I-1). Box I-1Bond Yield Sensitivity Versus Economic Sensitivity The upshot is that for stocks and sectors whose profits are in a major uptrend, the key driver of the price is the direction of the bond yield. Whereas for stocks and sectors whose profits are in a major downtrend, the key driver is the near-term direction of the world economy (Chart I-6 and Chart I-7). Chart I-6Exposure To Healthcare And Technology Determines Bond Yield Sensitivity Chart I-7Exposure To Financials And Energy Determines Economic Sensitivity Pulling all of this together, the rally in healthcare and technology stocks is extremely vulnerable to a sustained rise in the bond yield. But a sustained rise in the bond yield seems highly unlikely without a breakthrough vaccine or treatment for COVID-19. While the coronavirus is still in play, the long-term hollowing out and scarring in the jobs market will only become apparent in the coming months once furlough schemes and temporary relief programs end. This will force all central banks to remain ultra-dovish and where possible, become more dovish. Meanwhile, for financials and energy to produce a sustained rally, there must be no relapse in global growth during the autumn and winter of 2020/21. However, with the coronavirus still in play and the usual flu and virus season yet to come, a key hurdle to overcome will be the physical reopening of schools and childcare facilities this September. Hence, for the time being, remain overweight healthcare and technology versus financials and energy. This translates to underweight Europe versus the US. And overweight Germany, France, Netherlands and Switzerland within Europe. How To Play Good News In Europe Things have been going right in Europe. First, unlike in the US, the COVID-19 outbreak is subsiding, at least for now. New infections have been steadily declining through the warm summer months (Chart I-8). Chart I-8New Infections Declining In Europe, Rising In The US Second, the ECB has injected ample liquidity into the banking system which, combined with ultra-low interest rates, has permitted a strong expansion in bank lending. Though somewhat disappointingly, the bank lending surveys tell us that the loans are being used for emergency working capital requirements rather than investment. Third, the EU has approved a €750 billion Recovery Fund, over half of which will take the form of grants to the sectors and regions most stricken by the coronavirus crisis. Given that the fund will be financed by jointly issued EU bonds, this amounts to a fiscal transfer to the areas that need the most help. Hence, even if the amount of the stimulus may be smaller than in other parts of the word, it comprises a huge symbolic step towards greater unity in the EU and euro area. Still, despite this trifecta of good news, European stock markets have not outperformed (Chart I-9). This just emphasises that stock market relative performance has little connection with domestic economics and politics. To reiterate, stock market relative performance is almost always the result of the sector concentration of a handful of dominant stocks. Chart I-9Despite Good News In Europe, European Equities Are Not Outperforming Begging the question: how to play the continuation of good news in Europe? The answer is through the currency and fixed income markets, which have a much stronger connection with domestic economics and politics (Chart I-10 and Chart I-11). Chart I-10Play Good News In Europe Via European Currencies... Chart I-11...And Sovereign Yield Spread Tightening Remain long a basket of EUR, CHF, and SEK versus the USD. Our favourite cross out of these three is long CHF/USD given the haven character of the CHF in periods of market stress. To play bond yield convergence between the US and Europe and between core and periphery Europe, remain long US 30-year T-bonds and Spanish 30-year Bonos versus German 30-year bunds and French 30-year OATs. Dhaval Joshi Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading System* The spectacular rally in silver is fractally fragile, and at a point which has signalled several trend reversals through the past five years. Accordingly, this week’s recommended trade is short silver, with the profit target and symmetrical stop-loss set at 12.5 percent. In other trades, long GBP/RUB achieved its profit target. Against this, short Germany versus UK and long bitcoin cash versus ethereum reached their stop-losses. Long nickel versus copper reached the end of its holding period in partial loss. The rolling 12-month win ratio now stands at 59 percent. When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report “Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model,” dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com. Fractal Trading System Cyclical Recommendations Structural Recommendations Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Interest Rate Chart II-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations
Bob Farrell famously remarked “Markets are strongest when they are broad and weakest when they narrow to a handful of blue-chip names.” This could not be truer than today’s market, especially the NASDAQ. Not only are the top five SPX stocks comprising roughly 23% of the index, but the same five tech titans carry a 40% weight in the NASDAQ composite. This seems excessive and carries a lot of risk in case of even a mild disappointment. True, the collapse in interest rates has boosted the NASDAQ forward P/E to the stratosphere, but the longer these high flying stocks defy gravity the more painful the eventual snap will be (bottom panel). Already there are tentative signs of trouble brewing beneath the surface. NASDAQ breadth is sinking like a stone and this has proven a reliable leading indicator in the recent past, warning that a pullback is looming (top panel). Finally, the hypersensitive chip stocks are suffering from exhaustion, unable to outperform the tech titan led NASDAQ (middle panel). Any hiccups in the tech space will negatively reverberate in the SPX: currently the S&P tech sector plus the FANG (FB, AMZN, NFLX & GOOGL) comprise 40% of the S&P 500. Thus as tech goes so does the SPX. Bottom Line: We remain cautious on the near-term prospects of the S&P 500 until the election uncertainty lifts in November.
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and the current pageant suggests the most attractive country in the world is Israel. The basis is valuation and the structural change we are witnessing in global economies. With the advent of COVID-19, “platform”…
Highlights The economic performance of Sweden, which did not have a lockdown, has been almost as bad as Denmark, which did have a lockdown. This proves that the current recession is not ‘man-made’, it is ‘pandemic-made’. While the pandemic remains in play, investors should maintain a defensive bias to their portfolios: favouring US T-bonds in bond portfolios, and technology and healthcare in equity portfolios. The technology sector has become defensive, largely because it has flipped from hardware dominance to software dominance. A new recommendation is to overweight technology-heavy Netherlands. Fractal trade: short AUD/CHF. Feature Chart I-IASweden: Avoiding A Lockdown Did Not Prevent A Slump In Consumption... Chart I-1B...But Led To Many More ##br##Infections Sweden and Denmark are neighbours. They speak near-identical languages and share a broadly similar culture and demographic. Yet the two countries have followed completely different strategies to halt the coronavirus pandemic. Sweden chose not to impose a lockdown. Instead, it opted for a ‘trust based’ approach, relying on its citizens to act sensibly and appropriately. Whereas Denmark imposed one of Europe’s earliest and most draconian lockdowns. The contrasting approaches of Sweden and neighbouring Denmark provide us with the closest thing to a controlled experiment on pandemic strategies. The Recession Is Not ‘Man-Made’, It Is ‘Pandemic-Made’ The surprising thing is that the economic performance of Sweden, which did not have a lockdown, has been almost as bad as Denmark, which did. This year, the unemployment rates in both economies have surged by 2 percentage points (albeit the latest data is for May in Sweden and April in Denmark). Furthermore, high-frequency measures of consumption show that Sweden suffered almost as severe a contraction as Denmark (Chart of the Week and Chart I-2). Chart I-2Unemployment Has Surged In Both No-Lockdown Sweden And Lockdown Denmark This surprising result challenges the popular view that this global recession is man-made. This view argues that without the government-imposed lockdowns, the global economy would not have entered a tailspin. But if this view is right, then why did consumption crash in Sweden? The simple answer is that in a pandemic, most people will change their behaviour to avoid catching the virus. The cautious behaviour is voluntary, irrespective of whether there is no lockdown, as in Sweden, or there is a lockdown, as in Denmark. People will shun public transport, shopping, and other crowded places, and even think twice about letting their children go to school. In a pandemic, the majority of people will change their behaviour even without a lockdown. But if the cautious behaviour is voluntary, then why impose a lockdown? The answer is that without a lockdown, the majority will behave sensibly to avoid catching the virus, but a minority will take a ‘devil may care’ attitude. In the pandemic, this is critical because less than 10 percent of infected people are responsible for creating 90 percent of all coronavirus infections. If this tiny minority of so-called ‘super-spreaders’ is left unchecked, then the pandemic will let rip. All of which brings us back to Sweden versus Denmark. As a result of not imposing a mandatory lockdown to rein in its super-spreaders, Sweden now has one of the world’s worst coronavirus infection and mortality rates, four times higher than Denmark (Chart I-3, Chart I-4, Chart I-5). Chart I-3No-Lockdown Sweden Has Suffered Many More Deaths Than Lockdown Denmark Chart I-4Avoiding A Lockdown Meant More Infections… Chart I-5…And More ##br##Deaths Put simply, containing the pandemic depends on reining in a minority of super-spreaders. Which explains why no-lockdown Sweden suffered a much worse outbreak of the disease than lockdown Denmark. In contrast, the economy depends on the behaviour of the majority. In a pandemic the majority will voluntarily exercise caution. Which explains why no-lockdown Sweden and lockdown Denmark suffered similar contractions in consumption. Looking ahead, will the widespread adoption of face masks and plexiglass screens change the public’s cautious behaviour? To a certain extent, yes – it will permit essential activities and let people take calculated risks. That said, if you are forced to wear a mask on public transport and in the shops, and you have to spread out in restaurants while being served by a masked waiter, then – rightly or wrongly – you are getting a strong signal: the danger is still out there. Meaning that many people will continue to shun discretionary activities and spending. The upshot is that while the pandemic remains in play, investors should maintain a defensive bias to their portfolios. Explaining Why Technology Is Now Defensive A defensive bias to your portfolio now requires an exposure to technology – because in 2020 the tech sector is behaving like a classic defensive. Its relative performance is correlating positively with the bond price, like other classic defensive sectors such as healthcare (Chart I-6 and Chart I-7). Chart I-6In 2020, Tech Is Behaving Like A Defensive... Chart I-7...Like Healthcare The behaviour of the technology sector in the current recession contrasts with its performance in the global financial crisis of 2008. Back then, it behaved like a classic cyclical – its relative performance correlated negatively with the bond price (Chart I-8). Begging the question: why has the tech sector’s behaviour flipped from cyclical to defensive? Chart I-8In 2008, Tech Behaved Like A Cyclical The main reason is that the tech sector’s composition has flipped from hardware dominance to software dominance. In 2008, the sector market cap had a 65:35 tilt to technology hardware. But today, it is the mirror-image: a 65:35 tilt to computer and software services (Chart I-9). Chart I-9Tech Is More Defensive Now Because It Is Dominated By Software Computer and software services have many defensive characteristics suited to the current environment: For many companies, enterprise software is now business critical. It is a must-have rather than a like-to-have. Computer and software services use a subscription-based revenue model, minimising the dependency on discretionary spending. Computer and software services are helping firms to cut costs through automation and back-office efficiencies as well as facilitating the boom in ‘working from home’. The sector is cash rich. Despite these defensive characteristics, there remains a lingering worry: is the tech sector overvalued? The Rally In Growth Defensives Is Not A Mania Some people fear that the recent run-up in stock markets does not make sense, other than as a ‘Robin Hood’ day-trader fuelled mania. After all, the pandemic is still very much in play, and so are other geopolitical risks, so how can some stock prices be near all-time highs? Yet the recent run-up in growth defensives such as tech and healthcare does make sense. Their valuations have moved in near-perfect lockstep with the bond yield, implying that the rally is based on fundamentals (Chart I-10). Chart I-10Tech And Healthcare Valuations Are Tracking The Bond Yield Simply put, if the 10-year T-bond is going to deliver a pitiful 0.7 percent a year over the next decade, then the prospective return from growth defensives must also compress. It would be absurd to expect these stocks to be priced for high single digit returns. Since late 2018, the decline in growth defensives’ forward earnings yield has broadly tracked the 250bps decline in the 10-year T-bond yield. Given that the forward earnings yield correlates well with the 10-year prospective return, the depressed bond yield is depressing the prospective return from growth defensives – as it should. Tech and healthcare valuations have moved in near-perfect lockstep with the bond yield. But with the pandemic and geopolitical risks menacing in the background, shouldn’t the gap between the prospective return on stocks and bonds – the equity risk premium – be larger? This is open to debate. When bond yields approach the lower bound, the appeal of owning bonds also diminishes because bond prices have limited upside. Nevertheless, the gap between the tech and healthcare forward earnings yield and the bond yield has gone up this year and is much larger than in 2018 (Chart I-11). This suggests that valuations are taking some account of the pandemic and other risks. Moreover, in a longer-term perspective the current gap between the tech and healthcare forward earnings yield and the bond yield, at +4 percent, hardly indicates a mania. In the true mania of 2000, the gap stood at -4 percent! (Chart I-12) Chart I-11The Equity Risk Premium Has Risen In 2020 Chart I-12Tech And Health Care Valuations Are Not In A Mania In summary, until the pandemic is conquered, investors should maintain a defensive bias to their portfolios. Bond investors should overweight US T-bonds versus core European bonds. Equity investors should overweight the growth defensives, technology and healthcare, which implies overweighting the technology-heavy US versus Europe. A new recommendation is to overweight technology-heavy Netherlands. Stay overweight healthcare-heavy Switzerland, and bank-light France and Germany (albeit expect a technical 5 percent underperformance of Germany versus the UK in the coming weeks). And stay underweight bank-heavy Austria. Fractal Trading System* The AUD is technically overbought and vulnerable to a tactical reversal. Accordingly, this week’s recommended trade is short AUD/CHF, with a profit target and symmetrical stop-loss set at 4.2 percent. The rolling 1-year win ratio now stands at 63 percent. Chart I-13AUD/CHF When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report “Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model,” dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com. Dhaval Joshi Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading System Cyclical Recommendations Structural Recommendations Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Interest Rate Chart II-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations
China became the world’s number one source of Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) patent applications last year. China is the world’s innovation leader in such areas as digital communications, computer technology, audio-visual technology and telecommunications.
Highlights Treasuries: Keep portfolio duration close to benchmark on a 6-12 month horizon, but continue to hold tactical overlay positions that will profit from modestly higher bond yields: Overweight TIPS versus nominal Treasuries, hold duration-neutral nominal curve steepeners, hold real yield curve steepeners. IG Tech: Given our positive outlook for investment grade corporate bond spreads, the Technology sector’s high credit rating and defensive characteristics make it decidedly un-compelling. However, Tech spreads are attractive compared to other A-rated corporate bonds. HY Tech: We want to focus our high-yield allocation on defensive sectors where a large proportion of issuers are able to benefit from Fed support. The high-yield Technology sector checks both of those boxes and offers attractive risk-adjusted compensation to boot. Feature Chart 1Three Treasury Trades As we have previously written, bond yields should move modestly higher over the course of the summer as the US economy re-opens.1 However, there are enough potential medium-term pitfalls related to US politics and COVID transmission that we aren’t yet comfortable with below-benchmark portfolio duration. Instead, we recommend that investors keep portfolio duration close to benchmark on a 6-12 month horizon, but add three tactical overlay positions that will profit from higher bond yields: Overweight TIPS versus nominal Treasuries Duration-neutral nominal Treasury curve steepeners Real yield curve steepeners All three of these positions have performed well during the past couple of months (Chart 1), and in the first section of this report we assess whether they have further to run. The remaining two sections of this week’s report consider the outlooks for investment grade and high-yield Technology bonds, respectively. Three Trades To Profit From Higher Yields 1) Overweight TIPS Versus Nominals Chart 2Adaptive Expectations Model TIPS breakeven inflation rates have moved up considerably since mid-March. Back then, the 10-year TIPS breakeven rate troughed at 0.50%. It currently sits at 1.31%. Despite the large move, TIPS breakeven inflation rates still have a considerable amount of upside. One way to assess how much is through the lens of our Adaptive Expectations Model (Chart 2).2 This model considers several different measures of inflation expectations (based on realized CPI inflation and surveys) and uses the difference between those measures of inflation expectations and the 10-year TIPS breakeven inflation rate to forecast the future 12-month change in the 10-year TIPS breakeven. At present, the model forecasts that the 10-year TIPS breakeven inflation rate will rise 23 bps during the next 12 months, bringing it to 1.54%. It’s important to note that our model is biased towards measures of longer-run inflation expectations. As a result, it can be surprised from time to time by large fluctuations in drivers of short-term inflation expectations, like the oil price. This year’s massive drop in oil – and concurrent decline in headline inflation – were the main factors that caused the 10-year TIPS breakeven inflation rate to fall so far below our model’s fair value. However, as we discussed in last week’s report, the oil price looks to have troughed and there is preliminary evidence that we might also be past the lowest point for headline CPI.3 Profit from rising bond yields by entering a duration-neutral yield curve steepener. We see TIPS continuing to outperform nominal Treasuries over both short- and long-run horizons. 2) Duration-Neutral Yield Curve Steepeners Chart 3Stick With Steepeners Another way to profit from rising bond yields without taking a large duration bet is via a duration-neutral yield curve steepener. One example would be a long position in the 5-year note and a short position in a duration-matched barbell consisting of the 2-year and 10-year notes. Alternatively, you could use the 2-year note and 30-year bond as the two legs of the barbell. These sorts of duration-matched trades where you take a long position in a bullet maturity near the middle of the curve and go short the wings are designed to perform well in periods of yield curve steepening.4 In the current environment, where dovish Fed guidance has dampened volatility at the front-end of the yield curve, any bond sell-off will be felt disproportionately at the long-end, leading to a steeper curve. The only problem with this proposed trade is that it is no longer cheap. The spread between the 5-year bullet and 2/10 barbell is -6 bps and the spread relative to the 2/30 barbell is -3 bps (Chart 3). What’s more, the 5-year bullet trades expensive relative to the 2/10 and 2/30 barbells, according to our fair value models (Chart 3, bottom panel). However, for the time being we are inclined to overlook stretched valuations. The 5-year bullet does appear expensive but it has been more expensive in the past, most notably during the last zero-lower-bound episode from 2010 to 2013. Similar to then, the market is now priced for an extended period of a zero fed funds rate. We would not be surprised to see bullets become much more expensive in that sort of environment, and possibly even return to extended 2010-2013 valuations. We recommend holding onto duration-neutral yield curve steepeners, despite unattractive valuations. Specifically, we favor going long the 5-year bullet and short a duration-matched 2/10 barbell. 3) Real Yield Curve Steepeners Chart 4Higher Inflation Means Steeper Real Yield Curve The final position we recommend is a steepener along the real yield curve. We first recommended this trade on April 28 when a plunge in oil (and spike in deflationary sentiment) caused the real 2-year yield to jump to 0.28% compared to a real 10-year yield of -0.70%.5 Since then, the real 2-year yield has collapsed to -1% compared to a real 10-year yield of -0.87%. Although the real 2-year/10-year slope is once again positive, it has typically been higher during the past few years (Chart 4). We therefore expect further steepening as long as the oil price and headline inflation continue to recover from April’s lows. Much like during the 2008/09 financial crisis, the combination of the Fed’s zero-lower-bound forward guidance and a massive drop in both oil and headline inflation caused short-dated real yields to jump. Subsequently, this led to a massive steepening of the real yield curve, once the oil price and headline inflation started to recover. We believe that same dynamic is playing out today. Investors should continue to hold real yield curve steepeners, at least until rebounding oil and headline CPI return short-dated inflation expectations to more reasonable levels. Investment Grade Tech Risk Profile Technology accounts for 9% of the overall Bloomberg Barclays investment grade corporate index, which makes it the second biggest industry group, after Banking. Its large index weight is due to the presence of three tech giants: Microsoft (Aaa-rated), Apple (Aa-rated) and Oracle (A-rated) which, combined, constitute 38% of the Tech sector. Investment grade Technology is a highly defensive corporate bond sector. In sharp contrast with the equity market, Technology is a highly defensive corporate bond sector. That is, it tends to outperform the overall corporate bond index during periods of spread widening and underperform during periods of spread tightening. This largely comes down to the fact that Tech has a higher credit rating than the overall corporate index. Twenty five percent of the Tech sector’s market cap carries a Aaa or Aa rating compared to just 9% for the overall index (Chart 5). Further, of the high-flying FAANG stocks that garner a lot of attention from equity analysts, only Apple is a significant presence in the Technology bond index.6 Chart 5Investment Grade Credit Rating Distributions* Chart 6IG Technology Risk ##br##Profile The Tech sector’s defensive nature is confirmed by looking at its duration-times-spread (DTS) ratio and historical excess returns (Chart 6).7 The sector’s DTS ratio is consistently below 1.0, and its excess returns show a clear pattern of outperformance during periods of spread widening and underperformance during periods of spread tightening. Valuation In terms of valuation, although the Tech sector does not offer a spread advantage over the corporate index – which should be expected given its higher credit rating – we find that it trades cheap relative to its comparable credit tier (Table 1). Tech offers an option-adjusted spread of 115 bps versus 111 bps for the A-rated corporate index, and the sector still appears attractive after controlling for duration differences by looking at the 12-month breakeven spread. In absolute terms, Tech sector spreads are just above their median since 2010. The A-rated corporate index spread currently sits right on top of its post-2010 median. Table 1IG Technology Valuation Balance Sheet Health Chart 7IG Technology Debt Growth The Technology sector added a large amount of debt during the last recovery. The par value of the Tech index’s outstanding debt has grown 5.2 times since 2010 compared to 2.4 times for the benchmark. As a result, Tech’s weight in the corporate index has more than doubled, from 4% to 9% (Chart 7). However, earnings have done a pretty good job of keeping pace with the large increase in debt. The market cap-weighted net debt-to-EBITDA ratio for the investment grade Tech index is only 2.4, and the sector’s average credit rating has been stable since 2010. At the individual issuer level, there are 58 issuers in the Tech index and only 4 currently have a negative ratings outlook from Moody’s (Appendix B). What’s more, of the 16 Tech sector ratings that Moody’s has reviewed this year, 12 have been affirmed with a stable outlook, 1 was assigned a positive outlook and only 3 were assigned negative outlooks. Macro Considerations Chart 8Technology Sector Macro Drivers The Tech sector can be split into three major segments that have distinct macro drivers: Software (26% of Tech index market cap, includes Microsoft and Oracle) Hardware (29% of Tech index market cap, includes Apple, IBM and Dell) Semiconductors (24% of Tech index market cap, includes Intel and Avago Technologies) Software investment has been in a structural bull market for many years, and should remain resilient during the COVID recession as demand for remote working solutions increases. While we only have data through the end of March, software investment did not see the same collapse as other sectors during the first quarter (Chart 8). The Hardware and Semiconductor segments are more cyclical and geared toward manufacturing. As such, their macro outlooks were already challenged pre-COVID, due to the US/China trade war and manufacturing downturn of 2019. Both US computer exports and global semiconductor sales were showing signs of life near the end of last year, but were decimated when the pandemic struck in 2020 (Chart 8, panels 3 & 4). A revival in this space is contingent upon continued gradual re-opening and a return to economic growth. More optimistically, US consumer spending on personal computers and peripheral equipment has not fallen as much as broad consumer spending during the past few months (Chart 8, bottom panel). In the long-run, the 5G smartphone rollout is a significant structural tailwind for both semiconductor issuers and Apple. Meanwhile, the threat of significant regulatory crackdown on Tech firms remains a long-run risk. Our sense is that any push toward stricter regulations won’t have that much impact on Technology bond returns. This is because the subjects of most lawmaker scrutiny – Facebook, Amazon and Google – are largely absent from the Bloomberg Barclays Tech index. Investment Conclusions We expect that investment grade corporate bond spreads will tighten during the next 6-12 months. Against this positive back-drop, investors should focus exposure on cyclical (lower-rated) sectors that offer greater expected returns. With that in mind, the Tech sector’s high credit rating and defensive characteristics make it decidedly un-compelling. However, Tech does offer a slight spread advantage compared to other A-rated bonds and the macro back-drop is reasonably supportive. We would therefore recommend Tech bonds to investors looking for some A-rated corporate bond exposure. But in general, we prefer the greater spreads on offer from sectors that occupy the high-quality Baa space, such as subordinate bank debt.8 High-Yield Tech Risk Profile High-Yield Technology’s credit rating profile is similar to that of the overall benchmark, but with a slightly larger presence of low-rated (Caa & below) issuers (Chart 9). The largest issuers in the space are Dell (5.7% of Tech index market cap, Ba-rated), MSCI Inc. (5.1% of Tech index market cap, Ba-rated, see copyright declaration) and CommScope (8.1% of Tech index market cap, B-rated). High-yield Tech recently transitioned from being a cyclical sector to a defensive one. Interestingly, the high-yield Tech sector recently transitioned from being a cyclical sector to a defensive one. The sector behaved cyclically during the 2008 recession, underperforming the index when spreads widened and outperforming when they tightened. But Tech then outperformed the High-Yield index during the spread widening episodes of 2015 and 2020. Based on the sector’s low DTS ratio, this defensive behavior should persist for the next 12 months (Chart 10). Chart 9High-Yield Credit Rating Distributions* Chart 10HY Technology Risk Profile Valuation The High-Yield Technology option-adjusted spread (OAS) is significantly lower than the average OAS for the benchmark High-Yield index. However, it offers a spread premium compared to other Ba-rated issuers (Table 2). Adjusting for duration differences by looking at the 12-month breakeven spread makes high-yield Tech look significantly more attractive. The high-yield Tech spread would have to widen by 146 bps for the sector to underperform duration-matched Treasuries during the next 12 months. This compares to 96 bps for other Ba-rated issuers and 152 bps for the overall junk index. Table 2HY Technology Valuation It is apparent that the Tech sector’s low average duration (Chart 10, bottom panel) is a major reason for its relatively tight OAS. On a risk-adjusted basis, high-yield Tech valuation actually appears quite compelling, with a 12-month breakeven spread only 6 bps below that of the overall index. Balance Sheet Health Chart 11HY Technology Debt Growth The amount of outstanding high-yield Technology debt has grown a bit more rapidly than overall junk index debt since 2010 (Chart 11). As a result, Technology’s weight in the index has increased from 5% in 2010 to 6% today. At the issuer level, the Tech sector should benefit from having a large number of issuers that will be able to take advantage of the Fed’s Main Street Lending facilities. To be eligible for the Main Street facilities, issuers must have less than 15000 employees or less than $5 billion in 2019 revenue. Also, the issuers must be able to keep their Debt-to-EBITDA ratios below 6.0, including any new debt added through the Main Street programs. Of the 43 high-yield Tech issuers with available data, we estimate that 30 are eligible to receive support from the Main Street facilities (Appendix C). This even includes 11 out of the 16 B-rated issuers. Typically, we don’t expect that many B-rated issuers will be eligible for the Main Street facilities, which makes this result encouraging for Tech sector spreads. Investment Conclusions We recommend an overweight allocation to high-yield Technology bonds. As we wrote last week, high-yield spreads appear too tight if we ignore the impact of the Fed’s emergency lending facilities and consider only the fundamental credit back-drop.9 With that in mind, we want to focus our high-yield allocation on defensive sectors where a large proportion of issuers able to benefit from Fed support. The Technology sector checks both of those boxes and offers attractive risk-adjusted compensation to boot. Appendix A: Buy What The Fed Is Buying The Fed rolled out a number of aggressive lending facilities on March 23. These facilities focused on different specific sectors of the US bond market. The fact that the Fed has decided to support some parts of the market and not others has caused some traditional bond market correlations to break down. It has also led us to adopt of a strategy of “Buy What The Fed Is Buying”. That is, we favor those sectors that offer attractive spreads and that benefit from Fed support. The below Table tracks the performance of different bond sectors since the March 23 announcement. We will use this to monitor bond market correlations and evaluate our strategy’s success. Table 3Performance Since March 23 Announcement Of Emergency Fed Facilities Appendix B Table 4Investment Grade Technology Issuers Appendix C Table 5High-Yield Technology Issuers Ryan Swift US Bond Strategist rswift@bcaresearch.com Jeremie Peloso Senior Analyst jeremiep@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “Bonds Vulnerable As North America Re-Opens”, dated May 26, 2020, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 2 For more details on our Adaptive Expectations Model please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “How Are Inflation Expectations Adapting?”, dated February 11, 2020, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 3 Please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “No Holding Back”, dated June 16, 2020, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 4 For an explanation of why this works please see US Bond Strategy Special Report, “Bullets, Barbells And Butterflies”, dated July 25, 2017, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 5 Please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “Negative Oil, The Zero Lower Bound And The Fisher Equation”, dated April 28, 2020, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 6 Of the other FAANG stocks: Google accounts for just 0.5% of Tech bond sector market cap, Facebook has close to no debt, Amazon is included in the Consumer Cyclical corporate bond index and Netflix is included in the Media: Entertainment sector of the High-Yield index. 7 Duration-Times-Spread (DTS) is a simple measure that is highly correlated with excess return volatility for corporate bonds. The DTS ratio is the ratio of a sector’s DTS to that of the benchmark index. It can be thought of like the beta of a stock. A DTS ratio above 1.0 signals that the sector is cyclical (or “high beta”), a DTS ratio below 1.0 signals that the sector is defensive or (“low beta”). For more details on the DTS measure please see: Arik Ben Dor, Lev Dynkin, Jay Hyman, Patrick Houweling, Erik van Leeuwen & Olaf Penninga, “DTS (Duration-Times-Spread)”, Journal of Portfolio Management 33(2), January 2007. 8 For more details on our recommendation to overweight subordinate bank bonds please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “Negative Oil, The Zero Lower Bound And The Fisher Equation”, dated April 28, 2020, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com 9 Please see US Bond Strategy Weekly Report, “No Holding Back”, dated June 16, 2020, available at usbs.bcaresearch.com Fixed Income Sector Performance Recommended Portfolio Specification

